Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Exhausting work

stick and carrot race

Last updated: March 12, 2010

Source: South China Morning Post

In a letter to the SCMP, Christine Loh Kung-wai,  chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange, had this to say:

If Hong Kong doesn’t get the “carrots and sticks” formula right, it will continue to be hard to replace the old and highly polluting commercial diesel bus and truck fleet. There is no doubt about the harm these vehicles cause. Government data shows they are the principal emitters of roadside pollution, accounting for 88 per cent of the highly health-damaging particulates and 76 per cent of nitrogen dioxide, another pollutant.

Overseas research shows that those living within 500 metres of busy and congested roads are the worst affected. Negative health impacts include asthma, allergies, impaired lung functions in children and cardiovascular problems for the elderly.
(more…)

Prof Wong Tze Wai’s opinion on Air Pollution in Hong Kong

Prof Wong Tze Wai

12th Feb, 2010

Professor Wong Tze Wai is an environmental epidemiologist and occupational physician with experience in public health practice and research over a wide variety of topics. If you want to read his opinion on air quality in Hong Kong, click here to download.

Health lawsuits a possibility

SCMP, Tania Willis, Lantau

Feb 11, 2010

Last month The American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine published the results of studying pollution and its immediate effects on young and healthy people.

The article states that subjects exposed to heavy pollution (Beijing, Mexico City) showed prothombotic (blood clotting) and cardiac “disregulation” occurs after just two hours of exposure. This article came in the same week that Hong Kong saw some of the densest pollution yet (January 28) and it seems very likely people in the most highly polluted areas of our city are likely to be exposed to the same level of threat to their health.

With the example of smokers suing tobacco giants, if our government does not care about our health, isn’t it at least concerned about the potential for future lawsuits for failing to protecting the public’s health, particularly when the danger of pollution is this well-known?


Deadly air pollution on the increase in Hong Kong

Want to do sports in HK? There are only 30 days in HK which the air is safe to do sports outside according to the WHO guidelines.

Want to do sports in HK? There are only 30 days in HK which the air is safe to do sports outside according to the WHO guidelines.

A report in Hong Kong media last week says the city and its surrounding areas experienced life-threatening levels of air pollution one in every eight days last year.
The South China Morning Post reports figures from the Environment Protection Department showing there were 44 days of ‘very high pollution’ reported in Central, on Hong Kong island. In some areas air quality has deteriorated five-fold in just five years, and there are criticisms that official records do not show the whole picture.

Click here to read the report from New York Times.

Presenter: Bo Hill
Speaker: Gerald Winnington-Ingram, Clear the Air Hong Kong

WINNINGTON-INGRAM: We have now in Hong Kong a situation where we only have 41 days of healthy breathable air according to the WHO guidelines per year. Irrespective of the fact that you cannot see anything which is a shame, because it really is a beautiful city and a beautiful place to be living, the health implications are very, very serious and you certainly would not want to be doing any physical exercise on one of those days. We have only some 30 days in which it is safe to do sports outside and then according to the WHO guidelines.

HILL: Are there particular areas of Hong Kong, say Central or the New Territories, that suffer worse than elsewhere?

WINNINGTON-INGRAM: There are. For example, Nathan Road, which is an extremely popular tourist destination – well there we have nitrogen dioxide levels at some 380 milligrams per cubic metre and that’s well in excess of WHO guideline which is for 200 milligrams per cubic metre and in fact even Hong Kong’s own air quality objective is for 300, so it’s well in excess of that. So that’s Nathan Road. Plus also parts of the Central District – Des Voeux Road, which is a major thoroughfare running through the central business area, that has a reading of around 390 milligrams per cubic metre of nitrogen dioxide. Hennessy Road is another one which is in Wan Chai, again a very popular local area – 480. So these are areas you certainly don’t want to be going in at all on a bad day. But if you’re suffering from any form of respiratory disease or heart complaint, it is actually very dangerous. We had in 2008, over 1,000 avoidable deaths, some 81,000 avoidable hospital days as a consequence, something in the order of seven and a quarter million avoidable doctors visits and all of that amounts to the cost in the order of about 230 million Hong Kong dollars, which could have been avoided. Now that doesn’t even take into account all the other ailments such as coughs, sore throats and itchy eyes, that were not even reported.

HILL: So huge costs, not only monetary but also physically. What’s been done about it and can Hong Kong authorities be doing more?

WINNINGTON-INGRAM: Well, I think they could be doing a lot more and we certainly and other green groups are campaigning extremely hard. Fifty three per cent of air pollution is local and it’s actually Hong Kong is the dominant source. Yes, we do get air pollution coming from the Pearl River Delta of course, but roadside pollution which is a major problem in Hong Kong is caused by local conditions. Some 50 per cent of Hong Kong’s total emissions is also being caused by power plants. Forty per cent of roadside emissions have been caused by buses. The government’s figures go nowhere close to showing the real picture and the real affect of air pollution in Hong Kong.

source: Radio Australia‏
http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/connectasia/stories/201001/s2791277.htm

Air pollution influence Children’s health

Dr. Hedley from Department of Community Medicine, School of Public Health
University of Hong Kong had just hosting a talk about the Early childhood development and air pollution on 26th November.

