Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

June, 2012:

第三跑道 觸礁

Description: http://news.mingpao.com/20120617/ua__17PV016_.jpg

http://news.mingpao.com/20120617/uae1.htm

通識導賞﹕第三跑道 觸礁!

【明報專訊】香港歷來最貴單一工程項目、也涉及歷來最大範圍填海的機場第三跑道,上周罕有地在程序開展之初的環評框架諮詢中已無法過關,包括多個環保團體在內的209份公眾意見,狠批機管局提交的工程項目簡介粗疏,各項有關海洋生態、空氣質素及噪音影響的資料或缺漏或刻意淡化;候任特首梁振英的環保政策智囊、前天文台長林超英連日公開撰文反對項目,開宗明義提出「增長不是至高無上的指導原則」,環保署亦發信要求機管局根據《環評條例》提交附加資料,然後再重新諮詢。

工程項目處於環評諮詢的階段,社會的討論固然都集中在興建第三跑道的環境影響;然而,政府一直刻意將民間反對聲音簡化為一群「環保分子」與經濟發展的對立,本報訪問了一位有20年駕駛香港民航機經驗的機師,事實上,興建第三跑道卻是專業界別都質疑是技術上不可行、或至少是經濟效益不高的方案。

到底香港「航運樞紐」的地位是否及為何岌岌可危?

第三跑道的建與不建,支持與反對者的理據各是什麼?

1. 增長不合比例 新跑道服侍富豪?

政府多番強調現行機場的客運力接近飽和,興建第三跑道刻不容緩,IATA顧問報告的增長預測,是機管局用以推廣第三跑道的主要依據。然而,從表中可見,現時赤角機場的雙跑道設計,客貨運量尚未飽和,要滿足2030年的預測需求亦相去不遠。

林超英的文章則指出,與1992年原設計容量相較,2030年的增長預測是不合比例,「人次增加約一成,貨運量稍減,架次卻增加超過五成」,「現在的世界趨勢是民航機的載客量愈來愈大,按道理客量增加一成,架次不會增加逾一成」,推測飛機升降架次不合比例大增五成,很可能源自載客量極少的私人飛機,新跑道將主要由富人及特權階級享用。

對此,機管局回應指1992年時的估計基礎,是假設84%的航班是載客量逾300人的寬體飛機,然而,近年航空公司多開拓使用窄體機的、來往二三線城市的航線,航班平均載客量只約200人,2010年寬體飛機比例只有67%;貨運方面,業界亦有以中型貨機代替寬體貨機的趨向,因此預測將來的架次增長比客貨運量增幅較大。

2. 空牆阻隔 開放空域才是重點

比較2010年數字及原設計容量,現時的客運量只使用了近六成、貨運量更只用了不足一半。原來赤角機場設計時,機場島中央預留大片空地興建一幢X型大樓,以應付客流量增長,但這大樓現時還未興建,新規劃卻沒考慮先用盡現有設計,而是想再次大規模填海造地加建跑道。

另一方面則是多年來都磋商無果的空域問題。由於解放軍的空域限制,現時航班進出香港,只有一個進場點及一個離場點,而且飛機要先在香港上空盤旋爬升至15000呎以上,才能進入中國領空,儼如一堵無形的「空牆」。理大土木及結構工程學系副教授熊永達曾撰文指出,英國希斯路機場亦是雙跑道,但因有8個進場及離場點,故航班升降量可以是香港的兩倍。可見要提升機場吞吐量,中方是否肯開放空域才是重點;而另一份機管局委託英國NATS提供的顧問報告亦明言,若中方不放寬空域限制,即使建了第三條跑道,亦不會帶來任何的運力增長。

3. 地勢所限 跑道永遠做後備?!

第三跑道方案公佈以來,不少航空業界人士均指出新跑道可能花費巨資但得物無所用。已駕駛香港航班逾20年的機師JanBochenski接受訪問時解釋,香港受地形限制,赤角有多山圍繞,本已非建機場的理想選址;而飛機與地面(或峰頂)需至少保持1000呎的垂直距離,如圖中所示,從第三跑道起飛,飛機未有足夠時間爬升至安全高度便會到達大帽山,此路線根本不符國際航空的標準。現時各山峰之間只夠容許一條起飛與另一條降落的路線。因此再建第三、四、五條跑道,都只能同時使用其中兩條。

此外,飛機降落時若太接近前機、遇有氣流、看不清跑道等情,無法順利降落,便要往前U turn再回來,但第三跑道西北方已接近深圳的空中邊界,一旦降落失敗,航機將沒有足夠的空間轉彎。「第三條跑道永遠只能作為一條後備跑道,或者用來停泊飛機的停放場!」

Jan指出,現時香港上空滿是繁忙的飛機在兜圈,每次起飛和降落都要兜20分鐘,每次兜圈每架機用600公升燃油,既浪費燃油也增加污染;同時,空域限制也令本地的航空交通指揮混亂。「全歐洲的航空交通都由荷蘭的指揮中心協調,航機到達前數小時,機場已經知道,可以因應地面情指示航機加速或減慢,調節抵達時間。但往香港航班在中國領空時,通訊和指揮都受限制,指揮中心在航機抵港前3分鐘才能協調,以致經常擠塞,常常在最後關頭突然要轉向和更改路線。只要空域限制放寬,航空交通更有效率,升降架次已即時可以增加一至兩成。」

4. 機管局刻意淡化填海規模!!

興建第三跑道是香港歷來涉及最大範圍的填海工程,但看機管局的諮詢文件完全不覺,因文件隱去屯門的海岸線。林超英指出,其實興建赤角機場時,機場島的填海工程已將屯門與東涌之間的海面闊度收窄近半,幾乎黏連沙洲,再填海建第三條跑道,海面寬度便剩下原來約四分之一,屯門、大嶼山及深井之間的三角形海面幾成「內海」,水流將顯著下降,難以帶走污染物,沿岸居民都會受影響;本已密集的海上交通包括不同航線的渡輪,將擠得更迫更危險,也嚴重威脅中華白海豚的生活環境。

5. 港深機鐵 送走優勢?!

