| SCMP
Jennifer Ngo |
|
||||
|
Hong Kong is no longer in the top 10 Chinese cities for government integrity a year after topping a researchorganisation’s rankings, with a failure to tackle society’s problems blamed. The China Institute of City Competitiveness’s annual survey ranks cities and provinces according to 27 criteria, but its latest list, released at Baptist University yesterday, saw Weihai , in eastern Shandong , come top in the integrity stakes. “There were a lot of negative reports on the Hong Kong government in the past two years, which has affected its ratings,” said Gui Qiangfang, the organisation’s president. The 10th annual rankings include ratings for growth potential, liveability, innovation, environment and the economy. Economic development, social development and culture were also taken into consideration. Hong Kong ranked second for integrated competitiveness, taking in most of the criteria, with Guangdong at the top. Taiwan dropped to fourth after topping the list last year. Shanghai and Beijing were ranked seventh and ninth respectively. Gui said Hong Kong missed top spot because it was far smaller than its neighbouring province, which takes in big cities such as Guangzhou and Shenzhen, and because of the rapid growth of mainland cities. “Hong Kong is still undoubtedly the most competitive city [in China]. But in terms of growth, mainland cities have been taking big economic leaps,” he said. Hong Kong also missed out on the top 10 for innovation and liveability, and dropped from 10th to 13th for growth potential. “Hong Kong has [the] potential to become a very innovative city. There is good research in the universities here, but not much of it was actually developed and used,” Gui said. Gui said Hong Kong needs to encourage creative industries and should create room for development of industries other than finance. The research was compiled in association with Baptist University’s Advanced Institute for Contemporary China Studies, which has come under fire for producing a handbook for the controversial national education curriculum which critics say is heavily biased towards the mainland. Ranked No 2 in the integrity list is Ordos, located in Inner Mongolia, while Yantai , a city in northeastern Shandong, is third. The rundown from fourth to tenth is: Nanjing , Dalian , Siping in Jilin province, Harbin ,Zhuzhou in Hunan , Tangshan in Hebei, and Xinxiang in Henan. |
|||||
July, 2012:
City scores lower in integrity stakes
Mountain fear raised on third runway plan
Hong Kong Standard Wednesday, July 11, 2012
A veteran pilot doubts whether government planners can get on top of mountainous challenges to a third runway at Hong Kong International Airport.
Retired Cathay Pacific senior first officer Jan Bochenski, with 21 years of flying experience, said he and many other pilots fail to see a way around problems unless there is a mountain-cutting plan.
The 957-meter Tai Mo Shan, the highest mountain in the territory, is in the middle of the flight path to the proposed third runway, Bochenski said, and pilots about to land will need to bank aircraft at a sharp angle.
But a towering concern, he said, is Castle Peak at 583m being in the middle of a third runway’s essential escape route if something went wrong on landing.
He asked: “Is the government planning to cut down Castle Peak? Maybe.” But how could a pilot face such high ground if a plane lost an engine? This, he said, would be “impossible.”
Even if all engines were functioning, Bochenski added, aircraft need considerable power to clear mountains.
He also said that if aircraft were to try to avoid facing Castle Peak this would crowd airspace occupied by those using the other two runways.
The Airport Authority has already discussed routes linked to a third runway with Britain’s National Air Traffic Services.
An authority spokesman also said there would be enough “obstacle clearance” to meet requirements of the International Civil Aviation Organization. PHILA SIU
Minimise impact of third runway
| SCMP Jul 09, 2012 |
|
||||
|
Building a third runway at Hong Kong International Airport is a daunting task. With a construction cost of HK$136 billion, not only is it the most expensive infrastructure project to build, the 650 hectares of sea reclamation – and its impact on the environment – is also set to be the biggest ever. It is, therefore, imperative for the Airport Authority to put up a convincing case for expansion, while ensuring the damage to the environment will be reduced to an acceptable level. Recently, the runway project has had its wings clipped by a government watchdog. In a rare move, the Environmental Protection Department has demanded more details on air pollution, marine life and aircraft noise before giving the green light. The information submitted will be open for public comment for two weeks. It is disappointing that the authority has apparently failed to do its homework and suffered a major setback. It shows that better efforts are needed to fulfil the environmental protection requirements under the law. The airport is the lifeline of Hong Kong. In an increasingly competitive world, the importance of maintaining the city’s status as a regional aviation hub is beyond question. With the growth in passenger and cargo traffic expected to reach full capacity in eight years, a third runway is the right solution. On the other hand, a growing environmental awareness is holding back the pace of further development. The question is how to move forward while keeping the impact on air quality, marine life and local residents to the minimum. As public expectations for clean air and green living continue to grow, there is a need for the government to play a more pro-active role in vetting the environmental impact of infrastructure projects. The judicial review over the green assessment of the bridge linking Hong Kong with the Pearl River Delta is a good reminder that major building works may end up in court if they are found to be not properly scrutinised according to the law. Assessment should be professional rather than perfunctory. The authority is expected to redouble efforts to satisfy the assessment requirement and minimise the impact. It should be able to demonstrate that it is sincere in addressing critics’ concerns and is taking steps to reduce any adverse impact. The idea was first formally put on the public agenda as early as 2006, just eight years after Chek Lap Kok came into operation. Since then, the exponential growth in air traffic has reinforced the case to further expand. As regional competition intensifies, Hong Kong cannot afford to stand still. It is time for the project to take off. What we need are more effective efforts to address concerns over our environment. |
|||||
Stink of Guangzhou garbage plan refuses to go away
| City says landfills can’t handle all the rubbish and incinerators are a must. But residents have a host of worries, and don’t trust government | |||||
| PEARL BRIEFING Sally Wang SCMP Jul 07, 2012 |
|
||||
| Hundreds of residents of Qingyuan and Guangzhou took to the streets on June 10 to protest against a plan to build a garbage incinerator in Guangzhou’s Huadu district, close to Qingyuan.
It was one of the largest protests against government plans to build incinerators in Guangzhou, but just over a week later the standing committee of the city’s people’s congress confirmed plans to build five garbage incinerators by 2015, with one of three planned for Huadu to be completed by 2014. The government has cut the number of incinerators it plans to build by 2015 from six to five, and reduced its daily-capacity target from 15,000 tonnes to 11,000 tonnes, but public opposition remains widespread. The city already has one incinerator, in Likeng, in the northern district of Baiyun, which handles 1,000 tonnes of refuse each day. Most of the rest of the 18,000 tonnes of waste the city produces each day ends up buried in landfills, which, according to the Southern Metropolis Daily, already contain 40 million tonnes of garbage. While the scaling back of the city’s incineration plans can be viewed as official acknowledgement of public concerns, the government remains resolute in its determination to promote the burning of refuse both to solve its waste problem and to generate electricity. Xu Jianyun, a deputy director of Guangzhou’s Urban Management Committee who is in charge of building waste-treatment facilities, told the Southern Metropolis Daily that the city would create 20,000 tonnes of refuse a day by 2020 and had to reduce the amount being sent to landfills. But the public has concerns, with people complaining the incinerators will be built close to communities and could pose serious threats to residents’ health and the environment. There are nine villages and several residential communities within 2.5 kilometres of the proposed Huadu plant, the Nanfang Daily reported. Arguments over whether Guangzhou should have incinerators, and, if so, where, have been going on since 2009. Besides concerns over health and green issues, some people also doubt the government’s integrity, and worry about back-room deals. According to the government plan, incinerator operators will receive a 110 yuan (HK$134) subsidy for each tonne of household garbage burned. In the June 10 protest, people complained about a lack of openness in the bidding process and the selection of operators. In 2009, when the Guangzhou Guangri Group obtained the right to operate the city’s first incinerator, the Southern Metropolis Daily reported rumours that the brother of Lu Zhiyi, deputy general secretary of the Guangzhou city government, held a senior position in the group. It also reported that the group had given two cars to the leaders of the Urban Management Committee. The only response from the city government was that if special interests had been favoured, the city’s discipline-inspection commission would have stepped in to investigate the matter. Selecting sites for garbage incinerators is not an easy job for any government. Hardly any have been built in the US for more than 15 years, The New York Times has reported. But Guangzhou residents are also entitled to open and thorough hearings and reviews before the government makes decisions on incinerators. Independent and trustworthy third-party organisations should be appointed to assess the impact of such projects on nearby residents, and in particular the risks associated with dioxin, a cancer-causing by-product of incineration. The city government also needs to answer doubts about the fairness of the bidding process and about just how clean its own hands are. Only if it wins people’s trust will the Guangzhou government be able to deal with the stink created by its plans for the city’s garbage. |
|||||
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/jul/04/dirty-truth-chinas-incinerators?newsfeed=true
The dirty truth about China’s incinerators
The boom in polluting waste-to-energy plants in China has led to a backlash from residents, including one man’s long-running legal crusade
- Elizabeth Balkan for ChinaDialogue
- guardian.co.uk, Wednesday 4 July 2012 15.35 BST
, part of the Guardian Environment Network
A Chinese worker controls robotic arms to throw rubbish into an incinerator at a plant in Qionghai, Southern Hainan province of China. Photograph: Corbis
Xie Yong could be called a pioneer. He is one of very few to date to sue a Chinese government agency over its unlawful refusal of requested data. His crusade for change has little to do with civic altruism, however. Xie’s struggle is personal in nature, his actions forced by desperation. He has been battling his son’s paralysis-causing epileptic seizures and mounting health care costs since 2010. His son’s condition, Xie believes, is the result of toxic emissions from an incineration plant near his home.
