Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

Bridge promoters accused of taking wrong approach

Hong Kong Standard – 1 Sept. 2011

Environmental permits for key elements of the proposed Hong Kong-Zhuhai- Macau bridge would not have been granted, it is argued, if its government promoters had used the usual and traditional approach to forecast air quality.

This is a main finding of think-tank Civic Exchange concerning the controversial judicial review of the project.

The Court of Appeal has yet to set a date for delivering a verdict on a government appeal against a lower court ruling that quashed the environmental permits for two elements of the project.

Environmental lawyer David Renton, who authored a paper on the issue for the group, said the usual baseline is a five-year average of the most recent monitored air quality data available at the time of an assessment.

But the proponent of the bridge project, the Highways Department, used a computer model called PATH – for Pollutants in the Atmosphere and their Transport over Hong Kong – to predict background air quality instead of using monitored data to set the baseline.

Renton said impact-assessment reports on the project show the five-year average of the most recent data for the pollutants nitrogen dioxide and respirable suspended particulate around Tung Chung already near air quality objectives – AQOs, or limits Hong Kong has set.

Bridge-linked projects are boundary- crossing facilities on reclaimed land off Chek Lap Kok and a link road.

Had these figures been used as the baseline for the assessment, Renton said, the bridge’s cumulative impact would have caused air quality to exceed the objectives after the extra pollution produced by the projects and other sources were taken into account.

The director of environmental protection “could not have granted the projects an environmental permit in the face of an EIA report showing air quality would exceed the AQOs,” Renton said.

Civic Exchange head of environmental strategy Mike Kilburn added: “We don’t know what is in the [PATH] model and what data is used to run [it].”

The model was developed by the Environmental Protection Department as a tool for predicting the impact of various emissions reduction strategies being pursued by Hong Kong and Guangdong authorities on air quality in the SAR.

The Court of First Instance in April ruled for Tung Chung resident Chu Yee- wah, 65, who filed for a judicial review saying assessments were not done properly and the director’s decisions to grant permits should be quashed.

Greens aim to land further runway talks

Samson Lee

Thursday, September 01, 2011

Green groups strongly opposed to a third runway have urged the Airport Authority to hold a second round of consultations.

Previously, the activists had been insisting the authority suspend a three- month consultation exercise, which is scheduled to end tomorrow.

The authority met yesterday with a coalition of environmental groups in Central.

After a 3 hour closed-door meeting in the morning, the coalition told reporters they were sticking by their position not to support the third runway option until their demand for social impact assessments is met.

“We hope there is a second round of consultations,” said Chan May-ling, chief executive for Friends of the Earth Hong Kong, and spokeswoman for the green groups.

Chan said groups were disappointed that authority chief executive Stanley Hui Hon-chung did not show up as promised, sending only his deputy – executive director of airport operations Howard Eng Kiu-chor – to represent him.

“I was disappointed that Hui did not come to meet us. I expected to see him,” Green Sense president Roy Tam Hoi- pong said.

During the meeting, the coalition of 10 green groups, including the WWF, Greenpeace, and Conservation Association, demanded the authority conduct an impact assessment on social costs, including public health, before they pursue further discussions.

“Currently, it is hard for the public and us to decide based on the consultation paper because there is no information about the social costs we will face through the third runway proposal,” Greeners Action executive director Angus Ho Hon-wai said.

The green groups warned they may escalate their opposition if the authority does not look favorably on their demands within a month.

An Airport Authority spokeswoman said this is the third round-table briefing with the green groups, all chaired by Eng.

“Hui attended the previous briefings as a bystander,” she said, adding he was engaged in other matters yesterday

機場擴建諮詢 環保團體「唔收貨」

31 August 2011

(2011/8/31新聞稿) 本港10個環保團體發表聯合聲明,指香港機場管理局擴建機場的諮詢粗疏,諮詢文件低估了環境影響的嚴重性,甚至與機管局的顧問報告毫不相干,容易誤導公眾,因此環團對這個諮詢「唔收貨」。團體要求機管局先提供整全的環境、社會和經濟的影響及成本代價,讓公眾掌握客觀的資料,再展開真正的公眾諮詢。

機管局行政總裁許漢忠原答允與環團會晤,今早卻「縮沙」爽約,改由機管局機場運行執行總監伍翹楚出席。環團要求局方須先完成及公開以下有關社會及環境代價的研究或資料,再進行另一輪公眾諮詢。