現時珠三角的廣州、深圳、珠海、澳門多個機場幾成惡性競爭之局,各地紛紛爭取建更多跑道、開更多航線,但空域繁忙各不相讓,航班經常延誤。數年前已開始討論的港深機鐵(正名為「港深西部快速軌道」),最近結合在《鐵路發展策略2000》(檢討及修訂)裏提交作公眾諮詢,建議以跨境鐵路接駁赤角機場及深圳寶安機場,車程只需20多分鐘,用意是日後由深圳主攻國內航班,香港集中做國際航線。

然而該鐵路的深圳段造價為104億元人民幣,而香港段則要413億元人民幣,竟比廣深港高鐵還貴!到底是雙贏的互補合作,還是香港付鈔把本地航空業的優勢拱手相讓,可能要留待另一場討論。顯而易見的是,本地航運交通流量將在這種「深港融合」的趨勢下出現眾多變數,加上全球金融危機對客貨運需求的影響,機管局現時提出的2030年增長預測卻未見有充份考慮。

文 林茵

圖 「機場發展關注網絡」、林超英博客(草雲居)及政府諮詢文件

編輯 陳嘉文

Willawong residents fear exposure to toxic chemicals from waste incinerator

http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/willawong-residents-fear-exposure-to-toxic-chemicals-from-waste-incinerator/story-e6freoof-1225877201867

Description: Jasmin Daly of Willawong

Jasmin Daly, 75, outside her Willawong home, which is near a waste incinerator that’s potentially exposing residents to toxic chemicals. Picture: Mark Cranitch Source: The Courier-Mail

MORE than two dozen homes and businesses might have been put at risk of exposure to cancer-causing chemical emissions from a waste incinerator in Brisbane’s south.

The incinerator is also near the site of a huge proposed development earmarked for as many as 10,000 homes.

Lord Mayor Campbell Newman has called on the State Government to fast track air and noise testing after a report into the Willawong incinerator found toxic emissions could be affecting homes up to 1km away.

Homes along Sherbrooke Rd were believed to be the most at risk.

Cr Newman said preliminary modelling done for the report into the Ace Waste incinerator found that, if it operated 24 hours a day, nearby homes could potentially be exposed to dangerous chemicals above recommended levels.

The facility burns medical waste and is, legally, emitting 10 times the international standard of some chemicals.

A 300m exclusion zone was originally imposed around the incinerator. That was raised to 500m, and last February the Department of Environment and Resource Management increased it to 1000m amid concerns emissions might affect new development planned for the area.

Cr Newman said that council’s concerns were triggered after it began planning for the development, east of the site.

Willawong has been earmarked as a priority greenfield residential site by the State Government, with a predicted 6000 to 10000 homes planned to be built there.

While new development has been left in limbo until a final study into the incinerator is handed down in December, Cr Newman said the council was still worried about the effect it could be having on nearby workers and the residents of 15 homes.

He said the potential risk to existing homes had forced him to go public.

Cr Newman said council officers and DERM staff would doorknock homes and businesses to inform them of the potential risks.

One local resident, Jasmin Daly, 75, who has lived at her Sherbrooke Rd home for 46 years, yesterday said she knew nothing about the report.

“It doesn’t make me feel the best (to hear this),” she said.

“We have a lot of swamp birds and I watch them to see if they drop dead.”

DERM assistant Director-General, Damien Brown, said the results of the council-commissioned air studies “provided to date indicate no reason to suggest any health concerns for the nearest existing residents in the area”.

“ACE Waste are required to operate within strict environmental conditions and is regulated DERM,” he said.

PyroGenesis receives the ADRIQ’s Coup de Coeur award for Partnership and Innovation

http://www.stockhouse.com/News/CanadianReleasesDetail.aspx?n=8523592

PyroGenesis receives the ADRIQ’s Coup de Coeur award for Partnership and
Innovation

5/28/2012 8:23:00 PM

PyroGenesis receives the ADRIQ’s Coup de Coeur award for Partnership and
Innovation
MONTREAL, May 28, 2012 /CNW Telbec/ – PyroGenesis Canada Inc.
(“PyroGenesis” or the “Company”) (TSXV: PYR), an environmental solutions
company that designs, develops and manufactures plasma waste-to-energy
systems and plasma torch products, announced today that it received the
coveted Association pour le développement de la recherche et de
l’innovation du Québec’s (ADRIQ) 2012 « Coup de Cœur » award for
Partnership and Innovation, for its innovative solutions with regards to an
integrated waste management plan for Îles-de-la-Madeleine (the “Project”) .

The Project was geared towards finding a unique solution to waste
management challenges facing Îles-de-la-Madeleine. It included PyroGenesis,
the Centre de recherche sur les milieux insulaires et maritimes (CERMIM),
the municipality of Îles-de-la-Madeleine and the Université de Sherbrooke.
The goal was to evaluate the potential for developing and implementing two
coupled state of the art waste management technologies, namely PyroGenesis’
patented Plasma Resource Recovery System (PRRS) and a bio-methanization
process.

“This is a unique opportunity to demonstrate the technical and economic
viability of pairing these technologies for remote communities such as
Îles-de-la-Madeleine. The fact that International Small Islands Studies
Association is following the outcome with great interest underscores the
importance of this Project”, says Pierre Carabin, PyroGenesis’ Chief
Engineer. “PyroGenesis intends to demonstrate the advantages of this
integrated waste management solution, which will enable isolated
communities to manage their waste in a responsible, economic, and
sustainable manner”, says Gillian Holcroft, PyroGenesis’ Chief Operating
Officer.

“Waste management is a major challenge in our archipelago. This award is
encouraging us to pursue novel and affordable solutions that are adapted to
our environment” says Mr. Joël Arseneau, mayor of the municipality of
Îles-de-la-Madeleine. “The main objective of this integrated process is to
convert nearly all of the processed waste into usable products namely:
energy (heat and electricity) and slag (construction material). The project
is also exploring the use of slag as a cimentious substitute in the
production of concrete or granular material for road construction,” says
Arezki Tagnit-Amou a Civil engineering professor at Université de
Sherbrooke.

The technology which Pyrogenesis is providing combines the advanced
processes of plasma gasification and vitrification which is able to convert
unsorted waste into energy and usable by-products. Furthermore, the project
has benefited from the system Pyrogenesis has commissioned at the Hurlburt
Field Air Force Base in Florida by carrying out additional certified
emissions testing and to procure its partners with vitrified rock for
advanced material testing at Université de Sherbrooke.

Each year the ADRIQ honours technological collaborations between Quebec
researchers, entrepreneurs and their partners with the intent of
encouraging the creation of new partnerships which will lead to innovative
commercial achievements.

About PyroGenesis Canada Inc.

PyroGenesis Canada is an environmental solutions company that designs,
develops and manufactures plasma waste-to-energy systems and plasma torch
products. PyroGenesis’ proprietary plasma technologies utilize the intense
energy of plasma to gasify and vitrify virtually any type of waste without
producing hazardous by-products. PyroGenesis’ patented gasification and
vitrification technology is different from incineration because it produces
a clean synthetic gas from waste, which can be used for power generation.
PyroGenesis’ technology can also turn waste into a glassy rock that can be
utilized as construction material. PyroGenesis has marquee defense industry
and civilian customers that are using its technology in marine and
land-based applications. For more information, please visit
www.pyrogenesis.com

CIA Instant Investigation: Governor Weighs In on New Garbage Technology

http://www.kionrightnow.com/story/18793970/governor-weighs-in-on-new-garbage-technology

CIA Instant Investigation: Governor Weighs In on New Garbage Technology

Posted: Jun 15, 2012 9:20 AM <em class=”wnDate”>Thursday, June 14, 2012 9:20 PM EST</em>Updated: Jun 15, 2012 9:25 AM <em class=”wnDate”>Thursday, June 14, 2012 9:25 PM EST</em>

