Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

Price Too High For New Runway

SCMP – Updated on Dec 23, 2008

Hong Kong International Airport should not have a third runway.

The environmental consequences of a third runway are enormous in an area of Hong Kong that records very high pollution levels and is home to the endangered pink dolphin.

A new runway will cause huge increases in carbon emissions that will make a mockery of Hong Kong’s measures to reduce greenhouse gas pollutants.

At the recent Clinton Global Initiative conference held in Hong Kong, former US president Bill Clinton, who champions efforts to fight climate change, said: “Asia has a strong history of social responsibility and we have a unique opportunity to work together in innovative and effective ways to achieve positive change.”

Let us show the world that Hong Kong cares and responds to such calls.

Eliane Florentin, Mid-Levels

Britain ‘Needs Deeper CO2 Cuts’

Roger Harrabin, Environment analyst, BBC News – 1 Dec 2008

Official advisers to the UK government have demanded Britain slash greenhouse gases by a fifth of current levels by 2020 – the toughest target so far.

The Committee on Climate Change said the cut (21% on 2005 levels) is needed for the UK to play its fair share in combating dangerous change.

They propose firm carbon budgets for the next three five-year periods.

It is believed to be the first time that any major nation has attempted this.

If the budgets work, they are could be copied worldwide.

The independent committee recommends that by 2020 it should be made almost impossible to burn coal for electricity without technology to capture and store the carbon emissions.

This has major implications for the UK’s energy policy.

The report says fuel will inevitably become more expensive to achieve the carbon targets. But it says the government will need to compensate poor households rather than trying to keep prices down.

To make the targets even harder for the government, the committee recommends the UK should not be able to buy its way out of its obligations by paying poor countries to cut carbon on our behalf.

Until now, the government has been planning to buy up to half of our carbon credits.

The report will be widely welcomed by environmentalists, but they are angry that the committee has not set any specific targets for aviation – the fastest-growing source of emissions.

The committee has put aviation into the overall carbon budget but exempted it from specific targets until disputes over responsibility for international aviation emissions have been resolved.

Lord Turner, the committee chairman, said the cuts could be achieved without compromising our lifestyles or economy: “The reductions can be achieved at very low cost (an estimated 1% loss of GDP growth in 2020). The cost of not achieving the reductions at a national and global level will be far greater.”

The climate change secretary Ed Miliband said: “We will give the report in-depth consideration but I am pleased to say that from 2009 carbon budgets will take their place alongside the financial budget.”

A ministerial source told BBC News that the government would almost inevitably adopt the committee’s suggested carbon budgets.

The big question will be how far ministers accept the committee’s policies to achieve those reductions. The committee notes that the government has been good at making bold statements on climate but bad at putting firm policies in place.

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/sci/tech/7757865.stm

Entrepreneur Floats Plan For Seaplanes To Macau

Scheduled service awaiting approval from government

Gary Cheung – Updated on Jul 14, 2008 – SCMP

Seaplanes flying over Victoria Harbour and taking passengers to and from Macau will become a reality in the foreseeable future if the government approves a plan to relaunch the flights, which form part of the collective memory of Hongkongers.

WaterfrontAir, a firm founded by Canadian entrepreneur Michael Agopsowicz, plans to operate a scheduled seaplane service between a new Kai Tai Waterfront Aerodrome and the Pak On ferry terminal near Macau’s Cotai Strip.

The company intends to use a fleet of 18-seater DHC-6 Twin Otter floatplanes for the flights, which would take about 20 minutes.

It plans to create a licensed water aerodrome opposite the old Kai Tak airport runway.

Passengers would be taken to the Kowloon City ferry pier after the seaplanes landed.

The Tourism Commission and the Tourism Board have given their backing to the proposal because it would enhance Hong Kong’s appeal as a city with diversity and fun. But the project first needs to pass an environmental-impact assessment.

Mr Agopsowicz, also director of the company, said he would look for investors for the project and planned to commission an environmental-impact assessment and a noise- impact assessment in the second half of the year.

The firm plans to charge about HK$1,500 for a one-way trip, compared with HK$2,200 to HK$2,400 for a helicopter trip between Hong Kong and Macau or about HK$150 for a jetfoil. It plans to run 20 flights a day.

The firm estimates 150,000 visitors will take the trips every year.

Mr Agopsowicz said he discussed the concept with Permanent Secretary for Transport and Housing Francis Ho Suen-wai on March 18.

