Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

August, 2011:

Curious contradiction between the model and the reality

South China Morning Post – 3 Aug 2011

A recent report by the think tank Civic Exchange, “Roadside Air Pollution in Hong Kong: Why is it still so bad?”, draws attention to the curious contradiction in the government’s figures on polluting emissions. The Environment Bureau’s public consultation document – “Air Quality Objectives Review” – trumpets the success of what the bureau likes to call the “series of stringent measures” it has put in place since 1990 to reduce emissions from various sources, such as power stations and vehicles.

By 2007, it said, these measures had led to a decline by roughly half in the pollutants sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, respiratory suspended particulates, volatile organic compounds and carbon monoxide. These figures are derived by modelling, rather than by actual measurement.

That is, the government creates a model, based on the theoretical performance of these sources. However the bureau’s report also contains another set of data, showing the concentrations of the same pollutants as either flat or increasing. This data is based on empirical monitoring of the air.

The bureau notes this contradiction somewhat obliquely, in terms that could have come straight out of the British television programme Yes Minister’s guide to bureaucratic language: “It is apparent that the extent of the air quality improvement is not commensurate with the extent of emission reduction achieved over the past two decades …”

Firstly, one has to wonder why the bureau chose to play up the data derived from its model, rather than the data measuring the actual state of the air.

Secondly, Civic Exchange’s paper, by Dr Michael Edesess, a visiting fellow at the Hong Kong Advanced Institute for Cross-Disciplinary Studies, argues that the government’s model is flawed, in that it depends on the different sources performing at optimal level. In theory, a bus with a Euro V-standard engine produces six times less polluting emissions than a bus with a Euro I-standard engine. But if the Euro V bus is poorly maintained, then its emissions can be up to 20 times greater then its theoretical design. Edesess says that the difference in emissions between well and poorly maintained vehicles can be enormous. He notes that studies in the US city of Denver showed that “since 1999, one automobile in 20 emits more than the other 19 combined”.

He says the bureau’s model does not take account of poorly maintained vehicles. Edesess concludes that there needs to be more stringent inspection of vehicles and penalties for poorly maintained vehicles.

However, as a number of groups have been saying for some time, the government needs to introduce a more attractive scheme of accelerated depreciation and give subsidies to bus companies and truck owners to scrap their old vehicles. This is money that would be well-spent, but it’s not a programme the government shows any sign of taking any interest in, despite paying lip service to its concern for public health

Get rid of polluting vehicles

South China Morning Post – 1 August 2011

Kowloon Motor Bus (KMB) has complained about rising fuel costs and says the government should create a stabilisation fund for the firm. Giving public money to a for-profit enterprise is a dangerous path to take.

However, it seems to me that this debate opens the door to a greater opportunity.

On the one hand, it is true that fuel costs are increasing. On the other hand, bus and minibus fleets are still largely gas-guzzling, pre-Euro V vehicles.

It would seem obvious that it would be of use for the government to spend a few billion dollars that it has in its reserves to upgrade these fleets to hybrid/Euro V vehicles.

This would greatly reduce roadside pollution levels, lower the operational costs for bus operators and benefit all citizens.

Combine this measure with regulations mandating emission levels for vehicles over the long run (10 to 20 years) to avoid operators’ inertia and I think we would have a win-win solution. As a bonus, it would also make redundant the current idling engine legislation, which is virtually unenforceable.

KMB’s responsibility to optimise its routes would still hold if it wanted to compete with other operators.

I would say this is better use of government funds than the HK$6,000 handout to permanent residents.

J. C. Clement, Tai Kok Tsui

Better use of buses the way forward

South China Morning Post – 1 August 2011

Hit by soaring fuel prices, a few transport operators have called for government subsidies to support their operation one way or the other. Last week, the holding company of Kowloon Motor Bus (KMB) issued a profit warning in the coming months despite a 3.6 per cent fare increase in May. It suggested the government inject what it called “seed money” in a fund to buffer oil price changes and to ease pressure for future hefty fair increases. The Star Ferry appears to be following suit, calling for similar subsidies to avoid bigger fare rises.

The proposals, if adopted, may set a dangerous precedent for taxpayers subsiding private business. The two transport operators are not the only victims of rising oil prices. Everywhere enterprises have to streamline operations as well as exhaust cost-cutting and revenue measures to keep businesses viable. But having said that, KMB has reasons to worry in that any fare adjustment requires approval from the Executive Council. The process is a protracted political tussle and there is no guarantee they will get what they want. For instance, the increase sought by KMB was slashed from 8.6 to 3.6 per cent by the government, The decrease in passenger figures, from 2.64 million a day in 2009 to 2.55 million in the first half of this year, also adds uncertainty to its bleak outlook.

There have been suggestions that the fund could be used to make up for the gap in the fare increase sought and eventually approved. Apart from a government injection, the fund could be financed by KMB profits when its return exceeds a certain level. The proposal appears to be attractive at first glance. It may spare passengers hefty increases. But if such a buffer is to be set in place, the company may lose its incentive to enhance competitiveness and performance because of such a fallback. Besides, if business prospects are as bleak as what KMB has estimated, it seems unlikely that the company will be in a position to contribute to the fund.

The government has rightly quashed any hopes of such an ill-conceived proposal being taken further. It has asked a legitimate question – why should taxpayers subsidise bus passengers? KMB warned that if no action is taken the unavoidable outcome will be that the company folds. Such threatening remarks will not help to win it public support in tackling the difficulties it is facing.

The bus operator says 60 per cent of its routes are losing money. However, any plans to merge underused routes may cause inconvenience to passengers and face opposition. But half-empty buses running on the road are both wasteful and polluting. It is to be hoped that public opinion will now swing to support route rationalisation, an essential step to better utilise its 4,000-vehicle fleet.