By Brooke Holmquist – email

CIA Instant Investigation: Governor Weighs In on New Garbage Technology

Updated: Thursday, June 14 2012 9:25 PM EDT2012-06-15 01:25:10 GMTJun 15, 2012 9:25 AM Jun 15, 2012 9:25 AM

GONZALES, Calif.- Power or pollution? That’s the big question when people talk about the future of garbage on the central coast. It’s called plasma gasification. An incinerator breaks down trash andMore >>

GONZALES, Calif.- Power or pollution? That’s the big question when people talk about the future of garbage on the central coast. It’s called plasma gasification. An incinerator breaks down trash andMore >>

CIA Instant Investigation: Eliminating Property Tax

Updated: Tuesday, June 12 2012 8:47 PM EDT2012-06-13 00:47:45 GMTJun 13, 2012 8:47 AM Jun 13, 2012 8:47 AM

How does never having to pay property taxes again sound? Right now, people in North Dakota are voting to do just that.More >>

How does never having to pay property taxes again sound? Right now, people in North Dakota are voting to do just that.More >>

CIA Instant Investigation: City Credit Card Use

Updated: Thursday, June 7 2012 9:19 PM EDT2012-06-08 01:19:17 GMTJun 08, 2012 9:19 AM Jun 08, 2012 9:19 AM

Demanding answers; workers in one central coast city claim the city is wasting tax dollars on food and hotels, while laying off employees. More >>

Demanding answers; workers in one central coast city claim the city is wasting tax dollars on food and hotels, while laying off employees. More >>

CIA Follow File: New Water Project Announced for Future of Peninsula

Updated: Monday, April 23 2012 9:46 PM EDT2012-04-24 01:46:16 GMTApr 24, 2012 9:46 AM Apr 24, 2012 9:46 AM

There is still a lot to be fleshed out with this plan Cal Am has proposed, not only does it have to be approved by the Ca Public Utilities Commission.More >>

There is still a lot to be fleshed out with this plan Cal Am has proposed, not only does it have to be approved by the Ca Public Utilities Commission.More >>

CIA Follow File: Cell Phones in Prison Shutdown

Updated: Monday, April 16 2012 9:36 PM EDT2012-04-17 01:36:01 GMTApr 17, 2012 9:36 AM Apr 17, 2012 9:36 AM

New information on the fight to keep cell phones out of state prisons. More >>

New information on the fight to keep cell phones out of state prisons. More >>

CIA: A Look at SVMH Suitors

Updated: Thursday, March 22 2012 4:10 PM EDT2012-03-22 20:10:22 GMTMar 23, 2012 4:10 AM Mar 23, 2012 4:10 AM

Salinas Valley Memorial Healthcare is one step closer to finding a partner to merge with. More >>

Salinas Valley Memorial Healthcare is one step closer to finding a partner to merge with. More >>

Alejo: Methyl Iodide Makers Withdrawing From California

Updated: Wednesday, March 21 2012 11:16 AM EDT2012-03-21 15:16:56 GMTMar 21, 2012 11:16 PM Mar 21, 2012 11:16 PM

Arysta LifeScience, the maker of methyl iodide, announced it would officially withdrawal methyl iodide from California and the United States, Assemblyman Luis Alejo said in a statement released Tuesday.More >>

More Arrests Thanks to Finger Print Technology

Updated: Friday, February 17 2012 9:16 PM EST2012-02-18 02:16:40 GMTFeb 18, 2012 10:16 AM Feb 18, 2012 10:16 AM

New numbers show new finger print technolgy is helping Santa Cruz police stay on top of crime, even after a prison realignment plan is sending more criminals on the streets. More >>

New numbers show new finger print technolgy is helping Santa Cruz police stay on top of crime, even after a prison realignment plan is sending more criminals on the streets. More >>

Farm Workers Want Ban On Methyl Iodide

Updated: Tuesday, February 14 2012 8:52 AM EST2012-02-14 13:52:44 GMTFeb 14, 2012 9:52 PM Feb 14, 2012 9:52 PM

SALINAS, Calif. – Dozens of farm workers will be asking the Monterey County Board of Supervisors this morning (Tuesda) to back a state-wide ban of methyl iodide. The workers want the board to pass a resolutionMore >>

CIA Follow File: CeaseFire Ceases to Exist?

Updated: Tuesday, January 31 2012 2:10 AM EST2012-01-31 07:10:38 GMTJan 31, 2012 3:10 PM Jan 31, 2012 3:10 PM

More >>

GONZALES, Calif.- Power or pollution? That’s the big question when people talk about the future of garbage on the central coast.

It’s called plasma gasification. An incinerator breaks down trash and turns it into usable energy.

The waste is heated and converted into gas. Once the conversion process is over.

The clean gas is sent to low-emission engines that make it into energy. California’s talking about building a gasification plant in Gonzales.

But opponents say plasma gasification incineration costs too much and worry about pollution.

Opponents say the governor isn’t listening to his own advisory board, and supporting a plasma gasification plan.

The Center for Investigative Action went to work to find out if that’s true.

“We saw like a wink and a nod, yeah we’ll get this through.”

That’s why Margaret Serna-Bonetti and others went to meet with Governor Jerry Brown’s senior aids earlier this week.

They’re part of the outspoken opposition to the plasma gasification project for the Gonzales landfill.

They say a letter from Jerry Brown’s office supports something environmentally unsafe.

“Outrage that the Governor would intervene in a process like this that is state mandated,” said Bonetti.

Last month the new director of the CA Department of Resources, Recycling, and Recovery sent a letter to Plasco, the company the Salinas Valley Solid Waste Authority hired to complete the “garbage into energy” facility.

The department told Plasco this proposed facility doesn’t meet the gasification requirements of renewable energy standards.

But in 2010, Governor Schwarzennegger’s adminstration told Plasco the project did meet the definition of a gasification facility.

With conflicting opinions, the Governor decided to weigh in.

“We feel that’s unfair to change the rules mid-way through, since the last administrator gave them the go ahead, but this is certainly not a carte blanche support for the project, it still has to go through all CEQUA evaluations,” said Elizabeth Ashford with the Governor’s office.

Opponents of the project said the Governor shouldn’t take sides especially since there is a complaint against the Solid Waste Authority for pushing this project forward, sitting on the attorney general’s desk.

Brown’s office said it’s not taking sides, “All were saying in this letter is acknowledge that you were given the go ahead in the past and so were going to be supportive of legislation to continue on a pilot basis but it’s important to meet all the standards and be highly scrutinized,” said Ashford.

The Salinas Valley Solid Waste Authority is conducting studies for the first draft of the environmental impact report and Plasco is conducting tests at its facility in Canada.

Terms of Use: We welcome your participation in our community. Please keep your comments civil and on point. You must be at least 13 years of age to post comments. By submitting a comment, you agree to this site’s Terms of Service.