環團要求機管局在一個月內作出進行以上研究的承諾,並警告局方不可「偷雞」匆匆忙忙開展「環境影響評估」程序工作。環團警告,「倘機管局迴避環團的要求,我們會聯署要求機管局內的三名政府代表 (運輸及房屋局局長鄭汝樺、財經事務及庫務局局長陳家強、民航處處長羅崇文)和五名立法會議員 (何俊仁、何鍾泰、林健鋒、劉健儀及陳鑑林),站在捍衛公眾健康、環境質素及社會代價的立場,要求暫緩為該規劃大綱作出決定。」

聯署環團:世界自然基金會 (香港分會)、長春社、香港海豚保育學會、香港地球之友、綠領行動、綠色和平、環保觸覺、綠色力量、健康空氣行動、爭氣行動。

我們要求機管局至少進行的研究如下:

  • Ø 開放空域可行性及對航班升降影響之研究
  • Ø 香港機場未來50年之長遠發展規劃及擴建方案研究
  • Ø 要求訂出「還(生態補償)舊債」時間表 (機管局興建新機場時,承諾多項包括興建濕地等補償計劃,但當年答允的許多措施,至今仍未兌現)

氣候變化

  • Ø 研究及提供擴建計劃的碳排放數據,當中務須包括飛機的排放資料,還有因擴建而引致陸上及海上客貨運運輸的溫室氣體排放數據;
  • Ø 研究低排放航班的安排
  • Ø 承諾三年內實行機場島內地勤運輸電氣化

保護白海豚

  • Ø 限制高速船航線遠離白海豚棲息地可行性研究
  • Ø 白海豚來往重要棲息地移動路線之研究
  • Ø 研究香港西部水域基建發展對白海豚的累計影響

空氣質素

  • Ø 開展東涌列作低排放區之可行性研究
  • Ø 研究及公開因新增航班引致的海陸客貨運的空氣污染物排放數據
  • Ø 研究及公開北大嶼山基建對區內及南屯門的累計空氣質素影響 (基建項目,除港珠澳大橋,還應包攬東涌新市鎮的擴建計劃)
  • Ø 公佈為達更新後空氣質素指標而要削減的具體航班數字

環保團體重申並非反對香港的經濟發展,但強調機場擴建計劃的規模龐大,對社會及環境生態可造成不可彌補的害,基於可持續發展的考量,我們認為機管局更應提供更完整的訊息,讓公眾可以作出理性討論及判斷。

Keep vows, group tells Airport Authority

South China Morning Post – 31 August 2011

Green measures over building of Chek Lap Kok not good enough, says association

The Airport Authority has been told to make good on the environmental pledges it made when building the airport at Chek Lap Kok before asking the public to accept another huge project for a third runway.

The authority should “honour its cheques first before asking for more”, the Conservancy Association said, accusing the airport operator of not delivering satisfactorily the compensation it had promised for ecological losses during the original construction.

It said this failure underlined the need for the authority to disclose at earlier stage what compensation measures it planned to introduce if the third runway plan, involving 600 hectares of reclamation in key dolphin habitats, went ahead.

“They have to clearly demonstrate to the public that to what extent their measures could really protect the environment,” senior campaign officer Roy Ng Hei-man said.

Ng said the authority might consider starting the mitigation work even before construction on the HK$136.2 billion runway began.

Three days before the consultation on the project is due to end, the association said that in digging through the environmental impact assessment reports for the airport, produced in the 1990s, it had identified at least three pledges designed to compensate for the loss of Chek Lap Kok island, flattened for the airport.

It said checks on the sites showed none had been completed satisfactorily. In one, a waterfront site at Tai O where the authority had pledged to replant 11 hectares of mangrove for the loss of seven hectares on the island and in north Lantau, it found an estimated five hectares with one key species, common on the levelled island, growing poorly.

East of the Tung Chung new town where the authority promised to replant trees to compensate for removal of a 20-hectare secondary forest that was home to more than 101 bird species, the group found there were two dominant tree species, neither of which bore the right fruit to attract birds.

Parts of the site were just shrubs and weeds.

The association also said that to compensate for loss of a freshwater wetland, 16 other sites of similar characteristics were to have been included in country parks or designated as sites of special scientific interest. But so far, only one, in Sha Lo Tung, has been listed.

