http://www.epd-asg.gov.hk/english/24pollu_fsp/Central_Western_fsp.html
March, 2012:
Pearl River Delta TO release PM 2.5 in March – People’s Daily Online
Clear the Air says:
We welcome the actions and decision by the Government of China in listening to the discontent of its Beijing citizens and taking appropriate and rapid action to release this data on killer PM2.5 particulates in real time.
Hong Kong has followed suit today although it has been monitoring PM2.5 data for a far longer period than the Mainland; however continued prevarication by this Administration prevented the release of such data to the Hong Kong public.
The real time release of this PM2.5 data in the PRD will provide significant data for the Government of Hong Kong to use in its PATH computer modelling program system that tracks transboundary pollution sources.
We will then be able to see just how much PM2.5 pollution emanates from the PRD versus local sources.
Of significance is the fact that approximately 31% of airborne RSP in Hong Kong is believed to come from ocean going vessels and shipping within our waters whilst we have yet to mandate an Emissions Control Area (ECA) together with the PRD to force shipping to use low sulphur fuel instead of high sulphur bunker slops in the ECA.
We urge the Environment Minister Edward Yau to use his power under Section 7 (3) of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance to gazette the new Air Quality Standards into law without waiting till 2014.
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2012-03/08/content_14788493.htm
HK commences PM2.5 hourly reporting
Updated: 2012-03-08 12:20
(Xinhua)
HONG KONG – Hong Kong’s Environmental Protection Department (EPD) said on Thursday it will commenced the regular reporting in real time of fine suspended particulates (also known as PM2.5) from March 8, and the data can be accessed on the EPD website.
The data will reveal the hourly concentrations of PM2.5 as measured by the EPD’s air quality monitoring network, which comprises 11 general stations and three roadside stations.
A spokesman for the EPD said, “In anticipation of the inclusion of PM2.5 as a new criteria pollutant in the proposed new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs), we have progressively acquired new PM2. 5 monitors to extend continuous PM2.5 measurements to all air quality monitoring stations. The installation and testing of the new PM2.5 monitors has now been completed.”
According to the spokesman, to better understand the situation with regard to PM2.5 in Hong Kong, the EPD has been monitoring the pollutant since 1999 at three of its general air monitoring stations. And another general station was later added in 2005.
The monitoring results show that the level of PM2.5 in Hong Kong has reduced by 17 percent from 2005 to 2011. The spokesman said, this progress was owed to the control measures jointly implemented by the Hong Kong and Guangdong Governments in recent years.
The spokesman added that they will continue to collaborate with the Guangdong Provincial Government on emission reduction measures to further reduce the levels of particulates and other pollutants in Hong Kong.
Copyright By chinadaily.com.cn. All rights reserved
http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2012-03/08/content_14783365.htm
Early start on PM2.5 monitoring
Updated: 2012-03-08 07:47
By Li Wenfang and Wang Zhenghua (China Daily)
Environmental authorities of Guangdong province plan to start releasing PM2.5 readings on Thursday, an early-bird approach to meeting the stricter national air quality requirements.
The State Council announced last week that stricter standards would be adopted in cities, including readings for ozone and concentrations of PM2.5 – particulate matter smaller than 2.5 micrometers in diameter – which is considered more hazardous to health than larger particles.
Guangdong’s initial readings will come from 17 monitoring stations in the Pearl River Delta.
Readings at other stations in the delta would be made public by June 5, with those from all stations in the province available in 2014, said Li Qing, director of the provincial environmental protection bureau, at a work conference on Monday.
Given the marked air pollution in the delta, the number of days with air quality that meet the standards in Guangdong will fall 10 to 30 percent after the new standards are adopted, Li said.
Guangdong’s announcement came after Premier Wen Jiabao said in his work report on Monday that China will start monitoring PM2.5 in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region, the Yangtze River Delta, the Pearl River Delta and in other key areas, like municipalities directly under the central government, and provincial capital cities this year.
As an economic powerhouse of China, Guangdong faces an uphill task in environmental protection. With a large increase of output from coal-fired power plants last year, sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxide compound emissions went up, heightening the pressure to fulfill the emission reduction task in the 2011-15 period, according to the provincial environmental protection bureau.
Authorities will tighten clean air legislation this year, strengthening the treatment of emissions from automobiles and coal-fired power plants. They will also phase out obsolete capacities in industries involving furnaces, paper making, printing and dyeing, chemicals, construction materials and cement.
An investment of 100 million yuan ($15.8 million) is needed to enable all 97 national monitoring stations in Guangdong to test the air for PM2.5, in addition to staff recruitment and training.
In Guangzhou, capital of Guangdong province, daily air quality reports in line with the new standards, including PM2.5 readings, will be issued on the websites of the environmental authorities starting Thursday.
The new standards further emphasize public health guidelines and will serve as reference to the public in arranging their lives and outings, said Yang Liu, deputy director of the city environmental protection bureau, in a statement released Monday night.
He said city authorities will strengthen the control of automobile emissions and industrial pollutants, among other measures.
“The release should help improve air quality but the efforts should not stop here. I hope the government will increase transparency to make the data more convincing and will step up the supervision of the polluters,” said a university student in Guangzhou who identified herself only as Huang.
Following Guangdong, the financial center of Shanghai vowed to complete a monitoring network for PM 2.5 in June and focus on cutting emissions from vehicles and power plants – two major sources of the city’s pollutants.
The local environment protection department said about 25 percent of the city’s PM2.5 comes from car emissions, as a large amount of small pollutants are discharged from diesel-fueled vehicles on the road. The amount increases if the drivers of these vehicles adopt bad driving habits such as frequent sudden acceleration and braking.
Official statistics showed that Shanghai still has more than 200,000 “yellow-label cars” – heavy-polluting vehicles – discharging 20 to 30 times more pollutants than green-label cars.
Another 20 percent of PM2.5 in the city’s air comes from the chemical industrial process and industrial boilers and furnaces.
As such, the city plans to phase out 150,000 yellow-label cars by the end of 2014, and raise emission standards for newly registered cars, while providing sufficient approved-quality refined oil.
To fight pollution from thermal power plants, the city proposed cutting emissions by upgrading filtering and denitration facilities.
You may contact the writers at liwenfang@chinadaily.com.cn and wangzhenghua@chinadaily.com.cn
Liang Qianyun in Guangzhou contributed to this story.
Copyright By chinadaily.com.cn. All rights reserved
http://english.peopledaily.com.cn/90882/7751031.html
Pearl River Delta TO release PM 2.5 in March
(People’s Daily)
16:25, March 07, 2012
Edited and translated by People’s Daily Online
Seventeen automatic air quality monitoring stations in the Pearl River Delta in southern China’s Guangdong province will begin releasing monitoring results, including PM2.5 readings, according to new national air quality standards later in March.
Other monitoring stations in the region will adopt the new standards from World Environment Day on June 5, according to information from the Guangdong Conference of Environmental Protection Bureau Chiefs, which kicked off on March 5.
China’s new air quality standards include an index for PM2.5, particulate matter smaller than 2.5 micrometers in diameter. The Pearl River Delta was ordered to start monitoring PM2.5 this year. In addition to the Pearl River Delta, many cities in Guangdong is busy installing PM2.5 monitoring equipment, in hopes of implementing the new standards ahead of deadline and forming a monitoring network throughout the province.
It is estimated that the percentage of cities in Guangdong meeting the new air quality standards will drop by 10 to 30 percent. In order to improve air quality, the province will strengthen the regulation of the sales of environmental protection facilities, and improve social operations of automatic air quality monitoring at wastewater treatment plants and thermal power plants with a capacity of more than 300 megawatts.
http://english.cri.cn/6909/2012/03/07/3123s685425.htm
Beijing Joins Neighboring Regions in PM2.5 Control
2012-03-07 17:48:41 Xinhua Web Editor: sunwanming
| Beijing has joined five neighboring provincial regions in an initiative to cut the city’s PM2.5 pollutants, a top environmental protection official said Wednesday.
