Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Hazy logic

South China Morning Post

Christine Loh says officials misunderstand the true costs of polluted air by taking the route of ‘develop first, clean up later’

The government was caught napping with regard to Hong Kong’s air quality and then caught fudging the issue. That’s not a pretty picture; our air quality remains a serious daily threat to public health. It’s not that officials don’t want to improve air quality – of course they do – but they still can’t figure out how they can build highways, bridges, runways and incinerators without causing more air pollution. Their priority is to build infrastructure; they believe this is what matters more – you can always clean up later. They don’t see that they can do both.

Earlier this month, Beijing released tighter air quality objectives for the mainland. Hong Kong officials didn’t seem to know this was going to happen. It put pressure on them to come to a decision on Hong Kong’s own objectives after two years of dithering.

They had already been caught out once before: last May, the Ombudsman accepted a complaint from Friends of the Earth that the government was taking far too long to make a decision on revising Hong Kong’s objectives.

Now, officials are hedging. The government has announced it will begin work on an amendment to the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, to be tabled for discussion in the next legislative year – when the current government will, in fact, have stepped down. The delay was said to be necessary because of the time it takes “for completing the legislative process and other necessary preparatory work”.

The law doesn’t actually require a legislative amendment. The environment minister can amend the air quality objectives after consultation with the Advisory Council on the Environment. Since the council meets monthly, he could get this done well before the current administration steps down.

But the government is not going to do that. It wants to make sure there’s a “transitional period” of 36 months before the new air quality objectives take effect. This should give officials enough time to get approval for certain projects, such as a third runway, before the more stringent standards apply.

It would be seen as a disaster for the government if a third runway were not built, whereas putting off the implementation of revised air quality objectives is just a delay. To Hong Kong’s officials, this is being practical. The fact that the new objectives are necessary when considering projects is not acknowledged. The third runway and other new projects will indeed lead to additional air pollution.

Thus, the early implementation of the new objectives is impractical from the government’s perspective. This logic is, of course, diametrically opposite to the aim of having air quality objectives in the first place. Our officials’ objective has shifted from health protection to infrastructure protection.

It is this attitude that got them into trouble in the first place. They have left the cleaning up so late that catching up will require many urgent measures, such as banning old polluting vehicles, pedestrianising urban areas, regulating ships’ emissions, switching energy sources, and more. If the next administration retains the same mindset, it too will keep on fudging rather than pushing for aggressive pollution reduction.

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think tank Civic Exchange.cloh@civic-exchange.org

Hong Kong’s Air Pollution Index is shamefully misleading

South China Morning Post – 27 Jan 2012

In the executive summary of his paper Air Pollution and Public Health, written in 2009, University of Hong Kong Professor Anthony Hedley writes: “There is incontrovertible evidence that pollution levels currently experienced throughout the year in Hong Kong are causing an epidemic of health problems arising from damage to lungs, heart and blood vessels. Hong Kong’s pollution is a significant cause of premature death from cardiopulmonary disorders.

“Present levels of pollution cause injury to the immature developing lungs of children and adolescents. This damage will lead to lifelong health problems in many and a reduction in life expectancy.”

Professor Wong Tze Wai, with the Chinese University of Hong Kong, concluded an earlier paper, Health Impact of Roadside Air Pollution, by observing that: “Roadside air pollution is a cause for concern; levels of air pollutants at roadside are very high; public health is severely affected; needs urgent action to reduce roadside levels…”

Given these dire warnings by acknowledged public health experts, it is curious that roadside pollution does not excite the same sort of fears in the mind of the public as Sars and bird flu, even though it is responsible for far more deaths.

The World Health Organisation says there have been 341 deaths worldwide from bird flu since 2003 and a total of 913 deaths from Sars.