The Airport Authority said it had fulfilled its commitments to mangroves, secondary woodland and freshwater wetlands.

The Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department said designation of the 16 reserve sites were not pledges in relation to the airport development.

Ten groups will hold a joint press conference today to state their demands to the Airport Authority.

chifai.cheung@scmp.com

Airport talks near final approach

Hong Kong Standard – 30 August 2011

Science is fully in play as planners look at ways to lessen the impact on the environment of a third runway at Chek Lap Kok, a senior executive of the Airport Authority argued as he tried to take the heat out of opposition to the project.

“Development and environment are not mutually exclusive,” said executive director of airport operations Howard Eng Kiu-chor as he pointed to more impact studies and mitigation measures once people are convinced of a need for a third runway.

But green groups and some political parties continue to push the authority to extend the consultation, which ends on Friday after three months.

They were at a third runway forum and workshop organized by WWF Hong Kong in Wan Chai yesterday, with Eng claiming the authority has taken the environment into consideration in its proposed master plan.

For instance, Eng said, there would be no marine piling in order not to upset Chinese white dolphins.

But green groups remain unconvinced.

The WWF Hong Kong’s climate program head, William Yu Yuen-ping, said his group supports airport improvements but the authority has failed to provide a full picture of the environmental cost if a third runway is to be constructed.

And seeking more consultation on two choices – extending present facilities or a third runaway – Democratic Party lawmaker Emily Lau Wai- hing told Eng: “I don’t think, based on what you’ve done in these few months, that you should come to a conclusion that option two should be adopted.”

More “engagement and consultation” is needed, she added, and “if you try to come out and announce that option two is accepted, I think there will be a big uproar in the community.”

Law Cheung-kwok of the Aviation Policy and Research Centre at the Chinese University of Hong Kong backs a third runway option.

“Time is running out,” he said. “It is urgent and vital to construct the third runway to sustain our position as an international aviation hub.”

Separately, the Staff and Workers Union of Hong Kong Civil Airlines is also backing a third runway after a poll of 511 aviation industry workers earlier this month. Eighty percent support it.

At least one more public event is due this week.

Extended debate on runway ruled out

South China Morning Post – 30 August 2011

Pan-democrats want more time to study details, and economist questions benefits

The Airport Authority will not extend the consultation period for its proposal to build a HK$136.2 billion third runway at Hong Kong International Airport, which is set to end on Friday, despite appeals by lawmakers and an allegation that the economic benefits of the project have been grossly overestimated.

The pan-democrat camp has called for more time to digest the 2,000 pages of technical studies, saying that these reports were released only on August 8.

“All I ask for is two more months to study it before the authority reaches the conclusion that everyone is behind the proposal,” Tanya Chan of the Civil Party said.

But authority executive director Howard Eng said the consultation was only the first step and more detailed studies would be needed once a consensus was reached on whether the runway was actually needed.

Officials say the runway will bring an economic benefit of HK$912 billion over 50 years – seven times the cost. But an economist with a London-based institute that helped overturn the case for a third runway at Heathrow airport in 2009 said the actual benefit could be much lower.

“In the economic case for the third runway expansion there is a serious lack of sensitivity testing to account for future shocks in core factors like oil prices and economic growth forecasts,” David Thesis, a researcher at the New Economic Foundation, said. “Such assumptions in the consultation reports appear to be overly optimistic.”

Speaking at a forum organised by the green group World Wide Fund for Nature yesterday, Thesis said that, for example, the authority had used oil prices for 2009 – when crude was just US$53.5 per barrel – for its calculations. This was not only almost 40 per cent lower than current price at US$85.75 per barrel, but was also 50 per cent lower than the one-year peak at US$114.18 per barrel.

The benefits would shrink further if a price tag was put on the social and environmental costs, including an increase in fine-particle pollution, mainly in Tung Chung, that could increase mortality rates by nearly 13 per cent, Thesis said.

The UK government predicted a third runway at Heathrow could bring in a net £5.5 billion (HK$63.8 billion) in economic benefits after deductions for a £13.6 billion cost in worsening air, noise level and aggravated carbon emissions. The foundation predicts a loss of £4 billion.

We can help, say dolphin defenders

Hong Kong Standard

A conservation group wants the Airport Authority to take more notice of green groups that may help minimize the environmental impact of a third runway.

