Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

June, 2012:

Finding raises diesel cancer fears

HK Standard

Diesel fumes cause cancer, the World Health Organization declared yesterday.

Mary Ann Benitez and Choya Choi

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Diesel fumes cause cancer, the World Health Organization declared yesterday.

The conclusion, announced after a week-long meeting of a panel organized by the International Agency for Research on Cancer in Lyon, France, may make vehicle exhaust gases as important as a public health threat as secondhand tobacco smoke.

Before this, diesel exhaust had been categorized as “probable carcinogen” to humans.

But now the agency, which is the WHO cancer arm, has made a definitive determination that diesel exhaust does cause cancer.

“Based on sufficient evidence, exposure [to diesel exhaust] is associated with an increased risk for lung cancer,” a statement from the IARC and the WHO said.

“It’s on the same order of magnitude as passive smoking,” Kurt Straif, director of the IARC was quoted as saying by Associated Press.

“This could be another big push for countries to clean up exhaust from diesel engines.”

Straif said there may be many cases of lung cancer connected to the contaminant.

He said the fumes affected groups including pedestrians on the street, ship passengers and crew, railroad workers, truck drivers, mechanics, miners and those operating heavy machinery.

Reclassifying diesel exhaust as carcinogenic puts it into the same category as other known hazards such as asbestos, alcohol and ultraviolet radiation.

A spokesman for the Environmental Protection Department said the government has been “closely monitoring” the WHO study on the health effects of diesel engine emissions.

“As diesel vehicles emissions are the main source of pollution and have adverse effects on public health, the government has enforced a series of measures to control and reduce the emissions of diesel vehicles,” he said.

But Clear the Air chairman James Middleton did not mince words about the “failed” tenure of outgoing Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah.

“He has made 60 overseas trips in 59 months, presumably seeking a source of clean air for Hong Kong during his failed portfolio tenure,” Middleton said.

“His recent Greentech jaunt to Europe where he visited a polluting incineration plant and a Scottish distillery will be of doubtful use to Hong Kong’s environmental problems.

“Roadside pollution has increased during his tenure.”

Officials urged to heed WHO diesel warning

SCMP

News that fumes raises cancer risk means officials should clean up and reduce diesel fleet, groups say
Dennis Chong
Jun 14, 2012

The government should cut the number of diesel-powered vehicles on the streets, and make the remainder less polluting, to protect pedestrians now the World Health Organisation has classified diesel fumes as a cause of cancer, lobby groups say.

WHO experts said that the more diesel exhaust fumes people breathed in, the more they risked getting lung and bladder cancer.

At the end of March, about 130,000 diesel-powered vehicles were registered in Hong Kong.

The Clean Air Network and think tank Civic Exchange claim the government has been too slow in toughening environmental standards for diesel engines.

Clean Air said the WHO’s decision reinforced the need for the government to set out policies to encourage the use of cleaner fuel.

According to the group, more than 80 per cent of diesel vehicles have engines that meet the emissions standards in force in the EU before the year 2000. These pre-Euro-IV- standard vehicles account for most of the city’s emissions of two key pollutants, being responsible for 88 per cent of pollutant particles in the air and 76 per cent of nitrogen oxide.

The European Union has introduced progressively tighter emission standards for vehicles since 1992. Its Euro V standard for buses and trucks was introduced in 2008; the Euro VI standard comes in next year.

Clean Air general manager Helen Choy Shuk-yi said bus companies had been reluctant to upgrade their vehicles on cost grounds.

Mike Kilburn, of Civic Exchange, said it was crucial officials speed up the phasing out of old diesel vehicles.

He also said the government may not be fully informed on the emission levels of construction machinery and other equipment, such as diggers and cranes. “There is no standard for [their] maintenance,” he said.

The government must respond to the WHO findings since people could now easily understand the harm diesel exhaust fumes cause, Kilburn said.

An Environment Bureau spokesman said it had noted the WHO decision and would consider measures to tighten controls. He also said the government was planning new laws to control emissions from machinery and equipment.

The WHO said that while the risk of getting cancer from diesel fumes was small, since so many people breathed in the fumes in some way, raising the status of diesel exhaust to carcinogen from “probable carcinogen” was an important shift.

The WHO’s updated stance was based partly on the findings of a study conducted by the US National Cancer Institute/National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, which found that a wide exposure to diesel-related emissions by 12,300 underground miners increased their risk of death from lung cancer.

Choy said she expected the WHO to revise its pollution benchmarks along with the latest decision.

“Hong Kong will then fall far short of international standards in terms of its air quality benchmarks,” she said.