According to the Hedley Environmental Index, which measures the impact of air pollution on public health in Hong Kong, the average annual number of avoidable deaths attributable to air pollution over the past five years is 3,200. That is a total of 16,000 avoidable deaths in Hong Kong over the past five years alone. These figures are arrived at by a peer-reviewed methodology and have not been challenged by the government or the medical profession.

One of the reasons for the apparent lack of concern is that those struck down are not pronounced dead as a result of contracting a disease with a name like bird flu. It is a “silent injury”. People die from toxic attack on their respiratory and other functions.

Another reason for the apparent lack of understanding by the public of the risks posed by air pollution is the government’s Air Pollution Index. This takes the readings from the government’s air monitoring stations and reduces them to one number on a scale of 0 to 500 and divides the scale into five broad levels ranging from low to severe.

The system is explained at: www.gov.hk/en/residents/environment/air/api.htm. The problem is that these measurements are based on Hong Kong’s woefully outdated air quality objectives set in 1987 and hugely understate the health impacts. (See how API relates to air quality objectives (AQOs) at www.epd-asg.gov.hk/english/api_you/apitell.html.

Try comparing the government’s API and the Hedley index (http://hedleyindex.sph.hku.hk/home.php). We did this several days last week when the API index indicated low and “safe to go out”, while the Hedley index, using the same data but calibrated to the World Health Organisation Guidelines, measured “very poor”.

In other words, the API is completely misleading. Or as Professor Hedley called it on RTHK’sBackchat programme, “a complete piece of fiction”. He added: “It’s the government’s responsibility to translate this problem into health risks and to inform people what they are facing and what their children will face in future years – even if they clean up tomorrow.”

So perhaps it is time for Secretary of the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah (Golden Bauhinia) to stop this shameful practice and either publish figures that indicate the true health impacts or to stop publishing this information, which deliberately misleads the public.

Treat bad air problems as a crisis

South China Morning Post Letters

In respect of air quality, the people of Hong Kong want two things.

They want the truth about air quality where they and their children live, work, study and play so that they can make informed decisions as to how best to protect their health and take concerted and urgent action to improve it. They are not interested in targets.

Also, they want to be warned when the air is dangerous to their health and they want the government to start doing something meaningful about it without more years of dithering.

I was impressed and relieved when the administration got rid of all the diesel taxis and some of the diesel minibuses, which had a hugely beneficial effect on air quality back in 2003.

What has it achieved since then? We are still plagued with dirty old buses, minibuses, goods vehicles, ferries and ships, and the power companies have still not cleaned up their act.

The government has a pretty good record when it comes to managing crises. I am sure that the Hospital Authority would say that the steadily increasing cases of respiratory disease amount to a continuing and worsening crisis, so can we please start treating it as such?

Guy Shirra, chairman, Friends of Sai Kung

COURTS, ENVIRONMENT MINISTRY GUILTY OF ARSENIC IN WATER

22 January 2012

(AGI) Rome – The Consumers Association Codacons has reported that the Lazio Regional Administrative Court has sentenced the Health and Environment Ministries to pay compensation amounting to at least 100 euro per consumer for poisoned water in a number of regions (Lazio, Tuscany, Trentino Alto Adige, Lombardy and Umbria) where arsenic was found in the water.
Codacons has said “this sentence paves the way affirming that the public administration is held responsible for providing insufficient or defective or polluting services, which result in stress, damages and pose risks to citizens’ heath. This path will now be followed by those requesting compensation for polluted air and degradation present in Naples, in Rome and in other large cities where standards of living are seriously prejudiced by environmental degradation.”

http://www.agi.it/english-version/italy/elenco-notizie/201201221801-cro-ren1063-courts_environment_ministry_guilty_of_arsenic_in_water

Michael Tien struggles through a fog of information

South China Morning Post – 20 Jan 2012

RTHK’s Backchat programme yesterday produced more fireworks on the topic of Hong Kong’s air quality. Professor Tony Hedley, who is an acknowledged world expert on public health and the environment, described the government’s announcement of new air quality objectives (AQOs) as “disappointing, chaotic, out of control”.