In a letter to Mr Agopsowicz on May 5, the bureau said: “From the aviation point of view, we have no objection in principle to your idea, but the feasibility of the idea hinges on the satisfactory resolution of a wide range of technical issues.”

A bureau spokeswoman said these issues concerned the feasibility of the idea from the perspectives of civil aviation, district planning, land-use planning, environmental impact and interface with marine activities.

“The Tourism Commission considers that an alternative means of fast transportation to Macau should be a [welcome] addition to enhance connectivity and choice. The seaplanes championed by you look attractive and elegant, and are good for leisure travel,” the bureau said in its letter to Mr Agopsowicz.

The commission was of the view that the plan would enhance Hong Kong’s appeal.

In a letter to Mr Agopsowicz last month, Tourism Board executive director Anthony Lau Chun-hon said: “Not only can the service offer users the opportunity to view Hong Kong’s spectacular skyline and cityscape over Victoria Harbour, it can also strengthen Hong Kong’s image as a major cosmopolitan city.”

Scheduled seaplanes between Hong Kong and Macau were operated between the 1930s and 1950s.

Mr Agopsowicz said seaplanes did not have a significant environmental impact. “They compare very favourably to conventional motorised boats in terms of air and water pollution,” he said.

He added that the DHC-6 planes he planned to deploy for the services were much quieter than helicopters and the service would operate in daytime only.

Mr Agopsowicz said seaplane services did not require a huge amount of investment and he estimated that the start-up investment for the project would be below US$5 million.

Bruce Liu Sing-lee, Kowloon City district councillor representing the Kai Tak constituency, said he would support the proposal if the noise level was acceptable.

“I think the seaplane services would create a substantial number of job opportunities for the neighbourhood and the whole Kowloon City district,” Mr Liu said.

Farming Out The Pollution Problem

Oasis’s promise of a Hong Kong-based budget airline turned out to be a mirage after all.

Wednesday, April 16, 2008 – The Standard

Oasis’s promise of a Hong Kong-based budget airline turned out to be a mirage after all. But capitalism proceeds from its failures as well as from its successes, and in spite of the considerable (and perhaps unavoidable) inconvenience and loss to people holding now worthless tickets, entrepreneurial derring-do and the risk that accompanies it is one of the foundations of Hong Kong’s prosperity.

Oasis’s demise may, in the end, be no bad thing, for while cheap flights have permitted many more people to take many more holidays, the consequent increase in air travel results in worsening carbon emissions and a variety of problems related to airport development: noise, pollution and congestion.

The unfortunate truth is that budget airlines like Oasis encourage people to fly, which would be fine if airplanes didn’t belch out carbon and pollutants in rather large amounts. But they do.

I don’t wish to wax overly moral about this, for I will take advantage of low-cost flights myself when available, but any solution to reduce carbon emissions from air travel will result in higher prices, so maybe we shouldn’t mourn too much for the passing of the HK$1,000 Hong Kong-London ticket.

Indeed, high oil prices have much the same effect as a carbon tax and may be the best (and perhaps only practical) way to reduce carbon emissions from air travel.

Admittedly, the revenues from this “tax” go to oil companies and some not-always-entirely-in-favor regimes around the world, rather than the supposedly more benign national tax authorities of the consuming countries, but they are no less effective for that.

Further, the woes of Heathrow’s Terminal 5 have once more raised arguments against concentrating all aviation growth in a single location: regardless of projected demand, there are considerable reservations about the wisdom of continued expansion there.

London has several airports in addition to Heathrow, including Gatwick, London City Airport, Stansted and Luton. Budget airlines tend to fly from the latter two: their business models are based on the lower costs at these secondary airports. New York also makes use of at least three airports, and Washington two.

Hong Kong’s equivalents would be Macau and Shenzhen. If there are to be budget carriers, perhaps it’s just as well that they fly out of our secondary airports – something which has already begun to happen – reducing the pressure to expand Chek Lap Kok.

Airports are capital-intensive and the return on investment often problematical. Anyway, what Hong Kong wants are the passengers: plane take-offs and landings are just a means to an end.

If Macau and Shenzhen get the congestion, noise and pollution, and we get the passengers, then so much the better. It is true that both Macau and Shenzhen are more inconvenient than Chek Lap Kok, but perhaps not much more so than Stansted, or the Girona and Reus airports used by budget airlines flying to Barcelona. If you are someone for whom money is more valuable than time, you’ll put up with an extra 30-60 minutes on the bus or ferry.

