Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Global

No global warming for last 18 years

SCMP Letters to the Editor

We are advised that in order to better meet a 2007 agreement in combating “global warming”, our government is to implement further measures to reduce energy consumption.

I am all for reducing the waste in the use of energy – a laudable if futile aim, particularly if it is being done in order to reduce global warming – and reduction in pollution. However, please refrain from telling us that the essential trace gas carbon dioxide is a pollutant.

It is amazing that our government maintains, strengthens even, its agenda in relation to global warming when there has been no global warming at all for the last 18 years and counting. Even the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change acknowledges that.

G. Bailey, Ta Kwu Ling

We should all try to cut back on food waste

SCMP Letters to the Editor

All Hongkongers will have enjoyed traditional food during the Lunar New Year, such as turnip cakes, rice cakes, braised vegetables and red fermented beancurd.

All these feasts will have generated a substantial amount of food waste.

We all need to reflect on the part we play in discarding so much food. How many of us, during our festive feasts, left our plates empty?

With my family, I ate poon choi on the first and second days of the new year. We could not finish it all, but instead of throwing it away kept it as leftovers.

As well as trying to use leftover food at home, when we’re out, we should order less food. And if it is a set meal, for example, in a Chinese restaurant with a lot of different dishes, you can go without rice so you have room for other dishes.

There is a Chinese saying, “May you always get more than you wish for”. And it has long been a Chinese tradition to order more food than you will need to eat.

This is a bad habit and we need to change attitudes. We should only order what we need and not throw away the food that we do not eat.

Chan Yue-ching, Kowloon Tong

Put recycling bins at more locations

SCMP Letters to the Editor

The letter by Yannis Mak (“Recycling policy put on back burner”, March 3) reminded me of some concerns regarding recycling bins.

When you see recycling bins outside a building, you have to ask if it makes sense to have only three of them outside a 39-storey public housing block with roughly 16 apartments on each level.

So there are three little bins to hold all the recyclable material from around 600 households. It gives the impression that these bins are placed outside housing blocks by the government for decoration.

Recycling bins have been situated outside these buildings for years and yet little has changed.

Why doesn’t the relevant government department place these bins on each floor of a housing block? It is not easy to change old habits and get people to adopt new, environmentally-friendly ones, but having facilities like bins within easy reach is a big step forward.

I am also concerned about plastic recycling. I understand plastic bottles that are placed in the recycling bin are ending up in our landfills, because plastic recycling is not profitable. There are citizens who still care but they are put off by government indifference.

Officials must make recycling in Hong Kong more effective.

Debbie Cheng, Tseung Kwan O

Hong Kong rural leader denies waste dumping in HK$1.3m claim

A rural leader denied illegally dumping waste on one of his villagers’ properties, claiming he was being set up for money, the High Court heard yesterday.

Sheung Shui rural committee chairman Hau Chi-keung denied allegations by farmer Lau Oi-kiu that he instructed property agent Man Chun-shing, another defendant in the case, to carry out fly-tipping on Lau’s two fields. The court heard that Hau and Man allegedly damaged Lau’s two farming fields in July, 2009. She is claiming HK$1.3 million in damages from Hau.

Hau told the court yesterday: “All they need is money by taking this to court.”

Cross-examined by Lau’s barrister Yeung Ming-tai, Hau said: “I have so much land. Why do I need to occupy others’ land?” The court heard that Hau was a landlord in Ho Sheung Heung in Sheung Shui. “I have a big fortune,” he said. “People say I will get rich if land resumption is carried out. Yes, I will get rich, and it is out of my control.”

Hau said that after mid-July in 2009, government officials informed him of illegal waste dumping in Ho Sheung Heung. He said as a rural representative, he was duty-bound to remove the waste and restore the land to its original condition by planting grass and fruit trees.

He said he did this on behalf of the rural committee.

Court heard earlier that Man had admitted his liability for fly-tipping but disputed the compensation amount.

Lau’s son, Hau Tai-lok, told the court that the two defendants had threatened his family several times in hopes of scaring them away.

He claimed that outsiders dared not to carry out large-scale waste dumping in Ho Sheung Heung unless they were assisted by “people who had power in the village”.