“We have been talking about this for 22 years,” he said. “Today we have some of the worst air quality in the world, certainly by the standard of a developed economy… It is quite clear and I think it is official, the government is prepared to trade off child health in favour of business infrastructure development.”

The new measures “were unlikely to make any meaningful difference to the health impacts of the population”.

Jim Middleton, chairman of Clear the Air, said environment chief Edward Yau should be fired for his dilatory approach to improving the air, adding he must have been instructed to act this way to enable the government to continue with its infrastructure projects.

Mike Kilburn, head of environmental strategy at the Civic Exchange, said it would be challenging to met the mainland’s new objectives while Hong Kong’s would not be since they were so lax and would do little to improve air quality.

So it wasn’t exactly a public relations success for the government.

Some of the lighter moments were provided (unwittingly) by co-host Michael Tien, New People’s Party deputy and former rail bigwig. “Not being very technically oriented in this field, I kind of get the gist of it,” he said, as he painfully took us through his learning curve. “You have economic development, you have infrastructure development and this regional influence…” You would have expected him to have a better grasp of the subject.

CNN Pollution hits Hong Kong health, economy – Business 360 – CNN.com Blogs.mp4

download : Pollution hits Hong Kong health, economy – Business 360 – CNN.com Blogs

Challenge leaves us all out of breath

South China Morning Post – 19 Jan 2012

New emissions targets set for 2014 allow 18 days of levels above the maximum for nitrogen dioxide; the figure for last year was 241 days, shock study shows

http://www.scmp.com/files/SCMP/Opinion/Static%20Files/SCM_News_cartoon.6.jpg

The immensity of the challenge facing environmental officials responsible for cleaning the city’s air has been exposed by a study which has matched their latest targets with last year’s air quality figures.

The worst discrepancy is for nitrogen dioxide, a pollutant generated mainly by vehicles.

The targets for 2014 announced by the Environment Bureau on Tuesday, which are not legally enforceable, allow only 18 days of levels exceeding the maximum for this pollutant.

But if last year’s emissions are repeated, the levels will be in excess for 241 days of the year. Concentrations of respirable particulate matter at least 10 microns wide, or PM10, would exceed the limit by 35 days, but the proposed target is only nine days.

The figures, compiled by the University of Hong Kong’s school of public health for the South China Morning Post (SEHK: 0583, announcements, news) , came a day after the bureau said it would toughen the city’s air quality objectives in 2014.

The new objectives, updating targets formulated in 1987, lay down limits for seven pollutants that are between 10 per cent and 64 per cent more stringent than existing ones.

Critics have slammed officials for the delay in adopting the new objectives and aiming low, as targets for four of the seven pollutants – sulphur dioxide, PM10, PM2.5 and ozone – would be based only on the World Health Organisation’s interim, rather than ultimate, targets.

But officials said targets needed to be practical, as regional pollution – from sources outside Hong Kong’s borders – was beyond its control.

Dr Lai Hak-kan from the University of Hong Kong, who applied the 2011 figures to 2014’s standards, said the WHO suggested no allowances be made at all for most pollutants.

The exception was a three-day allowance for particulate matter, as these levels could be increased by typhoons and dust storms. But Lai said: “Our government sets an even higher nine days for particulate matter, PM10 and PM2.5 [the finest category of particulates, at 2.5 microns].

“Nine days of heavy pollution can cost many lives, especially for people with chronic illnesses. An even bigger problem is that no matter how many days the pollution goes over the limit, the government will, like in the past, face no legal consequences.”

Although the new targets will become statutory requirements after amendments to the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, there will be few legal consequences of a breach, except for infrastructure or construction projects.

When applying for a government work permit for such projects, the owners will have to ensure their works do not worsen the air quality by more than the legal limits.

According to the Clean Air Network, US citizens can take out a civil action against the Environmental Protection Agency if air quality standards are not satisfactory.