Mickey
8 hours ago

0

Share | Flag

Other companies like Solena actually use the CO to create biofuels for ships (partnered with Maersk), aircraft (partnered with 15 international airlines including 9 in USA) and a plant in Gilmor which will also produce bio naptha . The emissions of the plant come from the steam used to generate electricity from the hydrogen gas fuel. Any sand or metal in the MSW feed mix are emitted from the bottom of the chamber as molten vitrified slag that can be used after crushing as road aggregate. The US Navy now uses plasma gasification on its carriers. The option of course is 100% recycling, which no country will ever achieve or landfill that creates methane which is 21 times more damaging to the planet than CO2. Then of course there is the toxic ash from mass burn incineration which constitutes almost 1/3 by weight of what was thermally converted.

Mickey
8 hours ago

0

Share | Flag

A technologically poorly written article. Plasma does not heat up or burn garbage, it gasifies it into plasma status at 4-8,000 deg C. How can you have particulates at the temperature of the surface of the sun ? Incineration needs air to be present indeed it increases air flow for mass-burn. Gasification takes place in the absence of air and is not incineration, it is conversion of matter into molecular form. The resultant Syngas is mainly hydrogen and CO which is scrubbed to leave the clean hydrogen as the source for generating steam to create electricity.

Carbon millions squandered

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/opinion/political-news/carbon-millions-squandered-20120616-20h4x.html

une 17, 2012

  • ·        Read later

Up in smoke…

The Rudd government committed $400 million to set up the Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute. Three years on, there is precious little to show for the money.

THE Australian-funded $300 million Global Carbon Capture and Storage Institute set up by former prime minister Kevin Rudd has squandered taxpayers’ money for negligible results, ex-staff say.

And according to a survey of the institute’s 190 members, which include businesses, governments and institutions from around the world, many were ”fed up with the lack of focus … and fast losing patience” with its work.

Undertaken in 2010, the survey, which has been obtained by The Sunday Age, found 31 per cent of all members believed the organisation was ”fast losing its relevance and must start to demonstrate greater value to members immediately”. Another 48 per cent said it had done a good job to set itself up but ”it’s important it now starts to achieve more”.

Description: Illustration: Matt Golding

Illustration: Matt Golding

The institute’s new chief executive, Brad Page, said it was now refocusing its approach, but conceded the original $100 million a year ”seed funding” given to the organisation – launched with great enthusiasm by Mr Rudd in 2009 to ”lead the world” in the greenhouse gas reduction technology – was too much for the fledgling body to manage efficiently.

”It’s actually impossible to spend that amount of money responsibly,” Mr Page told The Sunday Age.

Documents released under freedom-of-information laws show a staggering $54.25 million was spent on ”operational expenses” in the institute’s first two years.

Among those expenses were numerous first-class air fares for board members and lavish overseas trips for more than 15 of the institute’s Australia-based staff to attend meetings in France and Japan, where they stayed in five-star hotels and were catered for by top chefs.

But for all its high-powered meetings, former staff and industry observers say the Canberra-based institute has never had a clear focus, and this has led to millions of dollars being invested in overseas projects that have been of negligible benefit to Australia.

Mr Page is now trying to make the institute financially self-sufficient in readiness for when Australia’s generous ”seed funding” finally runs out in five years.

Since 2009, the institute has received more than $235 million – $122 million of which it has already spent and another $113 million of which remains in a bank account, beyond the reach of Treasury’s cost-cutting razor, according to information provided at a recent Senate estimates hearing.

The not-for-profit organisation has 78 staff, including nine permanent staff working overseas.

When it was established, a spokesman for Mr Rudd said the institute would not ”actually fund demonstration projects overseas” but instead would ”provide expertise … and research”.

Three years on, it is administering $65 million in contracts with institute partners. It has allocated $21 million to the Asian Development Bank, almost $20 million to the Paris-based International Energy Agency, and $10 million to the Clinton Foundation headed by former US president Bill Clinton, and given a grant to another body called the Climate Group, to ”advance” carbon capture and storage.

The Sunday Age believes there is deep concern about what Australia is actually achieving from these contracts.

Mr Page said the institute aimed to make sure each new project around the world did not repeat the mistakes of the last.

He said the money going to overseas projects built up the institute’s publicly available ”knowledge bank” about carbon capture and storage, but from now on the institute would commission specific research and would no longer fund projects on the ground.

Read more: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/opinion/political-news/carbon-millions-squandered-20120616-20h4x.html#ixzz1y0CquRUk

‘Science fiction’ waste solution a real option

Plasma arc incineration is a forward-looking and realistic alternative to landfills, and won’t generate the toxic emissions associated with burning waste
Martin Williams
Jun 17, 2012

You’ve probably seen reports on plans for building a mega waste incinerator on an artificial island beside Shek Kwu Chau. Though rejected by a Legislative Council panel, the plans have not been abandoned. After four Hongkongers were this month given permission for a judicial review of the plans, the government responded that there is no alternative to building the incinerator at Shek Kwu Chau.

Is this true? Can Hong Kong find no better way of dealing with waste than shipping it to a beautiful coastal area and setting fire to it? There’s actually a range of alternatives, ranging from straightforward to one that seems verging on science fiction.

At first, I believed reports that the planned incinerator technology is so advanced that the emissions would be wonderfully clean. After all, Hong Kong used to have four waste incinerators, but closed them all down by 1997 because of concerns over air pollution – and the government would not be so crazy as to plan a similarly dangerous facility today. Or would it?

Information on incinerators reveals that even the best of them emit significant quantities of particulate, which were a key concern with the past incinerators, and have been shown to have more adverse health impacts than earlier realised. Improved techniques might reduce dioxins, yet incinerators produce an array of toxic molecules, along with mercury and cadmium. And chemicals not emitted to the air are trapped in chimney ash so toxic it can qualify as hazardous waste.

So incineration looks unwise, even irresponsible. But doing nothing is not an option. We’re among the world’s most throwaway societies, with landfills soon to reach capacity.

This profligacy means there is immense scope for reduction, reuse and recycling. Though the government claims a high, 52 per cent recycling rate, this figure is well below the 70 per cent rate achieved in Germany, and we set our sights low compared to San Francisco, which aims for zero waste to landfills by 2020. Currently, Hong Kong’s recycling efforts are prone to being so passive as to verge on being useless.

Even with massive boosts to recycling, we will need to treat remaining waste. One technique involves using bacteria to process food waste, and produces biogas that can be burned to generate electricity, together with material suitable for use as compost. But though widely adopted by some cities, such as Toronto, it may be best suited to small-scale applications.

What, then, of the “science fiction” technique? This seems far-fetched when you first hear of it, as it involves treating waste using plasma – the fourth state of matter – that can be hotter than the surface of the sun. Its time, however, may have come. Scientific American magazine included it among 20 “world-changing ideas” for making our planet cleaner, healthier and smarter.