Beijing’s high reading of PM 2.5 — fine particulate matter 2.5 microns or less in diameter — and poor air quality are correlated with air conditions in surrounding regions under the scheme, according to Minister of Environmental Protection Zhou Shengxian. This problem can hardly be solved by the Beijing municipal government alone, hence the joint action also involves neighboring regions including Hebei province and Tianjin city, Zhou said. He said people are particularly attentive to PM2.5 figures because particles at this level are considered more hazardous to health than larger ones. The official said China’s effort to cut PM2.5 is an indication that the country is now paying more attention to the environmental quality rather than the total pollutants discharged. |
| News @ AsiaOne
Beijing to switch from coal to gas to go green More than 100 smaller cities will adopt the new air quality standards in 2013. -China Daily/ANN Thu, Mar 08, 2012 Beijing is to take action to make its coal-fired power plants and heating facilities go green amid public concern over the city’s poor air quality, said a government official. Zhang Gong, director of Beijing municipal development and reform commission, said that an estimated 80 billion yuan (S$16.3 billion) will be invested to switch the city’s coal-fired power plants and heating facilities to natural gas. “We want to make sure that power plants and heating facilities will be fueled by natural gas in the coming three to four years, reducing the use of coal as much as possible,” Zhang said on the sidelines of the annual session of the National People’s Congress. Zhang said the move is set to improve Beijing’s air quality and ease public concern over PM2.5, particulate matter smaller than 2.5 micrometers in diameter, which can be hazardous after reaching a certain concentration. Emissions from coal-fired power plants and heating facilities, as well as from the 5 million cars running in Beijing, are a major source of PM2.5 in the capital, according to research conducted by the municipal government. Coal consumption in Beijing was around 26.3 million tons in 2011, with coal-fired heating and power plants accounting for 73 per cent. The remainder was for industrial use, Zhang said. “So reducing the use of coal is our priority to cut the concentration of PM2.5 in the city,” he said, adding Beijing will use more green energy in the near future. PM2.5 has been put higher up the government agenda amid growing concern over poor air quality in China’s big cities. According to a statement by the State Council at the end of February, the four municipalities – Beijing, Shanghai, Tianjin and Chongqing – and 27 provincial capitals, as well as three key regions – the Yangtze and Pearl river deltas and the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region – will monitor PM2.5 this year. More than 100 smaller cities will adopt the new air quality standards in 2013. The statement said the standards will be extended to all cities by 2015. Beijing has been releasing the data on the concentration of PM2.5 to the public since January. Replacing coal-fired plants with natural gas-fueled ones will make significant contribution toward improving air quality, said Ma Jun, director of the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs, a Beijing-based non-governmental organization. “However, it may take longer than expected,” Ma said. He said Beijing is actually a relatively small consumer of coal compared with its neighbors in Hebei province and Tianjin. “The hard work done by Beijing alone is not going to improve the overall air quality unless the neighboring cities also make an effort,” he said. Zhang from the reform and development commission of Beijing said that the experience of Western countries shows that improving air quality is a long and complicated battle. “The government is no longer focusing solely on the economic growth of the city. We want to have sustainable development and create a livable city for the people,” he said, adding that is the reason that the government has set an annual target of 8 per cent GDP growth during the 12th Five-Year Plan period (2011-15) instead of the double-digit growth of previous years. You may contact the writers at mengjing@chinadaily.com.cn and zhangyan@chinadaily.com.cn |
| Copyright ©2011 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved. |
| Privacy Statement Conditions of Access Advertise |
http://www.asiaone.com/News/AsiaOne%2BNews/Asia/Story/A1Story20120308-332248.html
Waste can become the fuel for a greener Hong Kong; Douglas Woodring says we need creative management, not an incinerator
Waste can become the fuel for a greener Hong Kong; Douglas Woodring says we need creative management, not an incinerator
Douglas Woodring
South China Morning Post
March 8, 2012
The large-scale incinerator planned for the island off southern Lantau, Shek Kwu Chau, has sparked strong debate about its practicality and, in many ways, the future of Hong Kong. This is not just a “not in my backyard” issue, it is about an ill-planned project that will affect the entire city and even those who might want to visit or live here in the future.
By holding the public hostage to a railroaded approval process, forcing us all to accept outdated technology, poor planning and lack of foresight, the government is setting itself up for further alienation from a public it is trying to win over with “harmonious” activities.
Southern Lantau is valuable because it will increasingly be the “lungs and heart” of the city we live in, along with the coasts and islands within our reach. Once these assets are taken away, there will be nothing left in the bank for us to draw on.
It was not so many years ago that Hong Kong remained one of the few countries that did not classify waste as a renewable energy source. This hindered many potential waste-to-fuel technologies and innovations that could have been set up around the existing landfills, where our waste planning basically equates to digging bigger landfill holes.
When Beijing put some pressure on our city to have a higher renewable energy input, the government then realised it had to allow waste to be turned to fuel in order to achieve its goals, already meagre when compared with the rest of our neighbours in the region.
So, we are now being told that waste can be valuable, and incineration can be the solution to our landfill issues, but we are being presented with an outdated way of thinking and planning that will greatly reduce the perceived benefits of such a plan. Why should our population, with a wealthy government, accept substandard thinking and solutions, and environmental degradation all at the same time? This is like building a highway and ensuring that it is designed with large potholes.
Technologies today have shown that waste has value as secondary raw materials. It is something we want to preserve, re-use and extract value from, while maintaining the value of our assets in the “bank” – our environment. Incinerating waste is the lazy way out of a problem; it depletes the resources right under our noses.
By separating all plastic waste, for example, economies of scale can be created for proper, value-added recycling. This saves energy and creates material that leading brands of the world are starting to use. After all of the valuable plastic material is extracted, the remaining material can be turned into fuel, not via incineration, but via distillation, which turns it back to a liquid. Plastic is stored energy after all, derived from petroleum.
The huge benefit this now creates is that all of our food waste and organic material can be treated separately, using new composting or other technologies. When all of these waste streams are separated, the creation of methane in landfills is avoided. Plastic can be harnessed as a fuel in a much bigger way. And, no incineration is needed.
An incinerator at Shek Kwu Chau will not only cause immeasurable long-term damage to the value of Hong Kong as a city by the sea, to the island it occupies, to the ocean it fills, and to the quality of life for tomorrow’s generation – it will show the world that we lack the skills and planning to create a truly world-class city. The plan will also create carbon emissions from support transport, probably offsetting the “renewable” resources it is meant to create.
Instead, we could deploy new recycling, composting and specialised waste-to-fuel options which would maximise the value that this secondary raw material represents.
We are missing out on a huge job creation opportunity here, not to mention an impressive environmental leadership role to be proud of.
Do we have the ability to guide this project and planning in the direction that this city deserves?
Douglas Woodring is founder of the Ocean Recovery Alliance and a Clinton Global Initiative Commitment Maker
Copyright 2012 South China Morning Post Ltd.All Rights Reserved
South China Morning Post
“GE & Chesapeake Energy Corp. Announce Collaboration to Speed Adoption of Natural Gas as Transportation Fuel”
Press Release
GE and Chesapeake Energy Corporation Announce Collaboration to Speed Adoption of Natural Gas as Transportation Fuel
· Initiative Targets Natural Gas Fueling Infrastructure Development
· Agreement Designed to Develop Products and Services for Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) and Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) Transportation and Home Fueling Solutions
· Chesapeake to Deploy More than 250 of GE’s ecomagination™-Qualified “CNG In A Box™”Fueling Systems across the United States through 2015 through its Affiliate, Peake Fuel Solutions
7 March 2012
HOUSTON—March 7, 2012—GE (NYSE: GE) and Chesapeake Energy Corporation (NYSE: CHK) today announced a collaboration to develop infrastructure solutions that will help accelerate the adoption of natural gas as a transportation fuel. This groundbreaking technology and services project marks a significant milestone toward increasing energy independence in the United States through the increased use of natural gas—an abundant, reliable and cleaner-burning source of energy for both consumers and commercial users.
To formalize the agreement, GE and Chesapeake have signed a memorandum of understanding on a product and services development partnership, representing a multi-year collaboration between the two companies to develop and bring to market compressed natural gas (CNG) and liquefied natural gas (LNG) transportation and natural gas home-fueling solutions. By improving access to CNG, which is most commonly used in light- to medium-duty vehicles such as pickups, vans, SUVs, taxicabs, transit buses, refuse and delivery trucks as well as consumer vehicles, along with LNG, which is commonly used for heavy-duty industrial purposes, dependence on foreign energy sources can be reduced while simultaneously lowering fueling costs and vehicle emissions.
The collaboration is designed to leverage GE’s global Oil & Gas technology portfolio with Chesapeake’s expertise in developing innovative fueling solutions to lower the ownership and operational costs of natural gas vehicle (NGV) fueling stations. With the development of shale resources dramatically increasing the amount of low-cost natural gas in North America, the GE-Chesapeake collaboration can help incentivize operators to put more NGVs on the nation’s highways.
As part of today’s announced collaboration, beginning in the fall of 2012 GE will provide more than 250 modular and standardized CNG compression stations for NGV infrastructure. These units, also known as “CNG In A Box™,”have gone through GE’s rigorous ecomagination-qualification process and will provide the core infrastructure to enable expanded access to CNG at fueling stations and other designated installations.
A vehicle using CNG can reduce annual fuel costs up to 40 percent, assuming 25,700 miles per year driven, gasoline priced at $3.50/gallon and CNG at $2.09/gasoline gallon equivalent. This represents savings totaling as much as $1,500 per fleet vehicle per year. In total, for each fleet vehicle using fuel provided by CNG In A Box instead of gasoline, a fleet operator can reduce CO2e emissions from fuel combustion by about 24 percent, or 2.2 metric tons per vehicle annually, assuming an average fleet vehicle travels approximately 25,700 miles per year.