Xie and his wife, Ma Hongmei, lived in Nantong, Jiangsu province, when Ma gave birth to their son, Yongkang, in 2008. Even before they could celebrate his first 100 days of life, Yongkang’sparents noticed he was not developing normally. He did not laugh like other babies and had trouble seeing and hearing. Most disturbing, he twitched incessantly and could not be placated. Shortly after, he became paralysed. Doctors eventually diagnosed him with cerebral palsy.
During Ma’s pregnancy and in her son’s first two months of life, the family lived a short distance from the local trash incineration plant. The facility’s odorous emissions were constant, but neither Ma nor Xie understood what risks they might be facing. Shanghai Xinhua Hospital determined that Yongkang’s disease was not genetic, but caused by environmental factors during Ma’spregancy.
Xie researched the science behind incineration emissions and health defects, spoke with experts, and learned that other couples in the village had experienced premature births and stillbirths. The couple concluded that their proximity to the plant, and the constant pollution it spewed, were to blame.
In 2010, Xie sought the assistance of the Center for Legal Assistance to Pollution Victims (CLAPV), a China-based legal aid NGO that provides assistance to citizens and wages legal battles in the name of environmental justice. The centre felt that his story justified legal action and, with Xie’s help, began collecting the evidence needed to build a case against the company that owned the plant, Jiangsu Tianying Saite Environmental Protection Energy Group.
In China’s first personal health-related legal case against a waste incinerator, the Hai’an local court heard the case in September 2010. Xie submitted analysis revealing dioxin concentrations in nearby air that grossly exceeded legal limits; reports documenting the physical condition of plant workers and other children living near the plant; and scientific papers demonstrating a link between dioxin and birth defects. The local judge rejected Xie’s claims, prompting him to appeal to the county court. A county-level trial took place May 2011, with similar results. The court deemed the evidence insufficient and issued a verdict against Xie.
In response to these blows, Xie turned directly to the authorities. He filed a request for emissions data for the plant in question from the local environmental protection bureau, to which he had legal entitlement (read more about China’s open government information laws here and here). His request was denied, on the grounds that releasing data would compromise the company’s business secrets. Xie next asked the provincial level Ministry of Environmental Protection, one administrative level higher, to release emissions reports to him. They, too, turned him down. But he is determined to continue his fight.
Activists like CLAPV’s Liu Jinmei believe that Xie’s efforts “indicate a growing awareness of safeguarding the rights of victims of pollutants”. However, it is hard to know how many individuals with situations similar to Xie’s, but completely unaware of the potentially serious health risks they face, are out there. This is because conditions at Chinese waste-to-energy facilities are by and large shrouded in mystery.
The incineration boom
China did not commission its first waste-to-energy plant until little more than a decade ago. Before 1990, public waste-treatment infrastructure handled less than 2% of the country’s household waste. At the same time, output of inorganic rubbish was marginal.
Rapid change in waste production and management trends occurred in China over the last two decades. China now generates over a quarter of the world’s garbage, at least 250 million tonnes annually. With municipal solid waste (MSW) growing 8% to10% annually, cities are under great pressure to deliver advanced waste-management solutions.
Landfills currently handle roughly half of China’s MSW, while only about 10% is incinerated. Official credo suggests that landfills will continue to play a dominant role. But Beijing’s push to increase the share of burned waste is unmistakable: a central target calls for 30% of MSW to be treated by waste-to-energy incineration by 2030.
Presently, incineration is growing at a feverish pace. Industry insiders and state-run media routinely declare 300 plants will be operational by the time the 12th Five-Year Plan runs its course in 2015. A 2009 study by banking group Standard Chartered found that over one-half of global orders for new waste-incineration facilities came from China.
Information on the number of waste-to-energy plants in China is scarce and, when available, difficult to unpack. Interviews with experts and policymakers rarely converge on a single number, but their guesses routinely fall somewhere between 100 and 200. In an independent, verified assessment I conducted in 2011, I detected at least 155 plants currently operating or under construction. I would not be surprised if plans for new plants have been announced in the three months during which my data has aged.
China’s earliest incineration plants deployed imported grate burn technology common in developed economies. Plant operators quickly found that Chinese MSW generally makes poor feedstock. This is because China’s vast informal sector extracts the most easily burned trash, like paper, wood and plastic. The remaining composition is largely organic waste, too wet to burn without costly pre-treatment or fuel supplements. Technological barriers aside, the price of these technologies also puts them out of reach for China’s second and third-tier cities.
Combined with these practical obstacles, Beijing’s drive to localise environmental technologies helped catalyse (state-funded) development of domestic incineration technologies suited to Chinese conditions. Newer plants prominently feature domestically developed equipment, including both grate and circular fluidised-bed (CFB) type incinerators. Though smaller in terms of capacity, CFB incinerators generate similar amounts of electricity to stoke grates. They are also more flexible in terms of feedstock, permitting coal to be added for easier ignition. For these reasons, CFB incinerators enjoy considerable popularity in the market and now account for about half of China’s MSW treatment capacity.
Early central-level legislation on municipal waste management – passed almost a decade ago – sanctioned private-sector involvement. These measures, intended to encourage growth in waste-to-energy installations, relaxed state control in a way that has yet to take place in the energy sector. However, the primary catalyst for growth in the sector has been generous government incentives.
Waste-to-energy incineration is classified as a renewable energy form in China, meaning that plants receive a feed-in tariff for every kilowatt hour of electricity they generate. Only two months ago, Beijing announced a fixed subsidised price for power purchased from waste-to-energy plants, which is about double that from coal-powered plants.
The results of these subsidies are dramatic. Both foreign and local waste-to-energy players have rushed to stake their claims, in some cases submitting loss-making tender offers just to get a foothold. Many waste-management experts suspect that Chinese city officials are among the most eager investors; using public infrastructure and tax revenue to profit personally.
Peeling back a green facade
The ongoing justification for favourable waste-to-energy policies in China is simple: cities stem the problem of growing waste while getting much needed electricity in the process. That formula, however appealing, appears too good to be true.
China’s incinerators, though canonised as a “clean energy,” have a dirty underside. Thermal waste treatment plants are subject to emissions regulations considerably looser than those for power plants. Legally, they can emit nitrous oxide and sulphur dioxide at, respectively, four and five times the levels of power plants in China.
Newer facilities are installed with air-pollution control systems, but these are costly to use and maintain. Thus, many plants operate without the required flue gas filtering equipment. Likewise, treatment of other highly toxic byproducts – such as wastewater removed before incineration and fly ash created during burning – tends to be either poor or non-existent. This follows partly from the lack of regulations on how waste-to-energy plants should treat wastewater.