The government says it will toughen air-quality targets in 2014.

dennis.chong@scmp.com

Waste Management

Milestone: By 2020, waste is managed as a resource. Waste generated per capita is in

absolute decline. Recycling and re-use of waste are economically attractive options for

public and private actors due to widespread separate collection and the development of

functional markets for secondary raw materials. More materials, including materials

having a significant impact on the environment and critical raw materials, are recycled.

Waste legislation is fully implemented. Illegal shipments of waste have been eradicated.

Energy recovery is limited to non recyclable materials, landfilling is virtually eliminated

and high quality recycling is ensured.

Download PDF : com2011_571

European Council adopts WEEE Recast

http://www.letsrecycle.com/news/latest-news/weee/european-council-adopts-weee-recast

8 June 2012

The Recast of the WEEE Directive has been formally adopted by the European Council of Ministers, its final step before entering EU law.

European Environment Commissioner Janez Potočnik confirmed that the Council had formally adopted the Recast yesterday, commenting on social networking site Twitter: “Council finally adopted the WEEE recast today – should see 85% of waste electronic equipment recycled in 2020. In EU, 20 kgs per person!”

With the Recast receiving formal approval from the Council of Ministers, the Directive will become law once it enters the Official Journal of the European Communities. Member States will then have 18 months to update their national legislation to comply with the changes.

Janez Potocnik has welcomed the WEEE Recast approvalJanez Potocnik has welcomed the WEEE Recast approval

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) is expected to introduce legislation in 2013 to bring the UK in line with the requirements of the Recast, and last week launched a call for evidence about ahead of implementing measures to make the WEEE system less costly for businesses (see letsrecycle.com story).

The Recast will see Member States subject to new targets for recycling waste electricals above the current target of 4kg per person. As of 2016, 45 tonnes of WEEE will need to be collected for every 100 tonnes put onto the market in the three preceding years. These targets will then rise further in 2019 to a rate of 65 tonnes from every 100 put onto the market.

Widened scope

The Council has widened the scope of the legislation to cover all electric and electronic equipment, such as photovoltaic panels, equipment containing ozone-depleting substances and fluorescent lamps containing mercury. These items will have to be collected separately and properly treated six years after the legislation enters into force.

The Directive will also establish greater producer responsibility, by encouraging design and production of EEE to take repair, upgrading, re-use, disassembly and recycling into full account.

Retailers of electrical items whose shop space covers at least 400m2 will be required to provide facilities for customers to return small WEEE (no more than 25cm) free of charge or show that an alternative system is equally as effective.

Tougher restrictions on the illegal export of WEEE, to prevent waste electricals from being processed in countries where conditions are hazardous to workers and the environment are also set to be introduced. The measures will see exporters made responsible for proving that goods are being shipped abroad for repair or reuse

Call to revise EU incineration rules

http://www.packagingnews.co.uk/news/eu-incineration-rules/

The European Commission should revise 2020 recycling targets set in the Waste Framework Directive to ensure that there is no incineration of waste that could be recycled, according to MEPs.

A resolution stating that the EU should maximise resources to kick start the economy was adopted by the European Parliament yesterday [24 May].

Valuable materials should be recovered instead of landfilled or incinerated and taxation should penalise resource waste to help boost the EU’s competitiveness, say MEPs.

The European Parliament said that the Commission should revise the 2020 recycling targets set in the Waste Framework Directive and ensure, by the end of the decade, that there is no incineration of waste that could be recycled or composted.

“The European Parliament and the European Commission have laid down ambitious plans to tackle resource use. It is now up to the member states to pick up the gauntlet and fight for resource efficiency.

“Implementation of my report would mean economic growth, creation of jobs and protection of the environment. What are we waiting for?” said rapporteur Gerban-Jan Gerbrandy after the resolution was adopted with 479 votes in favour, 66 against and 63 abstentions.

Call for landfill ban

The European Parliament’s resolution calls for a gradual phase-out of landfill of waste and calls on the Commission to make proposals to that effect by the end of 2014.

EU industry and consumers stand to gain from better designed products, say MEPs, who call on the Commission to propose an update to the eco-design directive to include non-energy related products and to demand better durability, recyclability and reparability of goods. Labelling should also provide consumers with guidance on resource use and environmental impact.

Taxation and subsidies

Parliament has urged Member States to shift towards environmental taxation, which MEPs state should allow cuts in other taxes, such as those on labour. Incentives, such as reduced VAT on certain secondary materials, could also help to correct market failures and promote innovation.

MEPs also call on the Commission and Member States to come forward with plans to eliminate environmentally-harmful subsides by 2020, echoing previous Parliament resolutions.