Samson Lee

Monday, August 22, 2011

A conservation group wants the Airport Authority to take more notice of green groups that may help minimize the environmental impact of a third runway.

Hong Kong Dolphin Conservation Society chairman Samuel Hung Ka-yiu said a balance may be struck between infrastructure development and environmental protection.

“It is about give and take,” Hung said. “If we take something from the environment, we need to give something back to the environment.”

However, consultancy reports released on August 8 by the authority still do not address concerns over the environmental threat, particularly to Chinese white dolphins

Hung said the studies provide information about the impact on air quality, but fail to tell the public how the dolphins will be affected and what mitigation measures the authority will take to protect the endangered creatures.

Calling on the authority to reveal the full environmental impact, he said “if there are serious problems, we can discuss together to find a solution.”

Hung hopes there will be more positive developments and talks with the authority before the end of consultation next month.

“Some people think we are radical and make some unreasonable requests. Actually, we are rational and for the good of Hong Kong.”

He said green groups tend to be placed in a position against the authority because it always mentions economic benefits instead of environmental costs.

“We are forced to oppose them because they do not consider the environmental impact seriously.”

Hung said there are about 200 Chinese white dolphins using Hong Kong waters and they are facing threats such as overfishing, water pollution and high-speed ferries.

He said the proposed reclamation area for the third runway is at the center of three core locations frequented by the dolphins – Lung Kwu Chau, the Brothers Islands and Tai O to Fan Lau waters.

Airport Authority Hong Kong issues eagerly awaited tender for core category concessions

http://www.moodiereport.com/document.php?c_id=6&doc_id=28292

HONG KONG. Airport Authority Hong Kong (AAHK) will this week issue tenders for its core category duty free concessions at Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA), setting in motion what may be the most hotly contested bids in industry history. [UPDATED STORY – The tenders were formally issued this afternoon (Monday, 15 August) Hong Kong time..]

On offer are the highly valued Liquor & Tobacco concession currently operated by Sky Connection, and the Perfumes & Cosmetics and Airside General Merchandise concessions, held by Nuance-Watson (HK). The bid deadline is 28 October.

The Moodie Report estimates liquor and tobacco sales last year at HKIA to have reached around US$200 million, with perfumes & cosmetics a little higher at about US$225 million.

But what really makes the contracts so attractive is HKIA’s passenger mix. AAHK noted that over 70% of its passenger base stems from Asia. Critically, 27% are from Mainland China, a booming market that has become an increasingly vital driver of the sector’s growth in recent years, particularly at HKIA.

Other high-spending nationalities are also to the fore: Taiwan accounts for 18%, South and Southeast Asia for 15%, Japan 7% and South Korea 5%. Such a mix amounts to a retailer’s dream.

The Liquor & Tobacco duty free licence, currently operated by Sky Connection, comprises 15 units across Departures and Arrivals. The space on offer covers around 2,730sq m, with stores measuring 20sqm up to 770sq m coming under this contract.

Cathay profit dives 59pc on big rise in fuel costs

South China Morning Post — 11 August 2011

Lack of gains from disposals also blamed for lower earnings of HK$2.8 billion for the first half to June

High oil prices took a heavy toll on Cathay Pacific Airways (SEHK: 0293)’ half-year profit, which came in at just HK$2.8 billion, down 59 per cent on the same period last year, the airline reported yesterday.

Also contributing to the big drop in profit was the absence of any gains from disposals, compared with a HK$2.16 billion gain in the same period last year from the sale of investments in subsidiaries.

Fuel costs rose HK$6.46 billion or 41 per cent to HK$18.56 billion. The jet fuel price jumped 53 per cent on average to US$128 per barrel, but fuel hedging, which covered 30 per cent of fuel consumption in the year and 20 per cent next year, helped Cathay pocket HK$962 million in hedging gains.

The drop in profit has not deterred the carrier from rejuvenating its fleet. Cathay announced yesterday it had ordered 12 new aircraft for HK$25.6 billion. The latest order will raise the number of aircraft on order over the period to 2019 to 97 – 79 wide-bodied passenger planes and 18 freighters. The estimated cost for the total order book is HK$200 billion. Some of the new planes will replace older aircraft, resulting in a net increase of 37 per cent from an existing fleet of 170.

The latest order is for four Boeing 777-300 extended-range passenger planes and eight Boeing 777-200 freighters, which will be primarily used on regional and European routes.

