Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

September, 2011:

HK government’s pet projects based on flawed assumptions

South China Morning Post – 1 Sept. 2011

Tung Chung resident’s judicial review exposes major shortcomings in the administration’s assessment and approval of infrastructure developments.

The recent judicial review of the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau bridge project has highlighted a policy snarl-up, which surpasses even this government’s uncanny talent for getting into a tangle.

It calls into question not only the assumptions underpinning the bridge project, but also the economic arguments advanced by the government to justify its other pet infrastructure projects, including the proposed third runway for Hong Kong International Airport.

Things began to go wrong for the government when Tung Chung resident Chu Yee-wah applied for a judicial review of the Hong Kong- Zhuhai-Macau bridge, saying the government’s environmental impact assessment of the project failed to meet its own standards for gauging the likely effect on local pollution levels.

The judge agreed and overturned the project approvals granted by the Environmental Protection Department. The government has appealed and a decision is expected towards the end of this month.

But even if the appeal court upholds the original approvals, Chu’s challenge exposed major shortcomings in the government’s procedures to assess and approve infrastructure projects.

Usually an environmental impact assessment provides a baseline scenario based on recorded data to show what air quality would be like if the project did not go ahead. Then it gives a projection of local air quality with the project in place (and any other projects that are planned) so the public can get an idea of the likely effects.

But the assessment for the bridge project neglected to include this background scenario. It simply asserted that air quality in 2031 with the bridge in place will meet the government’s objectives.

There are several big problems with this approach. As the judge in the initial review hearing pointed out, it treats the environment as a bucket into which pollutants can be poured until it is full.

The assessment says nothing about the amount of pollution the bridge and its traffic will actually add to the local atmosphere, which makes it impossible to gauge the environmental cost of the project. That defeats the purpose of the study in the first place.

There are other problems, too. For one thing, there are grave doubts about the use of the government’s model for projecting future air quality. In effect it is a black box. The output is only as good as the data put in, and that is questionable.

According to David Renton, an environmental lawyer with legal firm Baker Botts, the model says air quality will meet the government’s objectives largely because it assumes pollution levels will fall in line with government policies. Unfortunately, there is no assurance this will happen.

There are flaws, too, with the government’s air quality objectives, which dictate acceptable levels for different pollutants. These were fixed in 1987 and have not been changed since, despite an increasing body of evidence that they have been set well above concentrations damaging to human health. That’s especially worrying for inhabitants of Tung Chung, where as the charts (pictured) show, atmospheric levels of toxic pollutants commonly exceed levels that the World Health Organisation say should not be passed on more than one day in 100.

And despite what the government says, it is likely that air quality around Tung Chung will deteriorate. Although the environmental impact assessment for the bridge project predicted that local pollution levels will meet the government’s present standards in 2031, the assessment did not factor in plans to build a third runway at Chek Lap Kok, which will also add heavily to pollution in the area.

What this indicates is that in making its economic arguments for new infrastructure projects, the government has neglected to factor in environmental costs. In particular, it has failed to account for the future health costs caused by the air quality deterioration they will cause.

Given that the government’s economic forecasts for its projects already look stretched, this is a major omission. Add in the environmental and health costs, and it is highly doubtful whether Hong Kong’s prized infrastructure projects will bring the city any net economic benefits at all.

tom.holland@scmp.com

Power Assets’ Sustainability Report 2010

From: kkee@hkelectric.com [mailto:kkee@hkelectric.com]
Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2011 15:07
To: ‘chair@cleartheair.org.hk‘
Subject: Power Assets’ Sustainability Report 2010

(Message issued on behalf of T.C. Yee)

To:      Mr. James Middleton, Chair (chair@cleartheair.org.hk)

Clear The Air

Date:   31 August 2011

Dear Mr. Middleton,

Power Assets’ Sustainability Report 2010

It is my great pleasure to inform you of the publication and release of Power Assets Holdings Limited’s “Sustainability Report 2010”.