And the European Union can withhold funds from regional development projects if there is a breach of air quality standards. But Helen Choy Shuk-yi, general manager of Clean Air Network, said: “The air quality objectives will be meaningless if officials can’t tell us how legally binding they are. Will infrastructure works have to stop if the objectives are not met? Officials are only diverting our attention when they give us those figures.”

A spokeswoman for the Environment Bureau did not respond when asked about any consequences for a breach of the tougher standards.

Secretary for Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah said yesterday that the government would continue to implement the 22 measures identified to improve air quality.

But he reiterated that those measures would come with a cost. “We will have to share the costs,” he said. “By reducing emissions from power plants and making them switch to [natural gas], there may be a 20 per cent increase in electricity tariffs.”

By phasing out old buses with dirty engines, transport fees could rise by 15 to 20 per cent, he added.

Thomas Choi Ka-man, senior environmental officer from Friends of the Earth, criticised the secretary for highlighting just the costs and not the benefits to public health.

joyce.ng@scmp.com

Pollution hits Hong Kong health, economy – Business 360 – CNN.com Blogs

http://business.blogs.cnn.com/2012/01/18/pollution-hits-hong-kong-health-economy/

Description: http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/2012/images/01/17/t1larg.hong.kong.pollution.afp.getty.file.jpg

January 18th, 2012

01:00 AM GMT

Pollution hits Hong Kong health, economy

Posted by:
Andrew Stevens, CNN Anchor

Hong Kong (CNN) – Hong Kong is one of the world’s richest cities. Almost one in 10 households boasts a millionaire. The government sits on a cash pile of about $80 billion. Yet Hong Kongers are choking, sometimes to death, on their own success.

A bold claim, but the statistics are compelling. The Hong Kong University School of Public Health has just unveiled a new real-time cost of pollution index. According to new research from the university and local think tank Civic Exchange, there are 3,200 avoidable deaths a year in Hong Kong due to air pollution – more than three times higher than previous estimates.

As I write this (at 7:15 p.m. HKT Tuesday) the index reports there has been seven preventable deaths and more than 14,000 preventable doctor’s visits in Hong Kong in the 19 hours beginning midnight on Monday. Preventable, because the bad air quality that researchers say was responsible, can be easily improved.

The HKU’s team leader Professor Anthony Hedley – 22 years as chairman of community medicine at the university – says the model they have developed is “state of the art.” Certainly the Hong Kong government has nothing like it. In fact, they have no statistics on pollution-related health costs, and their methods for measuring pollution are, say critics, well out of date.

But even with that technology, the quality of the air at roadside level in Hong Kong is rapidly deteriorating. Roadside pollution levels reached a record high last year. The number of days that pollution was rated “high” hit 20%. That is five times more than in 2005.

And the impact, according to the Hedley Index, has been hard. To take December as an example: 311 people died, nearly 800,000 visits were made to doctors and heathcare experts and days lost at work cost the economy about $60 million.

But clean air campaigners say the level of roadside pollution could be brought to within acceptable World Health Organisation levels within weeks.

Roadside pollution is the chief cause of pollution-related respiratory illness in Hong Kong, according to Mike Kilburn of the thinktank Civic Exchange. He says that if the government spent some of their cash reserves in a cash-for-clunkers scheme to take dirty trucks and buses off the streets, then air quality would improve dramatically. Instead the government is giving Hong Kongers a tax rebate of around $800 per person.

The government appears to have been stung into action by the release of the Hedley Index. A few hours after the index was released the Environmental Protection Department held a press conference to announce it was modifying its pollution monitoring to bring it in line with WHO standards.

But many clean air campaigners greeted that move was greeted with a “too little, too late” response. The question they want answered is why is a government as rich as Hong Kong’s is not spending more on a move which could have a big and rapid impact.