The company which operates the facility near where Xie Yong’s family lived boasts on its website that it uses an advanced pollution control system which meets European emissions standards, but no details are given. This is a common claim among waste-to-energy developers. On the other hand, air and water pollution in waste-to-energy plants in China has been well-documented. According to some reports, some plants emit dioxins at levels 24 times higher than those from American waste-to-energy facilities.
Making matters worse, plant operators regularly add coal to the burning waste. In private interviews, Waste-to-energy plant operators admitted to using a feedstock mix comprising equal parts coal and rubbish, which far exceeds the 20% coal limit mandated by the central government. It is not unheard of for the share of coal to be as high as 70%. Under these conditions, plants are operating essentially as small coal-fired power stations – exactly the kind of facility that Beijing is trying to eliminate on public health grounds.
Finally, while incineration plants in Europe charge rubbish haulers “tipping fees” that may reach US$132 (840 yuan) per tonne of waste, these fees rarely exceed US$16 (100 yuan) per tonne in China, and usually hover around US$8 (50 yuan). When Xie’s son was born, the plant near his house was making US$10 (64 yuan) for each tonne of trash they accepted. Many experts say that environmentally sound performance, and the costs it requires, is not technologically feasible with such low tipping fees.
Light beyond the haze
Weak regulation and misaligned policies, combined with an absence of public emissions data, make for a truly toxic incineration sector. Xie Yong is not the only one who has noticed.
Beginning a few years ago, communities near existing plants, offended by odorous emissions and worried about possible health risks, began protesting against new projects. In one incident, which took place in Xie’s Jiangsu province, as many as 10,000 residents gathered and clashed with police over a waste incinerator in their village. According to Chinese media reports, by mid-2010 construction of at least six new plants had been postponed due to public opposition.
By some accounts, China’s leadership has heeded the warnings. In interviews, city officials have said that some Chinese mayors are blocking new projects, concerned they could trigger unrest, thereby marring their reputations and chances of promotion.
Alongside these grassroots efforts, NGOs like Beijing-based Green Beagle are working to substantiate public opposition to incineration with actual emissions performance data. Having campaigned for, and been denied, credible figures for almost five years, the organisation is exploring the possibility of establishing independent waste-to-energy emissions monitoring stations.
As for Xie Yong, it is too early to say whether he can navigate a way through China’s legal system and extract the data he is so desperate to get his hands on, in the belief it will demonstrate a more direct relationship between the plant’s operations and his son’s crippling illness. With every other option exhausted, Xie decided early this year to sue the provincial-level Ministry of Environmental Protection at the Jiangsu provincial court. The trial is expected to take place later this year.
“Taking the ministry to court is my last choice,” Xie has said. “It’s the only way I can get justice.” Though his case is still unresolved, growing numbers of onlookers await the outcome.
Xie’s legal fight – the first of its kind – highlights the pressing need for greater transparency and accountability in the incineration sector. At the same time, growing popular opposition suggests that persistent, and public, resistance may be China’s best bet for achieving meaningful regulatory reform in the waste-to-energy sector.
- © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.
From: James Middleton [mailto:dynamco@netvigator.com]
Sent: 12 June, 2012 08:12
To: Edward Yau Tang Wah EPD; EPD HKG; ceeo@ce-elect-office.hk; kswong@rlphk.com; martin.putnam@hkairport.com; elvis_au@epd.gov.hk
Subject: Residents in Guangdong say No to the Garbage Plant
Secretary for the Environment
Mr Edward Yau Tang Wah
Dear Sir,
In the recent EIA documents for the proposed Shek Kwu Chau incinerator project we could not find any reference to the following imminent incinerator projects
just across the border from Hong Kong.
Since your staff Mr Elvis Au has frequently stated in public that the majority of the winds across Hong Kong are northerlies for most of the year, it stands to reason that these upcoming 24/7 projects will have a serious influence on transboundary pollution levels in Hong Kong which is already affected by marine shipping pollution levels without any Emissions Control Area in place.
Why were these (easily searched) major polluting projects omitted by the consultants from the EIA on the Shek Kwu Chau incinerator?
Yours faithfully,
James Middleton
Chairman
http://www.martingmbh.de/index_en.php?level=1&CatID=9&inhalt_id=10&presse=84&do=showDetail#84
| 23/04/2012 Foshan Nanhai I, China |
| Extension by 3 lines |
| In March 2012, our cooperation partner Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Environmental & Chemical Engineering Co., Ltd. (MHIEC) was awarded the contract to supply the technical equipment for the extension of the Foshan Nanhai I plant. Three MARTIN reverse-acting grates with a width of 9.48 m will be used. The throughput is 3 x 500 t/d. (1500 t/d) Start-up of the 3 combustion lines is planned for 2013. |
| 07/12/2011 Dongguan Downtown, China |
| Order for delivery of three grate systems |
| Our licensee, Chongqing Sanfeng Covanta Environmental Industry Co., Ltd., has been awarded a new contract to supply grate systems. Three combustion systems will be supplied to the waste-to-energy plant in Dongguan Downtown (Guangdong province), People`s Republic of China. The grates with a throughput of 600 t/d each will be manufactured in China and will use the MARTIN SITY 2000 technology. (1800 t/d) |
| 19/10/2009 Dongguan, China |
| Order for delivery of 3 grate systems |
| Our licensee, Chongqing Luneng Environment Industry Co., Ltd., has been awarded a new contract to supply grate systems. Three combustion systems will be supplied to the waste-to-energy plant in Dongguan (Guangdong province), People’s Republic of China. The grates will be manufactured in China and will use MARTIN SITY 2000 technology. Each grate will have a throughput rate of 600 t/d. (1800 t/d) |
http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/714075.shtml
Residents in Guangdong say no to the garbage plant
Global Times | 2012-6-11 1:50:02
By Tu Lei
Hundreds of residents from two cities in South China’s Guangdong Province again took to the street in the provincial capital of Guangzhou Sunday to show their concern over a plan to build a garbage incinerator, according to several postings on SinaWeibo Sunday.
“We do not want the garbage incinerator built in our city, and we have no better option but to stage this rally,” a participant surnamed Hu from Qingyuan, a city neighboring Guangzhou, told the Global Times Sunday.
Hu said the Fenshui garbage incineration project near the boundary of the neighboring cities of Qingyuan and Guangzhou has vexed residents for its possible impact on resident’s health and the environment.
“Only two months are left for the provincial environmental protection bureau to make a final decision on its location. The company they’ve selected also isn’t qualified to build the plant, and there has been no open bidding for the project.” “Some 20 villages and three large residential communities are within 3 kilometers of the plant,” according to a posting from a Weibo account that was opened to oppose the plant.
There are nine villages within 2.5 kilometers of the plant, the Guangzhou-based Nanfang Daily reported on May 30. The first rally took place on the morning of May 23, when some 200 residents came to Guangzhou to show their displeasure. This time, “There were nearly 1,000 residents joining the gathering that lasted six hours,” Hu said.
“Burying the garbage will take too much land, while an incineration plant is quite scientific and popular overseas,” an official also surnamed Hu with the urban management commission of Guangzhou, told the Global Times. “We have made a thorough argument for picking the site and assessed the impact on the environment.”
The Standing Committee of Guangzhou City People’s Congress said in April that the city will build six garbage incineration plants over the next three years, and the location is to be finalized this year.
The city government said on May 22 that Guangzhou’s population is expected to be 18 million in five years, and they will produce 18,000 tons of garbage a day, far surpassing the city’s current handling capacity.
http://titan-machinery.com/en/industry-news/shenzhen-waste-incinerator/
China’s Largest Waste-To-Energy System Heads For Shenzhen
Posted in: Industry news | January 26, 2011 at 3:06 pm
The second phase of the Bao’an Waste-to-Energy Plant, which is invested in by Shenzhen Energy and Environment Company, is expected to be the largest of its kind in China with a daily production capacity of 4,200 tons.
It is learned that Shenzhen produces 12,074 tons of waste are being yielded in Shenzhen every day. Though city has set up seven waste incineration power plants with a total capacity of 4,875 tons per day, it can still not meet the increasing demand.