During cross-examination, Hau often brought humour to the four-day trial by repeatedly calling Lau’s counsel “lawyer So” [his surname is Yeung] and asking for the surname of his own counsel.

Judge Mr Justice Paul Lam Ting-kwok also had to remind Hau, who often gave lengthy yet irrelevant answers, to listen carefully to counsel’s questions and answer accordingly.

In response to the judge’s reminders, Hau said: “If I had paid attention to what my teachers said, I would have become a judge today.”

Both parties are due to give their closing submissions today.

Source URL (modified on Mar 4th 2015, 11:59pm): http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1729523/hong-kong-rural-leader-denies-waste-dumping-hk13m-claim

It is possible to wage war on waste without killing porpoises

Martin Williams

Christine Loh Kung-wai, undersecretary for the environment, writes that she and her colleagues see no conflicts between plans to build a “waste-to-energy project”, that is, a massive trash incinerator, and Hong Kong’s contribution to the UN Convention on Biological Diversity (“Vital project for waste management”, February 18).

Well, perhaps I can add to the explanation of Paul Melsom in his letter (“Environmental officers should seek to protect, not ruin”, February 4). I anticipate that while invisible to Ms Loh, the conflicts will be crystal clear to most people.

Essentially, the conflicts arise from waters just west of Shek Kwu Chau being a key habitat for finless porpoise, which the International Union for the Conservation of Nature classes as globally vulnerable to extinction, so should merit strong government protection efforts; yet this is the very site where the government plans to build an artificial island for one of the world’s largest waste incinerators.

As any conservationist would tell you, the best way to protect an endangered species is to safeguard its habitat. Yet the government plans to destroy a key place for the porpoise, and make a currently tranquil area busy with boat traffic plus round-the-clock work on feeding the incinerator.

Ms Loh writes of mitigation measures, such as designating nearby waters as marine park, and releasing fish fry. These may appeal to bureaucrats and engineers seeking to railroad the incinerator project through, but fail to impress conservationists such as Mr Melsom. The increasingly dire situation of the Chinese white dolphin shows that such efforts cannot compensate for the devastating effects of reclamation schemes.

Then, along with producing fumes too poisonous for it to be sited in the city, the incinerator will create highly toxic ash, and there are notions for dumping this in a landfill island to be built south of nearby Cheung Chau. So as well as severely impacting porpoises, the incinerator island will harm other wildlife and threaten human health.

Of course, Hong Kong does need to tackle its waste crisis, but should also protect biodiversity. Though officials are blinkered, there are more options than the government’s burn or bury strategy. From reducing ridiculous packaging, through increased reuse and recycling, to adopting less harmful and more advanced treatment technologies, it is possible to wage war on waste without killing porpoises.

Dr Martin Williams, director, Hong Kong Outdoors

Source URL (modified on Mar 2nd 2015, 12:01am): http://www.scmp.com/comment/letters/article/1724969/it-possible-wage-war-waste-without-killing-porpoises

From financing issues to manpower shortages, Hong Kong’s third runway plan is doomed to fail

Albert Cheng says recruiting air traffic controllers from overseas, to boost the capacity of the two existing runways, would be far cheaper

Airport Authority chiefs have been racking their brains on how to bypass the legislature to fund the proposed third runway, ever since the environmental impact assessment for the project was approved last year.

Last month, the authority submitted a proposal to the Executive Council on how to finance the massive infrastructure project. It has estimated the cost at HK$136 billion, a far lower figure than earlier market predictions of around HK$200 billion.

Even at this price, the odds of a smooth sailing through the Legislative Council remain slim. Public objections to the plan are mounting, with some people painting it as a white elephant, while green activists are seeking a judicial review to nullify the environmental permit already issued.

The authority has reportedly come up with a three-pronged approach to get round public opinion. It wants to waive dividend payment to the government for eight years, so that a special HK$40 billion fund could be set aside for the purpose. It paid a record HK$5.3 billion dividend to the government, which is its sole shareholder, in the last financial year.

It is also poised to impose a “runway construction surcharge” of between HK$150 and HK$200 on each passenger, generating another HK$3 billion a year for the next 10 years. This would be on top of the HK$120 departure tax now levied on passengers aged 12 or above who leave Hong Kong by air.

The remaining amount could be met by issuing bonds.

