Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

Airlines face soaring claims over fuel fix

South China Morning Post – 21 July 2011

Freight clients urged to sign up with law firms pursuing airlines for damages after European Commission’s finding of collusion in fuel surcharges

Top Asian and western airlines, including Cathay Pacific Airways (SEHK: 0293), Singapore Airlines Cargo and Korean Airlines, will face further pressure from global criminal and civil action over allegations they colluded to fix fuel surcharges on air cargo shipments between 2000 and 2006.

London-based lawyer Anthony Maton will step up that pressure when he begins a visit to Asia this weekend to persuade exporters and importers to lodge compensation claims against 37 airlines which flew cargo between Asia and Europe. They include 11 carriers who were fined €799.5 million (HK$8.8 billion) by the European Commission last year for fixing airfreight surcharges.

Maton, from Hausfeld & Co LLP, said Asian firms, including mainland cargo owners, undoubtedly suffered losses as a result of what he described as cartel-like behaviour by airlines in fixing fuel surcharges. So far more than 300 firms, who paid freight bills totalling at least US$3 billion, have signed up to Hausfeld’s action, but Maton said these numbers “are increasing all the time”.

“We are steadily signing and then joining in batches further claimants to the action,” he said.

Maton said that while most of the airlines were appealing against the European Commission fines, he doubted this would derail the compensation claims.

This view was shared by Peter Koutsoukis, managing director of Claims Funding International, who has launched a separate compensation claim at a court in Amsterdam in the Netherlands against three airlines – Dutch carriers KLM and Martinair and French partner Air France. Claims Funding International has formed a special company, Equilib, to fight the action on behalf of claimants which total at least 330 mainly European companies which spent around €6 billion on airfreight.

Koutsoukis said the three airlines filed a writ in an Amsterdam court asking that other airlines be joined, either as defendants or third parties to the action. These carriers, including Cathay Pacific Airways, have until August 17 to file a defence saying why they should not be included in the action.

Carriers are also facing a slew of legal action in Asia.

In Australia, nine carriers are being prosecuted by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission for alleged price fixing after six were fined A$41 million (HK$340.7 million). The carriers, including Cathay Pacific, Emirates Airlines, Thai Airways and Garuda, face the latest in a series of directions hearings at Australia’s federal court on August 5. The full trial against all nine carriers is due to start on July 2 next year and last three months.

In New Zealand, the Commerce Commission is taking action against the same group, although Air New Zealand has replaced Garuda.

Commission communications manager Alanah Kalafatelis said the court proceedings were taking place in two stages. The first stage, which focused on the definition of the air cargo market ended in June. She said the second stage of the trial, which was due to start in July 2012 and last about three months, would “address the price fixing arrangements”.

Australian law firm Maurice Blackburn has also launched a class action, financed by litigation funder IMF (Australia), against seven carriers, again including Cathay Pacific Airways, seeking compensation for alleged price fixing on cargo shipments. All seven airlines have filed defences to the action.

Maurice Blackburn principal Brooke Dellavedova said action was taken against the seven carriers even though the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission prosecuted 15 airlines, because “for the most part, they are the carriers with the most significant presence in Australia”.

She said more than 150 businesses had retained Maurice Blackburn to act for them. “We are unable to comment on the size of any overcharge caused by the alleged cartel at this stage,” she said. “However, we expect damages in this matter to be very significant given the large amount of international airfreight to and from Australia.”

Wildlife group warns of runway risks

Hong Kong Standard, Tuesday, July 19, 2011

A third runway may increase carbon emissions by 75 percent when flights connecting the SAR and 14 leading Asia Pacific destinations take off in 22 years, World Wildlife Fund Hong Kong has found.

It urges the Airport Authority to provide more analysis on the impact the third runway would have not only on the Chinese white dolphins but also on the recovery of the marine ecosystem.

“The authority seems able to quantify the potential benefits of the third runway but is strikingly reluctant to inform the public of its true environmental costs,” said Andy Cornish, director of conservation at WWF-Hong Kong.
The projection is based on factors including passenger numbers from published reports of airline trade associations and travel distance between Hong Kong and destinations such as Australia, New Zealand, the Philippines and Japan.William Yu Yuen-ping, head of the group’s climate program, estimates that with the third runway, emissions from flights connecting Chek Lap Kok to 14 destinations may jump 75.7 percent to 18.1 million tonnes in 2030, from 10.3 million tonnes in 2008.

