Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

June, 2012:

Road Side Pollution and Cardiovascular Disease

Kunzli et al (2010)’s study indicates an association between exposure to traffic-related air pollution and the progression of atherosclerosis in humans.

Download PDF : Kunzli (2010) – Ambient Air Pollution & the Progress of Atherosclerosis in Adults

Government to curb worst sources of pollution in Macau

http://www.macaudailytimes.com.mo/macau/36200-government-to-curb-worst-sources-of-pollution-in-macau.html

The result of a public consultation conducted on Macau’s 2010/2020 Environmental Protection Plan will be revealed within two months. “We are arranging the opinions of different sectors”, explained Cheong Sio Kei, Director of the Environmental Protection Bureau (DSPA) during a press conference held yesterday in occasion of the “2012 Macau Environmental Week”.
Cheong Sio Kei did not reveal the date for a final report, which includes measures that the government will take. When questioned about the plans the Government will carry out in light of the most recent report on the environment that shows deteriorating figures, the Director said they are studying new measures together with a science institution in South China. “We are going to work together with competent authorities in order to reinforce the quality of the environment and we are studying the establishment of maximum figures concerning the worst sources of pollution in Macau.” Cheong also stressed that after having defined the limit of exhaust fumes for motorbikes in 2008, the maximum quantity of exhaust fumes for cars in Macau is being analyzed. Therefore, DSPA is working together with the Transport Bureau. The criteria for “eco-vehicles” have already been published on the DSPA website. “We are not entitled to define a limit for the number of cars circulating in Macau”, Cheong said, “but we think that through the elimination of vehicles that are producing a high amount of pollution, we can contribute to the control of the number of cars.” The DSPA is also studying the use of electric cars in Macau.
Cheong mentioned the work is being carried out in conjunction with Zhuhai authorities in order to tackle pollution at the Canal dos Patos. In addition to the regulation of exhaust fumes, Cheong thinks there should be an independent consultation to analyze construction works that are established in natural areas.
The DSPA Director presented activities organized for the “2012 Macau Environmental Week” that will take place between June 3rd and 9th in order to commemorate “World Environment Day” on June 3rd. In collaboration with several governmental departments and associations from the cities and regions of Guangzhou, Hong Kong, Zhongshan, Zhuhai, Shengzhen and Dongguan, DSPA is organizing activities on Tap SeacSquare that aim at promoting the “reduction of waste at the source”.
The activities include a range of events related to daily life. The aim is to inspire the citizens to include environmental protection into their daily routine. According to research from 2011 on Macau citizens’ knowledge on environmental protection, the participation in environmental protection measures “was too low”.

It’s only ‘simple air pollution’

SCMP Laisee 10 June 2012

It’s only ‘simple air pollution’

We see that the government has failed in efforts to block a judicial review of the Shek Wu Chau incinerator. This will go ahead in November. But we have to say we were unimpressed by the remarks of the government’s counsel Johnny Mok Shu-luen SC at the court hearing. Pointing out that the government was not required to carry out a hazard assessment with respect to the proposed incinerator, he remarked, “We are talking about simple air pollution…It’s not going to be life-threatening. It’s only going to have a very limited impact.”

We know he is only doing his job, but it is disturbing to hear such offhand comments about air quality. Is he reflecting the thinking at the Environmental Protection Department? We think our learned friend should look at the Hedley Environmental Index, which can be found at http://hedleyindex.sph.hku.hk/home.php. There he will see that the number of avoidable deaths due to air pollution last month alone amounted to 200. The economic loss in terms of air pollution-related burden of disease and loss of productivity amounted to HK$42.5 billion last year and is HK$15.3 billion so far this year.

So much for “simple air pollution”, Mr Mok.