If you are interested in the content, please download the pdf file attached.

hk-ecdrf-2009

Tourism legislator should take fight for clean air to the streets

Edward Yau Tang-wah was testing electric car outside Legislative Council. Will Mr. Yau agree the car park beside Legco should closed down, or he need to encourage the peers to use electric car? (Source: Ming Pao)

Edward Yau Tang-wah was testing electric car outside Legislative Council. Will Mr. Yau agrees the car park beside Legco should close down, or he needs to encourage his peers to use electric car? (Source: Ming Pao)

When Paul Tse Wai-chun, the Legislative Council representative for tourism, was asked about the effect of recent record street-level pollution on tourism, he responded that the government was doing its best to remedy the situation. Really?

When we can no longer take our tourists to Mong Kok to visit the street markets, because the pollution levels are so high there, we have to question what the administration is doing.

Very little, judging by the ever-present PCCW, Hutchison 3G and CSL promotion minibuses that are parked on the streets of Mong Kok, hogging drop-off points and forcing other vehicles to double park and block the traffic.

At metered facilities, vehicles covered in promotional banners are parked there for no reason other than to provide a low-cost but highly visible advertising medium. This is despite the fact that commercial activities are prohibited at parking meters.

Some of this activity, and the accompanying illegal parking, is taking place within sight of Mong Kok police station. Where are the traffic wardens and patrolling officers who should be on the streets, writing tickets and getting the traffic moving?

Last week, while enjoying the serenity of Kowloon Park, I was asked to move out of the way to allow some government cars to drive by. What were these cars doing inside a public park, particularly when there is an MTR station close by?

It is high time that the car park beside Legco was closed down and Legco members and government officials forced to walk on the streets with the majority of the population.

We expect our Legco members to battle for the right of tourists and locals to clean air, not to recycle the feeble excuses that the Environmental Protection Department trots out about pollution coming from across the border.

It is being generated right here on our streets, under our noses. Take action, Mr Tse.


Source: SCMP, Martin Brinkley, Ma Wan

Fresh thoughts

SCMP

Any cross-border clean-up of air pollution must require co-operation among regional authorities. Opportunities for strong collaboration can be created and sustained, but Hong Kong must make this happen. A good place to start is our own government’s consultation on reviewing local air quality standards.

I’m often asked whether people across the border are sufficiently aware about environmental problems to want to do something about them. Studies clearly show a high level of public concern in the Pearl River Delta. In 2001-2002, when Civic Exchange worked with a Shenzhen organisation on the first environmental survey of public attitudes in the PRD, air pollution ranked third among people’s environmental concerns, behind food safety and clean drinking water. At the time there had been a spate of illnesses linked to contaminated food and water.

Further studies since then provide a clearer picture of what our neighbours think. In 2007, the mainland-based Horizon Research Consultancy Group surveyed the environmental attitudes of residents in 10 major cities. Among the nation’s many severe environmental problems, the health affects of air pollution was the leading concern. Urban air pollution was ranked the most urgent national environmental problem by 64 per cent of respondents. These results were corroborated by a Pew Global Attitudes Survey last year that found 74 per cent of Chinese respondents said air pollution was a serious problem.

Curiously, when residents in the 10 cities were asked in 2007 to rate their local air quality, many thought it was good or even very good. This may indicate that people have become accustomed to heavy air pollution and did not have sufficient information to know the severity of pollution. For example, half the residents of Beijing thought their city had moderate air quality, even though available data showed it was poor. Only 14 per cent said air quality was bad or very bad. In the case of Hong Kong’s neighbour, Guangzhou, 38 per cent thought air quality was good or very good, 32 per cent thought it was “neutral” – neither good nor bad – and only 30 per cent thought it was bad or very bad. Nevertheless, among the 10 mainland cities, Guangzhou residents were the least happy with the local air quality.

The 2007 survey tested whether residents thought economic growth was more important than environmental protection. A substantial majority, 77 per cent, favoured environmental protection even if it had negative impacts on the economy. The survey also explored people’s choice if the city were to set up a business that could provide more than 1,000 jobs but would cause pollution at the same time. Sixty-six per cent said they would object to it.

Some may argue that the mainland economy in 2007 was in much better shape and that people might respond differently today. This may be true but the point is the survey tells us mainland city dwellers are willing to consider sacrificing a degree of economic growth for a better environment.

In terms of how to improve environmental conditions, the mainland respondents wanted better public policies, higher penalties for offenders, better environmental technology, and improved laws and regulations. They also thought the most effective way to make their voices heard was through the media, local neighbourhood committees and even complaining directly to the authorities.

These findings provide a useful foundation to move ahead. Hong Kong’s moves to clean up its air through cleaner power plants and factories, integrated land use, cleaner fuels and electric vehicles, improved traffic management and other policies will set the pace for the rest of the nation.

By working closely with Shenzhen and Guangzhou to clean up shipping- and port-related emissions, Hong Kong can help the region adopt green port policies that are on par with those in the US and Europe.