The group also assumed that fuel efficiency will increase by about 20 percent from 2020 with the advancement in technology.

Yu said the emissions could at least double if long-haul flights are also calculated.

Cornish said members met with the authority on Thursday asking for more information on potential environmental impact but the authority declined their request.

WWF will today at the Legislative Council’s panel of economic development demand a halt to the consultation exercise.

A spokesman for the authority said it remains committed to completing the consultation on September 2 as scheduled.

Runway means more noise, poll reveals

South China Morning Post – 18 July 2011

Green group took readings on roofs and found noise levels similar to a busy road

The severe noise pollution caused by aircraft flying throughout the night across north Lantau and the New Territories will get worse if a third runway is built, say concerned residents.

The average noise level of planes passing over Ma Wan, Sham Tseng and Tsuen Wan between 11pm and 3am throughout the week hit about 70 decibels, similar to the level of a busy road, according to a survey conducted by Green Sense last week. The readings were taken on the roofs of residential buildings.

The environmental group claimed the survey was first of its kind carried out by a non-governmental body.

“With the present noise problem unresolved, it is unreasonable to construct a third runway and expand the noise pollution affected area,” said Jan Lai Ming-chuen, vice-president of Green Sense.

As the proposed third runway would be built in Chek Lap Kok north, it was expected that Tsuen Wan and Tuen Mun residents would also have to bear with loud aircraft noise, said Professor Chan King-ming, director of the Chinese University of Hong Kong’s environmental sciences programme. He suggested the government expand existing runways instead.

Residents of Ma Wan complained that aircraft noise had become more severe, disturbing their sleep and forcing them to keep their windows shut most of the time.

“How can you sleep peacefully with noise like a busy road next to you?” said Lam Wai-man, chairman of the owners’ committee of Park Island private housing estate in Ma Wan. He said the noise was loud enough to shake a ceiling.

In 1999, a year after the Hong Kong International Airport started operation, there was only one case of aircraft noise above 80 decibels recorded at night over Ma Wan throughout the year. In 2007, the number of cases had jumped to more than 300, said Lam, citing Civil Aviation Department figures.

Ma Wan was not included in the area affected by aircraft noise “beyond acceptable level”, according to the Airport Authority. However, the assessment was made in 1998.

The Airport Authority said last night it had a noise ceiling for the airport and so far the levels were below that standard. The authority met residents’ representatives in Ma Wan in July and agreed to set up a group to look at ways of further reducing the noise.

How much is Airport Authority spending to promote third runway?

South China Morning Post – 16 July 2011

The Airport Authority is obviously prepared to plough every furrow to disseminate its message that it will be the end of civilisation as we know it if its very costly plan to build a third runway is not given the green light.

We are bombarded from morning to night by adverts, commercials, letters to the media and banners lauding the benefits the project will bring to Hong Kong.

However, as Peter Lok Kung-nam, former head of the Civil Aviation Department, rightly pointed out (“Sky-high marketing for runway plan kept secret”, July 3), this media campaign by the authority is being carried out at a cost of millions of dollars to the public purse.

It is only recently that the airport has begun to make a return on the public money invested in its construction – cynics might question if this is coincidental with a new call for funds – and now revenue is being frittered away on an over-the-top promotion campaign.

Not only will the community forfeit substantial dividend returns, but there are also ethical considerations that need to be explored.

Is it acceptable that a publicly funded body spends considerable sums to promote its plans without allocating at least a percentage of the budget to publicise at the same time intelligent and legitimate views on the negative aspects of its plans?

Misuse of public funds is a very sensitive issue at the moment, as the government tries to ram through its proposed legislation to block resignations from the geographical constituencies in the Legislative Council. Its justification is the HK$150 million spent on the midterm “referendum” election that took place last year.

There are many in the community who believe that marketing campaigns like that for the airport and the MTR Corporation’s blitz for the express rail link are an even greater waste of public funds. The taxpayer has a right to know how much has been spent on these publicity drives.