At present, SEEC incinerates 2,450 tons of waste each day, which accounts for 50% of the city’s total waste incineration. In addition, the company has three projects under construction which are expected to add a daily capacity of 6,300 tons for the city.
Set up in 1997, SEEC is one of the major waste disposal companies in Shenzhen.
China’s Incinerators Loom as a Global Hazard
Timothy O’Rourke for The New York Times
A worker shoveled trash at the Baoan incinerator in Shenzhen, which also generates power.
O
Published: August 11, 2009
SHENZHEN, China— In this sprawling metropolis in southeastern China stand two hulking brown buildings erected by a private company, the Longgang trash incinerators. They can be smelled a mile away and pour out so much dark smoke and hazardous chemicals that hundreds of local residents recently staged an all-day sit-in, demanding that the incinerators be cleaner and that a planned third incinerator not be built nearby.
Timothy O’Rourke for The New York Times
A truck delivering trash to the Baoan incinerator in Shenzhen, China. The incinerator is relatively clean, but is also costly.
Enlarge This Image
Timothy O’Rourke for The New York Times
Zhong Rigang, the chief engineer at the Baoan incinerator, saw little enthusiasm among the public for recycling.
Enlarge This Image
Timothy O’Rourke for The New York Times
The Longgang incinerators in Shenzhen were the focus of a recent all-day sit-in by hundreds of local residents.
A blog about energy, the environment and the bottom line.
After surpassing the United States as the world’s largest producer of household garbage, China has embarked on a vast program to build incinerators as landfills run out of space. But these incinerators have become a growing source of toxic emissions, from dioxin to mercury, that can damage the body’s nervous system.
And these pollutants, particularly long-lasting substances like dioxin and mercury, are dangerous not only in China, a growing body of atmospheric research based on satellite observations suggests. They float on air currents across the Pacific to American shores.
Chinese incinerators can be better. At the other end of Shenzhen from Longgang, no smoke is visible from the towering smokestack of the Baoan incinerator, built by a company owned by the municipal government. Government tests show that it emits virtually no dioxin and other pollutants.
But the Baoan incinerator cost 10 times as much as the Longgang incinerators, per ton of trash-burning capacity.
The difference between the Baoan and Longgang incinerators lies at the center of a growing controversy in China. Incinerators are being built to wildly different standards across the country and even across cities like Shenzhen. For years Chinese government regulators have discussed the need to impose tighter limits on emissions. But they have done nothing because of a bureaucratic turf war, a Chinese government official and Chinese incineration experts said.
The Chinese government is struggling to cope with the rapidly rising mountains of trash generated as the world’s most populated country has raced from poverty to rampant consumerism. Beijing officials warned in June that all of the city’s landfills would run out of space within five years.
The governments of several cities with especially affluent, well-educated citizens, including Beijing and Shanghai, are setting pollution standards as strict as Europe’s. Despite those standards, protests against planned incinerators broke out this spring in Beijing and Shanghai as well as Shenzhen.
Increasingly outspoken residents in big cities are deeply distrustful that incinerators will be built and operated to international standards. “It’s hard to say whether this standard will be reached — maybe the incinerator is designed to reach this benchmark, but how do we know it will be properly operated?” said Zhao Yong, a computer server engineer who has become a neighborhood activist in Beijing against plans for an incinerator there.
Yet far dirtier incinerators continue to be built in inland cities where residents have shown little awareness of pollution.
Studies at the University of Washington and the Argonne National Laboratory in Argonne, Ill., have estimated that a sixth of the mercury now falling on North American lakes comes from Asia, particularly China, mainly from coal-fired plants and smelters but also from incinerators. Pollution from incinerators also tends to be high in toxic metals like cadmium.
Incinerators play the most important role in emissions of dioxin. Little research has been done on dioxin crossing the Pacific. But analyses of similar chemicals have shown that they can travel very long distances.
A 2005 report from the World Bank warned that if China built incinerators rapidly and did not limit their emissions, worldwide atmospheric levels of dioxin could double. China has since slowed its construction of incinerators and limited their emissions somewhat, but the World Bank has yet to do a follow-up report.
Airborne dioxin is not the only problem from incinerators. The ash left over after combustion is laced with dioxin and other pollutants. Zhong Rigang, the chief engineer at the Baoan incinerator here, said that his operation sent its ash to a special landfill designed to cope with toxic waste. But an academic paper last year by Nie Yongfeng, a Tsinghua University professor and government adviser who sees a need for more incinerators, said that most municipal landfills for toxic waste lacked room for the ash, so the ash was dumped.
Trash incinerators have two advantages that have prompted Japan and much of Europe to embrace them: they occupy much less real estate than landfills, and the heat from burning trash can be used to generate electricity. The Baoan incinerator generates enough power to light 40,000 households.
And landfills have their own environmental hazards. Decay in landfills also releases large quantities of methane, a powerful global warming gas, said Robert McIlvaine, president of McIlvaine Company, an energy consulting firm that calculates the relative costs of addressing disparate environmental hazards. Methane from landfills is a far bigger problem in China than toxic pollutants from incinerators, particularly modern incinerators like those in Baoan, he said.
China’s national regulations still allow incinerators to emit 10 times as much dioxin as incinerators in the European Union; American standards are similar to those in Europe. Tightening of China’s national standards has been stuck for three years in a bureaucratic war between the environment ministry and the main economic planning agency, the National Development and Reform Commission, said a Beijing official who insisted on anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the subject publicly.
The agencies agree that tighter standards on dioxin emissions are needed. They disagree on whether the environment ministry should have the power to stop incinerator projects that do not meet tighter standards, the official said, adding that the planning agency wants to retain the power to decide which projects go ahead.
Yan Jianhua, the director of the solid waste treatment expert group in Zhejiang province, a center of incinerator equipment manufacturing in China, defended the industry’s record on dioxin, saying that households that burn their trash outdoors emit far more dioxin.
“Open burning is a bigger problem according to our research,” Professor Yan said, adding that what China really needs is better trash collection so that garbage can be disposed of more reliably.
Critics and admirers of incinerators alike call for more recycling and reduced use of packaging as ways to reduce the daily volume of municipal garbage. Even when not recycled, sorted trash is easier for incinerators to burn cleanly, because the temperature in the furnace can be adjusted more precisely to minimize the formation of dioxin.
Yet the Chinese public has
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/12/business/energy-environment/12incinerate.html?pagewanted=all
shown little enthusiasm for recycling. As Mr. Zhong, the engineer at the Baoan incinerator, put it, “No one really cares.”
Keppel Seghers is currently one of the leading providers for imported WTE solutions in China. Its in-house technology is supplied for the expansion of an existing WTE plant in Shenzhen, Guangdong.
Keppel Seghers’ technology will enable the facility to treat an additional 3,000 tonnes to the existing 1,200 tonnes of municipal waste per day. When completed, the WTE plant will be the largest in China with an eventual capacity to treat 4,200 tonnes of municipal waste per day.
The existing WTE plant’s key components were also provided by Keppel Seghers in 1999, when it was built. Back then, the plant was also the largest WTE plant in China.
Heated opposition feared for city’s incinerator plan
Updated: 2011-09-17 08:06
By Zheng Caixiong (China Daily)
|
|||||||||
SHENZHEN, Guangdong – The government of the special economic zone is having trouble finding a location for the construction of a gigantic garbage incinerator.
Lu Ruifeng, executive deputy mayor of Shenzhen, said the city plans to build the world’s largest garbage incinerator, with a designed capacity to handle more than 5,000 tons of garbage a day.
“But it is really a headache to choose the right location for the project,” Lu said.
Lu made the remarks while meeting with Chen Xiaochuan, vice-chairwoman of the Guangdong Provincial People’s Congress, who was leading a group of deputies from the province’s legislative body to inspect the city’s environmental protection work early this week.
Although Lu did not reveal what the problems were, insiders said the city government worried the project could meet opposition from people living near any chosen location.
In Guangzhou, about 100 kilometers away from Shenzhen, the city government had to postpone construction of a similar project in its Panyu district last year because of residents’ strong opposition.