The public sector can play a further part by tightening rules on “green public procurement”, say MEPs, who call on the Commission to look into applying such environmentally-friendly conditions on EU-funded projects.

Resource efficiency plans

To expand improvements in resource use, MEPs call on the Commission to create task forces to develop European Resource Efficiency Action Plans in the areas of food and drink, housing, and mobility.

BAA’s third Heathrow runway plans back on the agenda

http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/jun/10/baa-third-heathrow-runway-plans?newsfeed=true

Description: Aerial view of planes on apron at London Heathrow Airport, UK

A government policy change will allow proposals for a third runway at London’s Heathrow airport to be submitted by BAA. Photograph: Ben Cawthra/Rex Features

The government will not block BAA from submitting proposals for a third Heathrow runway in a forthcoming revamp of policy on aviation hubs, in a move that heads off the threat of legal action by the airport owner.

A senior representative of the London mayor, Boris Johnson, said the government would allow BAA to push for expansion of Britain’s largest airport. Daniel Moylan, the mayor’s aviation policy chief, said it did not mean a third runway was back on the government’s policy agenda.

“Boris Johnson understands that for legal reasons the government is going to have to allow examination of every option. But this should not be taken as expressing a preference for a third runway,” said Moylan. Johnson is the most prominent political backer of a new airport in the south-east, with options including a new site in the Thames estuary. However, he is against the expansion of Heathrow.

The government is launching two aviation documents in July: a consultation on a “sustainable aviation framework”; and a request for options on maintaining airport hubs in the UK. If BAA lobbies for a third runway through the latter, according to one industry source, the government could use the principles established in the sustainable aviation study to rule it out emphatically or resurrect it.

“If a third runway at Heathrow can meet requirements for a sustainable aviation policy, it will be sifted through for consideration. If it cannot, it will be sifted out. That is a robust and entirely legal position to take,” said the source.

A senior aviation industry source said the options document would allow for a third runway submission, amid speculation that BAA will seek a judicial review if it is barred from submitting an argument for expansion. “The document will be carefully worded so as not to exclude any potential options for increasing hub airport capacity,” said the source.

The Department for Transport said the government remained against a third runway. “The coalition’s position regarding Heathrow has not changed,” it said.

The shadow transport secretary, Maria Eagle, said: “The only way we are going to get agreement on a long-term strategy is if ministers finally take up our offer to work together on a cross-party basis to develop a sensible alternative to the rejected Heathrow third runway and the unworkable fantasy Thames estuary proposals.”

However, allowing a submission on Heathrow expansion will increase fears among third-runway opponents that senior government figures are nonetheless sympathetic to BAA’s case. Those concerns are shared by Johnson’s camp, which believes high-profile campaigning by business leaders and Willie Walsh, the boss of International Airlines Group, is having an effect. Johnson is concerned that his lobbying for more airport capacity in the south-east will bolster the campaign for a reversal on Heathrow, instead of boosting his calls for a new airport.

Those fears have been stoked by an apparent softening in the vehemence of David Cameron and George Osborne’s opposition to new runways in the south-east. The prime minister said in March that he was “not blind to the need to increase airport capacity, particularly in the south-east“. A few days later, in the budget, Osborne made a pointed call to confront the lack of runways in the London area.

Zac Goldsmith, the Tory MP for Richmond, on Sunday reiterated his threat to stand down as an MP if his party backtracked on Heathrow.

SCMP letter

Incinerator plan is a disgrace

I refer to James Middleton’s letter (“Ash from incinerator is hazardous”, June 7), citing hazards associated with incinerators, and wish to point out that the use of such facilities to get rid of waste is basically the same as dumping this waste into our oceans.

Burnt waste is turned into gases; they stay with us and are then dissolved into rain clouds, and then the rain falls into our oceans. Most incinerators are located to allow emissions to discharge into the sea to reduce the impact to us land-dwellers.

Modern incinerators, such as the integrated waste management facilities being proposed in Hong Kong, merely ensure that emissions are odourless and invisible to the naked eye. However, no greenhouse gas will be captured, which will affect global warming. The Environmental Protection Department and minister Edward Yau Tang-wah, who are promoting these waste facilities, are a disgrace for not protecting our environment.