The authority’s plans are designed to deprive legislators of the proper channels to scrutinise the project.

I have made my position clear; I am unconvinced there is a need for an additional runway. Officials, for example, have yet to explain how we could better use the airspace immediately north of Hong Kong under mainland control.

As Beijing continues to erode Hong Kong’s role in the “one country, two systems” arrangement, our so-called special administrative region will increasingly become not so special – and be just another Chinese city. In this scenario, the premise for a drastic increase in air capacity for Hong Kong is questionable.

Meanwhile, the director general of civil aviation, Norman Lo Shung-man, has made a bad pitch even less appealing. He was condemned by legislators for squandering taxpayers’ money by turning his new office building into a luxurious amenity. The Civil Aviation Department also spent public money on security and electronic systems without government approval. It would be a stretch to ask the public to place their confidence in him to oversee the most expensive infrastructure project in the history of Hong Kong.

Economic, environmental and technical uncertainties aside, the project is also doomed by an acute labour shortage. There is now a shortfall of about 15 air traffic control and aeronautical communications personnel. The Civil Aviation Department has recruited 60-odd student officers over the past few years. That means only about 20 officers at the junior level each year.

It takes five years to train a student air traffic control officer. At least a decade is needed before they are ready to be promoted to a supervisory role. Even if we eventually get the hardware built in a decade or so, we would not have enough air traffic controllers to ensure safety and efficiency.

Our existing air traffic controllers are close to burn-out. They are often required to work overtime and are unable to take all their holidays. It is difficult for them to keep up their professional standards under such stress, even before any additional workload arising from a third runway. Our airport’s capacity is severely handicapped at night because there are not enough controllers to direct the planes. Carriers, such as Cathay Pacific, are not able to fully utilise their broad-bodied aircraft for the same reason.

I wouldn’t mind putting a new runway on our collective wish list. But it is hardly a matter of urgency.

If we fail to act now to improve the working conditions at the control tower, the two existing runways may become underused, rather than saturated as the authority has predicted.

There is a compelling case for recruiting more experienced air traffic control officers from overseas.

These people could help to significantly boost the number of landings and take-offs for the two serving runways from 62 flights per hour to 68 flights per hour, or more.

Even if we were to reward, say, 30 expatriates with salaries of more than HK$1 million a year, that amount would be peanuts compared with the price of the third runway and would be money well spent.

This alternative prescription is simple: reform the Civil Aviation Department and liberalise its recruitment policy for air traffic controllers.

Albert Cheng King-hon is a political commentator. taipan@albertcheng.hk

Source URL (modified on Feb 26th 2015, 12:43pm): http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1723763/financing-issues-manpower-shortages-hong-kongs-third-runway

HONG KONG AIMS TO GET THIRD RUNWAY READY BY 2023 AS DEMAND SOARS

http://macaudailytimes.com.mo/hong-kong-aims-to-get-third-runway-ready-by-2023-as-demand-soars.html

Hong Kong, the world’s largest international air cargo airport, aims to start construction next year on a third runway that will open by 2023 as regional rivals step up efforts to capture growing passenger traffic and cargo demand in Asia.

The new facility will help Hong Kong International Airport boost capacity to 100 million passengers and 9 million tons of cargo a year by 2030, Financial Secretary John Tsang said in his budget speech yesterday. The airport said it handled 63.4 million passengers and 4.38 million tons of cargo last year, both records.

“It is imperative for us to take forward the development of a three-runway system in order to meet our long-term air traffic demand and to maintain our status as an international and regional aviation center in the face of fierce competition from other airports in the region,” Tsang said in a prepared statement.

Tsang’s pledge comes after Singapore announced plans Monday to spend S$3 billion (USD2.2 billion) to begin developing a fifth passenger terminal at Changi International Airport over the next decade, and as other countries gear up to tap growing travel demand from China and other parts of Asia.

Beijing has started construction on a second international airport, while the southwest Chinese city of Chengdu has received regulatory approval for a new 69.3 billion yuan ($11.1 billion) airport that will have three runways.

Hong Kong’s third runway is projected to cost HK$150 billion ($19.3 billion).

Hong Kong’s total trade came to HK$8.4 trillion last year, with air cargo through the airport comprising nearly 40 percent of exports and imports by value, Tsang said yesterday.