After the Guangzhou government chose a site in the Panyu district to build its garbage incinerator in late 2009, the overwhelming majority of nearby residents signed a petition to oppose the project. They were worried it would pollute the environment and harm their health.
As a result, the Guangdong provincial government had to make concession and announced it would postpone construction.
The Guangzhou garbage incinerator project had also stirred controversy among environmental experts and scholars.
Zhao Zhangyuan, a retired researcher for the Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences, said incineration will cause pollution.
“Burning garbage produces many poisonous gases, even when advanced technology and equipment are used,” said Zhao, who strongly opposed construction of the project.
Guangzhou authorities are now looking for a different site to build their garbage incinerator.
But Xu Haiyun, chief engineer with the China Urban Construction Design and Research Institute, said garbage incinerators will not pose health risks because the gases discharged would be strictly in line with the country’s standards.
“There is a garbage incinerator in downtown Bonn, Germany, and similar facilities have been constructed in Japan,” Xu said.
Lu Ruifeng promised Shenzhen’s garbage incinerator would use the world’s most advanced technologies, equipment and management system and uphold the strictest discharge standards to avoid polluting the environment.
“Shenzhen, a densely populated city that lacks land resources, will treat its waste mainly through burning in the future, in addition to burying and composting,” Lu said.
According to Lu, Shenzhen’s treatment rate of consumer waste will exceed 80 percent in 2015.
In addition, a number of garbage treatment facilities will be built or expanded in the coming years.
Yin Qingwei, a Shenzhen white-collar worker, said the city needs to build a big garbage incinerator to deal with its growing garbage problem.
“But the government should carefully consider the public opinion and seek suggestions from residents to choose the right location,” he said.
Construction should not start before the majority of residents have reached an agreement with the government, he added.
China Daily
http://news.newclear.server279.com/?p=3958
Shenzhen plans world’s largest incinerator
Apr 6th, 2012 by Editor.
Choi Chi-yuk and Cheung Chi-fai
Sep 15, 2011
Shenzhen plans to build the “world’s largest” rubbish incinerator, capable of processing 5,000 tonnes a day, in an effort to cope with the almost five million tonnes of domestic waste produced by the city each year.
Lu Ruifeng, the city’s executive vice-mayor, told a group of Guangdong provincial People’s Congress delegates on Tuesday that because its landfills could no longer cope with the growing trash pile produced by its 13 million residents, the city was planning to build the world’s largest incinerator, the Guangzhou-based Nanfang Daily reported yesterday.
Lu said public consultations had been held on site selection. He admitted that where to put the incinerator was one of the most challenging problems for the project.
The Nanfang Daily said Shenzhen planned to build three waste incinerators by 2015 to burn 80 per cent of the city’s rubbish. It said two of the plants would be in Laohukeng and Nanshan district, both in the west of the city, with the third to be built at an unspecified site in the city’s east.
A report in the Guangzhou Daily said Shenzhen had three waste incineration plants in the pipeline, capable of processing a total of 6,300 tonnes of rubbish a day.
Lu said that in order to meet environmental protection standards for the incinerator’s emissions – smell, liquid, ash residue and airborne ash particles – it would make use of mechanical grate technology to improve combustion. It would also adopt advanced management and stick to the highest global air quality standards, the Nanfang Daily reported.
It said Shenzhen was dealing with 4.8 million tonnes of trash a year.
Michelle Au Wing-tze, senior environmental affairs officer at Friends of the Earth (Hong Kong), said Shenzhen was taking a wrong path in waste management.
“Guangzhou has just started to ask people to separate and recycle waste, but Shenzhen is heading in the opposite direction,” she said.
“It is definitely not an image boost to tell others the incinerator will be the world’s largest.”
Au said that if the incinerator had any adverse environmental impacts, like dioxin pollution, it would not just hit Shenzhen and Hong Kong but could spread far beyond the region.
Last year, the daily per capita waste disposal rate in Shenzhen was 1.26kg, compared to 1.28kgin Hong Kong and 0.77kg in Guangzhou.
Hong Kong is also planning to build a large incinerator, with a capacity of 3,000 tonnes a day, on a reclaimed site at Shek Kwu Chau, south of Lantau Island. Environment officials have not ruled out the need to build an extra incinerator to cope with mounting waste.
Waste incineration projects are a sensitive issue in Guangdong, with proposals for new plants often met by fierce local demonstrations, forcing plans to be put on hold. In January, more than 1,000 residents from two districts of Guangzhou staged separate protests against incinerator projects near their neighbourhoods.
Growing environmental awareness among mainlanders as living standards have improved in recent years have fuelled more protests over environmental concerns.
Copyright (c) 2011. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved
http://news.asiaone.com/News/Latest%2BNews/Singapore/Story/A1Story20120506-344097.html
ASIAONE NEWS SINGAPORE
Loud bangs then fire at Tuas incinerator
AsiaOne
Sunday, May 06, 2012
SINGAPORE – An incinerator at a waste management plant in Tuas caught fire early Sunday morning. According to witness statements, three loud bangs were heard before flames were sighted.
An eyewitness told the Straits Times that technicians on duty were transporting oil sludge into a funnel leading to the incinerator when they heard the three loud explosive bangs, followed by the flames.
The technicians then sounded the alarm and left the control room, which reportedly caught fire just seconds later.
The roof also partially collapsed, reported the English daily.
The Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) said they were alerted to the fire at around 12.50am at Eco SWM, in Tuas. Deploying three fire engines, SCDF officers put out the fire within 30 minutes of their arrival.
A SCDF spokesperson said that all 25 employees who were onsite when the incident happened are accounted for. No injuries have been reported.
Download PDF : Stink of Guangzhou garbage plan refuses to go away
download pdf : SingaporeExpertreport (1)
Download PDF : Untitled attachment 00711 (1)
Environment: Airlines begin to realise green fuel is a complex proposition
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8d7212cc-b484-11e1-bb2e-00144feabdc0.html#axzz1zwcWyrWI
July 7, 2012 4:21 am
By Rose Jacobs
©Rolf Bewersdorf
Clean skies: Lufthansa ran eight daily commercial flights between Hamburg and Frankfurt for six months last year on a fuel made in part from vegetable oils
Jeremy Woods, a lecturer in bioenergy at Imperial College in London, has created a chart that describes pathways you might follow if you were working to produce a biofuel. It is a mess of labels and lines, showing a range of feedstocks – from algae to eucalyptus to sugar cane – technologies and possible final products.
“I call it the ‘horrendogram’,” he jokes.
Yet airlines are serious about navigating that maze as they seek to meet environmental targets set out by their main trade body, the International Air Transport Association.
The aviation industry aims to halt carbon emissions growth from 2020 and to halve emissions from 2005 levels by 2050, even as air traffic increases.
A significant part of those savings will have to come from carriers switching from traditional fossil fuels to alternatives.
But while the technology is already available in some cases, as made clear by multiple test flights in recent years, a commercially viable synthetic fuel remains a middle to long-distance prospect.
Lufthansa, the only airline with a dedicated biofuels department, ran eight daily commercial flights between Hamburg and Frankfurt for six months last year on a fuel made in part from vegetable oils. Government funding brought down the premium from three times the cost of traditional jet fuel to two times, but Joachim Buse, head of biofuels for the airline, said no rollout is imminent, nor could one happen without board approval.
While most experts predict the biofuel premium will fall as production ramps up, feeding economies of scale, there is uncertainty surrounding the ease with which greater production can be achieved.
Vegetable oils are an expensive feedstock, even those that are not part of the human food chain (which airlines such as Lufthansa now insist upon), while alternative sources such as carbon captured for recycling require processing at hugely expensive plants.
“It’s a chicken and egg situation,” says Mr Buse. “Nobody wants to invest in a refinery as long as he has no security in acquiring sufficient feedstock for his production. But on the other hand, feedstock producers are waiting for someone to come and say, ‘whatever you produce, we will buy it from you’.”
For a global industry, the solutions to sourcing are, so far, surprisingly local.
