Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Fine-Particulate Air Pollution And Life Expectancy

Improvements in life expectancy among Americans during the 1980s and 1990s were associated with reductions in fine-particulate air pollution…

Title: Fine-particulate air pollution and life expectancy in the United States

Authors: CA Pope III, M Ezzati, DW Dockery – Reference: N Engl J Med 2009; 360: 376-386,

Reviewer: Robert Goldberg, PhD, Contributing editor, ProCor; Professor of Medicine and Epidemiology, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, Massachusetts, USA

Problem addressed: Air pollution in the US and life expectancy.

Purpose of study: To examine the association between changes in fine particulate air pollution during recent decades and life expectancy in Americans residing in major metropolitan areas.

Location of study: United States

Study design: Investigators of these ecologic and cross-sectional analyses utilized data from a variety of sources to examine the a asociation between changes in average life expectancy over the period 1978-1982 and 1997-2001 with declines in fine particulate air pollution among residents of 211 county units in 51 major metropolitan areas throughout the US. To this end, data from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Inhalable Particulate Monitoring Network, other air pollution monitoring sources, and national mortality data were collated and analyzed. Age standardized death rates from lung cancer and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) were also utilized as proxy indicators of accumulated exposure to cigarette smoking, which may have acted as an important potential confounder.

Results: In the initial period examined (1978-1982), average life expectancy in the US was 74.3 years whereas average life expectancy increased to 77 years during the most recent period under study of 1997-2001. During the period of improved life expectancy, ambient concentrations of fine particulate matter declined in each of the metropolitan areas examined whereas the death rates from lung cancer and COPD increased.

A variety of cross-sectional and regression analyses were performed to examine the association between changes in the concentrations of air pollutants and increases in life expectancy while controlling for several sociodemographic variables and proxy indicators for cigarette smoking. A decline of 10 ug per cubic meter in the concentration of ambient fine particulate matter was associated with an estimated increase in average life expectancy of slightly more than six months.

Comments: The results of this observational study suggest that improvements in life expectancy among Americans during the 1980s and 1990s were associated with reductions in fine particulate air pollution as measured by various sources in major metropolitan areas throughout the US. While other factors were associated with increases in average life expectancy during the years under study, improvements in air quality were estimated to have contributed to as much as 15% of the overall increase in life expectancy observed.

The results of the present study, which were based on the best data available to the investigators with its inherent strengths and weaknesses, provide encouraging support for the health benefits associated with improvements in air quality noted throughout the US over the past several decades. This has been a direct result of significant discussions and efforts to improve air quality by the EPA and other federal and local agencies.

While there are ongoing concerns with the state of the US economy, and much needed increases in health related sources of funding, the results of the present study suggest that efforts directed at improving the air that we breathe have paid significant dividends with regards to improving life expectancy in Americans. Efforts to improve the quality of the air that Americans (and those of all nations) breathe, and the water they drink, need to be continually encouraged as topics of environmental concern might be placed on the back burner during these difficult economic times. Broad policy level efforts remained needed, as well as efforts that each person can do more of, such as driving their automobiles for fewer miles (with concomitant increases in physical activity), need to be continually encouraged to improve both the general environment as well as our quality and duration of life.

Green-lung Vision Strikes Terror In Officials’ Hearts

Stephen Vines, SCMP – Updated on Feb 13, 2009

Very occasionally someone comes up with a brilliant idea for improving Hong Kong and, almost always, it strikes terror in the hearts of the bureaucrats who run this place. The architect Rocco Yim Sen-kee has had an idea of this kind. It involves creating a magnificent green lung in the middle of Hong Kong Island, running from the Zoological and Botanical Gardens in Central to Victoria Park in Causeway Bay. This green corridor would be achieved by linking existing parks with a network of boulevards surrounded by trees and other vegetation stretching from above Central to the harbourfront and creating a zone of calm in the midst of bustle and pollution.