“Both GE and Chesapeake are known for taking on tough energy challenges and putting the best minds and technologies to work to develop solutions,” said Aubrey K. McClendon, Chesapeake’s Chief Executive Officer. “The partnership announced today between GE and Chesapeake’s affiliate, Peake Fuel Solutions, combines Chesapeake’s natural gas expertise with GE’s extensive global manufacturing capabilities and will bring transformative products to industries and individual consumers across the U.S. These products and services will allow customers to enjoy the clear advantages of clean, affordable and abundant American natural gas at about half the cost of gasoline.”
Said GE Energy President & CEO John Krenicki, “GE is fundamentally committed to natural gas—our technologies help extract it, move it and turn it into power, whether it’s highly efficient gas turbines delivering electricity at the utility scale or, in the near future, a vehicle at a refueling station. What makes this project particularly exciting is thatit paves the way to taking the immense reserves of natural gas being discovered in the U.S. and using them right here in the U.S. That paves the way for faster economic growth, energy security, more jobs and reduced environmental impact.”
This CNG technology will be brought to market by Peake Fuel Solutions—a Chesapeake affiliate—which has extensive experience with natural gas vehicles, vehicle emission controls and natural gas market dynamics. Chesapeake also brings considerable in-house expertise in CNG market development to the GE collaboration, including retail station relationships, fleet outreach and education programs and policy engagement.
CNG In A Box takes natural gas from a pipeline and compresses it on-site at an industrial location or at a traditional automotive refilling station to then turn it into CNG. A CNG vehicle, such as a taxi, bus or small truck, can then refill its tank using a traditional fuel dispenser, much like those used for diesel or gasoline refueling.
Key features include:
· The gas compression, storage, cooling, drying and controls are easy to ship and maintain due to its compact “In Box” design.
· The units come in two configurations: an 8 foot x 20 foot container or 8 foot x 40 foot container, depending on the site’s need.
· Its modular and intuitive design makes it “Plug & Play” on-site.
· The offering includes GE Wayne branded dispensers with credit card capability and provision for “Point Of Sale” interface.
· The fuel dispenses at a rate of about 7 gasoline gallon equivalent per minute.
Other elements of the new collaboration include:
· Aftermarket services for natural gas fueling infrastructure.
· GE’s LNG fueling plants, which adapt GE’s proven large-scale LNG liquefaction technologies to smaller-scale operations. Using LNG as a substitute for diesel or fuel oil can reduce combustion emissions up to 25 percent.
· Development of home refueling technologies.
· Co-marketing of products and services resulting from the partnership.
About GE
GE (NYSE: GE) works on things that matter. The best people and the best technologies taking on the toughest challenges. Finding solutions in energy, health and home, transportation and finance. Building, powering, moving and curing the world. Not just imagining. Doing. GE works. For more information, visit the company’s website atwww.ge.com.
GE Energy works connecting people and ideas everywhere to create advanced technologies for powering a cleaner, more productive world. With more than 100,000 employees in over 100 countries, our diverse portfolio of product and service solutions and deep industry expertise help our customers solve their challenges locally. We serve the energy sector with technologies in such areas as natural gas, oil, coal and nuclear energy; wind, solar, biogas and water processing; energy management; and grid modernization. We also offer integrated solutions to serve energy- and water-intensive industries such as mining, metals, marine, petrochemical, food & beverage and unconventional fuels.
Follow GE Energy on Twitter @GE_Energy.
About Chesapeake Energy Corporation
Chesapeake Energy Corporation (NYSE: CHK) is the second-largest producer of natural gas, a Top 15 producer of oil and natural gas liquids and the most active driller of new wells in the U.S. Headquartered in Oklahoma City, the company’s operations are focused on discovering and developing unconventional natural gas and oil fields onshore in the U.S. Chesapeake owns leading positions in the Barnett, Haynesville, Bossier, Marcellus and Pearsall natural gas shale plays and in the Granite Wash, Cleveland, Tonkawa, Mississippi Lime, Bone Spring, Avalon, Wolfcamp, Wolfberry, Eagle Ford, Niobrara and Utica unconventional liquids-rich plays. The company has also vertically integrated its operations and owns substantial midstream, compression, drilling, trucking, pressure pumping and other oilfield service assets directly and indirectly through its subsidiaries Chesapeake Midstream Development, L.P. and Chesapeake Oilfield Services, L.L.C. and its affiliate Chesapeake Midstream Partners, L.P. (NYSE: CHKM). Further information is available at www.chk.com where Chesapeake routinely posts announcements, updates, events, investor information, presentations and news releases.
About ecomagination
ecomagination is GE’s business strategy to help customers meet their environmental and operational challenges. It is based on GE’s belief that solving environmental problems is good business around the world. It represents a pledge by the company to continually improve operations and invest in research and development that will produce more innovative ecomagination products. Through ecomagination, GE is driving a global energy transformation with a focus on innovation and R&D investment to accelerate the development and deployment of clean energy technology.
About Peake Fuel Solutions
Peake Fuel Solutions (PFS) advances innovative fuel solutions with products and services that create demand for clean, affordable natural gas. A significant focus of PFS is to increase compressed natural gas (CNG) and liquefied natural gas (LNG) infrastructure across the U.S. Other PFS projects include development of on-road and off-road technologies that reduce emissions and dramatically cut fuel expenses for the trucking, maritime, rail and oil and gas industries. An affiliate of Chesapeake Energy Corporation, PFS leverages the expertise of other Chesapeake affiliates to implement many of its fuel solutions. Further information is available at www.chk.com.
PRESS CONTACTS
Sean Gannon
GE
+1 212 587 5059(mobile)
sean.gannon@ge.com
Rob Discher
Edelman
+ 1 512 634 3654
robert.discher@edelman.com
Jim Gipson
Chesapeake Energy Corporation
+1 405 795 9247
jim.gipson@chk.com
GE news
Masto Public Relations
information@mastopr.com
Putting a spin on pollution
Premier promises growth will not damage environment, but fails to report missed targets, prompting idea he wants to leave on a high note
Premier Wen Jiabao pledged yesterday that China’s pursuit of staggering economic expansion would not come at the cost of public health or the environment, in an apparent bid to placate simmering anger over widespread ecological degradation and key pollution-cut targets that were missed last year.
But his soothing words, offered at the opening of the last parliamentary gathering ahead of the leadership shake-up later this year, failed to cheer up mainland environmentalists, who pointed to a shroud of smog hovering over the capital yesterday and the bleak reality that an ecological crisis is behind the country’s economic success.
Speaking to nearly 3,000 deputies of the National People’s Congress, Wen said: “We will show the world with our actions that China will never seek economic growth at the expense of its ecological environment and public health.”
The premier, who will step down in March of next year, also vowed that Beijing was capable of striking a fine balance among economic growth, public welfare and conservation.
Although his remarks were hailed by state media as showcasing the government’s determination to curb pollution and heed public concerns, environmentalists said they also served as a grim reminder that China’s pollution woes had gone from bad to worse under his watch over the past decade.
Even Wen painted a rather gloomy picture. He admitted his government failed to meet several mandatory targets last year on emission controls and energy efficiency, which were among the commitments made by the world’s largest carbon emitter to help tackle global warming.
However, for the first time in the six years since his government rolled out a set of pollution and energy curbs, Wen did not give details about the missed targets in his annual policy address, rekindling accusations he may want to gloss over pollution problems and put a positive spin on his legacy before his retirement.
According to a report issued yesterday by the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), the missed annual targets included both energy intensity and carbon intensity, as well as nitrogen oxides, an air pollutant that contributes to ground-level ozone formation and can cause serious lung damage.
While energy consumption per unit of GDP, a measure of energy intensity, dropped by just 2 per cent, compared with an annual target of 3.5 per cent, details about curbing carbon intensity were omitted from the NDRC report.
Amid mounting international calls for China to make stronger efforts to cut its greenhouse gas emissions, Beijing promised last year that it would reduce carbon emissions per unit of gross domestic product by 17 per cent from the 2010 level by 2015.
“It is so disappointing that the government did not have the guts to confront its own failure [on the mandatory targets]. Apparently, the truth [about China’s pollution problems] is too bleak to be made public,” said Li Yan , a campaigner for Greenpeace China.
Despite the government’s repeated calls to rein in industrial polluters and to change the mainland’s economic growth model, energy-intensive and heavy-polluting industries have seen a rapid, robust expansion.
Li and other environmentalists said Wen and his government should be held responsible for this rise. Beijing last year lowered its pollution-cutting targets for the 12th five-year plan, after setbacks and strong resistance from local authorities.
In an effort to repair the damage, Wen yesterday urged a speedy compilation of plans to cap total energy consumption, which may see a ceiling on coal consumption in the next few years.
Environmentalists have said capping coal consumption would help reduce the country’s reliance on dirty coal and assist the push for a low-carbon economy.
Beijing has also made it a priority to expand clean-energy sectors, such as nuclear and hydropower facilities.
A recent environmental ministry-sanctioned study also confirmed widespread concerns that pollution had deteriorated at a faster rate than the efforts to reverse degradation.
Findings released last month showed that the estimated total cost of ecological degradation on the mainland in 2009, including the direct cost of pollution, was nearly 1.4 trillion yuan (HK$1.72 trillion), or 3.8 per cent of the mainland’s economic output. By comparison, the figure was 1.28 trillion yuan in 2008.