US and Asian airlines are largely focusing on fuels from crops that can be grown domestically, since the land is available, while Qatar Air has explored using natural gas to fuel aircraft, hoping to exploit the country’s vast reserves.
Carriers in Europe – where EU regulations have pushed farmers into growing crops for the biodiesel used in surface transport – are looking at a greater variety of feedstocks.
Solena, BA’s main biofuel partner, has recently secured both funding and a site in east London for a plant that would turn household waste into synthetic aviation fuel.
Jonathan Counsell, head of environment at BA, says the flag-carrier’s two main requirements were that the source of its biofuel be sustainable – “we kept away from crops” – and commercially viable.
Britain’s high volumes of household waste mean the feedstock meets the first requirement, while the UK’s high landfill tax helps Solena, and therefore BA – which has signed a 10-year agreement to buy the fuel – tick the latter box.
Mr Counsell says the fuel will be cost-competitive with traditional jet fuel at today’s oil price – about $100 a barrel. He expects the plant to fuel BA’s City Airport operations, or about 2 per cent of the airline’s total fuel demand.
US airlines are also signing offtake agreements with a number of biofuel producers, says Christopher Surgenor, editor of Green Air, a website about aviation and the environment. “But they won’t necessarily agree a price in advance.”
In fact, he questions the extent to which airlines should be in the business – via partnerships or even offtake agreements – of integrated biofuel production.
Instead he points to intermediaries such as SkyNRG and Honeywell UOP, which manage the whole supply chain, buying the biomass in bulk, paying production companies to transform it into fuel and selling that on to airlines.
The oil companies could get involved as they have in biodiesel production, but Charles Cameron, head of technology, refining and marketing at BP, warns they would be reluctant to do so as long as margins were lower for biodiesel and traditional jet fuel.
“This is going to require some financial engineering,” he told a green aviation conference late last month.
Dr Woods at Imperial agrees. But while Mr Cameron points to government subsidies and tax structures as the way to bring down the synthetic jet fuel premium, Dr Woods says the solution must be multifarious, including better use of regulation and oversight to spread the burden of monitoring the biofuel supply chain – as well as an acceptance that the supply chain itself needs to draw on a wide range of feedstocks, including controversial sources such as elements of the human food chain.
He believes the industry is at a turning point, where it begins to accept that biofuels are not a simple solution to the problem of emissions.
“The airlines are at the point of understanding that what they’re getting is not what’s important, it’s where it’s produced and how it’s produced.” He welcomes that embrace of complexity, as well as the industry’s expanding focus, from biofuels to turbine efficiency and drag reduction.
Mr Surgenor points to other nearer-term opportunities for greener flying, such as rationalisation of air traffic control and new codes of practice for departure and ground operations.
As for commercialising aviation biofuels, “while there are promising signs from around the world, beware anyone who predicts when that will be and on what scale”, he says.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2012. You may share using our article
A methodological oddity
SCMP Lai See 07 July 2012
The Economist Intelligence Unit has adjusted its methodology for determining the world’s most “liveable” city. As a result, Hong Kong has been catapulted from 10th position to first, ahead of Amsterdam, Osaka, Paris and Sydney. The Economist notes this has resulted in “a few oddities”. It cites Hong Kong, noting that “a generation of schoolchildren are condemned to carrying asthma inhalers because their little lungs are speckled with contaminants blowing across the harbour from mainland China”. They might have added “and from Hong Kong’s roadside pollution”.
| Liveable? Tell that to the kids |
Beijing gives Tsang a slap in the face
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/China/NG04Ad01.html Tsang’s Beijing slap in face
Mickey Mao
So when Tsang is charged by ICAC with misconduct in public office will Beijing be offering any bouquets? Likewise Henry Tang. Both abused their positions whilst in public office. Tang prima facie also cheated the Rating and Valuation Department out of rates for years – that’s fraud isn’t it? He ‘handed over ’house 7 (the basementgate house) to his wife – yet the Government rates bill still jointly covers both house 5A and 7 York Road – he missed that one.
Why did Tsang do nothing about the Environment – is HK Mayor CY Leung’s offering an office manager job to Edward Yau a sign that Yau has ‘sold the ranch’ on who was guilty of environmental prevarication for 5 years? There can be no other reason for employing the former environment minister with the worst failed portfolio.
And the belching diesel old Euro II buses – why was nothing done when Clean Air Zones in the worst polluted areas could have been mandated? Would that be anything to do with the fact retired Chief Secretary Rafael Hui reportedly sat on the board of KMB and retired Commissioner of Police , Tsang’s brother Tsang Yam Pui, sits on the board of Citybus and New World First Bus? The cost per head for a commercially lease-able 8 seat private jet to Phuket is US$ 11,800 – so Tsang was with his wife and everyone forgets the police minder who accompanied him everywhere – that’s US$ 35,000 and Tsang told everyone he paid for TWO Dragonair economy tickets (HKD 2900 per head) to the jet owner – I wonder who paid the hotel rooms including his police minder? – as can be seen from his abuse of public funds on overseas trips Tsang likes his US$ 8,000 a night rooms in Brazil and Washington whilst as a city mayor he earned far more than Barack Obama. This Tsang admission however leaves the jet owner with a problem since he does not have a commercial aircraft licence like CX or Dragonair. If he took Tsang’s money and cashed the cheque (what do you think?) he has a problem – if he didn’t then Tsang got a freebie for his threesome group. Given that police officers and other public officials have been charged and convicted with misconduct in public office for accepting far lower discounts there appears to be a major prima facie case against Tsang. No doubt the ICAC is looking into the Singapore Property Guru online report that Tsang’s apartment in Futian was to be ‘free’ and his free helicopter ride in Phuket, association with triad linked junket persona in Macau and a free hotel suite there. Strange that he was reported as staying on Joseph Lau’s boat in Macau in February (who now has a serious date with the criminal court there) then hitched a lift back on the Sunseeker of Charles Ho, owner of HK Tobacco Co Ltd just 2 weeks after there was no tobacco tax increase in the Budget. See More ……
o The reign of Donald Tsang summarised nicely in one single article.
Beijing gives Tsang a slap in the face
By Augustine Tan
HONG KONG – Donald Tsang Yam-kuen, the second chief executive of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, stepped down from office over the weekend after serving seven years without getting a time-honored sinecure from the central government of China. In the context of Chinese culture, that’s a slap in the face.
By comparison, his predecessor Tung Chee-hwa, though retired somewhat disgracefully, was given an honorary status of a “state leader” – vice-chairman of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference. Some observers point out that there may be a grace period before Beijing makes its final decision on whether and how to reward Tsang for his seven years of service. But it is almost certain that the central leadership is much less happy and satisfied with Tsang’s service than with Tung’s.
In any case, on the day he officially stepped down, Tsang still had to stay around to hear President Hu Jintao pointedly tell his successor Leung Chun-ying to run “a clean and efficient” government in Hong Kong.
Since the integrity of Hong Kong’s leaders has never been challenged before and corruption in government was never a public issue until recently, this was clearly regarded as a matter of grave concern.
Beijing may yet throw a sop at Tsang, but there’s no doubt that the central government has judged Tsang’s administration of Hong Kong and found him wanting.
Seven years of Tsang’s stewardship has left Hong Kong more divided, and more lopsided in its division of wealth since Britain handed its “Pearl of the Orient” back to China.
Tsang undoubtedly was aware of Beijing’s assessment. When he stepped out of his official residence, Government House, just before midnight on Sunday, his bow-tie firmly in place, a painful smile frozen on his face, he looked as if he were walking the last stretch to the guillotine. It was that grim.
The final weeks of his administration were most unlike any other run-up to a change in administration. Some of his key people were busy undermining his successor in public. Every day brought a fresh “expose” about “illegal structures” in Leung’s house on Victoria Peak. Every expose brought fresh demands that Leung “step down” even before his taking office. And every fresh demand sparked questions about Leung’s ability to manage Hong Kong.
It was not lost on pro-Beijing Hongkongers that Tsang and most of his officials, in close partnership with the property tycoons, had strenuously supported Henry Tang Ying-yen, the former chief secretary for administration, for the chief-executive succession in March. The front-runner until the final few weeks and long regarded as Beijing’s candidate, Tang was thrashed by Leung.