LCQ16: New Air Quality Objectives

Hong Kong (HKSAR) – Following is a question by the Hon Abraham Shek Lai-him and a written reply by the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, in the Legislative Council meeting today (June 6):
Question:

The Government proposed in January 2012 a set of new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) which lays down the atmospheric concentration limits for seven pollutants together with a host of air quality improvement measures to help Hong Kong achieve the AQOs. However, in the new AQOs, the concentration limits of four pollutants (i.e. sulphur dioxide (SO2) (24-hour mean), ozone, respirable suspended particulates and fine suspended particulates (PM2.5) (annual-mean and 24-hour mean)) fail to match the highest levels prescribed in the World Health Organization (WHO)’s Air Quality Guidelines published in 2006, and the green groups have criticized the Government for taking a “half-hearted” approach to implement the air quality improvement measures. In addition, it has been reported that according to the China Statistical Yearbook 2011, Hong Kong’s nitrogen dioxide level ranks 31st out of 32 major cities in China. In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:

(a) whether the Government has considered the public health impact with limits of SO2 (24-hour mean) and PM2.5 benchmarked against WHO’s Interim Targets and Air Quality Guidelines; if it has, of the details; if not, the reasons for that; whether it knows any details of affirmative overseas examples in which limits comparable to those in the new AQOs are adopted; of the principles considered and views from the public consultation in 2009 which affirm the proposed limits;

(b) given that it has been reported that the Ministry of Environmental Protection on the Mainland has proposed a tougher limit for nitrogen dioxide than that of Hong Kong, whether it will consider imposing a standard at least on par with that proposed by the Ministry; if it will, of the details; if not, the reasons for that;

(c) whether it has considered the difficulties construction projects will encounter and additional compliance cost they will incur in securing approval against the new AQOs under the Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance (Cap. 499), including but not limited to, as reported, the proposed construction of the third runway at Hong Kong International Airport the emission level of nitrogen dioxide of which may exceed the proposed limit; if it has, of the details with any follow-up mitigation measures taken in alleviating the situation; and

(d) given the absence of any government figures in evaluating the public health impact of air pollution, whether the Government has considered establishing a mechanism similar to the Hedley Environmental Index in assessing the public health impact of air pollution and publicizing the real-time information on the impact; if it has, of the details with the expected cost and manpower resources involved; if not, whether it has considered any ways besides the established measures in enhancing public awareness of the health impact of air pollution?

Reply:

President,

(a) In setting our new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs), we have made reference to the recommendations of the World Health Organisation (WHO) as well as the standards of other advanced places. When the WHO published its new Air Quality Guidelines (AQGs), it also reminded governments that they should consider their own local circumstances carefully before using the guidelines directly as legal standards. It also pointed out that the standards set in each country will vary according to specific approaches to balancing risks to health, technological feasibility, economic considerations and other political and social factors. In fact, WHO also recommends interim targets as incremental steps in a progressive reduction of air pollution in more polluted areas and to promote a shift from concentrations with acute, serious health consequences to concentrations that if achieved, would result in significant reductions in risks to health. Such progress towards the guideline values should be the objective of air quality management and health risk reduction in all areas.

The AQOs we are proposing have been drawn up in accordance with the above WHO guidelines .As far as we know, no country has fully adopted the WHO’s ultimate guidelines values as their statutory air quality standards. Apart from suspended particulates which are under strong regional influence, our new AQOs are on par with those of other advanced countries, such as the European Union (EU) and the United States (USA).We have adopted the WHO’s ultimate AQGs in their entirety for three of the seven major pollutants (i.e. nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide and lead) and in part for another pollutant (i.e. sulphur dioxide).

In addition, we will review every five years the feasibility of tightening the AQOs and formulate corresponding air quality improvement plans.

As for sulphur dioxide (SO2), the 10-minute limit in the proposed AQOs has already benchmarked against the AQG of WHO and the 24 hour-limit is same as that of EU (i.e. IT-1 of WHO), which is on a par with the standard currently adopted by advanced countries/economies. This has been reduced by more than 60 per cent comparing to the existing AQO value.