Capital to lead nation in trash burning
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/cndy/2012-03/06/content_14762943.htm
Asia’s largest household refuse incineration plant, which is under construction in Beijing, will become operational in October and have a daily processing capacity of 3,000 tons.
The plant is expected to handle one-fourth of the city’s trash, and its annual energy output will exceed 300 million kilowatt hours.
Power and heat generated by the plant will be supplied to all four districts in western Beijing, namely Mentougou, Shijingshan, Haidian and Fengtai, Zhu Jimin, chairman of Shougang Group, one of China’s largest iron and steel companies, which invested more than 2 billion yuan ($317 million) in the project, said at a news conference on Sunday.
According to Zhu, the group is also conducting research and development on transforming food waste into organic materials and oil products, in order to prevent it from being used to produce “gutter oil” in the catering industry or causing pollution at landfill sites.
“The plant will be located in a mining area in the city’s western outskirts in Mentougou district, which is sparsely populated, to limit the impact of its emissions of ash, cinder, dioxin and volatile heavy metals such as manganese on the public,” said Mao Da, an expert in solid-waste management at Beijing Normal University.
Due to health concerns and the smell emanating from the plant, many local people have objected to having it near their homes.
Mao said that “a strict environmental evaluation audit is important for the plant, to ensure that the environment is not impaired in the future”.
“You can never underestimate the pollutants from incineration plants.”
With the growing volume of household trash in the capital, incineration is playing an increasingly important role, according to Chen Liwen, a researcher with Green Beagle, a green non-governmental organization based in Beijing.
Composting, landfill and incineration are the three major ways garbage is treated in China.
Mao said that composting is not a practical option, as this method only works effectively if the waste is biodegradable, such as food waste and garden garbage.
And, as there are few available sites for landfill, Mao said that the government is left with no other option but incineration, which requires less space, and is seemingly the best choice for urban areas, despite the waste gas and cinder it produces.
“However, there is no evidence or testimony to prove that incineration plants are free of the hazards from ash and emissions of flue gas, which contain significant amounts of particulate matter, heavy metals and dioxins,” said Mao.
Gaoantun, in Beijing’s Chaoyang district, is currently the biggest garbage incineration plant in China. It processes 1,600 tons of garbage every day and produces an annual energy output of 200 million kWh.
(China Daily 03/06/2012 page3)
Copyright By chinadaily.com.cn. All rights reserved
AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE section 7 (3) and 8 (2) Consideration of Judicial Review of delay to act and lack of Duty of Care to the public’s health
From: teresa_leung@enb.gov.hk [mailto:teresa_leung@enb.gov.hk]
Sent: 06 March, 2012 14:39
To: James Middleton
Cc: CEO
Subject: Fw: 轉寄: Re: AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE section 7 (3) and 8 (2) Consideration of Judicial Review of delay to act and lack of Duty of Care to the public’s health
Dear Mr Middleton,
I refer to your email of 9 February to the Chief Executive. I am authorised to reply on his behalf.
Thank you for your comments regarding the updating of Air Quality Objectives. You may wish to note that relevant issues have been addressed at recent replies by the Secretary for the Environment to questions from Legislative Council members, details of which are available at the following links:
http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201202/08/P201202080318.htm
http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201202/29/P201202290264.htm
Yours sincerely,
Teresa Leung
Environment Bureau
LCQ18: Updating Air Quality Objectives
**************************************
Following is a question by the Hon Frederick Fung and a written reply by the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, in the Legislative Council meeting today (February 8):
Questions:
The Government announced on 17th of last month that it will commence work on the amendment of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance (Cap. 311) to update the existing Air Quality Objectives (AQOs), and it expects to introduce a bill in the 2012-2013 legislative session, and officially implement the new AQOs in 2014. In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:
(a) given that while the authorities launched a four-month public consultation on updating the existing AQOs in mid-2009, of the reasons why the outcome is only announced until now and the decision of adopting the new AQOs is made after a lapse of as long as two and a half years; of the actual work and procedures to be involved from now on up to the date of formal introduction of the bill; whether it can expedite the related work, and consider advancing the date of official implementation of the new AQOs; in addition, whether it can advance the updating of the existing method of compiling the Air Pollution Index (API), or simultaneously release on a daily basis the APIs compiled according to the existing AQOs and the new AQOs respectively; if not, of the reasons for that;
(b) given that the new AQOs have not fully adopted the ultimate objectives set out by the World Health Organization (WHO) (e.g. the average 24-hour AQO for sulphur dioxide will be tightened from 350 µg/m³ to 125 µg/m³, which is significantly different from WHO’s ultimate objective of 20 µg/m³; the average 24-hour AQO for respirable suspended particulates will be tightened from 180 µg/m³ to 100 µg/m³, and a gap still exists between this and WHO’s ultimate objective of 50 µg/m³; regarding the newly added average 24-hour AQO of 75 µg/m³ and annual AQO of 35 µg/m³ for fine suspended particulates, an obvious gap exists respectively between the two AQOs and WHO’s corresponding ultimate objectives of 25 µg/m³ and 10 µg/m³), of the specific reasons for the authorities not adopting WHO’s ultimate objectives for such pollutants (including whether it is because it is impossible for Hong Kong to achieve WHO’s ultimate objectives for such pollutants at present, together with the reasons why it is impossible to achieve the objectives for various pollutants); whether the authorities will draw up a timetable for achieving WHO’s ultimate objectives eventually;
(c) whether it has assessed the price the community has to pay upon the implementation of the new AQOs; if it has, of the specific details (including the specific impact of the new AQOs on electricity tariffs and travelling expenses in future); of the expected time when such impact will be reflected in the levels of relevant charges and fees; whether the authorities have assessed the impact on the livelihood of the grassroots, and what measures they have in place to alleviate such impact; and
(d) given that the Government has expressly stated that prior to the official implementation of the new AQOs, it will endeavour to adopt the proposed new AQOs as the benchmark in conducting environmental impact assessment (EIA) for government projects for which EIA has not yet commenced, whether the authorities will consider encouraging and facilitating other private projects to adopt the proposed new AQOs in conducting air quality assessment under EIA as well before the official implementation of the new AQOs; if not, of the reasons for that?
Reply:
President,
(a) Implementation of the new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) and related transitional arrangements require amendment of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance. We shall table the Amendment Bill to the Legislative Council in the 2012-2013 legislative session. Taking into account the time needed for drafting, submission and scrutiny of the Bill and other preparatory work, we expect the new AQOs to take effect in 2014. To tie in with the update of the AQOs, we will review and improve the existing Air Pollution Index system accordingly.
(b) The new AQOs have all been set in accordance to the target levels of the World Health Organization (WHO). Among the seven criteria pollutants, four (i.e. nitrogen dioxide, carbon monoxide, lead and sulphur dioxide) are fully or partially adopting the ultimate WHO Air Quality Guidelines (AQGs). As for suspended particulates, the emissions originated from Hong Kong and from the Pearl River Delta region are in the ratio of 1:99. As a result, the particulate concentrations of Hong Kong are subject to strong regional influence. We and the Guangdong Provincial Government have committed to implementing a number of measures to improve the regional air quality. Taking into account the regional influence, the air quality objectives for suspended particulates cannot be updated in one go. Instead, we have to draw up a practicable proposal. We propose to update the respirable suspended particulate (PM10) objectives to WHO Interim Target(IT)-2. For fine suspended particulates (PM2.5), which account for about 70% of the PM10 in Hong Kong, we propose to set them at WHO IT-1 level. As for sulphur dioxide, we propose to update the 24-hour objective to WHO IT-1 (i.e. 125 micrograms/cubic meter), which is already 60% more stringent than the existing objective, and on a par with the level of the European Union.
Achieving the WHO AQGs is our ultimate target. We shall review the feasibility of further tightening the AQOs every five years, and draw up corresponding air quality management plans.
(c) Implementation of the proposed new AQOs and air quality improvement measures will help alleviate air pollution problems and bring about health benefits which include reducing the number of hospital admissions due to asthma or other respiratory conditions. According to the Consultant’s study report, implementation of the recommended Phase 1 emission control measures would lead to an anticipated benefit of about $1,228 million annually due to improvement in public health, which is significantly higher than the estimated annualised cost of about $596 million to be incurred by the society. The Consultant also estimated that some 4,200 hospital admissions could be avoided because of the improvement measures. In addition, the average life expectancy of the population would be increased by about one month or around 7,400 life years saved each year.