At the same time, if there is not already such a mechanism in place, then there is an urgent need to ensure that the views of the “minority shareholders” are accorded the same rights to media promotion as those of the board, to ensure that the revenues of statutory bodies engaged in commercial activities are spent in an equitable manner.

Martin Brinkley, Ma Wan

The sky’s the limit

South China Morning Post

Proceeding with the third runway is pointless if nothing is done to increase local airspace capacity

Albert Cheng
Updated on Jul 16, 2011
What lies at the heart of the debate of whether Hong Kong International Airport should build a third runway to keep the city’s position as an international aviation hub is not hardware capacity or airspace boundary; but the airport’s ability to increase aircraft movements.

First and foremost, we must boost our capacity to handle more landings and take-offs to cope with increasing air traffic. Failing to do so would mean falling behind our neighbouring rivals.

In theory, having an extra runway should put the city ahead of other airports and enhance its competitive edge. The runway’s current estimated price tag of HK$136.2 billion, while high, is certainly within Hong Kong’s means. But we should not go ahead with the project unless we are absolutely sure that it is worthwhile.

We are racing against time to meet rapidly rising air traffic demand. Even if we could get the green light to start building the new runway tomorrow, the project would take between eight and 10 years to complete. By then we could be confronted with a new set of problems.

Our priority is airspace capacity. With the nearby Shenzhen airport expanding so rapidly, it is very likely that our airspace capacity will be pushed to the limit in the near future. So, if we do not resolve this issue quickly, we risk being marginalised. In short, having all the additional hardware in place 10 years from now will be pointless if we no longer have the airspace available to match the expansion.

Rapid development in the Pearl River Delta over the past decade has seen growth in its gross domestic product exceed or approach 10 per cent every year, according to mainland statistics.

The International Air Transport Association has found a correlation between GDP growth and an increase in air traffic. With GDP forecast to continue growing in the coming years, passenger traffic is also likely to rise. This means there will be tough competition for airspace in the region.

Hence, it is critically important that our airport takes action to boost its capacity to handle more aircraft movements. On average, Shenzhen airport’s single runway, one of the world’s busiest, handles more than 500 flights per day while Hong Kong’s average is more than 800.

However, we have to bear in mind that a substantial portion of our air traffic goes through the mainland, which means we don’t really have the upper hand when it comes to competing for the allocation of more airspace.

In other words, if we want to get more airspace, we must first make sure we have the additional capacity to fill up the extra quota.

First, we need to maximise our dual-runway system. Instead of permitting one runway for landings and one for departures, we should lift the restriction to optimise usage. Had we applied a bit of flexibility, we could have easily raised aircraft movements to 1,200 per day.

Our capacity crisis is a man-made one more than anything else. A third runway will not solve the problem in the long run if we fail to effectively manage and maximise our resources.

Could city still fly without runway 3?

South China Morning Post — 11 July 2011

Controversial plan for a third runway has attracted massive support from business and the aviation sector, but others question the social and environmental costs

Is the HK$136.2 billion third runway project our only choice to remain competitive?

The barrage of information in the three weeks since the proposal’s release would make you think so.

The Airport Authority has argued that the investment would bring a huge return: an economic benefit of HK$912 billion over 50 years.

Stakeholders from the tourism, aviation, logistics, hotel and retail sectors have all echoed their support for what would be the city’s most expensive works yet.

But every time there is a public debate on the need of a new piece of infrastructure, the economic benefits are touted first, with officials pledging to mitigate the social and environmental costs. It takes longer for the project’s impact on public health, air quality, water, marine life and natural habitats to emerge.

When the secretary of state for transport of the United Kingdom voiced his support back in 2009 for the building of a third runway at London’s Heathrow Airport, it was estimated that the improvement would provide a net benefit of £5.5 billion (HK$68.7 billion).

However, a group called the New Economics Foundation found that if the costs of noise, air quality, surface congestion and community blight were taken into account, the project’s costs could outweigh its benefits by at least £5 billion.

In a world-class city as fast and efficient as Hong Kong, it may seem like there is no reason big enough to stand in the way of growth. But while the damage to our environment may not have quite reached breaking point yet, we are no longer the up-and-coming economy we were three decades ago, when development ruled above everything else.

