The U.K. counties of Worcestershire and Herefordshire near Wales began subsidizing the purchase of disposals by residents in 2005, after studying the issue and concluding that using disposals was a cost-effective, convenient, and hygienic means of diverting kitchen food waste from landfills. According to their analysis, using in-sink disposals for food waste costs less and has a better carbon footprint than other waste disposal options. The counties estimated that lower solid waste disposal costs would pay for the cost of subsidies in approximately three years.
Waste Management
Australia: Assessment of Food Disposal Options in Multi-Unit Dwellings in Sydney
In 2000, the city of Sydney, Australia investigated the impact of food waste disposals in five areas: environmental, economic, microbial risk, social acceptance, and technical/operational for sewer systems. For each area, the impacts of disposals were compared to that of collecting food waste with municipal waste and sending it to landfills, centralized composting of food and garden waste, and home composting. Among the report‘s conclusions was that 1) the disposal of food with municipal waste was the least satisfactory of all options, 2) individual composting was environmentally ideal, but impractical for multi-unit dwellings, and 3) using a food waste disposal was second best for energy consumption, global warming potential, and acidification.
The Netherlands: The Environmental Aspects of Food Waste Disposers
Food waste disposals were relatively unknown in the Netherlands in 1996 when Dr.ir. J. de Koning and Professor ir. J.H.J.M. van der Graaf, two researchers from the Section of Sanitary Engineering at the Delft University of Technology, studied their effects on sewer systems and wastewater treatment. The study concluded that using food waste disposals had a negligible impact on both. Eight years later, Dr.ir. J. de Koning conducted a follow-up study at the request of the Dutch government, specifically to quantify the impact of food waste loading on the Dutch sewage system and the effects of disposal use on the biological wastewater treatment process. The study, which ended in July 2004, reinforced that impacts to the sewer system and wastewater treatment facility were negligible. In addition, de Koning concluded that the use of food waste disposals could improve the current system for the collection of kitchen, garden and food waste, specifically in areas where separate collections had been abandoned because of environmental and/or economical reasons.
United States: City of New York Reverses Partial Ban on Residential Disposers, Finds Benefits Exceed Negligible Impact on Sewer System, Water Quality
New York City had banned food waste disposals in areas served by combined storm and sanitary sewers since the 1970s. In 1995, the City Council directed the city‘s Department of Environmental Protection to conduct a 21-month pilot project that studied the impacts of using disposals on the environment, public health, and the cost associated with operating the water and sewer system. The impact of grease and food solids on sewers, the impact on water consumption, and the impact of possible increased pollutant loading on receiving waters were among the various issues examined. The study concluded that the impact of food waste disposals in any of these areas was “de minimus,” and the previous ban was overturned.