We note that our PM2.5 level has been under strong regional influence. The particulate matter emissions of Hong Kong and the Pearl River Delta region are in the proportion of 1:99.The particulate concentrations of Hong Kong are, therefore, under strong regional influence. While we and the Guangdong Provincial Government have already endeavoured to implement a number of measures to improve regional air quality, taking into account the regional influence, we would not able to update the air quality objectives for suspended particulates with just one go, but have to take a more practical approach. We propose the WHO IT-2 for respirable suspended particulates (PM10) be adopted. With fine suspended particulates (PM2.5) accounts for about 70 per cent of PM10 found in Hong Kong, we propose to benchmark its level at WHO IT-1.

(b) The new national standard for annual nitrogen dioxide (NO2) proposed by the Ministry of Environmental Protection is the same as ours and WHO’s ultimate AQG. In addition, the WHO currently has not established any 24-hour limit for NO2.Our practice is in line with other countries such as EU, USA and Australia.

(c) Following the introduction of the new AQOs, to obtain the environmental impact assessments approval, it will be necessary for designated projects to demonstrate their air quality impacts will meet the new legal standards. When updating the AQOs, the Government has also put forward a basket of 22 new air quality improvement measures to help reduce ambient air pollutant levels. At the same time, when the proposed objectives have become legal standards, designated projects have to implement adequate and appropriate mitigation measures in areas of design, construction and other operation standards, where necessary, to meet the legal requirements.

(d) Implementation of the proposed new AQOs and air quality improvement measures will help alleviate air pollution problems and bring about health benefits, including reduction of number of people admitting to hospitals due to asthma or other respiratory illnesses. According to the Consultant’s study report, implementation of the recommended Phase 1 emission control measures would lead to an anticipated benefit of about $1,228 million annually due to improvement in public health, which is significantly higher than the estimated annualized cost of about $596 million to be incurred by the society. The Consultant also estimated that some 4,200 hospital admissions could be avoided because of the improvement measures. In addition, the average life expectancy of the population would be increased by about one month or around 7,400 “life years” saved each year. In addition, the existing Air Pollution Index (API) has been providing a simple way of describing air pollution levels in Hong Kong. To tie in with the updating of the AQOs, we will correspondingly review and improve the existing API system.

Source: HKSAR Government

Air Pollution Fuels Hospital Visits in Hong Kong

http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2012/05/31/air-pollution-fuels-hospital-visits-in-hong-kong/

Deteriorating air quality in Hong Kong is sending more people to hospital, says a new survey.

According to a pair of researchers at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, who examined day-to-day pollution levels and hospital visits over a six-year period, a rise in airborne pollutants in Hong Kong was associated with a rise in emergency hospital visits.

Published in Environmental Health Perspectives, the study, led by professor Yu Tak Sun Ignatius and Ph.D candidate Hong Qiu, comes as residents report increasing levels of frustration with the city’s pollution. In 2010, a survey found that one out of four Hong Kongers have considered leaving the city because of its air quality, up from one in five in 2008, according to local think-tank Civic Exchange. A few years ago, the director of the city’s Philharmonic Orchestra had his family do just that, packing them up and moving them to Wisconsin, citing frustration with the city’s lung-choking air.

A previous study by the University of Hong Kong this year suggested that air pollution was responsible for some 3,200 annual deaths in Hong Kong(pdf). Businesses consistently rank pollution as one of their top issues of concern in moving staff to Hong Kong, particularly those with young children.

Mr. Yu and Ms. Qiu found that every 10 micrograms per cubic meter daily increase in coarse airborne pollutant particles resulted in a 1% increase in emergency hospital admissions for respiratory disease, or an additional 830 hospital admissions.

The study controlled for other kinds of pollutants, including PM2.5, superfine air particles dozens of times thinner than a human hair, which Hong Kong and mainland China only began publicly monitoring earlier this year. While such superfine particles are the greatest source of concern for public health experts, because of how they can penetrate the body’s organs, the Hong Kong researchers also found that so-called “coarse” particles—including those between 2.5 and 10 micrometers in size—likewise “have a high impact on public health,” said Ms. Qiu.