Tsang also announced plans to develop air financing in Hong Kong and pledged to explore measures to promote such business. Clement Tan, Bloomberg

Harmful ozone levels in Hong Kong up 35pc in last 15 years

Concentrations of ozone in the city’s air have increased by a third in the last 15 years, highlighting yet again the severity in regional air pollution, according to government data.

Between 1999 and last year, concentrations of ambient ozone at the city’s general air quality monitoring stations rose by 35 per cent, despite levels of all other pollutants showing decreases.

Preliminary data released by the Environmental Protection Department today recorded ozone concentrations at general stations increasing by 7 per cent from 43 micrograms per cubic metre to 46 micrograms per cubic metre last year.

“This once again shows more needs to be done in terms of cooperation with the region,” said Mok Kwai-cheung, the department’s assistant director of environmental protection.

Ozone is a major component of photochemical smog that reduces visibility and threatens human health when exposure is prolonged and high.

The pollutant is formed by a reaction between volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and nitrogen oxide (NOx) generated from other combustion sources. The dirty, orange smog enveloping views of the harbour on heavily polluted days is created when these two pollutants react with sunlight.

Hong Kong has set a target to reduce NOx by 20 to 30 per cent and VOCs by 15 per cent by 2020 in accordance with a regional air quality management plan between the city and Guangdong.

A cross-border study funded by the department last year found that nearly half of the ambient VOC levels in the Pearl River Delta region were traffic-related, with petrol exhaust the biggest single contributor.

The report suggested that reducing traffic in the delta region by half could be one of the most effective means of combatting regional smog. But cutting VOC emissions from traffic by half could achieve the same effect.
________________________________________
Source URL (modified on Feb 24th 2015, 6:52pm): http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1722475/harmful-ozone-levels-hong-kong-35pc-last-15-years

Time to put our waste to better use

Doug Woodring says by fixing the problem of our mounting waste – by treating it as a resource – we can create opportunities to address other challenges such as climate change

Some 8 million tonnes of plastic waste makes its way into our oceans every year, according to recent reports. That is the same as placing five garbage bags of trash on every foot of the coastline on our planet. And that is just plastic.

To put the World Bank’s estimates of global municipal solid waste production into perspective, it would be like covering all of California in waste to a depth of almost 10 metres each year. And the scary fact is that some predict this figure will double within 15 years, as population growth and consumption take their toll on our resources.

So, it is worth asking, is our waste footprint a bigger concern than climate change? In the scheme of long-term impact, it’s hard to say, but what is not hard to say is that most of our communities lack the waste management and recycling infrastructure to keep waste from creating problems in our societies and environment.

Unlike climate change, which affects certain locations at certain times, waste affects billions of people on a daily basis, and it is right under our noses. But because it is not “sexy” in terms of the technology and remediation options that exist for harnessing these resources, and because the waste treatment modus operandi in many countries is controlled by the “old guard”, it has proved hard to close the gap between our consumption “outflows”, and our ability to channel that material for job creation, innovation, clean water, better tourism and improved societies.

In some ways, waste is the “magic” point from which we could correct some of our bigger environmental ills. Why? Because trash is something everyone can see, feel, touch and also do something about. It is not like carbon, which children can’t see, and adults can’t judge.

With plastic in particular, the hardest of the municipal solid waste streams to create economies of scale for – due to the wide variety of types and colours – people know that it should not be in the natural environment. Worse, many times, a brand name is associated with that trash. Of course, the companies did not dump it, but to an increasingly aware public, the brand name carries a lot of negative impact for those trying to make their communities a better place.

All the onus cannot be put on the public to put their waste in the right place. In many places, the education system fails to provide the base of knowledge needed for proper recycling and waste management, nor is there the capacity to deal with many materials we discard.

The result is a direct threat to our water systems, which many argue is the next hot topic on the global list of challenges to be addressed.

On the ocean side of the equation, more than 1 billion people rely on protein from the sea each day, yet many are fishing in coastal zones affected by pollution. Trash that is not dealt with can lead to problems of disease, reduced tourism, agricultural impact and flooding.

All these problems can be solved with the right systems. When these systems start to be improved, it is also possible to engage the local community on other, more complex issues, such as those related to climate change.