Plasmas are so energised that they abound with charged particles. They make up stars, and occur in lightning. Plasmas have also been harnessed for an array of uses by forming them in arcs between electrodes – and it’s these plasma arcs that are now being deployed for transforming waste.

Though plasma arc torches originated in the late 19th century, their main development stems from the 1960s, when Nasa deployed them for generating the extreme temperatures needed to test heat shields for re-entry vehicles. Their applications include destroying medical waste, recovering metals from electronic waste, rendering asbestos harmless – and treating municipal waste.

Plasma waste treatment differs from incineration in several important ways. Notably, incineration means burning: oxygen reacts with organic chemicals to form smaller molecules that might themselves react together, leading to hundreds of compounds being found in incinerator emissions. Incinerator ash, particularly the fly ash from chimney stacks, contains the dangerous chemicals that are not emitted.

Plasma processes are much hotter, perhaps well over 4,000 degrees Celsius. These temperatures, coupled with intense ultraviolet light, blast molecules apart; organic chemicals disintegrate to simple components. The resulting gas mixture called syngas (synthetic gas), is mainly carbon monoxide and hydrogen. Other material forms something like lava, which can be solidified into glass-like material with metals and other toxins so effectively “locked” within that Japanese incinerators treat fly ash with plasma arc torches.

The syngas can be burned to generate electricity, rather as incinerators may be used for “waste-to-energy”. But in another marked contrast to incineration, the syngas has other possible uses. One company, Solena Fuels, is working with airlines and a shipping company to develop projects that transform syngas into jet fuel and ship fuel from waste. Advanced Plasma Power, which specialises in plasma arc treatment of municipal waste, is exploring ways to synthesise natural gas.

Here in Hong Kong, the Environmental Protection Department has fielded an array of objections to plasma arc treatment. One objection is correct: there are no large-scale plasma arc waste treatment facilities in operation. However, several projects are being planned or built worldwide, and set to become operational well before Hong Kong could complete its outdated incinerator.

Contrary to an EPD assertion, there are plasma arc companies willing to work on treating Hong Kong waste. Solena Fuels has suggested building waste-to-jet-fuel facilities at landfill sites. Advanced Plasma Power has formed a consortium prepared to financially guarantee a large-scale facility, and first build a pilot plant – just as they hope to build a pilot project for New York. The city closed its last waste incinerator in 1999. It, too, has a serious waste problem, but instead of looking backwards for solutions, it is seeking proposals for waste-to-energy projects that exclude mass burn incineration.

Under retiring chief executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen and his environment chief, Edward Yau Tang-wah, Hong Kong has been fixated on a return to incineration. With the Legislative Council giving the thumbs-down to the Shek Kwu Chau plans, and the advent of a new leadership team, perhaps we can instead look to the future, and to ideas for building a cleaner, healthier and smarter Hong Kong.

Martin Williams is a Hong Kong-based writer specialising in conservation and the environment, with a PhD in physical chemistry from Cambridge University

Description: Artist's impression of the plant on Shek Kwu Chau.

Alternatives to Incineration

http://www.farmerscampaign.org/pages/alternatives.html

Alternatives to Incineration

Total Recycling

100% recycling of our waste is impossible, or is it? Recently the farmers campaign became aware of a British recycling technology which can take residual waste previously ‘non­recyclable’ and process it into useful products to create jobs and make money from waste. Those arguing for incineration have said “what else can you do with ‘non­recyclable’ waste such as plastic meat trays contaminated with organic material, nappies, tooth brushes and polystyrene?” The answer is first put the waste through a ‘Materials Recycling Facility’(MRF) and extract high value recyclables. The residual waste left over can then be fed into a “Saltus” process offered by ‘Cardinal Mark Ltd’. A visit to the company’s operation near Chester provided an insight into the waste industry’s future.

A practical demonstration transformed a mixture of waste into a material that has a guaranteed value and wide range of uses. The new material is feed into an extrusion process capable of producing a diverse range of products. Sample products included pallets, fence posts, boards and structural beams, they appear capable of outperforming traditional materials. The process sounded too good to be true which is why a visit to the company was necessary. After signing their ‘Non Disclosure Agreement’ the company answered a series of questions. Any company still offering incineration should take note and recognise their business model is outdated, communities do not want incinerators and improved recycling makes them obsolete.

Total Recycling 2

Description: http://www.evrs-zero-bury.co.uk/_/rsrc/1292236294155/home/DSCI0027.1292235185545
An advanced form of Autoclaving (steam treatment) reduces residual waste initially to a sludge then adds a catalyst in the process to produce a consistent quality and valuable fibre for re-manufacturing. Plastics and other materials are recovered separately for recycling as part of the process. This system allows waste including old carpets, nappies, leather, plastic bags and other materials previously considered non-recyclable to be effectively recycled. For more information Visit: EVRS

Hello! Welcome to evrs.

For the last 8 years, we have conducted research and development, to produce the evrs “Zero-Bury” technology, using Thermally Induced Chemical Transformation (TICT). As a result, we can now design, build, own and operate waste recycling plants specialising in resource recovery of “lignocellulosic biomass” from non-hazardous residual wastes. We can successfully process comingled materials such as residuals, black bag waste, packed food, and bulky waste including furniture, and scale plants to meet the “proximity principle”.

Our plants are excellent neighbours, with no discharges to air, to land or to water, and the 0.1% not recycled though our plant is recycled by specialists for us, so we can claim total recycling. Our carbon footprint is 93% less than sending the same material to landfill – yes, just 7%

We hope you enjoy our website, why not look at the services we offer or get in touch?

“evrs”, the Heart logo, “Zystur” and “Waste to Worth” are registered trademarks of Zystur Ltd.

see our unique steam-powered fire defence system, courtesy of Firetrace:

http://www.firetrace.co.uk/steamextinguisher.wmv

Mechanical & Biological Treatment MBT
MBT is already established in other counties including Cambridgeshire. The term describes a range of technologies that either compost or digest biodegradable waste and recovers a high proportion of material for recycling through using advanced mechanical sorting/processing. The MBT process significantly reduces the waste and produces compost like output that can be used for land reclamation. If the compost like output is not used it can be economically sent to landfill without incurring the financial penalties or pollution problems associated with disposal of untreated waste. With MBT incineration is not necessary and the required diversion from landfill can be achieved.
MBT technology – Donarbon

Lancashire rejected incineration

“Their waste solution produces energy, diverts waste away from landfill and is combined with proactive waste reduction”. Use this link to find out morehttp://www.globalrenewables.eu/ur3r-process

New Earth Solutions

‘New Earth Solutions’ provide Mechanical and Biological Treatment of residual waste. It has significant advantages over Energy from Waste Incineration. Instead of vaporising valuable Aluminium, lead and other metals, these along with plastics are recovered.