For those who find Mong Kok and Causeway Bay suffocating and the city’s traffic intolerable, this project may offer exactly the right opportunity to contemplate how much more of our standard of living and natural resources we are willing to sacrifice in exchange for a boost to the city’s economy.

Officials have never clearly explained how many years of growth the third runway will bring.

But a careful look at figures provided by the Airport Authority shows that the runway – with an annual capacity of 620,000 flight movements – could handle growth only until 2031 before the airport would be saturated again. That assumes annual growth of 3.2 per cent in traffic demand, said to be a prudent projection.

Is it value for taxpayers to spend HK$136.2 billion, plus other unquantified costs in worsened air quality, traffic and the permanent loss of 650 hectares of marine habitat, for a runway that could become saturated eight years after it opens?

Here are some of the factors that have not received much public discussion yet.

How important is an airport to the economy of a city?

No one disputes the aviation sector’s importance to Hong Kong. But it would be an overstatement to suggest Hong Kong’s economy would fall into the abyss if the airport failed to expand.

While accessibility is crucial for a city’s economy, air traffic is not the only means of facilitating the flows of goods and people.

Macau, for example, has only a tiny airport serving some 4 million passengers a year – less than one-tenth of Hong Kong’s traffic – but its gaming and tourism sector has prospered throughout the years.

An enclave with just a fraction of the land area of Hong Kong’s Lantau island, Macau entertained nearly 25 million tourists last year, compared to 36 million for Hong Kong.

“People fly to a city, not to its airport,” an industry insider said. “A corporation does not decide where to list its shares because the place has a nice big airport.”

Could Hong Kong make better use of nearby airports on the mainland?

Chek Lap Kok need not be the only airport that serves Hong Kong.

The Airport Authority and Cathay Pacific have repeatedly rejected suggestions that we should use the capacity of neighbouring airports, such as Shenzhen Baoan and Zhuhai . They said co-operation between airports “simply never works” because passengers hate switching between them.

Besides, the argument goes, funnelling passengers to other airports would deny Hong Kong the economic benefits of keeping them here.

But advocates for regional co-operation say this is tunnel vision.

“Forget about the money you could have made by selling a bowl of fish-ball noodles – as long as traffic keeps flowing, it does not matter which airport they land in,” a business leader familiar with the industry said. “The whole region’s economy will benefit.”

And the advocates are not really talking about funnelling passengers from airport to airport. They see Shenzhen simply as a second airport for Hong Kong – like Gatwick Airport is for London.

Shenzhen Baoan airport just opened its second runway and will add a third in time. It takes more than an hour now to get there from Hong Kong by metro or cross-border coach, and flights suffer frequent delays due to congested airspace.

But civil aviation officials are struggling to free up more sky for commercial flights in light of an acute growth in air traffic demand, and there are plans for a rail link that could link Chek Lap Kok and Shenzhen Baoan in 20 minutes, with a stop possibly in Hung Shui Kiu, Yuen Long.

“Shenzhen airport is just 30 kilometres away from us, why don’t we make better use of it?” asked Peter Lok Kung-nam, former commissioner of civil aviation. “They have space to expand, not us. Besides, with five airports co-existing in the congested airspace within a radius of 150 kilometres, it is difficult to see how any of them can utilise its capacity well.”

For years, the Airport Authority engaged in talks with mainland authorities over closer co-operation for the five airports in the Pearl River Delta: Guangzhou, Hong Kong, Shenzhen, Zhuhai and Macau. The idea was to consolidate the airports’ interests and assign Hong Kong to manage it all, but the Hong Kong government apparently didn’t like the idea.

“Hong Kong thinks it could excel on its own, but the truth is we have this natural limitation in land and resources,” the business source said. “Today they may be slow and inefficient, but you can’t count on their flaws forever, when they become just as efficient as us, why should a mainlander shun the airport in his backyard and come all this way to Hong Kong to bridge a flight?”

Hong Kong now processes 80 per cent of air passengers and 90 per cent of cargo originating from the Pearl River Delta. But most future growth will be from the mainland, according to projections by the aviation sector.