A good analogy is the “broken window” theory for poor neighbourhoods, in which maintaining and monitoring our communities, while fixing all the broken windows, helps create an atmosphere of order and lawfulness – in this case, preventing more trash being dumped. If you can sort out the waste issues, you create a sense of pride in the area and its waters, with a greater chance that people will recycle and dispose of waste responsibly.

Creating economies of scale for plastic waste, with the help of the companies involved in distributing it in the first place, will lead to many positive results.

This means creating bring-back programmes, using reverse supply chains to recapture some of the material sold, the use of recycled content in products and being part of the “design-for-recycling” economy. This will create a strong social uplift, which is needed in many parts of the world.

Waste is a “forgotten” resource, and by dismissing the value that different waste streams can create, we end up inadvertently adding to climate change ills. Organic waste produces methane, which is 23 times more harmful to our atmosphere than carbon dioxide. There are all kinds of technologies to make use of organic waste, but when it is mixed with plastic, the aggregated waste (plastics and organics) becomes virtually worthless, unless there is a hi-tech sorting facility or incineration is used for energy recovery.

Not everyone has such technology, however, so by seeing plastic as a valuable usable raw material, and one that can be recycled while creating jobs along the way, with the help of companies, governments and other communal institutions, we can channel these resources back into use.

This will help keep the organic material in a more usable, pure form, allowing composting or gasification for energy and avoiding methane production from rotting waste.

Virtually everyone wins in this cycle, except maybe the “old guard” who are afraid of change. There are no natural enemies for waste, but we have not changed our collective mindsets to harness the opportunities for improvement. If we do, we can move to the next level of climate-related challenges.

Doug Woodring is founder of the Ocean Recovery Alliance/Plastic Disclosure Project
________________________________________
Source URL (modified on Feb 24th 2015, 5:31pm): http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1722450/time-put-our-waste-better-use

Photo Essay: Hong Kong’s waste problem

http://www.timeout.com.hk/big-smog/features/71168/photo-essay-hong-kongs-waste-problem.html

CNY is a time for plenty of fun, plenty of food – and plenty of waste. Anna Cummins goes on a sobering visual journey into Hong Kong’s ongoing rubbish problem and looks at what exactly is being done to combat it. Photography by Calvin Sit.

Hong Kong has a problem. Together we generate more than six million tonnes of waste every year – and only 48 percent of it is recycled. An immense 13,800 tonnes of rubbish is going directly into the ground every single day. More specifically, local environmental group Green Power estimates that 180 million red packets, 1.5 million mooncakes, a million mooncake tins, 62,500 plastic lanterns and five million items of disposable cutlery are thrown away during CNY alone. In other words, this is a particularly pertinent time of year to think about what we chuck in the bin.

Now, this is all kind of bleak. We know CNY is meant to be fun. But change comes from awareness – and maybe, during all the festivities, now is the time to think of the harm we’re all creating to the environment. In this feature, we’re also looking at some of the positive ways in which Hongkongers are fighting back against excess. So it’s not all bad news! Come with us as we look at the ever-increasing waste problem in the all-too-fragrant harbour…

image001 (2)

THE LANDFILL

This is the North East New Territories landfill, which sits on an exposed slope in Ta Kwu Ling, close to the border with China. This literal mountain of rubbish, constantly compressed by large trucks and encircled by scavenging birds, forms a distinctly dystopian landscape – with the towers of Shenzhen rising along the hazy horizon. Every few metres, the fragment of a distinctive red carrier bag from the wet markets floats between the scattered mattresses, plastic water bottles, children’s toys, instant noodle packets and other recognisable household objects.

The NENT landfill is one of three currently in use in Hong Kong and, despite being the smallest of the trio, it can hold 35 million cubic metres of rubbish. At the current rate of dumping, it will be full in two years, although a controversial series of extensions will soon add several years to that. The landfill is open from 7am to 7pm every single day of the year. In that time, a steady stream of trucks pull up to unload – each 40ft truck carries 21 tonnes of household waste. More than 2,700 tonnes of waste is dumped here daily. Find out more at epd.gov.hk.

image002 (1)

SAVED FOOD

No, this isn’t the lunch basket of a particularly hungry office worker. This is just some of the food that’s left unsold at the end of the day in a busy branch of coffee store Pret A Manger. The popular chain has a policy of not putting fresh food out for sale on the next day.