During the public consultation in 2009, we initially estimated that with the increase in percentage of natural gas for local electricity generation to 50%, electricity tariff would probably increase from the current level by at least 20% in phases. However, as the adjustment of electricity tariff will be implemented in phases, it is difficult to ascertain the eventual increase at the moment. For instance, with the capital cost of the desulphurisation equipment previously installed by the power companies spreading over a period of time, the impact on tariff is lower than originally expected. To reduce vehicle emissions, it was estimated previously that if the franchised bus companies were to replace all the Euro I and Euro II franchised buses by the end of 2014, the bus fare would increase by about 15% in a single year. However, Government introduced in recent years a number of measures, including funding the retrofitting of Euro II and Euro III franchised buses with selective catalytic reduction devices and subsidising bus companies to test environment-friendly products and devices, such as hybrid and electric buses. These measures, which are funded by Government, will help alleviate the pressure for bus fare increase. Therefore, it is difficult to conclude at this moment if implementation of the air quality improvement measures would eventually result in an increase in the charges of public services to the previously estimated levels.
(d) Before the relevant legislative amendment becomes effective, Government will take the lead to adopt the proposed new AQOs as the benchmark for conducting air quality impact assessment under the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for those government projects that have not yet started their EIA studies. Individual major infrastructure projects, such as the construction of a third runway for the airport, the Airport Authority has indicated they will adopt the new AQOs for the EIA study. For other private projects, the project proponents may consider whether or not to adopt the new objectives for air quality impact assessment according to their own circumstances.
Ends/Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Issued at HKT 15:58
NNNN
LCQ13: Updating Air Quality Objectives
**************************************
Following is a question by the Hon Frederick Fung and a written reply by the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, in the Legislative Council meeting today (February 29):
Questions:
In reply to my question on February 8 this year concerning the implementation of the new Air Quality Objectives (AQOs), the Secretary for the Environment (SEN) did not give any definite response to the inquiries about updating the existing Air Pollution Index (API) first and the need to amend the legislation, and emphasised that the implementation of the new AQOs and related transitional arrangements required amendment of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance (Cap. 311) (the Ordinance). In this connection, will the Government inform this Council:
(a) given that it is already stipulated in section 7(3) of the Ordinance that “[a]ny air quality objective may be amended from time to time by the Secretary, after consultation with the Advisory Council on the Environment”, of the justifications for SEN to point out that the implementation of the new AQOs required amendment of the Ordinance; and the related transitional arrangements mentioned by SEN;
(b)whether it has studied the feasibility of updating the existing API first; and
(c)whether it has assessed the impact on public health of postponing the implementation of the new AQOs to 2014?
Reply:
President,
(a) and (b) Apart from serving as objective standards for local air quality, Air Quality Objectives (AQOs) are a major factor for consideration in granting licences to specified processes (e.g. power plants) under the Air Pollution Control Ordinance and in assessing the impacts of designated projects on air quality under the Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance. In the process of updating the AQOs, we must make appropriate transitional arrangements, including drawing up a specific timetable for introducing the new AQOs to enable applicants of licences for specified processes and proponents of designated projects to plan their work on a highly transparent and legally sound basis. We also have to consider carefully the impact of the introduction of the new AQOs on projects for which an environmental permit (EP) has been issued. In the process of implementing the project, if application for variation of the EP becomes necessary and a new Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is warranted, applying the new AQOs may require significant amendments to the original design of the project, which will have major implications on the planning, cost, and even feasibility of the project. In order to reduce the uncertainty to those designated projects which have already completed the statutory EIA process as well as maintain the integrity of project planning, we have proposed, after careful consideration, a 36-month grace period from the commencement date of the new AQOs during which the new AQOs shall not apply to an application for variation of the EP.
Amendment of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance is a prerequisite for the implementation of the new AQOs and the aforesaid transitional arrangements. We shall table the Amendment Bill to the Legislative Council in the 2012/13 legislative session. To complement the updating of the AQOs, we shall review and improve the current Air Pollution Index system accordingly.
(c) We have been endeavouring to improve the air quality and have already implemented a series of air improvement policies and measures, targeting in particular the power generation industry, vehicles and fuel oil quality, in order to reduce air pollution generated from their operation. Along with updating the AQOs, we shall step up the implementation of the 19 Phase I emission control measures as well as three additional measures. The latter include retrofitting of Euro II and III franchised buses with selective catalytic reduction devices, installing remote sensing devices at roadside and conducting advanced emission tests to strengthen control on emissions from petrol and LPG vehicles, requiring ocean-going vessels to switch to cleaner fuels while berthing and setting up Emission Control Area in Pearl River Delta waters in the long run. In addition, to underscore Government’s determination and to take a leading role, Government has decided that Government projects, for which EIA studies have not yet been commenced, would endeavour to adopt the proposed new AQOs as the benchmark for conducting air quality impact assessment in the EIA studies, so that newly planned Government projects could match the more stringent air quality requirements as soon as possible.
Ends/Wednesday, February 29, 2012
Issued at HKT 12:30
NNNN
—– Forwarded by Alex YF YIU/CEO/HKSARG on 2012/02/10 上午 11:19 —–
| “CEO” <ceo@ceo.gov.hk> 2012/02/10 上午11:18 Please respond to “CEO” <ceo@ceo.gov.hk> |
|
Dear Mr Middleton,
Thank you for your email of 9 February to the Chief Executive. A reply will be given to you in due course.
Yours sincerely,
(Alex Yiu)
for Private Secretary to Chief Executive
—– Original Message —–
From: James Middleton
To: ceo@ceo.gov.hk ; gmleung@ceo.gov.hk ; panel_hs@legco.gov.hk
Cc: Edward Yau Tang Wah EPD
Sent: Thursday, February 09, 2012 8:58 AM
Subject: AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE section 7 (3) and 8 (2) Consideration of Judicial Review of delay to act and lack of Duty of Care to the public’s health
Dear Chief Executive,
We welcome a reply from the Government as to why it deems it necessary to wait till 2014 to enact the new AQO’s when it can be done simply under the existing Air Pollution Control Ordinance, since the power to do so is vested in the Secretary.
We note that the Principal Officials Accountability System requires Ministers be accountable for the success or failure of their portfolios to the Chief Executive (and not the public of Hong Kong.)
http://www.hkbasiclaw.com/PCLL%20HK%20Constitutional%20Law/4%20Political%20and%20Administrative%20System/Cheung%20Chor%20Yung%20Quest%20for%20Good%20Governance%20Principal%20Officials%20Accountability%20System.pdf
“Principal officials under the accountability system will accept total responsibility and in an extreme case, they may have to step down for serious failures relating to their respective portfolios.
They will be appointed to the Executive Council and will be responsible for all aspects of their portfolios. Their role and responsibility are as follows:
* to gauge public opinion and take societal interests into account in serving the community;
* to set policy objectives and goals, and develop, formulate and shape policies;
* to secure the support of the community and LegCo for their policy and legislative initiatives as well as proposals relating to fees and charges and public expenditure;
* to exercise the statutory functions vested in them by law;
* to oversee the delivery of services by the executive departments under their purview and ensure the effective implementation and successful outcome of policies; and
* to accept total responsibility for policy outcome and the delivery of services by the relevant executive departments.”
http://www.cmab.gov.hk/en/press/press_53.htm
Does the Chief Executive consider the Secretary for the Environment has done his job successfully when the Hedley Index tells us 3,200 people are dying here each year from pollution related illnesses and roadside pollution has increased, not declined ?
During Chinese New Year when the PRD factories and construction sites were shut the API levels at all 14 Hong Kong stations were shown as ‘High’ and the winds were from the East.
Thus transboundary pollution cannot be simply blamed for the toxic state of our air.
Does Edward Yau consider his portfolio is successful ?
We note the HK AQO’s were only released by coincidence after China accepted people-power protests and accordingly started to reveal PM2.5 levels and install further PM2.5 monitoring stations.
Taiwan has already adopted the same air quality standards as used by the US EPA including strict PM2.5 levels.
These newly issued Hong Kong AQO’s had not changed since the (unnecessary) ARUP report with its recommendations was released more than 2 years ago even though higher qualified WHO experts had devised the WHO Air Quality Guidelines in late 2005.
Is that 2 year delay acceptable to the Chief Executive after all public consultations were completed and is it acceptable to further delay effective implementation till 2014 when the existing Cap 311 law allows rubber stamping of the updated AQO’s by the Secretary ?
Yours sincerely,
James Middleton
Chairman
www.cleartheair.org.hk
SCMP Laisee 09 Feb 2012
Yau should come clean
Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau was at his slippery best in the Legislative Council yesterday in answering questions on why it was taking so long to introduce new air quality objectives. He once again repeated the erroneous assertion that implementing the new AQOs requires new legislation. This, as we have pointed out before, does not seem to square with the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, which says the AQOs “may be amended from time to time by the secretary, after consultation with the Advisory Council on the Environment”. In other words, they just need to be gazetted. If the government had any interest in cleaning the air, the new objectives could be law within weeks. But the public’s awareness of the problem is growing and Edward Yau’s obfuscations are looking increasingly tatty.