Tang was floored by exposes of his infidelities, his illegally constructed basement “palace” in his villa home at Kowloon Tong, and for spinelessly pushing his wife forward to take the blame for some of his wrongdoings.
During the election campaign there were exposes and counter-exposes. Donald Tsang’s support of Tang brought out into the open a slew of questionable dealings the former had with several tycoons, including a sweetheart deal for a luxury retirement apartment in Shenzhen, and various other examples of high living and traveling at public expense.
His supporters and officials saw the exposes as Beijing-instigated punishment for interfering in a selection process that is a monopoly of the central government.
Tsang went to the Legislative Council several times to apologize for his shortcomings. But detractors noted that corruption had dogged Tsang even earlier. They included the offer of a government cash coupon for those who switched to energy-saving light bulbs, which ostensibly benefited an in-law.
Over the past few years many people, especially those in the pro-Beijing camp, have asked whether there was any correlation between Tsang’s proximity to the property tycoons and the almost total absence of housing development for the lower-income groups. Not until his final year in office was any land released for low-cost housing. Instead, the Home Ownership Scheme originally set up to provide housing for the middle class was declared a “failure” and ordered to surrender its holdings – for private development.
The scheme was revived last year at the instigation of Wang Guangya, director of the Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office under the State Council, China’s cabinet.
It was a rare instance of direct intervention by the central government. According to a member of the National People’s Congress (NPC), China’s parliament, who spoke on condition of anonymity, Tsang had threatened to resign over thorny issues on several occasions.
“Now everything has come to an end, and CY [Leung] will take over; it’s all about revenge … Somebody has to pay for one candidate’s loss. There’s going to be a lot more in the coming months,” the NPC member added.
The campaign against Leung morphed into one of the largest ever anti-government, anti-Beijing protest marches in Hong Kong since 2003, with more than 100,000 marching from Victoria Park to the new government headquarters in Admiralty to demand Leung’s departure – just a few hours after he was sworn in by President Hu on Sunday.
While the central government may not be overly concerned about such demonstrations, it is entirely a different matter when it comes to divisions within the pro-Beijing camp. And the property tycoons have been very much an integral part of that camp. Others like NPC Standing Committee member Rita Fan Hsu Lai-tai, the former president of the Legislative Council who seriously wanted to run for the chief executive’s post but found no supporters from within the pro-Beijing camp, have also been taking swings at Leung.
The attacks against Leung have since the weekend extended to officials he has selected to be part of his government. His choices have been described as lightweight, inexperienced and worse.
Tsang’s supporters, if not Tsang himself, have been very active in promoting the rift. With Legislative Council elections scheduled for September, it is unlikely that Beijing will take its eyes off Hong Kong in the coming months.
Leung’s attempt to get the Legislative Council to approve his plan to revamp the government shortly before he took office was defeated by one vote. This showed how precarious his position – and that of the central government – can be if the division within the pro-Beijing camp is allowed to fester.
The slap in the face for Donald Tsang may be just the beginning – and the easiest step to take. More difficult might be calming the tycoons, who may just be mad enough to want to take their fight to the mainland.
They won’t win, but might be able to create some upsets. Is this why the richest Chinese in the world, property tycoon Li Ka-shing, is preparing to withdraw from the scene altogether by announcing how his empire will be divided between his two sons?
Augustine Tan is a Hong Kong-based journalist.
(Copyright 2012 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please contact us about sales, syndication and republishing.)
4 cities withhold info on ash disposal
http://www.waste-management-world.com/index/from-the-wires/wire-news-display/1700675375.html
Yomiuri
The Daily Yomiuri(Tokyo)
July 6, 2012
CHIBA–Four cities in Chiba Prefecture have stopped disclosing the names and locations of companies charged with burying incinerated ash from ordinary debris, which contains radioactive cesium, The Yomiuri Shimbun learned Thursday.
Matsudo, Abiko, Nagareyama and Narita are cities in the prefecture where relatively high levels of radiation were detected following the crisis at the Fukushima No. 1 nuclear power plant in Fukushima Prefecture.
The four cities, which ask companies to collect incinerated ash, said they made the decision because disclosing such information would cause fierce opposition from people living near disposal companies and final disposal sites.
Since the public has expressed serious concerns over the disposal of radioactive ash, the procedures for disclosure of such information will likely become more important, observers said.
The Matsudo municipal government disclosed in its fiscal 2011 general waste disposal program the names of four municipalities where private final dump sites used by ash collecting companies were located.
In its fiscal 2012 program released in April, however, such information was missing.
Abiko disclosed the names and locations of disposal companies until last year, but the companies’ names were crossed out in black in its document for this fiscal year.
Nagareyama started releasing the names of companies that rejected incinerated ash beginning last July. This fiscal year, however, it did not release the names of firms newly contracted to bury the ash.
Narita also did not disclose the names of such companies, though it did so last fiscal year.
The Waste Disposal Law obliges municipalities to map out a disposal program with basic information such as the details of companies that deal with waste materials.
The four cities’ documents on ordinary waste disposal programs are available for public viewing.
Last fiscal year, the documents of the four cities listed a total of eight municipalities in seven prefectures as places hosting final dump sites.
Currently, the ash being buried outside the four cities meets the radiation safety standards set by the central government at 8,000 becquerels or lower per kilogram–an acceptable level for a landfill.
To justify the decision to avoid disclosing information on disposal sites, an official of the Matsudo government said, “Local governments that accept the ash may be criticized by their residents, which could hinder their work and make them decline to accept the ash.”
The other three cities also referred to possible opposition from local residents as reasons for their decisions.
Meanwhile, The Yomiuri Shimbun has learned that Choshi, Chiba Prefecture, and Nakano, Nagano Prefecture, accepted incinerated ash from Matsudo.
The two cities and ash collecting companies have explained the situation to residents, giving information on the source, concentration of radioactive materials and other details.
The identity of other local governments accepting the ash remains unknown.
In Chiba Prefecture, some local governments have never disclosed the names of companies that dispose of the ash.
Because the four cities released the names of such entities until last fiscal year, their policy changes have attracted scrutiny.
Ichikawa, a city adjacent to Matsudo, started disclosing some companies’ names last year.
“People pay a lot of attention to waste disposal matters,” said the official of the municipal government that stated all the names of companies charged with waste disposal this fiscal year.
“Local governments can make their own decisions on what they choose to mention in the documents on their disposal program. But we think it’s best for them to state the names of companies they ask [to dispose of incinerated ash],” said an official of the Environment Ministry’s waste division.