Even supporters of the third runway say it could take the mainland less than a decade to catch up.

“It may have taken us many years to build our critical mass,” a former aviation official said. “But the mainland airlines do not have to wait before they gather sufficient cargo and passengers to launch a route. They have the backing of the government.”

The rise of the mainland in terms of infrastructure and labour skills has driven both Hong Kong’s manufacturing industry and port cargo businesses to the north during the past three decades.

Hong Kong argues aviation is different because it competes more on service quality than costs. But costs still make an impact somewhere, as can be seen by the many budget flyers who have shifted to Shenzhen over the years.

“Decades ago, the shipping industry also cited economic reasons to persuade the government to build a tenth container terminal. They didn’t succeed, and the sector is shrinking. But is it because they failed to get that terminal? Or was it a losing game anyway?” the official asked.

Even without the third runway, Chek Lap Kok will be able to handle 74 million passengers and 6 million tonnes of cargo when already-planned expansions are completed – exceeding Heathrow, which served a total of 65 million passengers last year.

With a third runway, Hong Kong would be able to handle 97 million passengers – more than Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, the world’s busiest since 1999, handling an annual average of just below 90 million passengers in the past five years. It has five runways.

Will a saturated airport maintain its global connectivity?

Officials say that when an airport is saturated, its global connectivity doesn’t remain at the same level. It slowly deteriorates. That’s because airlines, squeezed with fewer flight slots, tend to replace the less profitable destinations with more flights to profitable ones.

At Heathrow, the number of destinations fell from a peak of 220 during the 1990s to 186 nowadays. But a better deployment of flight slots has enabled the London airport to top the world in international passengers captured.

If an airport reaches capacity, some connecting flights may be replaced by direct flights that serve mainly local residents and those for whom the airport is their final destination.

Direct-flight passengers are said to bring four times the level of economic benefit of transfer and transit passengers – who only stop by in Hong Kong for a few short hours before boarding another flight to their intended destinations.

In the past five years, transfer and transit passengers made up about one-third of all passengers at Chek Lap Kok; during the Kai Tak era, that proportion was once as low as 10 per cent. Because travel demand by local residents has largely matured, the momentum for future growth is expected to come from mainland visitors – many of them using the Chek Lap Kok airport for overseas flights – further boosting the proportion of transit and transfer passengers at the Hong Kong airport.

“There is only so much growth you can expect from local residents,” the business leader said. “The bankers in Central are already travelling two to three times a week, if they travel any more their wives will divorce them. Shall we spend all this money to build a runway that serves primarily the less profitable transit and transfer passengers?”

He added: “It is funny that when we suggested sending the passengers to Shenzhen Airport, officials said it would not work because it was inconvenient for passengers. However, it was not so inconvenient when they asked mainland passengers to come to Hong Kong for transit.”

A full-capacity airport actually has some benefits for airline companies, as they are forced to make more efficient use of their aircraft in loading and yield.

“Sometimes an airline opened a route just to keep a favourable time slot or expand its network. The economic value of that destination, however, could be marginal,” Lok said. “The aircraft may only be half full or even less at off-peak seasons, wasting resources and [being] not so environmentally friendly.”

Runway supporters say that transit passengers do help boost traffic volume.

And airports in major cities like Singapore and Dubai compete to act as hubs for their regions.

Stanley Hui Hon-chung, the Airport Authority’s chief executive, has warned that passengers may shoulder higher air fares and suffer a worse service if a saturated airport suffers the stress of constant overcrowding.

More flights may be delayed and more bags may go missing, as they do at Heathrow.

On the other hand, if the HK$136.2 billion third runway is given the go-ahead, passengers may be charged more under the user-pay principle.

Is expansion really the key to boosting air traffic levels?

There may be as many arguments for as against the runway proposal – but even without an airport expansion, there are ways to increase Hong Kong’s air traffic.

A recently published study from the European Commission said Europe’s busiest airports could boost their capacity by 28 million passengers every year just by improving the allocation of take-off and landing slots. Another possibility would involve opening up more of the airspace controlled by the mainland.