RTHK 17/1/2012
|
|||||||
| 17-01-2012 | |||||||
| The Executive Council has approved new air quality objectives for Hong Kong, which will set more stringent caps on seven types of pollutants. The Environment Secretary, Edward Yau, says some of the objectives comply with the strictest standards set by the World Health Organisation, and the rest meet its “interim” levels. The new standards include, for the first time, a cap on very fine particles measuring less than 2.5 microns across. These particles, known as PM 2.5, are considered very dangerous as they can easily get into peoples’ lungs. However, the government will use the loosest WHO interim standard as a benchmark for these particles. Mr Yau said the government hopes the new standards will be implemented in 2014, after the relevant laws are amended. The objectives will be updated every five years. Mr Yau also said the government will immediately endeavour to adopt the new standards as the benchmark for conducting environmental impact assessment reports for its construction projects. But there’ll be a 3-year “transitional period” for private developments. Hong Kong’s air quality objectives were last updated in 1987.
|
Why secretary’s announcement seems to be full of hot air
LAI SEE
Howard Winn
Jan 21, 2012 www.scmp.com
More reasons why Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau’s
announcement on air quality objectives should be treated with considerable
scepticism.
The government’s press statement on the revised AQOs says: “The
government will start preparatory work on the amendment of the Air
Pollution Control Ordinance with an aim to table the Amendment Bill in the
2012-13 session of the Legislative Council. Taking account for the lead
time for completing the legislative process and other necessary preparatory
work, including formulation of modelling guidelines and compilation of
emissions inventories, it is expected that the proposed new AQOs
would take effect in 2014.”
So the government says new revised AQOs require new legislation which
has to be put to the Legislative Council. However, a look at the Air Pollution
Control Ordinance which deals with AQOs clearly shows that it is
completely unnecessary to go to Legco to revise AQOs.
Chapter 311 of the Air Pollution Control Ordinance, Section 7 – Secretary to
establish quality objectives – says: “Any air quality objective may be
amended from time to time by the Secretary, after consultation with the
Advisory Council on the Environment.”
This is clearly another attempt by the administration to pull the wool over
the eyes of the community and to delay the process for yet another two
years. The saga of the AQOs started in 2007 when consultants were hired
to determine appropriate levels for Hong Kong (Arup was paid US$6 million
for an entirely unnecessary exercise which had already been done by the
World Health Organisation).
This, together with various internal discussions dragged the process out
until 2009 when Public Consultation started. In June 2010 the government
declared the public views were too divergent to see a clear way forward
and there was silence on the matter until last week.
For this bureaucratic achievement, Edward Yau was last year awarded the
Golden Bauhinia, which is supposed to be for eminent persons who have
given very distinguished services to the community or who have rendered
public or voluntary services of a very high degree of merit.
Chapter: 311
Title: AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE Section: 7 Heading: Secretary to establish quality objectives
Gazette Number:
Version Date: 30/06/1997
(1) The Secretary shall, after consultation with the Advisory Council on the Environment,
establish for each air control zone air quality objectives or different objectives for different parts
of a zone. (Amended L.N. 165 of 1984; L.N. 57 of 1994)
(1A) The Secretary may publish air quality objectives for an air control zone by issuing a
technical memorandum which may specify different objectives for different parts of the zone.
(Added 13 of 1993 s. 5)
(2) The air quality objectives for any particular air control zone or part thereof shall be the
quality which, in the opinion of the Secretary, should be achieved and maintained in order to
promote the conservation and best use of air in the zone in the public interest.
(3) Any air quality objective may be amended from time to time by the Secretary, after
consultation with the Advisory Council on the Environment. (Amended L.N. 165 of 1984;
L.N. 57 of 1994)
(4)-(5) (Repealed 13 of 1993 s. 5)
Chapter: 311
Title: AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE Section: 8 Heading:
Authority to seek to achieve quality objectives
Gazette Number:
Version Date: 30/06/1997
(1) (Repealed 13 of 1993 s. 6)
(2) The Authority shall aim to achieve the relevant air quality objectives as soon as is
reasonably practicable and thereafter to maintain the quality so achieved.
(3) If in the opinion of the Secretary the achievement or maintenance of any air quality objective
would be better served by the exercise by the Authority in a particular manner of any of his
powers under section 15(4), 17 or 22, the Secretary may give directions in writing to the
Authority as to the manner in which he shall exercise those powers; and, in the case of a
direction which relates to section 15(4), any such direction may be of a general nature or relate to
a particular case or particular cases.
(4) The Authority shall comply with any direction given to him under subsection (3) and the
discretion conferred on the Authority by section 15(4), 17 or 22 as the case may be, shall not
apply to any specified process in respect of which such a direction is in force.
RTHK Govt ‘not serious’ about cleaner air
30-01-2012
Erica Chan of the
Clean Air Network
spoke to Timmy
Sung
A green group has accused the government of not being serious about
improving air quality. The Clean Air Network cited government figures that
showed overall expenditure on improving Hong Kong’s air quality had
dropped from 0.26 percent in the year 2000 to only 0.18 percent last year,
even though the actual amount of money spent increased.
It says the data shows the administration lacks commitment to solving the
problem. The campaign manager for the group, Erica Chan, said that
Beijing is spending much more money than Hong Kong on improving air
quality.
Jan 31 SCMP
Emergency measures are needed
I refer to Guy Shirra’s letter (“Treat bad air problems as a crisis”, January 25).
Last year in a letter to these columns, I said Hong Kong does not have an air pollution problem, it has an air pollution
emergency. Thus, the government’s crisis managers should be treating the situation as an emergency.
In Lai See (“Hong Kong’s Air Pollution Index is shamefully misleading”, January 27), Howard Winn quotes Professor
Anthony Hedley as writing: “Hong Kong’s pollution is a significant cause of premature death from cardiopulmonary
disorders.
“Present levels of pollution cause injury to the immature developing lungs of children and adolescents. This damage
will lead to lifelong health problems in many and a reduction in life expectancy.”
Lai See also mentions that around 3,200 deaths a year in Hong Kong can be directly attributed to the air quality
emergency whilst World Health Organisation figures for bird flu are 341 deaths worldwide since 2003 and a
worldwide total of 913 deaths from severe acute respiratory syndrome.
We have a typhoon warning system that is presumably based on some form of risk management principles. The
conclusion of this process seems to be that when the typhoon signal No 3 is hoisted, the weather has become
sufficiently dangerous for workers to prepare to return home. When the No 8 signal goes up, workers remain at
home.
Given that very few people are killed or injured by typhoons in comparison to the numbers killed and injured
by our poisonous air, the Air Pollution Index must follow a similar warning system to that used for typhoons.
Workers should remain at home when roadside air pollution is deemed to be unsafe. Perhaps days and days
of empty offices and lost production might ram home the point that there is an emergency and emergency
measures are needed to deal with it.
Mark Ranson, Sai Kung
We’re breathing ‘dangerous’ air SCMP 28 Jan
Just in case you didn’t notice the air yesterday – it was bad. According to the
government’s air pollution index, the pollution level was “high” – that is, it was at the
midpoint of the index. It tells us: “Very few people, if any, may notice immediate health
effects. Long-term effects may, however, be observed if exposed at such [a] level
persistently for months or years.”
However, according to the Hedley Environmental Index, which follows World Health
Organisation guidelines, the air quality can be classified as “very dangerous”.
Jim Middleton, chairman of green group Clear the Air, observed that yesterday’s bad
pollution occurred even though factories and construction sites in the Pearl River Delta
were closed and despite a decline in Hong Kong traffic while many people were on
holiday. “But the ocean-going vessels and ferries, along with the local power stations
and buses, were running.”
Middleton remarked: “Our secretary for the environment has done nothing for our air
quality other than massive prevarication, yet he earned a Golden Bauhinia from a chief
executive intent on building white-elephant infrastructure [ahead of] his duty [to] care for
the health of the public.”
SCMP
Treat bad air problems as a crisis
In respect of air quality, the people of Hong Kong want two things.
They want the truth about air quality where they and their children live, work, study and play so that they can make
informed decisions as to how best to protect their health and take concerted and urgent action to improve it. They are
not interested in targets.
Also, they want to be warned when the air is dangerous to their health and they want the government to start doing
something meaningful about it without more years of dithering.
I was impressed and relieved when the administration got rid of all the diesel taxis and some of the diesel minibuses,
which had a hugely beneficial effect on air quality back in 2003.
What has it achieved since then? We are still plagued with dirty old buses, minibuses, goods vehicles, ferries and
ships, and the power companies have still not cleaned up their act.
The government has a pretty good record when it comes to managing crises. I am sure that the Hospital Authority
would say that the steadily increasing cases of respiratory disease amount to a continuing and worsening crisis, so
can we please start treating it as such?
Guy Shirra, chairman, Friends of Sai Kung
Clearly lagging
Mike Kilburn fears air pollution in Hong Kong could get even worse, given the
latest evidence that clean-up measures are proving ineffective and officials are
failing in their duty to protect public health
Jan 19, 2012
This month marks a major watershed for air quality in Hong Kong. At the beginning of
the month, the Environmental Protection Department said that roadside pollution last
year was the worst on record. At the same time, Clean Air Network presented a table
from the China Statistical Yearbook 2011 ranking Hong Kong’s nitrogen dioxide levels
(a key indicator of roadside pollution) 31st out of 32 major cities in China – only Urumqi
was worse. This is especially embarrassing considering that Hong Kong has a service based
economy with very little industry and correspondingly fewer sources of pollution
than any other city on the list.