There is not, of course, immigration control between London and Stansted, but Geneva airport, for example, manages to accommodate passengers to and from both France and Switzerland, by having each country maintain its own immigration and customs, while British immigration for travelers on the Eurostar from Paris is at departure in the Gare du Nord.

The larger issue is that we can’t look at our relations with our regional neighbors exclusively as a zero-sum game where every visitor to, or via, Macau, for example, is one lost to Hong Kong. Neither Macau nor Shenzhen is a competitor for those visitors who want what Hong Kong has to offer.

Budget flights to these two places are likely to increase rather than decrease visitors here, or at least would if transit to Hong Kong could be streamlined.

Whether or not this will actually happen remains to be seen, but Oasis’s demise is a reminder that not all business activities which might benefit Hong Kong should necessarily be based here and that moving certain activities outside the confines of Hong Kong might allow us to concentrate on the higher value-added ends of the business.

Harsh Controls For Ships, Planes

Published on Apr 4, 2008

Latest proposal will hit poorer countries hard

Airline and shipping operators, especially those in developing countries, will be hit hard if a European Union proposal on greenhouse gas emissions is adopted, officials warned yesterday.

The EU submitted a proposal yesterday to the ongoing Bangkok round of climate-change negotiations to replace the Kyoto Protocol, which expires in 2012.

Delegates from 163 countries have participated in the United Nations-sanctioned conference here with the objective of managing carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases blamed for global warming.

As a result, EU delegates asked for the control of greenhouse gases from the use of maritime and aviation fuels.

According to EU delegates, airlines and shipping lines are important sources of these emissions, which have been growing at a fast rate and neither is covered by the Kyoto Protocol.

“Even though it is just the first draft of a proposal, there is a strong chance it will be approved by member countries,” said Sirithan Pairojborriboon, director of the Greenhouse Gas Management Public Organisation.

“If that’s the case, airline operators [such as Thai Airways International and other Asian carriers] will be affected significantly, as they will be forced to control their emissions or else they will be charged for such emissions.”

Sirithan warned that the burden would be heavy for airline operators in developing countries, as currently they have no obligations on emission controls under the global climate pact.

“These operators could be forced to pay even though the total emissions of their respective countries is not within the level of Annex I countries,” he said, adding that the tourism and logistics industries might also be affected.

Annex I countries have to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by about 5 per cent from the 1990 level. Under the Kyoto Protocol, this target is supposed to be met by 2012.

Currently, Thailand and other developing countries are not on the Annex I list and emission cuts are still voluntary.

According to Sirithan, the EU has suggested two options for its proposal: allowing an emission trading system among airlines or initiating a carbon dioxide charge on airlines.

The EU proposal yesterday faced strong opposition from many delegates from developing countries, he said.

“They fear that a rise in costs from greenhouse gases will affect air fares or route management and in the end reduce the airline industry’s competitiveness,” Sirithan said, adding that the EU plan is expected to be debated more widely in the next round of climate talks in Bonn, Germany, in June.

The EU proposal was submitted to one of the two meetings at the Bangkok Climate Talks – called the Meeting of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Further Commitments for Annex I Parties under the Kyoto Protocol – which will end today.

Kamol Sukin

The Nation

Aviation Takes Climate Cause Under Its Wing

Giovanni Bisignani – Updated on Feb 27, 2008 – SCMP

Aviation is the lifeblood of the Asian economy. Across the region, 10.5 million aviation-related jobs support US$807 billion in business. So, it should come as no surprise that the industry is growing. What may surprise many is the responsible approach of the industry – globally – to its environmental impacts.

Let’s start with the facts. The Nobel-Prize-winning Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is the only authoritative source of global facts. It estimates that aviation contributes 2 per cent of the world’s man-made carbon dioxide. This is expected to grow to 3 per cent by 2050. This is far less than the current emissions from road transport, shipping, deforestation or energy production. Aviation is, and will remain, a small part of the big problem of climate change.

Being small is not a licence for complacency. And a growing carbon footprint is unacceptable for any industry. The challenge is to keep the many benefits of aviation while eliminating any negative impacts.

Aviation has delivered impressive results. Over the past four decades, fuel efficiency has improved 70 per cent. And the billions being invested in new aircraft are helping to put aviation on target for a further 25 per cent improvement in fuel efficiency by 2020.

The solution is not just about buying new aircraft. How we operate them is equally important. The International Air Transport Association (Iata) is working with airlines to identify environmental efficiencies. Last year, we identified operational measures that saved 7 million tonnes of carbon dioxide. Another 4 million tonnes was saved by shortening more than 300 routes.