Although this is largely a decision for the mainland’s military authorities, the Civil Aviation Department in Hong Kong could continue to develop new air traffic control arrangements with its counterparts in Macau and the mainland.

After the latest update of air traffic control handling, the two runways at Chek Lap Kok can handle up to 68 movements an hour, well behind the 80 movements an hour London Heathrow can handle with the same number of runways.

Geographical constraints – the presence of two hills to the south of the runway – go some way to explaining that discrepancy – but there are hopes that improvements in technology will allow the city to offer more flights per hour and further narrow the gap.

Fourth runway may be needed

South China Morning Post – 6 July 2011

Airport Authority figures indicate that proposed third runway may reach full capacity as early as 2029, just six years after coming into service

The HK$136.2 billion it would cost to build a third runway at Chek Lap Kok may only buy six to eight years of growth in traffic for the airport before it is saturated again, according to Airport Authority figures.

In three public forums – the last of which took place on Saturday – to lobby support for the project, officials said the multibillion-dollar investment would cater for the airport’s needs until 2030 and beyond, but did not say how far beyond.

A careful look at the figures provided in the Airport Master Plan 2030 – a blueprint outlining the airport’s development for the next two decades – shows that even using the authority’s “prudent” projection of an average annual growth in air traffic of 3.2 per cent, the runway will be full by 2031. Taking the more “aggressive” prediction of 3.6 per cent, the runway would reach capacity as early as 2029, six years after its opening in 2023. This does not take into account any delay the project may encounter during a construction over 11 years.

“The Airport Authority should tell the public if the third runway can only meet growth for a few years,” said Emily Lau Wai-hing, chairwoman of the Legislative Council finance committee that will determine if the project receives public funding. “Do we need a fourth runway? We should listen to all opinions.”

Hong Kong Dolphin Conservation Society chairman Samuel Hung Ka-yiu said there was simply no more space for a fourth runway.

“It is ridiculous that such a costly project could just meet a few years of growth,” he said. “The third runway is just 1 kilometre from a marine park in Lung Kwu Chau. If they built a fourth runway, the park would have to be removed. How many natural resources can we afford to lose in this expensive game chasing economic growth?”

The third runway would boost the airport’s handling capacity from 68 flights an hour to 102, which translates into 620,000 movements a year. According to the authority’s forecast, air traffic demand will reach 602,000 movements by 2030 based on annual growth of 3.2 per cent. If the growth continues for just another year, aircraft movements will reach 621,264 – already exceeding the capacity of a three-runway system by 1,264 flights.

Under the more robust prediction of 3.6 per cent growth each year the number of aircraft movements will exceed 600,000 by 2028, and over 620,000 by 2029 – one year before the end of a period where growth demand was said to be sustainable.

In fact, the third runway is likely to be saturated even earlier than that.

In the 20 years to 2010, the annual average growth for passenger throughput, cargo throughput and aircraft movements were, respectively, 4.8 per cent, 8.5 per cent and 5.5 per cent – all higher than the rate adopted by the authority in forecasting air traffic for the next 20 years to 2030. Besides, officials appeared to have used a lower base when plotting the growth curve; while aircraft movements reached 316,000 last year, the dot reflecting the number of flights for 2010 was put below the line of 300,000.

An Airport Authority spokesperson said last night that with future air navigation technology and improvements in air traffic management, runway capacity could potentially be stretched further.

“This may increase by about 10 per cent in future if there are enhancements in aircraft or air traffic control or the Pearl River Delta airspace structurer.”

It earlier said Hong Kong will lose more than 100 million passengers and 15 million tonnes of air cargo in the 10 years to 2030 without the third runway. Officials have said they will review the need of a fourth runway in due course.

http://www.scmp.com/files/SCMP/News/Static%20Files/SCM_News_runway06.IMG.jpg

Emissions from aircraft will grow

The 2 per cent aviation emissions figure Cathay Pacific  Mark Watson cites (“Aviation industry is committed to addressing climate change impact”, June 20) in response to my letter (“Emissions accelerating, not declining”, June 13) differ from the 3-3.5 per cent cited by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) website.