Victims of the tourist squeeze
| A policy aimed at making Hong Kong more accessible to mainland tourists may have succeeded too well, according to some of its previous backers | |||||
| Amy Nip Jul 06, 2012 |
|
||||
|
As a way of reviving Hong Kong’s battered economy after the 2003 outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome, the Individual Visit Scheme was an almost immediate cure. It filled empty hotels, and restaurant owners and retailers rejoiced at the reappearance of travellers on the city’s once-deserted streets. Over the nine years since, the scope of the scheme – which allows mainland tourists to travel to Hong Kong by themselves rather than in a tour group – has been expanded from the initial four cities to 49, making 270 million people eligible to visit Hong Kong. The impact has been remarkable, with the Tourism Board reporting that 3.1 million visitors flooded in in January, up 23.9 per cent on the same period last year. They accounted for about three quarters of that month’s total of 4.14 million visitors. In 2002 Hong Kong received 16.6 million visitors, of whom 6.9 million, or 41.6 per cent, were from the mainland. By last year the number had soared to 41.9 million, 67 per cent of whom came from the mainland. But not everyone is happy with the fallout from the influx. Bookshops have been replaced by outlets selling jewellery, watches and electronic appliances to the big spenders. Local mothers have difficulty buying milk formula – a sought-after commodity for mainlanders – and consumers confronted with rising inflation blame the tourists for soaring prices. When the mainland’s simplified characters finally made it on to outdoor advertisements and restaurant menus, alongside the traditional ones preferred in Hong Kong, the anger intensified. Hongkongers began calling the influx a cultural invasion, likening it to a plague of locusts. No consultation was carried out before the government opened the gates in 2003 – and not that many people would have objected, given the prevailing economic slump. Nevertheless, it was unusual for any policy with such a significant impact not to undergo a sustainability assessment first. Such studies have been mandatory since 2001, when the government adopted guidelines that require any new policy’s consequences for the economy, social infrastructure and cultural diversity to be taken into account. The government’s argument was that the scheme was a timely measure that brought immediate benefits and was one of the most successful and welcome liberalisation measures adopted under Beijing and Hong Kong’s Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement. According to James Tien Pei-chun, now chairman of the Tourism Board, the time has come to review a policy he once enthusiastically supported. In March 2004, writing in this newspaper in his capacity as the chairman of the pro-business Liberal Party, Tien said: “Our economy is well on the way to recovery, thanks to the benefits from the Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement and the Individual Visit Scheme. At last, our property market is flourishing, the stock market is climbing and our consumption is rising, but it will be some time before these benefits reach the ordinary citizen.” Eight years later, Tien believes the scheme needs to be reassessed. “The new government will have to look into the problem,” he said. “There are an increasing number of conflicts as mainland Chinese integrate with Hong Kong society. It is necessary for the government to look into the positive and negative aspects of welcoming mainland tourists into the city.” The economic benefits are obvious. Tourism is the fastest growing of Hong Kong’s four pillar industries, the others being financial services, professional services and trading and logistics. The tourism sector employed 218,100 people in 2010, making it a major employer, particularly for those with lower qualifications. But the rising numbers are not without their drawbacks. Since 2009, when Shenzhen allowed its permanent residents to apply for multiple-entry visas, day-trippers increasingly target daily necessities rather than luxury goods.Tien said this was pushing up prices of basic commodities and fuelling conflict between locals and tourists. Further growth of the tourism sector was also not guaranteed as infrastructure problems came into play. The supply of hotel rooms, for one, has been a bottleneck for the development of tourism, he said. Accommodation used to be low on the mainlanders’ list of priorities, with 70 per cent of their budgets going to shopping and just 10 per cent to hotels, Tien said. Now it was becoming harder for them to find affordable lodgings, with even a room in the New Territories costing more than HK$1,000 a night. When tourist numbers were soaring, hotel supply was growing more slowly: the number rose from 94, providing 37,277 rooms, to 184, with 61,828 rooms. The occupancy rate jumped from about 58 per cent to 89 per cent. Almost all hotels were packed last Christmas, and room rates, even in Chungking Mansion, went through the roof. The Commerce Department expects that by 2016 there will be 254 hotels in the city, providing more than 74,000 rooms, but Tien warns that rising prices may nevertheless see tourists going elsewhere. “If a trip to Hong Kong costs more than HK$10,000, why wouldn’t they go to Rome or Paris instead?” he said. “They could get luxury brands for less than in Hong Kong after getting refunds for value-added tax.” Land supply has always been scarce. Tien said this meant it was necessary for the government to rethink its priorities. “Should the government allocate land for public housing and offices or malls and hotels for tourists?” he said. Even one of the biggest beneficiaries of tourism – the retail industry – has begun to feel the pain. Caroline Mak, chairwoman of the Retail Management Association, said the lack of new retail space plus rising demand for land had caused rents to more than double since the Individual Visit Scheme was introduced. Noonly were shops in busy tourist districts affected, the upward pressure was being felt in neighbouring communities. The labour shortage had worsened, with an association survey showing that 8.9 per cent of vacancies remained unfilled for prolonged periods. Government statistics in March showed the retail industry employed 256,844. Mak said rising rents made products more expensive, while labour shortages threatened the quality of service. Both trends would reduce Hong Kong’s attractiveness as a shopping paradise. With many shops turning to jewellery, watches, electronics and international brands, the local touch is disappearing quickly, leaving visitors with “a homogeneous shopping experience”. “Local shoppers have come to me complaining about the long distances they have to cover to buy daily necessities … even convenience stores cannot withstand the high rents,” Mak said. It also made the retail industry – more than half of whose sales are made to tourists – more vulnerable to economic changes. In the first five months of this year, the volume of sales of jewellery, watches and valuable gifts – previous must-haves for mainland tourists – dropped 2.9 per cent from a year ago in the face of global economic uncertainties and a cooling off of the mainland property market. Over the same period, total retail sales volume increased 9.1 per cent. Mak said a committee should be set up to review retailing’s impact on other sectors, including advertising, transport and catering. Then it should work out long-term directions regarding the number of hotels required, labour supply and retail space. “Now it’s time to stop and think about how we can achieve sustainable growth. We should say no quick cures,” she said. Although tourism is a thriving sector in many parts of the world, figures suggest its impact and the friction it generates are far greater in Hong Kong than elsewhere. Despite its small size, the number of visitors to Hong Kong is comparable to that to entire nations: last year it welcomed 40 million visitors, almost two thirds of the 62.7 million received by the United States. The UN World Tourism Organisation has forecast that by 2020 China will be the fourth-biggest source of tourists after Germany, Japan and the United States. Hong Kong will rank fifth in terms of tourist arrivals, with the top four destinations being China, France, the United States and Spain. “The ratio of tourists to locals in Hong Kong is very high,” said Terence Chong Tai-leung, associate professor of economics at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. The ratio is almost six to one for Hong Kong, which has a population of seven million. Mainland tourists, with their massive spending power, inevitably raised the demand for goods and added to inflation, which was aggravated by the depreciation of the Hong Kong dollar against the yuan. Chong said this was not a pattern repeated elsewhere: those going to New York, for example, seldom devoted all their time to shopping. Chong said government intervention in the supply of hotel rooms had to be handled with caution. The availability of rooms would limit tourist numbers, meaning it was not necessary for the government to limit the numbers of visitors. The importance of mainland visitors to Hong Kong is likely to continue growing, according to Tony Tse, assistant professor in Polytechnic University’s school of hotel and tourism management. He said it would be wise to put more emphasis on other source markets so the city did not become over-reliant on one particular market. Apart from shopping and dining, there was also room for enhancing and showcasing its culture. “Hong Kong is unique in being Chinese in its roots and having a strong British influence,” he said, and more could be done to showcase the city’s colonial past. Although no sustainability study has been conducted, according to the Commerce and Economic Development Bureau the government has maintained close communication with mainland authorities on the Individual Visit Scheme’s implementation. “Looking ahead, in considering whether to encourage more visitors, we should take into account whether we have enough facilities, such as the capacity of border control points and tourist attractions, supply of hotel rooms and transport,” a bureau spokesman said. |
|||||
New dimension in cross-border pollution fight
Jasmine Siu
Friday, July 06, 2012
The Chinese University of Hong Kong has launched the first cross-border air and water quality monitoring system – though it admits it is far from perfect due to the lack of data from the mainland.
It expects that with more funding it will be able to place sensors on main roads in the Pearl River Delta to provide early warning for government officers and the public.
The system currently depends on the air pollution index released by the Environmental Protection Department and data collected from 3,000 chimneys.
It then analyzes specific areas where pollution is most severe and its direction of dispersal.
The project – run by the university’s Institute of Space and Earth Information Science – combines the technology of satellite imagery and virtual geographic environments to provide near-real time 3D data.
“In terms of technology, this is a major breakthrough,” Hu Mingyuan, a postdoctoral fellow at the institute, said.
Researchers hope the institute can gain access to mainland data in a few years and release a more accurate analyses on an hourly basis.
Approximately HK$2 million has been spent on the two-year-old project and the institute is hoping to obtain an extra HK$2 million government grant.
According to the Clean Air Network, a local nongovernment organization, Hong Kong’s air pollution mortality rate is eighth-highest in the world, far worse than the mainland, India and Vietnam.
While the high number of motor vehicles contributes to the city’s poor air quality, the situation is made worse when monsoon winds bring pollutants from the delta region, which is known for its high level of industrial development.
Meanwhile, the system for monitoring water quality is now entering an operational phase and will be completed by 2014. More data from the mainland is also needed.