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange. cloh@civic-exchange.org

Socioeconomic disparities in air pollution-associated mortality

Elsevier Inc. – 26 November 2007

Abstract

This study aimed to determine whether individuals with lower socioeconomic status (SES) were more susceptible to the acute effects of ambient air pollution than those with higher SES. We included 24,357 Hong Kong Chinese aged 30 or above who died of natural causes in 1998. Information on individual socioeconomic characteristics was obtained by interviewing proxy informants with a standardized questionnaire in all four death registries. Individual SES was indicated by three measures: type of housing, occupational group and education attainment. Poisson regression was performed to assess the short-term effects of ambient air pollution measured by PM10, NO2, SO2 and O3 on mortality for each SES group. The differences in the effects between SES groups were estimated by the interaction between air pollution and SES. We found that PM10 and NO2 were associated with greater risk of mortality on people living in public rental housing than in private housing. The effects of all four pollutants were significantly greater in blue-collar workers than the never-employed and white-collar groups (p<0.05). However, we found no compelling evidence of effect modification by education attainment. Our results provide new evidence on the role of individual’s SES as effect modifiers of the short-term effects of air pollution on mortality. The reduction of risks associated with air pollution for socially disadvantaged populations should be a high priority in public health and environmental policies.

More information on: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6WDS-4S7HSDP-1&_user=10&_rdoc=1&_fmt=&_orig=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_searchStrId=942173795&_rerunOrigin=google&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=a4db5b5a6fb74c4ffb2a8b12af10a3c9

Road Particles Pose ‘Higher Risk’

By David ShukmanEnvironment correspondent, BBC News – 9 June 2009

Children may be at greater risk from the microscopic particles in traffic pollution than was previously thought.

Early findings from a major study in London seen by the BBC show that the lung capacity of 8- and 9-year-olds is 5% lower than the national average.

And 7% of the children – surveyed in the Tower Hamlets area – have lung function reduced to a level internationally regarded as hazardous.

The London study is being led by Professor Jonathan Grigg.

He works out of the Centre for Paediatrics at Barts and the London School of Medicine and Dentistry.

Leaf clues

The particles – so-called “particulates” – are produced in vehicle exhaust and are far smaller than the width of a human hair.

Less than 10 microns across, they are often referred to as PM10.

The results come as researchers at Lancaster University warn that levels of particulates are often higher than shown by official monitoring devices.

Analysing the particulates collected on roadside leaves, the research shows that the pollution can be most intense at the height of many children.

Britain already faces penalties from the European Union for multiple breaches of standards for particulate pollution.

Professor Grigg told BBC News: “Our findings in the East End of London are that children living here have slightly lower lung function than what we’d expect from the national average.

“Now, if that’s due to air pollution, as we suspect, they’re going to be at increased risk from a range of respiratory disorders such as asthma and infection, and may be at risk in adulthood.”

Cough test

A total of 203 children at 10 different schools are taking part in regular tests over several years.

Interim findings from 149 children show that 11 of them have lung capacity that is 80% or lower than the national average – a threshold regarded by researchers as vulnerable to a range of breathing conditions.

One test involves encouraging the children to cough – so the carbon content of their sputum can be analysed.

Microscope analysis shows how particulates are reaching deep into the lungs. These results will add pressure on the government over Britain’s failure to meet European Union air quality standards.

The EU requirement is for average PM10 concentrations to stay below 40 micrograms per cubic metre of air – but most of the country’s major conurbations record higher levels. And the new research by Lancaster University shows that the particulate
levels may be even worse than official figures show.

The official data is gathered at automatic monitoring stations which typically sample air at a height of three metres – mainly to avoid the risk of vandalism.

But Professor Barbara Maher and her team have devised a new technique for measuring the magnetic response of particulates on roadside leaves – many of the particles contain fragments of metal.

And the readings show higher concentrations of particulates at lower levels.

‘Progress made’

Interviewed beside a busy road in Lancaster, Professor Maher said: “We’re
surrounded by this invisible mist of these millions of toxic particles – you can’t see them but we know, we’ve measured them, they’re here. “When we do our leaf magnetic measurements, our research shows that down at small child height the concentrations – the number – of these very fineparticles is sometimes twice the current EU regulation standard.”

One set of measurements, outside the Cathedral School in Lancaster, revealed particulate levels that were above the EU standard. The school’s head, Anne Goddard, said the findings were “quite worrying”.

“It’s the only playground we have at the school and it’s right next to the road. The levels are high so obviously the effect on the children, especially those with asthma, is a concern.” The Environment Secretary Hilary Benn admits there is a problem but says 24 out of 27 members of the European Union are in breach of the standards and that most of the landmass of Britain does meet the requirements. He also said that “huge progress” had been made in the last few decades with the Clean Air Act and changes in vehicles standards. “But we need to do more and principally that will be about cars and lorries and buses,” he said. “And we’ve been working with other countries in Europe to improve the standards to get these PM10 particles down because we know it has an effect on our health.”

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/science/nature/8092182.stm

No More Bottled Water!

http://d.yimg.com/kq/groups/3171822/439419450/name/water-disaster.pps