On the commercial impact of the emissions trading scheme proposed by the European Union for next year, chief executive John Slosar said the extra cost would be passed on to passengers since the carrier was required to buy carbon credits to neutralise its emissions.

The scheme is part of the EU’s plan to cut emissions by 20 per cent from the 1990 levels by 2020. Cathay has described the scheme as discriminatory as it penalises long-haul carriers since the EU will charge flights to and from Europe, including non-EU areas.

“We are fully covered and have already bought the carbon credits for next year,” Slosar said.

He did not detail the costs and Cathay has yet to decide by how much each European ticket would be priced higher. European routes account for about 20 per cent of the airline’s total traffic.

Mainland carriers have said the emission scheme would cost them 800 million yuan (HK$973.44 million) next year, which translates to 300 yuan more for each ticket.

For the six months to June, Cathay reported a 15.9 per cent year-on-year rise in passenger ticket sales to HK$31.77 billion. Weakening cargo demand since April narrowed cargo sales growth to 7.7 per cent at HK$11.6 billion.

After an exceptionally good year in 2010, when the carrier enjoyed record earnings, soaring fuel prices and softening cargo demand have cast a cloud on the outlook for the remainder of the year.

If the recession in the global economy is sustained, cargo demand would continue to weaken, chairman Chris Pratt said. “But Hong Kong and Cathay are in quite a special place and as China continues to do well, we will benefit,” he said.

Aircargo news

http://www.aircargonews.com/0811/FT110808.html

http://www.aircargonews.com/FT11/Hongkonglead080811.jpg

In some quarters, capacity sharing partnerships between HKIA and airports in southern China have been advanced as an alternative to HKIA moving forward with plans to build a third runway. Cathay Pacific has been rather outspoken on the issue, pointing out quite reasonably that Shenzhen and Hong Kong have separate governments, border controls and administrative systems. They also have different currencies, immigration requirements and air services agreements, not to mention leading operators and stakeholders.
http://www.aircargonews.com/FT11/chinesewarehouse.jpg “Even if the challenges outlined above could somehow be resolved, there’s no reason to think that the other PRD airport hubs would surrender their runway capacity to Hong Kong. All of the PRD airports are in competition and this is good for passengers and other users,” said Cathay in one statement.
As HKIA weighs up its expansion options, the truth of the matter is that competition between Hong Kong and its Mainland rivals is fierce now and will intensify in the coming decade.
As previously reported here, the Pearl River Delta region of southern China produces over 25 percent of the country’s exports and is responsible for more than 10 percent of national industrial output. Over the last decade HKIA has retained its dominance of air cargo uplift from the region, a dominance that helped it become the world’s leading cargo airport in 2010. But its cross-border rivals of Guangzhou (CAN) and Shenzhen (SZX) are making inroads.
CAN saw volumes rise almost 20 percent in 2010 to 1.14m metric tons, helping the airport retain its status as the 21st largest cargo airport globally, according to figures from Airports Council International. Shenzhen, meanwhile, is now the 24th largest and one of the fastest growing cargo airports in the world, handling some 809,363 tons in 2010, a year-on-year gain of 33.6 percent.
Both airports have ambitious plans to expand by building additional runways and already boast the presence of major hubs operated by leading carriers – UPS at SZX and FedEx at CAN. The two logistics majors have been highly vocal about the service benefits that have been possible since the hubs were established. Both airports are now also improving service levels, supported by strong investment in hinterland infrastructure from regional and federal authorities.
http://www.aircargonews.com/FT11/alwynMendonca.jpg Alwyn Mendonca, (left) Managing Director for South China and Hong Kong at GAC, said these efforts are now bearing fruit. In the past, 90 percent of GAC’s airfreight cargo was handled at HKIA because it was the most cost-effective option, especially since GAC builds its own units in Hong Kong.
“However,” he added, “we are gradually seeing more cargo moving directly through Guangzhou and Shenzhen as customs in Southern China becomes more efficient. For every shipment, we carefully evaluate all options to find the best, and most cost-effective, way to get the cargo to its final destination.
“There has been considerable improvement in customs services at both CAN and SZX in the past few years. Paperless export declarations are now a reality for some general cargo, depending on the commodity, and it is now possible to complete the process within a day.”
Christian Hein, Vice President for air freight Product Management in the Asia Pacific at Schenker, said improved customs services were seeing more cargo directed to CAN and SZX, a trend he predicted would accelerate.
“There are more domestic and international carriers calling into these two airports now and they offer good connections overall,” he added.
“There are increasingly more customers requesting us to operate directly out of these two airports due mainly to their proximity to manufacturing operations, and to a certain extent, an increasingly influential and sizeable consumer market.
http://www.aircargonews.com/FT11/RobertTimmerman.jpg “Though the fuel surcharge level is higher than Hong Kong, the overall freight rate all-in is still competitive.”
Robert Timmerman, (right) Area Manager Greater China at Panalpina, said that although airfreight rates were attractive from mainland airports, add-on fuel and security surcharges ultimately aligned pricing with HKIA.      “The fact is that the carrier portfolio in both Shenzhen—mainly served by Jade Airlines to date, and Guangzhou, which sees a diversified portfolio going forward, combined with the expanding China Southern fleet including Boeing 777 freighters—will allow us to provide direct lift from and to Mainland China to support the growth.
“Hong Kong, however, will retain its strengths in view of the local trading solutions available and successfully conducted for years.
“A dilemma going forward related to airlifting through Mainland airports are the restrictions related to second customs’ bond transfer. This cannot be conducted at present. If the Logistics Provider could build Aircraft ULDs themselves this would substantially increase control and thus reduce exposure on damages.”
http://www.aircargonews.com/FT11/Andy.Weber080811.jpg Andy Weber, (left) President of Kuehne + Nagel Asia Pacific, said CAN and SZX still lacked sufficient route coverage, flight frequency and airport cargo handling options, but had a speed advantage over HKIA in terms of accessing factories in the PRD because of overland transit times.
“Buyers increasingly demand high-speed delivery of products or components, and the time lost can constitute a competitive constraint,” he explained.
“This would suggest that Hong Kong’s future as a key air-cargo hub will heavily depend on its capability in providing speedy intermodal transports by land, sea or air between Hong Kong International Airport and the factories in South China.”
The final word on competition between HKIA and southern Mainland China rivals goes to Hein: “An additional runway [at HKIA] would definitely enhance competitiveness. Nevertheless, the competition between HKIA and other South China regional airports is keen and will remain so for years to come.”