It is more flexible and has a lower carbon foot print than an electricity producing incinerator, the price tag is also less. A facility to deal with 200,000 tonnes per year would cost around £25 million. New Earth have five plants operating including those at Bristol and Bournemouth with a sixth in progress.

New Earth Solutions

A more efficient approach
Instead of putting all mixed waste through an MBT plant, food can be collected separately from other waste, this can and is being done in many parts of the UK. Norwich City Council recently started doing this. The food waste can be fed to an anaerobic digester converting a high proportion of it to methane gas used for generating electricity. The compost like output after digestion is a useful agricultural product and can be spread on farmland. Anaerobic Digestion is a proven and effective technology. When other waste is not contaminated by food a greater proportion of it can easily be recycled. There is very little of our waste, which cannot effectively be recycled, even plastics. Norfolk County Council lags behind other areas, we are not recycling materials that others can.
Biomass Energy Centre

Thermal Treatment of our waste.
If the thermal treatment of our waste could really be justified it should only be used after we have already reduced the waste through the cleaner technologies such as MBT and AD. The type of incineration favoured by Norfolk County Council would still not be justified because cleaner, more efficient Plasma Gasification is now available. Incineration is the technology of the past.

Plasma Gasification (not to be confused with low temperature gasification)
This technology has now proven itself and is replacing traditional incineration (as currently favoured by NCC). Plasma uses a high temperature electric arc to super heat waste breaking it down into fuel gas for generating electricity and a solid glass like slag which is inert and can be used to produce rock wool insulation material. After taking into account the electricity needed to sustain the plasma plant it still produces more electricity than a traditional incinerator. A study from Cassino University’s Department of Industrial Engineering showed, “integrated plasma gasification combined cycle (IPGCC) has been evaluated. The system efficiency (31% LHV) is very high in comparison with the efficiency of conventional technologies based on waste incineration (20%)”. NCC officers responsible for our waste claimed Plasma is unproven and only works on a small scale. Plasma has operated in the UK for over 30 years, commercial scale plants are already established and many more are going through procurement. NCC officers said banks would not finance plasma, which is very misleading because some companies offering Plasma are prepared to finance the project themselves, only charging a tipping fee which is cheaper than proposed for their incinerator.
UK 300,000 tonne plasma gasification plant
The Plasco Energy Group
A Thames Gateway Article
Enviroparks News

Other technologies include Autoclave, Pyrolysis Gasification
Another emerging technology can be found on the following link: www.polyflow.co

New technology converts residual waste into substitute Petrol.
Companies are now building commercial scale plants, visit Reclaim Resources Ltd’s website for more information here: www.reclaimresources.com.

There can be no justification for Norfolk County Council getting locked in to a 25 year contract for an incinerator which will stifle recycling and prevent more efficient technology being used.

Mixed contaminated plastic can economically be recycled into valuable raw material for manufacturing, markets already exist for these materials. View the report using the link http://www.wrap.org.uk/document.rm?id=11123

There will be further updates coming soon.

In the 1990s Americans discovered EfW incinerators were expensive and inefficient, now European countries like Germany are discovering the same. When EfW incinerators reach the end of their contracts… the German authorities do not intend to build any more. View a youtube presentation by Mike Biddle showing a more modern approach to waste, there is not much that cannot be recycled.

Mike Biddle: We can recycle plastic!
Click on image below, to view video

Hu Jintao signs HK$23b in deals on Denmark trip

Clear the Air says:   too bad Edward Yau’s ‘Greentech’  jaunt to Europe,  funded by the public purse for him and indirectly through Universities for his accompanying ilk, did not manage to sign any deals

whilst taking in the delights of Europe and its clean air.  Of course he did visit a Scottish distillery. We wonder of what benefit  such a trip could be to Hong Kong’s Environment above the gratification

of the outgoing Minister who is charged with protecting it and who has the worst performing of all failed portfolios, rapidly followed by the Education Prevarication minister, Suen to be no more.

Hu Jintao signs HK$23b in deals on Denmark trip

Denmark’s foreign minister says he will discuss Syria, Tibet and human rights with his Chinese counterpart
Agencies in Copenhagen
Jun 16, 2012

President Hu Jintao , who is on a three-day state visit to Denmark, penned a string of business deals worth a total of 18 billion krone (HK$23.6 billion) with some of the Nordic country’s largest companies.

The deals were signed yesterday and include agreements with Danish container and shipping group A.P. Moller-Maersk, brewer Carlsberg, wind turbine maker Vestas and dairy co-operative Arla.

Hu arrived on Thursday and has toured Copenhagen’s harbour aboard the royal yacht, cruising by green technology projects as well as the Little Mermaid statue which was briefly lent out to China for the Shanghai World Expo in 2010.

Hu’s visit is the first official state visit to Denmark by a Chinese leader since the countries established ties 62 years ago. He is accompanied by a large delegation of Chinese officials and business leaders.

APM Terminals, the ports arm of A.P. Moller-Maersk, will take a 25 per cent stake in a project to expand Ningbo Port with total investments of 4.29 billionyuan (HK$5.26 billion), the companies said.

Ningbo , in the northeastern province of Zhejiang , is the sixth-largest container port in the world and the third-biggest in China, with throughput of 14.5 million 20-foot equivalent units (teu) last year and strong growth in recent years, APM Terminals said.

China is Denmark’s eighth-largest export market, and by the end of March this year 331 Danish companies were doing business there.

Last year, Danish exports to China totalled 15 billion krone and its imports from China amounted to 36 billion krone.

Thomas Bostrup, of the Confederation of Danish Industries, said the major agreements sealed between Danish and Chinese firms during Hu’s visit “will give a lot more orders because it will be noticed in China that their president is here and will give some exposure to the competencies and technologies that we have in Denmark”.

Hu will meet Danish Prime Minister Helle Thorning-Schmidt today before taking off for the summit of the Group of 20 major developed and developing nations in Mexico.

Meanwhile, Danish Foreign Minister Villy Sovndal said he would discuss Syria, Tibet and human rights when he meets Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi in Copenhagen.

“I will be raising issues that we do not necessarily agree on such as human rights and Tibet,” Sovndal said on the Baltic island of Bornholm. “We are worried about the situation for the minority in Tibet, we are worried about human rights,” he said.

Still, he said he would primarily be raising the issue of the ongoing hostilities in Syria.

“I will be taking time to see whether China is ready to play a more constructive role in connection with the macabre situation we see in Syria, with massacres of innocent people who are just protesting against a regime that lost its legitimacy a long time ago,” Sovndal said.

China froze relations with Denmark in 2009, after two successive prime ministers welcomed Tibet’s exiled spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, at the official government residence.

Those relations were mended in late 2010 when the Danish parliament made it clear that Copenhagen had a one-China policy and did not back independence for the Himalayan territory.

Associated Press, Agence France-Presse, Reuters

Trouble ahead over proposal to end small-house policy

SCMP

Villagers and academics say Carrie Lam’s ideas on indigenous rights and welfare will cause controversy

Joyce Ng
Jun 14, 2012

New Territories villagers and social science academics say the woman tipped to be the next chief secretary will spark huge controversy with her ideas to end the small-house policy and reform the city’s welfare system.