The ICAO’s projected aircraft emissions growth of 3-4 per cent per year contrasts with Mr Watson’s planned halving of emissions by 2050. In 38 years, a 3.5 per cent exponential growth will quadruple, not halve, current emissions: 628 million tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) annually will become 2,512 million tonnes. Because aircraft engines release CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulates into the stratosphere, their impact is amplified. Current contrail-generated cirrus clouds insulate the atmosphere adding an independent warming effect greater than all previous aircraft CO2/NOX emissions since we began flying. Also, the 70 per cent of improvement in aircraft fuel efficiency has already been achieved. To “radically reduce” that remaining 30 per cent of emissions is technically increasingly difficult.

Any future efficiency improvements are offset by the doubling of flights projected by the Airport Authority (advert in this paper on June 21). I quote: “HK’s GDP forecast at compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 3.4 per cent” (GDP doubles in 20 years); “Mainland’s CAGR at 7 per cent” (an unrealistic quadruple GDP increase over 38 years); “Air traffic demand doubling by 2030”, coincidentally, a 3.5 per cent annualised growth in demand. Where is this growth to come from? Cheap extractable oil, without which these growth projections are unfeasible, is almost exhausted.

If the authority’s growth projections are correct, aircraft emissions will rise exponentially, making climate change a major problem – or peak oil will terminate the 20th century infinite-economic-growth/business-as-usual model, making flying prohibitively expensive, thereby killing demand. Thus, a third runway either adds to climate change or is redundant.

Richard Fielding, Pok Fu Lam

Letters to Editor SCMP

Airport Authority Hong Kong – Online Survey

Airport Authority Hong Kong (AAHK) is consulting the public on the Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA) Master Plan 2030 (MP2030), which outlines the strategic direction of the future development of HKIA, that is, maintaining the existing two-runway system or expanding into a three-runway system, and has commissioned the Social Sciences Research Centre (SSRC) of the University of Hong Kong to independently collect and compile public views. Your opinion is very important and valuable for this consultation. It will only take a few minutes to complete this questionnaire and all information collected will be kept strictly confidential and for collective analysis only. If you have any queries on this survey, you can contact the SSRC at 3921 2600 between 9 am and 6 pm from Monday to Friday.*

http://www.hkairport2030.com/en/listen/comments.html

MasterPlan 2030 :

http://www.hkairport2030.com/en/

http://www.hkairport2030.com/en/environment/index.html

OPTION 1 :

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y163/Caelusxxx/Tworunwayoptionlayout_Eng.jpg

OPTION  2 :

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y163/Caelusxxx/Threerunwayoptionlayout_Eng.jpg

Runways required

http://www.economist.com/node/18744513/print

Private investors can make airports bigger, but not big enough

WITH their crowds, delays and “retail opportunities”, airports

impart feelings that range from irritation to despair. The experience
is likely to get worse. Over the next 20 years the number of jets circling
the planet is set to double, but investment in airports probably
won’t. In Europe twice as many passengers are expected to
squeeze through 41% more capacity.
One reason why airports are grim is that many are state-owned. Of the world’s 30 busiest ones,
19 are state-owned and most of the rest are public-private
partnerships. In the past they were “administered rather than managed” to serve state-owned
airlines, says Andreas Schimm of Airports Council International (ACI), an umbrella body.
Governments now try to run airports on commercial lines, but few do it well. Privatisation could
help.
Incheon and Cheongju airports in South Korea are likely to seek private investors soon. So are
Munich, Moscow’s two smaller airports, France’s regional airports and a host of others. Even in
America, where complicated federal rules discourage either selling or buying airports, a scheme
to privatise Chicago Midway and four other airports is picking up speed again. In Brazil, however,
an effort to woo private cash to spruce up shabby airports before the football World Cup is
stalling.
An airport ought to be a sound investment. BAA, which runs Britain’s biggest airports, has coined
it. Eyebrows were raised when Macquarie, an Australian bank, bought Sydney airport in 2002.
But it quickly boosted revenues and profits. The “release value” of taking public assets private
can be enormous, says Peter Morris of Ascend, a consultancy.
Investors could now be more wary, however. Empty public coffers might encourage governments
to demand too high a price. The liberalisation of air travel has increased competition between big
hubs, especially in Europe and the Gulf. And the soaring growth of low-cost airlines has added to
the pressure. Budget carriers are far more flexible and ruthless than their full-fare competitors. If
business sags or landing fees rise, they will drop an airport as surely as a baggage-handler will
drop a bag marked “fragile”.
Privatisation can improve efficiency and service quality. But passengers may face other torments.
Airports earn just 18% of their revenues from airlines, according to ACI. The rest comes from
passenger fees, parking charges, rent from retailers and so on. Rather than squeezing airlines,
which can fly away, it is more tempting to go after passengers, who are hemmed in by metal
detectors and armed police.
Airlines grouch that landing fees always rise at privatised airports. Giovanni Bisignani, the boss of
IATA, a group that represents airlines, argues that the best airports are those with good
managers and tough regulators, and that ownership matters less. But regulations will surely have
to weaken to attract private money.
By some estimates $1 trillion of new investment will be needed over the next two decades to
match airport capacity to flight plans. Yet there are barely a dozen airport groups that might be
tempted to bid for the terminals and runways on the block. They are unlikely to raise enough
cash to keep pace with the rising volume of passengers. The queues will only grow longer.