“These coarse particles shouldn’t be ignored,” said Ms. Qiu, who says the city’s future air quality objectives should adopt standards that explicitly address such particles. “They can also cause cardiovascular and respiratory disease.” Even short-term exposure to heavy air pollution, experts say, can prompt heart failure, arrhythmias and stroke.
– Te-Ping Chen. Follow her on Twitter @tepingchen

Leung aide sees no need for third runway

SCMP

City can’t cope with more visitors disrupting our daily lives, says former Observatory chief
Cheung Chi-fai
Jun 09, 2012

A former Observatory director and adviser to the incoming chief executive has questioned the need for a third runway and the scope of the environmental impact study proposed for the huge project.

Lam Chiu-ying, who helped incoming chief executive Leung Chun- ying develop his environmental platform, said the HK$130 billion project was not sustainable.

The city simply did not have the capacity to deal with more visitors, he said.

“Does the airport need to grow indefinitely? Can it? I don’t think it fits into our reality. The number of tourists visiting Hong Kong is approaching capacity. If we want to avoid our lives getting further disrupted, I don’t see any incentive for us to expand the airport.”

The extra runway is forecast to generate HK$900 billion in long-term economic benefits. But Lam believes it shouldn’t be built because it will trigger a string of negative chain reactions in the daily lives of Hongkongers.

Lam also questioned whether the Airport Authority would weigh the environmental impact carefully enough. The project calls for the reclamation of 650 hectares of sea north of the two existing runways.

Lam fears the reclamation will lead to irreversible changes in the flow of water between Tuen Mun and Lantau, degrading the water quality.

Lam’s comments, made on his personal blog, come just a few days before Monday’s deadline for public comments on the profile of the runway project.

The profile, which spells out the potential impact of its construction, is the first step in activating the statutory environmental impact assessment study process.

After that, the Environmental Protection Department will issue a study brief – a detailed list of guidelines on the scope and technical requirements of the study.

The department has already received 140 submissions since posting the profile on its website on May 29.

Friends of the Earth made its submission yesterday, demanding that the profile include studies of air pollutants including nitrogen dioxide and fine particulate matter.

The group also criticised the profile for omitting any mention of the potential health impacts of increased air, land and marine traffic on the more than 200,000 residents of Tung Chung new town.

The Clean Air Network shared those concerns. “Many important issues are not explored in depth in this profile, and that gives us a great deal of concern,” campaign manager Erica Chan said.

Lam is calling on the public to voice their concerns about the project.

chifai.cheung@scmp.com

Professor’s trips raise questions

SCMP 9/6/2012

Professor’s trips raise questions

Lai See (“Burning question over rubbish trips”, May 26) has revealed that a Baptist University professor who has received a number of research grants from the Environmental Protection Department in recent years and is an advocate of incineration is organising a trip to Taiwan.

This is to be paid for by the Environment and Conservation Fund, http://www.ecf.gov.hk/en/home/index.html on whose funding committee the professor sits.

This visit, together with a similar one to Singapore when 50 people were invited, appears to be a government exercise in “manufacturing consent” (using Noam Chomsky’s phrase for brainwashing).

Does not this report raise the interest of the directorate of audit, and the chancellor of the university, in regard to the use of public funds and academic independence? If not, why not?

S. P. Li, Lantau

Beijing’s condemnation of US pollution figures a smokescreen for dirty air

SCMP

June 09, 2012

Shooting the messenger is never a good idea, especially when people’s health is at stake. Yet that is what the Chinese government seems intent on doing to US diplomatic missions, which since last year have been issuing data on the smallest and most harmful air pollution particles, PM2.5, in three cities. Deputy Environment Minister Wu Xiaoqing has called for an end to the service, condemning it as a violation of national laws and diplomatic codes of conduct. His criticism is not only unreasonable but unjustified – and worse, ignores the risks posed by poor air in China’s heavily polluted cities.