Lau Wong-fat, chairman of rural affairs body the Heung Yee Kuk, gave a guarded response when told of development minister Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor’s latest remarks on the small-house policy. “This is only her view and only what she told you. I have never heard about that. I don’t want to comment,” Lau said.

Junius Ho Kwan-yiu, a lawyer and chairman of the Tuen Mun Rural Committee, was alarmed. “I am curious to know how the government interprets Article 40 of the Basic Law, which protects our traditional rights and interests,” Ho said.

He argued that male indigenous villagers’ traditional rights and interests include the privilege of building small houses, the right to burial (as opposed to cremation), the right to be free from paying government rent for land they own, and their interests in protecting the fung shui of villages.

“Does she want to limit it, or really cancel it? If she means the small- house policy should be improved, I can understand. If it is not, is it the right thing to do? I don’t understand,” Ho said. Asked if he thought the kuk would launch a judicial challenge, the lawyer said one had to “think twice [before doing] everything”.

Eric Cheung Tat-ming, an assistant law professor with the University of Hong Kong, said the government would need to conduct a thorough legal study if it wanted to end the small-house policy.

“Government lawyers must study the historical background, how the small-house policy evolved over the years. Only by a historical study can they deduce and define what exactly the traditional rights are – whether inheriting and selling a small house is part of these rights, for example – and be safe from a possible legal challenge,” Cheung said.

Malcolm Merry, a HKU law professor specialising in land disputes, earlier said the abolition of the small- house policy would be in accordance with the Basic Law, as the modern three-storey village house did not exist until 50 years ago and was not custom.

Democratic Party lawmaker Lee Wing-tat agreed the small-house policy should be terminated, but said the minister did not have to set a deadline as late as 2029. The government would have to conduct a public consultation, he added.

Lam already had a blueprint to reform the welfare system when she was director of social welfare, but failed to implement it because she had no power to control other departments, said Nelson Chow Wing-sun, professor of social work and social administration at HKU.

Chow said he suggested to Lam that she should allow only the elderly and the disabled to remain covered by the Comprehensive Social Security Assistance Scheme, and those who had the ability to work should be excluded.

He also proposed to her that the Labour Department help those excluded from the CSSA to find jobs. For single parents, a category of existing CSSA recipients, the department could help create suitable part-time jobs, so they would still have time to look after their children.”But then she told me that she met opposition and she had no power to control the work of other departments,” Chow said. “The CSSA is only to maintain a basic living standard, but cannot cater to the needs of different people.”

Fernando Cheung Chiu-hung, a social science academic and Labour Party member, said he was “scared” by Lam’s hints on welfare reform.

“Given her track record of curbing welfare expenditure, it seems to me that what she has in mind is more like a cost containment exercise than widening the safety net,” Cheung said.

He said he agreed with Lam that the CSSA scheme should be abolished, “but only provided that new social insurance systems [be implemented] to protect the unemployed, the sick, and the disabled, and subsidies for the low-income group, as in the US and the UK”.

joyce.ng@scmp.com

End small-house policy, says Lam

The woman tipped to be chief secretary says this rural ‘right’ cannot be preserved forever as she discusses her hopes for a ‘big social experiment’ to overhaul welfare

Olga Wong and Joyce Ng
Jun 14, 2012

The candidate favoured to become the next chief secretary is calling for an end to what some see as the infinite demand from rural indigenous villagers for homes under the small-house policy.

In an interview with the South China Morning Post (SEHK: 0583, announcements, news)in which she outlined the challenges the next government must tackle, Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor also hinted at “a big social experiment” to overhaul the welfare system.

“Not long after my appointment, I talked to the Heung Yee Kuk and asked if they could draw a line,” she said, as she reviewed her term as the development minister since 2007.

“If life is unchanged for 50 years until 2047, as set out under the Basic Law, and only 18-year-old [or older] indigenous male villagers are eligible for a small house, how about ending it in 2029? I have asked them and offered different options. But they just didn’t come back,” she said.

Under her plan, the last generation to enjoy what the villagers regard as their right would be those born in 2029 and who would become 18 in 2047. The small-house policy gives male indigenous villagers in the New Territories the right to build a house close to their ancestral homes. It has drawn criticism because in some cases it is being abused for profit.

Lam said she now sees an opportunity to propose an end to the policy in the next five years. However, she admitted her relationship with some rural representatives had turned sour as a result of stepped-up actions on clearing illegal structures in village houses since April.

“They were agitated about my enforcement [on illegal structures],” she said. “Now that they realise the law has to be enforced, they would probably think about what to do with the remaining village zones that cannot accommodate all their [housing] demands. I do think the next administration should make a start.”

One of the challenges, Lam said, is to convince the public that the government may need to give something to villagers in return when the policy is ended. This could include providing more infrastructure to the villages and speeding up the application process with more efficient use of land.

On welfare, Lam, who was director of social welfare between 2000 and 2003, said she had in mind a “very big social experiment” to tackle poverty and narrow the wealth gap. One idea was to reform the Comprehensive Social Security Assistance scheme, calling it “a whole new paradigm shift to deal with poverty”.

“I have always felt that the CSSA is not the best scheme. If it is a good scheme, why are there so many ‘three-nothings’ and ‘four-nothings’ in Hong Kong,” she said, referring to the working poor who do not benefit from government relief measures because they are not welfare recipients, taxpayers or eligible for public housing.

Improvements to the safety net in the past five years included means-tested transport subsidies for workers, and vouchers for kindergarten education and for health checks for the elderly with private doctors.

A tip of her hard hat

SCMP

After five years at the helm of the city’s development, Carrie Lam says she has done her best. But she’d like to see thorny land policies and a welfare revamp resolved

Olga Wong and Joyce Ng
Jun 14, 2012

Sitting in her office at government headquarters in Admiralty, overlooking the newly reclaimed waterfront, Secretary for Development Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor – who’s reputed to be tough – makes a confession.

As the end of her five-year tenure approaches, she admits she has been unable to resolve problems arising from the controversial small-house policy – which grants male indigenous villagers in the New Territories the right to build a house near their ancestral homes – because the government is not ready to tackle them.

Since 1972, the policy has allowed those villagers to build a three-storey house, with up to 700 square feet of space on each floor. But it has been abused by some for quick profits.

“I confess that I can’t do it because we don’t have that readiness to tackle such a big subject,” she said candidly.

This is a rare admission. The minister has never backed down in the past when faced with tough issues, from relocating the historic Queen’s Pier to make way for a bypass, to amending the law to make it easier for developers to acquire flats in old buildings for redevelopment.

She stood her ground on a plan to take away floor-area concessions from developers and in dealing with angry rural representatives who burned her in effigy after the announcement of a policy to clear long-standing illegal structures.