So – what happens to it all? Food waste is one of the largest problems the city faces in its ongoing trash tumult – with 3,200 tonnes of edible goodness being chucked away daily. That’s one third of the whole city’s municipal solid waste. If that wasn’t shocking enough, NGO Feeding Hong Kong explains it a different way – all those daily dumped dishes would fit on 120 double decker buses. That’s one reason why Pret has been donating its leftovers – around 2,000kg of salads, wraps and sandwiches every month – to Feeding Hong Kong since 2009. Grub like this heads to the charity’s food bank, situated in a warehouse in Yau Tong, before being distributed by volunteers to those in need. Maybe the city’s supermarkets, which chuck away 29 tonnes of food every day, should sit up and pay attention. Find out more at feedinghk.org.

image003

REUSED TEXTILES

This colourful mass is a bundle of used clothes – trussed up and sitting in a textile recycling warehouse near to Sheung Shui. The huge storage facility is packed, literally, to the rafters with clothes that have been saved from landfill through donation drives run by NGOs such as Friends of the Earth and Redress, before being repurposed and recycled.

We love fast fashion in our city. Around 80,000 tonnes of textiles are thrown out every year and it’s easy to see why – with an abundance of cheap and cheerful outlets to pick from in almost every district, a seasonal wardrobe update is more than tempting. But considering that textiles are close to 100 percent recyclable, the impact that the textile industry continues to have on the planet is shocking – a simple cotton T-shirt requires up to 2,700 litres of water to produce (WWF) and fabric dyeing is responsible for around 20 percent of all industrial water pollution in the world (World Bank). Buying secondhand has never seemed like such a good idea… Find out more at redress.com.hk.

image004

REFURBISHED ELECTRONICS

If the telly is on the blink, your fridge light has packed in, the hinge of your washing machine is rusting up or you’ve got limescale in your kettle, think twice before dropping your electronics off at the tip and getting something new and shiny. This is the Tuen Mun warehouse of the Weee Go Green Recycling Programme, run by St James Settlement. Since 2003, the project has been giving a new lease of life to 20,000 appliances annually. Expired and unwanted electronics are collected from homes and businesses before being taken to a workshop in Tuen Mun’s EcoPark, where they are either restored and redistributed to local families in need, or otherwise dismantled and recycled.

Only 20 percent of the 70,000 tonnes of computers, televisions, rice cookers and other electronics that we dispose of annually goes to landfill in Hong Kong. That’s because the other 80 percent is exported out of the city. This is supposedly for recycling, although this can have disastrous effects for towns like Guiyu in Guangdong, which has become infamous for being the largest e-waste processing site in the world, provoking terrible environmental consequences. Thankfully, there are now several other schemes also copying what Weee Go Green is doing. Phew! Find out more at weeegogreen.sjs.org.hk.

image005

MARINE PLASTICS

This is Waterfall Bay. The small beach sits on the south side of Hong Kong Island, close to Aberdeen. The golden sunset and wispy clouds certainly set a beautiful scene. But there’s something else catching our eyes here. And that’s all the crap. You see, this is an unmanaged beach – meaning the government doesn’t clear the detritus that accumulates here. And that’s clearly a problem.

The items you’ll find washed up on our city’s beaches are most notably petroleum-based plastics (such as PET) – bottles, plastic bags, food containers and six-pack rings, which can take years to degrade. In fact, 80 percent of the world’s marine waste is plastic. And, once it has degraded, the toxic chemicals within the plastic, such as bisphenol A, or BPA, are released into the ocean and can wash up on beaches or end up inside marine animals. That puts a damper on sunbathing.

Reversing the terrifying trend is a giant undertaking, particularly as not all of the waste in our oceans necessarily comes from Hong Kong. In fact, it’s estimated that China produces a third of the entire world’s plastic pollution.But HK citizens can do their part by not throwing rubbish on to the beach or just on the floor in general, even in the city – vast quantities get washed through storm drains into the sea. For their part, the Environmental Protection Department has launched a campaign, ‘Clean Shorelines’, to find ways of solving the problem. Find out more at bit.ly/CleanShorelines