Adding insult to injury, the mainland pre-empted the long-delayed release of Hong
Kong’s air quality objectives by announcing its own. This was embarrassing for Hong
Kong officials who, by dithering for two years since consulting the public on a set of draft
objectives, have forfeited Hong Kong’s position as the pacesetter for introducing tougher
air quality standards in China. The Ministry of Environmental Protection’s air quality
objectives are very similar to those proposed by Hong Kong, but they differ in three
important aspects.
First, the ministry has proposed an additional 24-hour limit for nitrogen dioxide of 80
micrograms per cubic metre that is not included in Hong Kong’s objectives. This means
the mainland’s standards for this key pollutant are even tougher than Hong Kong’s.
Second, by publishing a set of targets that most, if not all, major cities will take years to
achieve, the ministry has signalled its understanding of the powerful role targets can
play in driving down pollution – something our officials have yet to grasp. In a radio
interview broadcast last year, Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah
insisted that “apart from setting a target, you have to have a way to achieve it”.
As mainland leaders have shown, the target can certainly precede the plan for
attainment, and two years were lost while Donald Tsang Yam-kuen’s administration
tried to figure out how to meet the air quality objectives it proposed in 2009.
Third, even though concentrations of respirable suspended particles of 2.5 microns or
less (PM2.5) in many mainland cities are more than double those in Hong Kong, the
ministry has set the standard for PM2.5 at the same level as Hong Kong’s – 35
micrograms. As with the target for nitrogen dioxide, this sends a strong message that
protecting public health has been accorded a high priority by Beijing.
Conversely, in a May 2011 meeting of the Legislative Council, frustrated lawmakers
suggested that the government had not released the new air quality objectives because
it feared that major infrastructure projects may fail to meet the new standard. In his
response, Tsang appeared to confirm this view: “We must carefully assess the
economic and social impacts of any new air quality objectives on Hong Kong. It is only
by doing so that we can put forward any long-term and firmly established air quality
objectives that are appropriate to all works projects and economic development.”
But there is clear evidence that Hong Kong’s poor air quality is now threatening
economic health as well as the well-being of the public. Last September, the Airport
Authority released a report expressing concern that high nitrogen dioxide emissions
from aircraft using a third runway would create difficulties in securing approvals under
the Environmental Impact Assessment Ordinance, and could not legally go ahead.
In a similar vein, it was concerns about the health impacts of added traffic on the
proposed bridge to Macau and Zhuhai that provoked a judicial review that held up the
project.
This week, the government acted. On Tuesday, Yau announced that new air quality
objectives for Hong Kong had been approved by the Executive Council and would
become law in 2014. These are identical to the objectives put out for public consultation
in 2009, raising serious questions about what has been achieved by the two-year delay.
The government’s press release also included a rather cryptic statement referring to
new infrastructure projects, saying that “all government projects for which environmental
impact assessment studies have not yet commenced would endeavour to adopt the
proposed new air quality objectives as the benchmark”.
Environmental assessments follow a statutory process that permits approval of projects
if their emissions do not exceed the current air standards. The ordinance makes no
allowance to “endeavour” to adopt a new standard, and the director of environmental
protection would very swiftly find herself back in court were she to require proponents to
meet air quality objectives that were yet to be legally adopted. Hence, regrettably, those
fine-sounding words are essentially hollow.
Meanwhile, the need to address air pollution grows more urgent. The University of Hong
Kong’s School of Public Health and Civic Exchange have launched a revised version of
the Hedley Environmental Index. The refined calculations of health impacts indicate that
an average of 3,200 premature deaths have occurred each year over the past five
years, up from the previous estimate of 1,000 deaths per year.
So what can we conclude? In short, our air quality can get worse, and officials are
fudging the issue rather than making it better. The clean-up measures introduced to
reduce pollution are failing in key areas – especially at the roadside. The consequences
for our health are far worse than we imagined.
The officials whose job it is to improve air quality do not understand the key tools
of their trade, and appear more concerned with perpetuating development than
protecting public health. It is hardly surprising that Hong Kong has lost its position as
the environmental leader in China.
Mike Kilburn is head of environmental strategy for public policy think tank Civic Exchange
Yau rubbishes fears on incinerator policy – The Standard
Yau rubbishes fears on incinerator policy
Mary Ann Benitez
Tuesday, March 06, 2012
Building a new incinerator is an essential part of the government’s strategy for solid waste management, a senior official said.
Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah was addressing legislators’ concerns yesterday that the government might abandon the incinerator plan if chief executive candidate Leung Chun-ying wins on March 25.
Civic Party lawmaker Audrey Eu Yuet-mee noted at a special Finance Committee meeting scrutinizing the 2012 budget that Leung’s election platform states that the SAR may do without incinerators. His rivals Henry Tang Ying-yen and Albert Ho Chun-yan thought otherwise, she said.
Yau insisted that the government will stick with the “holistic” strategy for solid waste reduction that includes an incinerator.
“Experience in Europe and other developed cities shows that, even with the implementation of various measures on waste reduction at source, there is still a substantial amount of waste that cannot be recovered which requires treatment,” he said.
“In the context of Hong Kong, even if the target recovery rate of 55 percent is achieved, there will still be about 8,000 tonnes of [municipal solid waste] that cannot be recovered or recycled and which requires treatment on a daily basis,” he added. This is why an incinerator is essential.
“We are developing a sludge treatment facility which employs state-of-the-art incineration technology,” Yau said. “It is expected to be commissioned in 2013. By then, daily disposal of sludge at landfills will be reduced by nearly 1,000 tonnes.
” It will also demonstrate how modern technology can serve as an effective means in tackling the problem of [municipal solid waste].”
There are plans to increase the plant’s capacity from 800 tonnes to 2,000 tonnes of waste a day.
Incinerator
These are the Chinese newspapers reported the JR case. The first and the fifth article (The Sun and Oriental Daily) belong to the same group mentioned Tsang’s likely collusion with the developers in the first and the last paragraph.
郭更質疑指,曾蔭權原本計劃在離任後到深圳福田居住,而另一選址屯門曾咀剛好鄰近福田,在曾咀興建焚化爐,可能影響到曾蔭權的「新
居」和福田發展商的利益,當局選址上可能涉及利益輸送。
Kwok suspected that Tsang’s original retirement plan was to live in Futian, and the other site is coincidentally located in Tsang Tsui near Futian. If the incinerator were to be built in TT, this might affect Tsang’s new home and the interest of the developers. The EPD might have colluded with the developers.
郭續指,當局考慮在屯門曾咀或石鼓洲興建垃圾焚化爐時,聲稱焚化爐不會造成污染,結果以會加劇污染為理由否
決在曾咀興建,與先前的說法自相矛盾。
Kwok continued to point out that when the EPD was making decision between SKC and TT, they claimed that the incinerator would not cause pollution. However, their reason for rejecting TT was that it would further pollute TT. This contradicted their original claim.
成報 – 20120304 – 唐梁何環保論壇首過招 跨區整治有共識 建焚化爐分歧大
文匯 – 20120304 – 長洲坊會主席入稟 反環署建焚化爐
新報 – 20120304 – 石鼓洲填海建垃圾焚化爐 老翁恐污染入稟阻興建
明報 – 20120304 – 倡建焚化爐 台下報噓聲 論壇首同台 唐得分遠遜梁何
明報 – 20120304 – 石鼓洲建焚化爐長洲居民提覆核
Full text of paper submitted by SEN at Special Meeting of LegCo Finance Committee
Hong Kong, Mar. 5 — Hong Kong SAR Government issued the following news release:
Following is the full text of the paper submitted by the Secretary for the Environment, Mr Edward Yau, at the Special Meeting of the Finance Committee of the Legislative Council today (March 5):
Chairman,
I am delighted to attend the Special Meeting of the Finance Committee today to brief Members on the part of next financial year’s Estimates which relate to the Environment Bureau (ENB) as well as our future work in key policy areas.
Government Resource Commitment in Environment Protection
The Government has attached a lot of importance to protecting the environment and devoted substantial resources and manpower in taking forward this area of work. The amount of funding allocated to ENB’s policy portfolio totalled nearly $60.3 billion under the current term of Government. The annual funding allocation has been on the rise. It more than doubled from $6.3 billion in 2007-08 to $13.9 billion in the next financial year.
In addition to directly providing financial and manpower resources for work in environmental protection, the Government has also allocated a considerable amount of resources in support of different quarters in the community in furthering the environmental cause. They include non-governmental organisations, charitable bodies, schools and residents organisations. In the period of 2008 to end 2011, the Environment and Conservation Fund approved more than 2,000 projects which promote energy saving, waste reduction and recycling, greening, conservation and scientific research on environmental protection. They far exceed the total number of around 1,000 projects approved in the 14 years since the Fund was set up in 1994. The subsidies amount to over $1 billion and have effectively facilitated different sectors of the community to actively undertake environmental projects.