The ingenuity of the plan lies in the way it links what exists with what could be built with relatively little effort. But an enormous amount of determination and vision for it involves cutting (very modestly) into the fortress which Government House has become and possibly infringing on the new government palace, or headquarters as it is formally known – which, as it happens, Mr Yim has designed.

You can almost sense the nervous twitching of the bureaucrats as they contemplate an idea that involves such revolutionary thinking. Indeed, it would not be surprising if those on the front line of obstructing new ideas were already reaching for a familiar set of adjectives to put down the plan. In bureaucrat-speak, these would include assertions that the plan is far too idealistic (a very bad word in government circles), that Mr Yim is well intentioned but naive (a catch-all description of anything that requires imagination), and, of course, there is always the trump card of declaring the scheme impractical because it involves a lot of work.

By coincidence, on the day Mr Yim revealed his plan, an alliance of non-governmental organisations launched an appeal to the Town Planning Board to impose a height restriction on the latest official plan for destroying the historic Central Police Station complex which is now in the hands of that well-known conservation body, the Jockey Club.

It’s the same old story – the government is full of ideas for destroying Hong Kong’s heritage and ominously challenged when it comes to building anything new that is less than ghastly. Anyone doubting bureaucrats’ love of the ugly and absurd need only glance at the Central Library in Causeway Bay.

Meanwhile, a growing number of citizens have decided enough is enough; the destruction of Hong Kong’s heritage in the name of progress has gone too far, and they are arguing that the government should no longer try measuring progress by the amount of concrete poured but should look at ways of improving the environment on a human scale.

Mr Yim’s plan provides an ingenious way of better utilising the precious few green spaces in the middle of the city, even though it should be noted that there are probably more concrete than green areas in both the Victoria and Hong Kong parks. This plan would not create anything resembling a natural green habitat but it would cleverly carve something special out of the scarce green areas.

Why, then, is it close to certain that the bureaucrats (and their good friends in the property development
community) will oppose a scheme of this kind? It is not that the bureaucrats are necessarily full of bad intentions or that they are simply too lazy to work on a scheme that requires more effort. Such an assertion is unfair, particularly to some of those in the bureaucracy who are genuinely trying to create a better environment.

However, institutionally, the bureaucracy is inclined to avoid plans for transforming the existing infrastructure. Instead, bureaucrats love grand plans that involve knocking things down and building something grand anew. They see such schemes as their legacy projects and even dare to hope that one will eventually bear their name. If anyone deserves recognition for a great idea, it is Mr Yim but, alas, he is not a bureaucrat.

Stephen Vines is a Hong Kong-based journalist and entrepreneur

Air Standards To Reveal Priorities

SCMP – Updated on Feb 13, 2009

Soon, the government will replace the hopelessly outdated air pollution index (API). What it decides to replace it with will give us an insight into the government’s priorities. If the government is most concerned about the health of Hong Kong people it will adopt strict pollution guidelines.

These will allow for much less air pollution than the current standards and will drive down pollution when they are used to evaluate future developments, such as agreements with Guangzhou. The downside is that, in the short term, we will exceed these guidelines almost every day and so Hong Kong may get some bad press.

If the government is mostly concerned about public relations, it will adopt very lax guidelines. These may be only slightly stricter than the current API and will do nothing to fix the pollution problem or improve the health of Hong Kong people. By doing this, the government may successfully evade the bad press, but at a cost to our lungs.

Let us see what it does.

William Hayward, Wan Chai

Idling Engine Ban Necessary

SCMP – Updated on Feb 04, 2009

When will Hong Kong stop debating and simply do the right thing and ban all idling vehicles? It is a shame that any vehicle is allowed to sit and idle for more than five minutes. Engines should be switched off to reduce emissions, oil pollution and noise pollution.

I have read that idling vehicles slow down the catalytic converter, which is what helps keep emissions down, but only works when it is hot.

If a vehicle is going to be sitting for more than 30 seconds it is better to shut it off, even though turning it on will use a burst of gas.