In Asia, reorganising air traffic over the Bay of Bengal is saving 50,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide a year. Modernised approach procedures at Japanese airports will save 160,000 tonnes. And, if we could sort out the tangle of air-traffic procedures for the Pearl River Delta’s five airports, a further 250,000 tonnes could be saved. These achievements illustrate the positive impact of Iata’s four-pillar strategy on climate change: invest in new technology; operate aircraft effectively; build and use efficient infrastructure; and, provide positive economic incentives. Together, these initiatives have limited the growth of our carbon footprint to 3 per cent per year, even while air travel expands at between 5 per cent and 6 per cent.

Last June, I challenged the industry to achieve carbon-neutral growth on the way to a carbon-free future by developing a zero-emission aircraft in 50 years’ time. The vision is ambitious. But it is possible.

Asia has a role in building aviation’s future as a benchmark for environmental responsibility. By 2010, intra-Asia traffic will be the largest single market in the world. With an aircraft fleet that is two years younger than the global average of 11.8 years, it already has a head start on fuel efficiency. And the region’s growth is a unique opportunity to develop leading-edge infrastructure.

Asia also has the opportunity to avoid the political hypocrisy that has characterised the debate in Europe. Taxes applied in the name of the environment have only helped solve budget problems. Europe’s rushed unilateral approach to include aviation in its emissions trading scheme is contrary to international treaties.

There are two unique opportunities for Asia. First, transport ministers from the Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation forum laid the groundwork for environmental leadership last year with an agreement that technology, operations and infrastructure must be at the core of aviation’s environmental agenda in the region. Second, the region’s sovereign wealth funds could be used strategically to fund basic research in green technologies. The Group of Eight meeting in Japan later this year can provide a global stage for Asia to show its support for the air transport industry’s strong vision for environmental responsibility.

Giovanni Bisignani is director general and chief executive officer of Iata

Oasis Hong Kong Airlines to Fly Climate Neutral

Oasis Hong Kong Airlines Invites its International Passengers to Fly Climate Neutral™ – PRWeb

Oasis Hong Kong Airlines has partnered with the climate solutions company Climate Friendly™, to offer its passengers the opportunity to neutralise the greenhouse gas emissions from their flights through investment in renewable energy in China.

Hong Kong (PRWEB) January 28, 2008 — Oasis Hong Kong Airlines has partnered with the climate solutions company Climate Friendly™, to offer its passengers the opportunity to neutralise the greenhouse gas emissions from their flights through investment in renewable energy in China. Oasis is one of the first airlines worldwide to develop a programme based on the full environmental impact of flying, supporting the use of renewable energy carbon credits.

Passengers who choose to offset their emissions using this programme are simply required to input their flight information into Climate Friendly’s air travel calculator. This informs the passenger of their resulting carbon footprint and recommends the equivalent value of renewable energy credits from the selected wind farm in China — the passenger is then given the option of purchasing these energy credits to neutralise their emissions.

Oasis has chosen to support energy credits which assist the Hebei Wind Farm, a 40-turbine project in the Wolongtu Mountains in China’s far north. The wind farm generates some 58,000 MWhs of clean energy a year, providing much needed clean and secure energy for the region and displacing the use of polluting coal-fired electricity which is common in this area and a large pollutant. The wind farm is reducing 60,000 tonnes of greenhouse gas pollution each year in China.

“There is no more important environmental issue than climate change,” said Stephen Miller, Oasis Hong Kong Airlines’ CEO. “We are thrilled to announce this opportunity for our customers to help us begin to neutralise Oasis’ flight emissions through renewable energy projects in China. However, as an expanding airline this is just the start and we hope to extend the programme to other regions worldwide as our network grows.”

Climate Friendly works internationally with businesses and individuals to find innovative approaches to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The programme developed for Oasis is one of the first of its kind allowing passengers to support clean energy in the airline’s own region.

“Oasis Hong Kong Airlines is the first airline in the world to take into account the full environmental impact as recommended by the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and Greenhouse Gas Protocol. This initiative enables Oasis to offer its customers the chance to take real and direct action on climate change,” said Joel Fleming, CEO of Climate Friendly. “By encouraging its passengers to neutralise their flight emissions through wind farm credits in China, Oasis is showing that all businesses can find ways to address this urgent issue and be part of the solution.”

Oasis passengers can learn more about the Oasis Climate Neutral Programme by visiting www.oasishongkong.com under “About Us”.