It was those potential threats to health that prompted first the US embassy in Beijing, and then its consulates in Shanghai and Guangzhou, to fill a gap for American expatriates. Informing about PM2.5 particles, which can lodge deep in the lungs and enter the bloodstream, is common practice in developed countries, but until this year, not on the mainland or in Hong Kong. Chinese officials have collected PM2.5 data, although not released it, instead issuing information about larger PM10 particles, which makes air readings look better than they really are. In Beijing, that meant results were good or excellent 80 per cent of the time, contrasting sharply with those from the embassy showing just 20 per cent of days as acceptable.

Unsurprisingly, word of the discrepancy got around and became a major topic of discussion on microblogs, embarrassing the central government and prompting it to call on cities to follow suit. There nonetheless has remained a gap in readings, explained away as being down to different standards. But whether those of the World Health Organisation are followed, as the US does, or lower ones are adhered to, the fact remains that numbers alone are not enough. Monitoring and releasing information is pointless unless measures are also taken to make the air healthier. A nation’s success relies on the health of its people. Criticising the United States for highlighting a failing is a smokescreen for grievous inaction.

Legco approves loan to Harrow

SCMP

Teachers’ union head says it’s wrong to use public money to fund the school and critics see loan as sign of collusion between government and private sector
Ada Lee
Jun 09, 2012

The Legislative Council yesterday approved a HK$273 million interest-free loan to the exclusive Harrow International School for construction of its premises.

The loan is to meet “part of the construction costs of its new school premises” in Tuen Mun, and is part of the government’s commitment to support the international school sector to meet the demand for places for foreign families, according to a government document to the Finance Committee.

But Fung Wai-wah, president of the Hong Kong Professional Teachers’ Union, doubted the legitimacy of using taxpayers’ money to fund the school. Some critics also see the loan as another sign of collusion between the government and the private sector.

Harrow will be the first international school with boarding facilities in Hong Kong. It is expected to accommodate 400 primary and 750 secondary pupils when the first phase of construction is completed. There will be 99 classrooms, a boarding house, swimming pool, fitness room, an outdoor sports field and other facilities, the paper said.

Construction for Harrow’s premises is supposed to be completed by the end of the year. The first phase of the construction is expected to cost HK$878 million.

“As a non-profit-making organisation, [Harrow] can only obtain a bridging loan for the construction of school premises from private or commercial sources with the backing of the government’s interest-free loan,” the government paper said.

“The provision of an interest-free loan to [Harrow], which provides non-local curriculum for the international community in Hong Kong, will help in facilitating the provision of additional international school places to meet the demand.”

But Fung said taxpayers’ money should be used in a better way.

“Although generally speaking, the school is nonprofit, it’s not right to use public money to fund a school with abundant resources.”

He said the lack of international school places in Hong Kong should be alleviated from the root of the problem.

“There are many international schools in Hong Kong. It’s just that some are taken up by local students. We may have to rethink how to allocate those places to those who are really in need.”

The 3.7-hectare site at So Kwun Wat was allocated to the school in 2009, along with three other sites for international schools. Harrow is required to reserve at least half of its places for non-local students. The school’s first batch of HK$600,000 debentures sold out last year.

A report from moving consultant firm Crown Relocations in February found that only two international schools on Hong Kong Island, and four in the New Territories and Kowloon, had vacancies for Primary One pupils. The report surveyed 37 international and English Schools Foundation schools popular with expats.

Government figures show there is growing demand for British curriculum school places, driven by a 35 per cent growth in the British population in Hong Kong in the past five years.

ada.lee@scmp.com

Govt denies treating Harrow generously

RTHK

09-06-2012
The government has dismissed allegations that it has given preferential treatment to Harrow International School.

Local newspapers have speculated that generous offers concerning rent and loans might have been granted under pressure from the Chief Executive, Donald Tsang, because of his son’s romantic relationship with the niece of the director of Harrow’s management company.

The school is being charged a nominal 1-thousand dollars in rent annually, for a site in Tuen Mun that is worth up to 1.4 billion dollars.

Legco’s Finance Committee has just approved a 270-million dollar loan – interest free – for Harrow to build its campus.

But the Undersecretary for Education, Kenneth Chan, said everything was above board and legal.