While an hour of idling can produce 2.36kg of carbon dioxide in a car, imagine what all these public and tourist buses produce?

We’ve heard it all before, but Hong Kong still has a growing number of people with asthma, lung and heart conditions who would welcome the idea. What is more, this pollution hurts Hong Kong’s tourism and attractiveness as a place of work.

D. F. Weil, Kowloon Bay

Clean Air Prolongs Life

Medi watch – Jerome Watson – SCMP – Updated on Feb 02, 2009

Cleaner air increased life expectancies in 51 US cities by a “remarkable” five months, on average, and by double that in what were the worst polluted areas, say researchers from Brigham Young and Harvard universities, based on an analysis of data over two decades. By 2000, Americans were living 2.72 years longer, on average, than 20 years earlier, with as much as five months of that gain due to reduced pollution, AP reports. “Such a significant increase … is remarkable,” says team leader Arden Pope.

Sore Throats Thanks To Air

Updated on Jan 24, 2009 – SCMP

I live in Kowloon East near the sea and on Thursday and Friday the air was filthy.

There was an obvious burning smell like a barbecue.

My children started coughing at night and we all needed to limit our time outdoors to avoid sore throats and general discomfort.

Based on this very crude performance indicator of the air smelling like London in the 1800s, the government’s performance is poor.

Even the “ban” on idling engines is too much for officials to handle properly.

It is very hard to take the Environmental Protection Department seriously.

The economic downturn will finally do more to help air quality than the department can organise itself.

P. Gilbert, Lam Tin

Follow WHO Guidelines

Updated on Jan 24, 2009 – SCMP

Perhaps now is a good time to draw the chief executive’s attention to research recently published in the New England Journal of Medicine.

This suggests that reducing the current level of air pollution to that of the World Health Organisation guidelines would extend his life (and that of the rest of us) by nearly three years.

David Chappell, Lamma

Air Quality Standards Review

The following letter was sent to the Director of Environmental Protection by Clear The Air:

Director of Environmental Protection – ENB

24th January 2009

Air Quality Standards Review

Dear Sir,

We are writing to express our NGO’s concern that Hong Kong’s air pollution is damaging local residents’ and visitors’ health and that the Administration’s belated current measures to address the problems remain ineffective whilst simply reporting platitudes.

Hong Kong is an extremely wealthy and developed first world city with ample resources to reduce air pollution , given the will to do so, and yet we know from the Hedley Environmental Index that last year alone 1,155 people died prematurely, there were over 83,000 avoidable hospital bed days, and 7.25 million doctors’ visits which were directly attributable to the toxic effects of local air pollution; this was at a minimum conservative cost of over HK$2.3 billion to society. We also know that for the major part of the year, the major pollution sources were locally generated. Our local power stations in 2007 burned 3 times more coal than they did in 1997 and 40% less gas than in 1999. Their greed is killing people. Perhaps you should suggest Exxon executives come and live here with their children ?

Given this evidence, we call on the Administration to demonstrate its commitment to imminent improvement of public health and reduction of resultant health costs by setting the World Health Organization’s Air Quality Guidelines as the new Air Quality Standards for Hong Kong, and to set out a strategy on how it intends to achieve these Standards. Without gazetted Standards the ‘Polluter Pays’ principle cannot be effective.

In this strategy please address all the major sources of pollution, but please apply particular urgency to reducing emissions from marine vessels and non Euro V diesel on road / off road vehicles. We encourage you to enact large increases in road tax for non Euro V diesel trucks, vans and buses (thereby making these vehicle owners trade up to Euro V) and to insist forthwith on low sulphur bunker fuel use within Hong Kong waters. We appreciate that the emissions from local power stations might soon be reduced following your Department’s belated requirement that flue gas desulphurization equipment is installed as well as Nox burners. In addition the level of the Standards you set MUST therefore require the power companies apply Best Available Current Technology and fuel mix and that includes agglomerators which can catch the lethal PM0.1 ultrafine and PM2.5 heavy metal emissions which the Electrostatic Precipitators cannot currently catch.