Posted by: Andrew Stevens, CNN Anchor
Filed under: Asia • environment • Hong Kong

Air Quality Objectives to be updated for better air quality

http://7thspace.com/headlines/403857/air_quality_objectives_to_be_updated_for_better_air_quality.html

Hong Kong (HKSAR) – The Government will adopt proposed new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) together with a package of air quality improvement measures, drawn up based on the results of public consultation, to better protect public health.

Speaking at a press conference today (January 17), the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, said thatfresh air is an essential part of a quality living environment and is vital to people’s health as well as maintaining the competitiveness of Hong Kong.

The Government will start preparatory work on the amendment of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance with an aim to table the Amendment Bill in the 2012-13 session of the Legislative Council. Taking account of the lead time for completing the legislative process and other necessary preparatory work, including formulation of modelling guidelines and compilation of emissions inventories, it is expected that the proposed new AQOs would take effect in 2014.

The Government will review the practicability of the tightened AQOs every five years and formulate the air quality improvement package accordingly.

In 2007, the Government commissioned a consultancy study to review Hong Kong’s existing AQOs and develop a long-term air quality management strategy.

Taking into account the World Health Organization (WHO)’s new guidelines and practices in other advanced countries, the review proposed a set of new AQOs benchmarked against the WHO’s Interim Targets and Air Quality Guidelines, accompanied by a host of proposed air quality improvement measures that are required to help Hong Kong achieve the new objectives.

The new AQOs (see Annex A) are comparable to those being adopted by the European Union and the United States.

To attain the new AQOs as soon as practicable, the Government has drawn up 19 air quality improvement measures (see Annex B) and has been pressing ahead with implementation of measures over which the community has wider consensus. In addition, the Government has put forward additional improvement initiatives targeting the problem of roadside nitrogen dioxide.

Further measures include retrofitting Euro II and III franchised buses with selective catalytic reduction devices to reduce their nitrogen oxide emissions. In addition, the Government has introduced the use of roadside remote sensing equipment and dynamometers for emissions testing to strengthen control of emissions from petrol and liquefied petroleum gas vehicles. The Government is also working on measures to reduce marine emissions to further improve air quality.

Having considered carefully the need to preserve the integrity of the environmental impact assessment (EIA) system as an ongoing mechanism, as well as regulatory certainty for proponents of projects that have already completed the EIA process, the Government proposes to provide for a time-limited transitional period of 36 months from the commencement date of the new AQOs. During this transitional period, the new AQOs would not apply to an application for variation of an Environmental Permit.

To underscore the Government’s commitment to adopting the best practices as well as to provide greater certainty to works departments in planning new development projects, all Government projects for which EIA studies have not yet commenced would endeavour to adopt the proposed new AQOs as the benchmark for conducting air quality assessment under the EIA studies.

Exco backs new air quality objectives

RTHK

17-01-2012

The Executive Council has approved new air quality objectives for Hong Kong, which will set more stringent caps on seven types of pollutants. The Environment Secretary, Edward Yau, says half of the objectives comply with the strictest standards set by the World Health Organisation, and the rest meet its ‘interim’ levels. Mr Yau said the government will draft the necessary legislation to enforce the new standards. Hong Kong’s air quality objectives were last updated in 1987.

Public ‘misled by primitive air checks’

17-01-2012http://www.rthk.org.hk/rthk/radio3/hongkongtoday/images/Subpage_12.gifhttps://mail.google.com/mail/u/1/?ui=2&ik=9ed62dbd70&view=att&th=134eac506ebd76ff&attid=0.3&disp=emb&zw
Professor Anthony Hedley
The Environmental Protection Department has been accused of misleading the public with “outdated and primitive” methods of measuring local air quality. Experts from the University of Hong Kong’s School of Public Health say the measurements bear no relation to actual health risks.

Professor Anthony, Hedley from the University’s department of community medicine, says the public should know that poor air quality is extremely dangerous, particularly for children.