Aviation adviser calls for regional airspace accord

South China Morning Post – 9 Aug 2011

Authority’s consultant says pact with neighbours could help ease Southeast Asia’s crowded skies

A consultant who studied plans to build a third runway at Chek Lap Kok airport has recommend that Hong Kong enter a pact with Southeast Asia’s other major air-traffic hubs to ease the region’s crowded airspace.

London-based aviation adviser NATS said in a report the Airport Authority released yesterday that better information sharing between the region’s big cities could let passengers spend less time in holding patterns or sitting on the tarmac.

The firm urged local authorities to spearhead the creation of a regional airport “cluster” to better exchange information when bad weather or other events snarl air traffic.

“There is currently no means of regulating traffic within the Southeast Asian area except by local agreements between area control centres,” said NATS, which had previously studied the implications of building a new landing strip at the busy Lantau Island airport.

“This lack of capacity management allows significant traffic peaks to develop,” the report continued.

The 13-year-old Hong Kong International Airport, which is running at 90 per cent of capacity at peak hours, has already formed a network with airports in Taiwan and Japan since receiving the report.

“If there is a storm over Taiwan, for example, the airports there should notify us so we could stop our flights from taking off,” said one Hong Kong civil aviation officer.

The consultant also advised aviation authorities to liaise with airlines over the amount of time their pilots spend on the runway.

The report found that while the average plane landing in Hong Kong stays on the runway for 54.9 seconds before taxiing to the terminal, a flight into London’s overcrowded Heathrow airport makes way for other planes in less than 50 seconds.

The airport could increase its capacity by training pilots to leave the runway more quickly, NATS found. The civil aviation officer said several air carriers had pledged to alert their pilots to the problem. “Sometimes pilots linger on the runway in order to take the closest exit to stand,” the official said. “Now we ask them to leave the runway as soon as they can.”

The firm also proposed Hong Kong to assume a leading role in processing air traffic data among the five airports in the Pearl River Delta including Guangzhou, Macau, Shenzhen and Zhuhai, to improve traffic flow. Hong Kong and the mainland have long been at odds over which side should give up its system and no immediate solutions are expected.