We would stress that Air Quality Standards and a clean air strategy that do not lead to rapid improvements in public health cannot be considered an acceptable outcome of the Review and action is required, not further consultation of a public that has already grown tired of this Government’s lack of decisive action.
Yours faithfully,

James Middleton
Chairman Energy Committee

Health Concerns As Hong Kong Pollution Levels Rise

23rd Jan 2008 – AFP

HONG KONG (AFP) — Thick smog enveloped Hong Kong again on Friday, as scientists and campaigners said recent pollution had reached levels ten times above annual World Health Organisation guidelines for clean air.

The heavy haze descended on the city, blocking views across the financial hub’s famous Victoria Harbour and raising serious health concerns.

The Hedley Environmental Index, a website created by professors at Hong Kong University and think tank Civic Exchange, said levels of breathable particles in some areas were 10 times recommended annual WHO levels on Friday.

Levels of nitrogen dioxide and sulphur dioxide were five times WHO annual guidelines, the index found, making Thursday Hong Kong’s most polluted day in more than 12 months.

“This is smog, not fog,” said Alexis Lau, a professor at Hong Kong University for Science and Technology.

“The worst part is that most of these are fine particulates which are the most detrimental to our health.”

According to the government’s own air pollution index, levels in the heavily populated areas of Hong Kong were still “very high” on Friday, or well over 100 on the official scale.

When the government index is above 100, people with existing heart or respiratory problems are advised to stay indoors.

Hong Kong’s government is currently in the process of renewing its air quality guidelines, which are now more than 20 years old. Scientists say they are woefully out of date.

Pollution has in recent years become an increasing health and economic headache for the financial hub.

Emissions from the southern Chinese factory belt over Hong Kong’s northern border have combined with local emissions from power plants and transport to park a thick haze over the city for large parts of the year.

The Hedley Environmental Index, which combines air quality and public health data, puts the associated costs of the city’s poor air at 12.5 billion Hong Kong dollars (1.6 billion US) since the start of 2004.

It has, it said, [Hong Kong air pollution] caused more than 6,100 premature deaths.

HK Pollution Levels 10 Times Clean Air Guidelines

23 Jan 2009, 1633 hrs IST, AFP – The Economic Times

HONG KONG: Thick smog enveloped Hong Kong again on Friday, as scientists and campaigners said recent pollution had reached levels ten times above annual World Health Organisation guidelines for clean air.

The heavy haze descended on the city, blocking views across the financial hub’s famous Victoria Harbour and raising serious health concerns.

The Hedley Environmental Index, a website created by professors at Hong Kong University and think tank Civic Exchange, said levels of breathable particles in some areas were 10 times recommended annual WHO levels on Friday.

Levels of nitrogen dioxide and sulphur dioxide were five times WHO annual guidelines, the index found, making Thursday Hong Kong’s most polluted day in more than 12 months.

“This is smog, not fog,” said Alexis Lau, a professor at Hong Kong University for Science and Technology.

“The worst part is that most of these are fine particulates which are the most detrimental to our health.”

According to the government’s own air pollution index, levels in the heavily populated areas of Hong Kong were still “very high” on Friday, or well over 100 on the official scale.

When the government index is above 100, people with existing heart or respiratory problems are advised to stay indoors.

Hong Kong’s government is currently in the process of renewing its air quality guidelines, which are now more than 20 years old. Scientists say they are woefully out of date.

Pollution has in recent years become an increasing health and economic headache for the financial hub.

Emissions from the southern Chinese factory belt over Hong Kong’s northern border have combined with local emissions from power plants and transport to park a thick haze over the city for large parts of the year.

The Hedley Environmental Index, which combines air quality and public health data, puts the associated costs of the city’s poor air at 12.5 billion Hong Kong dollars ($1.6bn) since the start of 2004.

It has, it said, caused more than 6,100 premature deaths.