WITH their crowds, delays and“retail opportunities”, airportsimpart feelings that range fromirritation to despair. The experienceis likely to get worse. Over the next20 years the number of jets circlingthe planet is set to double, butinvestment in airports probablywon’t. In Europe twice as manypassengers are expected tosqueeze through 41% morecapacity.One reason why airports are grimis that many are state-owned. Ofthe world’s 30 busiest ones, 19 are state-owned and most of the rest are public-privatepartnerships. In the past they were “administered rather than managed” to serve state-ownedairlines, says Andreas Schimm of Airports Council International (ACI), an umbrella body.Governments now try to run airports on commercial lines, but few do it well. Privatisation couldhelp.Incheon and Cheongju airports in South Korea are likely to seek private investors soon. So areMunich, Moscow’s two smaller airports, France’s regional airports and a host of others. Even inAmerica, where complicated federal rules discourage either selling or buying airports, a schemeto privatise Chicago Midway and four other airports is picking up speed again. In Brazil, however,an effort to woo private cash to spruce up shabby airports before the football World Cup isstalling.An airport ought to be a sound investment. BAA, which runs Britain’s biggest airports, has coinedit. Eyebrows were raised when Macquarie, an Australian bank, bought Sydney airport in 2002.But it quickly boosted revenues and profits. The “release value” of taking public assets privatecan be enormous, says Peter Morris of Ascend, a consultancy.Investors could now be more wary, however. Empty public coffers might encourage governmentsto demand too high a price. The liberalisation of air travel has increased competition between bighubs, especially in Europe and the Gulf. And the soaring growth of low-cost airlines has added tothe pressure. Budget carriers are far more flexible and ruthless than their full-fare competitors. If0Airport privatisation: Runways required | The Economist Page 1 of 2http://www.economist.com/node/18744513/print 04-Jul-11About The Economist online About The Economist Media directory Staff books Career opportunities Contact us Subscribe [+] Site feedbackCopyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2011. All rights reserved. Advertising info Legal disclaimer Accessibility Privacy policy Terms of use Helpfrom the print edition | Businessbusiness sags or landing fees rise, they will drop an airport as surely as a baggage-handler willdrop a bag marked “fragile”.Privatisation can improve efficiency and service quality. But passengers may face other torments.Airports earn just 18% of their revenues from airlines, according to ACI. The rest comes frompassenger fees, parking charges, rent from retailers and so on. Rather than squeezing airlines,which can fly away, it is more tempting to go after passengers, who are hemmed in by metaldetectors and armed police.Airlines grouch that landing fees always rise at privatised airports. Giovanni Bisignani, the boss ofIATA, a group that represents airlines, argues that the best airports are those with goodmanagers and tough regulators, and that ownership matters less. But regulations will surely haveto weaken to attract private money.By some estimates $1 trillion of new investment will be needed over the next two decades tomatch airport capacity to flight plans. Yet there are barely a dozen airport groups that might betempted to bid for the terminals and runways on the block. They are unlikely to raise enoughcash to keep pace with the rising volume of passengers. The queues will only grow longer.