Built on our experience of independent social and environmental reporting since 2004 together with the encouraging feedback from our stakeholders over the years, this first annual Sustainability Report titled “On the Road to Sustainability” is prepared and assured to GRI A+ Application Level. The Report illustrates our enduring commitment to the journey towards sustainability. It covers the sustainability issues of Power Assets and provides our stakeholders an overall picture of our economic, environmental and social performances in 2010.

I hope you would enjoy reading the Report.  If you have any views or suggestions regarding our sustainability performance or reporting, please contact me at 3143 3889 or e-mail (tcyee@hkelectric.com).   Please also feel free to tell us your views via the online feedback form of the Report.

Thank you for your continued support.

T.C. Yee

General Manger (Corporate Development)

The Hongkong Electric Company Limited

Power Assets Holdings Limited

ONLINE FULL REPORT : http://www.powerassets.com/pahweb/sr2010/home.htm

Seminar on PM Pollutants

Dear Professors, Students and Colleagues,
Please be informed that a seminar by  Dr. Zhi Ning, Assistant Professor,
School of Energy and Environment, City University of Hong Kong will be held
on 5 Sept 2011 (Monday).

Schedule and abstract of Dr. Zhi Ning’s talk as follows:

Date: 5 Sept 2011 (Monday)
Time: 3:00p.m.
Venue: Room 1003, IENV (Lift 4)

Seminar Title:
Sources and Health Effects of PM Pollutants

Abstract
——–
Air pollution, including particulate matters (PM) and co-pollutants, is
ubiquitous component in the atmosphere exerting important impacts on human
health and global climate. Current air quality standard across different
regions is based on PM10 and/or PM2.5 mass concentration, however, PM is a
highly heterogeneous mixture with particle size ranging from a few
nanometers to a few tens of micrometers, and chemical compositions including
carbonaceous compounds, inorganic ions, heavy metals and trace elements etc.
A better understanding of the physicochemical properties of PM from
different sources is vital in assessing their impact on the environment and
devising emission control and mitigation strategies. In addition, numerous
epidemiological and toxicological studies have documented robust
associations between PM mass and adverse health outcomes. However, in
considering plausible biological mechanisms of injury, prevailing scientific
opinion contends that PM mass, as regulated in air quality standards, is
only a surrogate measure of other physical or chemical properties of PM that
are the actual cause of the observed health outcomes. A shift in the
paradigm for monitoring air quality from the current focus of atmospheric
pollutant concentrations toward identifying the most harmful toxicity
drivers is needed to improve our understanding of the source specific
adverse health effect and to inform policy makers to better protect the
public health. This presentation covers a series of case studies of
characterizing PM from heavy duty diesel vehicle emissions retrofitted with
newest control devices and source identification of ambient coarse PM in
southern California , as well as their potential implication to public
health.

Bio of Dr. Zhi Ning recently joined the School of Energy and Environment in
City University of Hong Kong as an Assistant Professor. He has been a
Research Assistant Professor in University of Southern California and
Aerosol Research Manager of the Southern California Particle Center since
2009 after he received his Ph.D degree in the Environmental Engineering from
University of Southern California . His achievements in the doctoral
research work have been recognized by honoring him as the very first
recipient of the Outstanding Research Assistant Award at USC in 2007. Dr.
Ning has published about 30 peer-reviewed publications in the field of
environmental engineering with a focus on aerosol related research. His main
research interests include the aerosol sources characterization and
identification, instrumentation for pollution control and measurement and
personal exposure assessment.

All are welcome!

For EOs, please forward the above seminar announcement to the faculty
members, staff and students at your Department for me.  Thanks a lot.

Best regards,

Vanessa
______________________________
Program Assistant
Division of Environment
HK University of Science & Technology
Tel. no.: (852) 2358-8362
Fax: (852) 2335-9317