Nigel Lam, Kowloon Tong

Tony Blair avoids attempted citizen’s arrest in Hong Kong

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2012/jun/14/tony-blair-avoids-citizens-arrest/print

:

Tony Blair avoids attempted citizen’s arrest in Hong Kong

British activist interrupts former prime minister’s speech with accusations of war crimes

Share29

Peter Walker

guardian.co.uk, Thursday 14 June 2012 13.19 BST

Tony Blair was delivering a speech at the University of Hong Kong in his role as founder of the Tony Blair Faith Foundation. Photograph: Antony Dickson/AFP/Getty Images

The list of places where Tony Blair must look over his shoulder for protesters during his endless carousel around the global lecture circuit now includes Hong Kong, after a speech on faith and globalisation was interrupted by an activist seeking to make a citizen’s arrest on the former prime minister.

Tom Grundy, a Briton living in the Chinese territory, said he walked towards Blair a few minutes into the address at Hong Kong University (HKU) with the intention of apprehending him for alleged offences connected to the Iraq war.

The 29-year-old said he had registered online to attend the talk, which took place on Thursday evening local time. Although Blair makes considerable sums as a paid-for speaker, this event was a more personal engagement, marking a link between HKU and his own Tony Blair Faith Foundation. Grundy carried with him a sheaf of notes about the legal basis for the attempted arrest, covering, he said, alleged violations of the UN charter, the Nuremberg principles, and the Geneva and Hague conventions.

“I waited till he’d been speaking a minute or so before I stood up and went towards him and said, ‘Mr Blair, under Hong Kong’s Power 101 law – the law which allows for citizen’s arrest here – I’ll be arresting you for crimes against peace’,” Grundy told the Guardian shortly afterwards.

“There was a gaggle of photographers just in front of him. As I tried to pass through them to him, one of the gentlemen with him prevented me from going any further.”

To his surprise, Grundy said he was not bundled away by Blair’s guards or campus security and eventually left after the police, who he hoped would assist in arresting Blair, failed to arrive. He was not arrested and was allowed to stay on campus.

The protester said he was himself “too flustered” to note Blair’s reaction. “He gave the usual line about ‘That’s democracy in action’,” Grundy said. “He was talking about faith and globalisation, and I made the point to him that he can’t speak about religion when he’s set back religious tolerance by decades.”

Such protests have become an increasingly common feature of Blair’s agenda since he left office. Last month, his testimony to the Leveson inquiry into the media was interrupted by an activist who shouted that the former PM should be arrested for war crimes. David Lawley-Wakelin, 49, gained entry to the room at the Royal Courts of Justice via an unguarded rear staircase.

Grundy said: “I think he’s so used to it now, and that’s part of the idea, to let him know that he should have to endure this wherever he goes. If he’s at an event and the press are around, someone needs to remind him that he’s a war criminal.”

© 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

What a waste

http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTURBANDEVELOPMENT/0,,contentMDK:23172887~pagePK:210058~piPK:210062~theSitePK:337178,00.html

Download PDF : What_a_Waste2012_Final

Emission of heavy metals from animal carcass inc… [Chemosphere. 2004] – PubMed – NCBI

So you are what you eat, clank clank

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15081760
Chemosphere. 2004 Jun;55(9):1197-205.

Emission of heavy metals from animal carcass incinerators in Taiwan.

Chen SJ, Hung MC, Huang KL, Hwang WI.

Source

Department of Environmental Engineering and Science, National Pingtung
University of Science and Technology, Nei Pu, Pingtung 91201, Taiwan.
chensj@mail.npust.edu.tw

Abstract

The metal emissions from three incinerators burning different feedstock in
Taiwan were characterized in this study. It was found that the Incinerators
A and B, treating pig carcasses and animal (including pigs) carcasses,
respectively, had much higher metal concentrations in stack flue gases than
Incinerator C that combusted medical wastes. However, Incinerator A
obtained relative lower metal contents in fly ash and bottom ash than the
other two incinerators, mainly because the former used a much lower
feedstock rate (although burning at a lower temperature) than the latter.
For all the incinerators, (1) Fe, Ni, Pb, and Zn were dominant in both the
fly ash and bottom ash while most of the Cd and Pb (more volatile) were
present in the fly ash; (2) Fe emission factor was the highest and
Zn/Pb/Ni/Cr emission factors were greater than those of Mn/Cd/Cu; (3) the
Cu emission factors in bottom ash were relatively higher in comparison with
those in fly ash; and (4) indicatory metals were the same (Fe, Zn, Pb, and
Cu). The metal emission factors obtained from the livestock incinerators
were much higher than those reported from MSW incinerators. Likewise,
crematories that burn human cadavers must create similar pollution issues
since metal supplements are part of human’s normal diets. This causes an
environmental concern and this work has important ramifications both in
technical and regulatory decisions.

Copyright 2004 Elsevier Ltd.