During the past few years, we have carried out extensive work in different environment policy areas. In terms of legislation, we introduced five new ordinances to establish a new regulatory framework in the areas of energy efficiency, air quality, waste reduction and to promote behavioural change in the community. At the same period, some 30 amendments to the principal ordinances or subsidiary regulations were also introduced. I will now give a brief account of what we have done and plan to do in several key areas of our work.
Improving Air Quality
In respect of improving air quality, in the past few years we have made tremendous efforts to reduce emissions from power plants, which are a major source of local emissions. Starting in 2005, we have progressively tightened the emission caps of power plants through signing new Scheme of Control Agreements with the power companies and amending the Air Pollution Control Ordinance. In 2010, the cap on sulphur dioxide (SO2) emissions from the power sector was tightened by 67 per cent. We will keep up the effort to further tighten the emission caps from 2015 onwards by 34 to 50 per cent from the 2010 levels with a view to minimising the pollution caused by power generation.
Air pollution at the roadside is also a major focus of our efforts. We have tightened the statutory specifications of vehicle and industrial fuels to those of the most advanced countries. To reduce roadside air pollution, we intend to raise vehicle exhaust emission standards to the Euro V level. Through subsidies and tax concessions, we encourage owners of diesel commercial vehicles to replace their old vehicles with new ones, and vehicle buyers to choose more environment-friendly cars. With regard to the transport trades, the Government is conducting a trial of retrofitting selective catalytic reduction devices on Euro II and Euro III buses, as well as subsidising franchised bus companies to undertake trials of hybrid and electric buses. The ultimate policy objective is to adopt zero-emission buses across the territory. The $300 million Pilot Green Transport Fund has been effective in encouraging the transport sector to try out green and innovative transport technologies. Within less than a year after its launch, the Fund has received a very positive response with 24 applications approved and grants totalling over $60 million.
The various measures have brought fruitful results. Monitoring data showed that between 2006 and 2010, the ambient concentration of SO2 and respirable suspended particulates (RSP) had dropped by 45 per cent and 17 per cent respectively. Through the joint efforts of the governments of Hong Kong and Guangdong, the air quality of the Pearl River Delta (PRD) region has improved following implementation of a range of regional emission reduction measures. From 2006 to 2010, the levels of SO2, nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and RSP in the region dropped by 47 per cent, 7 per cent and 14 per cent respectively.
Looking ahead, the high concentration of NO2 at the roadside is the most prominent air pollution problem facing us. Between 2006 and 2010, the roadside concentration of NO2 increased by 22 per cent. Since emissions of NO2 from poorly maintained petrol and LPG vehicles constitute a major source of roadside air pollution, the Government has proposed to use roadside remote sensing equipment to screen out petrol and LPG vehicles with excessive emissions. The owners of such vehicles will be required to take corrective actions. To facilitate vehicle owners in adapting to the more stringent emissions control, Government will seek approval from the Finance Committee soon for an allocation of $150 million to replace the catalytic converters and associated components of LPG taxis and light buses.
As a result of reduction in emissions from land-based sources and increase in movements of marine vessels, emissions from the latter account for an increasing proportion of Hong Kong’s total emissions. Marine vessels have become the largest local source of RSP emissions, and the second largest emission source of SO2 and nitrogen oxides after power plants. It is therefore necessary to introduce appropriate measures to control such emissions with a view to further improving regional air quality. In last year’s Policy Address, we announced an initiative to explore with the governments of Guangdong, Shenzhen and Macao proposals for requiring ocean-going vessels to switch to low-sulphur diesel while berthing in PRD waters, and setting up an Emission Control Area in the region. We will also discuss with the trades to improve the quality of marine fuels sold locally so as to reduce vessel emissions.
To encourage ocean-going vessels to switch to cleaner fuels when berthing in Hong Kong waters, the Government proposes to reduce by half the port facilities and light dues charged on ocean-going vessels which switch to low-sulphur diesel at berth. The proposed waiver scheme will run for three years and is estimated to cost up to $260 million in terms of public revenue forgone. The Environmental Protection Department and Marine Department are drawing up implementation arrangements for the proposal. At the same time, we will also start discussions with relevant authorities in the PRD region on regional control of marine emissions.
Another important task before us is to update the Air Quality Objectives (AQOs). The new AQOs are set in accordance with air quality targets of the World Health Organization (WHO). Four out of the seven major pollutants, namely NO2, carbon monoxide, lead and SO2, have fully or partly adopted WHO’s ultimate air quality targets, and are broadly on a par with the standards of other advanced regions such as the European Union and the United States. We shall embark on the necessary legislative exercise to implement the new AQOs and the relevant transitional arrangements. Our intention is to introduce the Bill in the LegCo session of 2012-13 and to make the new AQOs statutory standards by 2014. We will also review every five years the feasibility of tightening the AQOs. In addition, to demonstrate the Government’s commitment and to take the lead in applying the new AQOs, the Government has decided that for public works projects with environmental impact assessment (EIA) studies not yet commenced, they will endeavour to adopt the new AQOs as the yardstick for air quality assessments. This will allow newly planned public works projects to align with the more stringent requirements on air quality at the earliest opportunity.
Solid Waste Management
I now turn to waste management which is an imminent issue that we have to work on. The three strategic landfills are expected to approach full capacity one by one in 2014, 2016 and 2018. Our complete reliance on landfilling to handle nearly 10,000 tonnes of municipal solid waste (MSW) on a daily basis is certainly not sustainable.
Early last year, Government put forward a basket of specific measures under the management strategy, which included proposals on waste reduction and recycling as well as development of modern treatment facilities. Our target is to raise the MSW recovery rate to 55 per cent by 2015. Our policy initiatives on “Reduce and Recycle”, together with extension of landfills as well as introduction of modern treatment facilities, are essential elements in our holistic plan of ensuring proper MSW management. They are intertwined as indispensable components of our comprehensive strategy.
With the continuous expansion of the Source Separation of Waste Programmes, our MSW recovery rate increased from 45 per cent in 2006 to 52 per cent in 2010, which overshoots the original target laid down in 2005. It is comparable to that of other cities at a similar level of development. This could not be achieved without the concerted efforts of the entire community. With the enactment of the Product Eco-responsibility Ordinance in 2008, we are progressively introducing mandatory producer responsibility schemes (PRSs) under this legal framework. In 2009, we implemented the Environmental Levy Scheme on Plastic Shopping Bags (PSBs). The PSB distribution from the 3,000 registered retail outlets covered by the Levy Scheme dropped by as much as 90 per cent. As the next step, in a bid to promote waste reduction at source, we will expedite our work in making legislative proposals to extend the Levy Scheme to cover all local retailers, and to implement a PRS on waste electrical and electronic equipment.
As I just mentioned, introducing modern treatment facilities and timely expansion of the landfills are essential waste management measures. Experience in Europe and other developed cities shows that, even with the implementation of various measures on waste reduction at source, there is still a substantial amount of waste that cannot be recovered which requires treatment. In the context of Hong Kong, even if the target recovery rate of 55 per cent is achieved, there will still be about 8,000 tonnes of MSW that cannot be recovered or recycled and which requires treatment on a daily basis. We are developing a Sludge Treatment Facility which employs state-of-the-art incineration technology. It is expected to be commissioned in 2013. By then, daily disposal of sludge at landfills will be reduced by nearly 1,000 tonnes. It will also demonstrate how modern technology can serve as an effective means in tackling the problem of MSW. Our next step is to discuss our plans on the development of the Integrated Waste Treatment Facilities, and the extension of the three existing landfills in the LegCo. I look forward to discussing the proposed projects with Members in details with a view to coming up with a practicable way forward.
Green Economy
Lastly, I would like to take the opportunity to share our thoughts on the development of environmental industries. I am delighted to find there has been a promising growth in this sector. The value added and employment of environmental industries in 2010 recorded a growth close to 20 per cent and 11.3 per cent respectively over 2009. We will continue our heavy investment in environmental infrastructures, thereby creating jobs and generating business opportunities for the environmental protection and engineering sectors. Besides, Government has been providing impetus to the development of industries and profession related to environmental protection by setting up the EcoPark, promotion of electric vehicles, enacting legislation on buildings energy efficiency, and taking the lead in going green. We will also continue to support the industry’s participation in such activities as environmental exhibitions and trade missions to help build collaboration platform with local and overseas enterprises. With more facilitating policies and measures rolled out, I am confident that green industries in Hong Kong will continue to flourish.
Conclusion
Chairman, the Government will continue to enhance its environmental strategies and take proactive actions to transform Hong Kong into a green city offering quality living. I look forward to receiving the LegCo’s continued support in pursuit of our policies and measures in the coming financial year. Chairman, I welcome Members to put forward their questions on this part of the Estimates and, together with the Permanent Secretary and other colleagues, I would be pleased to answer Members’ questions.
Source: Hong Kong SAR Government
Website: news.gov.hk
Copyright 2012 Hong Kong Government News, distributed by Contify.com
All Rights Reserved
Wire News provided by