Although Lam’s “can-do” spirit seemed to dim on the small-house policy, she said the problem still needed tackling through high-level co-ordination. Lam, who is tipped to be the next chief secretary, said she was willing to confront the issue soon by calling on the incoming administration to end the policy.

There are numerous hot-button issues awaiting her if she serves another five years. She hopes the new administration can realise some of her ideas, including an overhaul of the welfare system and the establishment of a harbour authority, something she has pledged to achieve.

“I told David Akers-Jones that I would not allow the small-house- policy file to be stuck in my in-tray,” she said, referring to the former chief secretary who advised chief executive-elect Leung Chun-ying during his election campaign on a review of the policy. Akers-Jones administered the policy in the 1980s.

Lam said she gave up trying to resolve the small-house problems halfway through her term, when she found nothing could be done in the short term.

Firstly, she said, it is difficult to enforce the law in the New Territories. There was strong opposition, for instance, from villagers who were told to remove extra storeys built on their houses without permission from the Buildings Department.

Second, the government had to be pragmatic: it could not simply end the policy without compensating villagers who stand to benefit from it. This is something that may not sit well with urban dwellers, who already complain of unfair treatment.

“At least I didn’t compound the problem by giving [the villagers false] hope,” said Lam.

Rural villagers – including Heung Yee Kuk chairman Lau Wong-fat, who has been appointed an Executive Councillor – have repeatedly demanded more land for small-house development.

Those lacking land for further expansion can apply for a village expansion area [VEA], a measure introduced in 1981 allowing the government to use private land outside the village and provide infrastructure. Lam said she did not grant a single one during her term, explaining: “If the demand is infinite, how many VEAs would I have to create? Also, tension between the rural and urban sectors would be intensified as there’s already not enough land for building public flats.”

Rural land is rapidly running out, with just one-third of the original 4,960 hectares made available for small houses remaining, according to the Development Bureau.

Lam said drawing a line to end the infinite demand for village houses would send a clear signal that the government should no longer widen the rural-urban gap.

Another of her battles will be reforming the heavily criticised social welfare system, an idea that has been deeply rooted in her mind since she headed the Social Welfare Department from 2000 to 2003.

Lam said she had “two unfinished agendas” when she left the department. One is a coupon system for elderly beneficiaries that would allow them to freely choose the institutions they want to stay in, rather than be allocated ones that usually provide cheap, unsatisfactory services.

The second one is what she called “a whole new paradigm shift to deal with poverty” – an overhaul of the Comprehensive Social Security Assistance scheme. “The scheme, by design, cannot reach out to certain people for whatever reasons. Sometimes for a noble reason, these people don’t want to go on CSSA because of social stigma,” she said.

Lam, who has no deputy and often works long hours, is well known for initiating cross-disciplinary projects and policies that need other bureaus’ support.

One example proposed during her tenure is the plan to establish a harbour authority, a dedicated agent to upgrade the city’s waterfront, which would require the input of transport, marine and lands officials and those managing open space.

Public consultations, passing the required legislation and obtaining lawmakers’ approval for the authority’s funding is likely to take several years, and will fall to the future Housing, Planning and Lands Bureau, to be supervised by the financial secretary. Lam said “someone is watching” to ensure the plan won’t be shelved by the next administration.

Having described Victoria Harbour five years ago as an unpolished diamond, Lam said the government would not let the waterfront lie idle any longer. Various organisations have shown interest in occupying the newly reclaimed waterfront sites in Central before they are tendered out early next year, she says. The Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra and Tourism Board plan to hold a concert and festival respectively.

The tenders are expected to bring public arts exhibits, pop-up restaurants and even a Ferris wheel to the Central waterfront. If the government worked in concert, she said, the harbour could be more vibrant with the introduction of large-scale water taxis, similar to the Thames Clippers in London.

Commenting on the role of the Culture Bureau, a new body to be formed and supervised by the next chief secretary, Lam said culture should be encompass city planning, education, industrial development, commerce, and promotion both overseas and on the mainland.

“The Culture Bureau is not just the usual LCSD culture,” she said, referring to the Leisure and Cultural Services Department, which is often criticised for being too bureaucratic and lacking in vision.

While Lam has repeatedly topped public opinion polls – partly due to the fact she has dealt firmly with property developers and rural villagers who are increasingly seen by Hong Kong urbanites as “common enemies” – it is unlikely that her popularity can stay at such a high level.

If she does become chief secretary, Lam will deal with even thornier issues such as political reform, and other matters that ride the tide of public approval and disfavour.

But when asked if she had any worries about the immediate future, she replied: “I never consider popularity in my work … It doesn’t bother me at all.”

She pointed out that if popularity was her main concern, she would not have opted for two widely criticised moves. One was her decision to cut CSSA by 11 per cent during the economic downturn in 2003. Another was amending a law in 2010 making it easier for private developers to acquire old buildings by lowering from 90 per cent to 80 per cent the threshold for triggering compulsory sales of remaining unsold flats in a block.

“I do it because I truly believe it was necessary to make a caring and just society. I never have this illusion that I will be popular in whatever position,” she said.

Despite the rocky patches during her term, Lam looks back on her track record with a measure of pride.

“The past five years were very, very exhausting,” she said. “But it was a very fulfilling five years, especially now. Wherever I go [in the city], I can point to my son and say, ‘Your mum has a part to play in this.'”

Known for rarely taking a break from work, she has recently been told to take it easy. Her doctor advised her to control her blood sugar.

However, Lam, looking at her future, says: “It seems I will have no break.”

CONTROVERSIAL POLICIES

2007 Went ahead with Queen’s Pier demolition despite public opposition

2007 Halted attempt by the owner of King Yin Lei to deface the Stubbs Road mansion only after they had started to do so

2008 Came under fire after buildings officers failed to order maintenance work for an old tenement in To Kwa Wan before it collapsed and killed four people.

2009 Announced the demolition plan for the West Wing of the Former Central Government Offices on Government Hill

2010 Curbed a policy that allowed developers to build green features in residential projects at low cost and include them as part of the gross floor area, making the flats look cheaper on a per-square-foot basis

2010 Got lawmakers to amend the law of compulsory sale for redevelopment, making it easier for developers to acquire old buildings

2011 Launched a “flat-for-flat” option under the new Urban Renewal Strategy. It offered new replacement flats for homeowners affected by URA projects, though the owners have to move to smaller homes if they get the option for free

2011 Announced plans to make Ho Tung Gardens a monument. The owner objected and some lawmakers hesitated to pay billions of dollars to the owner as compensation

2012 Cracked down on illegal additions to village homes, prompting fierce opposition from villagers.

IN HER WORDS

If a prerequisite for this open forum was to require the government or myself to pledge a “no-relocation, no-demolition” for Queen’s Pier, then, sorry, I can’t do it.

July 2007: on the demolition of Queen’s Pier in Central

I have never seen a developer willing to scale down its projects by this much … it has fulfilled corporate social responsibility.