Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Basic Law Sets Out Obligation To Public Health

Jul 04, 2008 – SCMP

Christine Loh Kung-wai is right to say that Hong Kong’s 20-year-old air quality objectives do not adequately protect public health (“Smoke screen”, June 26), but she is wrong about one thing. The problem is not that Hong Kong’s environmental laws do not mention public health.

Article 39 of the Basic Law requires the government to implement the provisions of the International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rights through Hong Kong law. Article 12 of the covenant imposes a duty on governments to take steps to secure the highest attainable standards of public health for everyone, including progressively improving all aspects of environmental and industrial hygiene.

By undertaking to tighten its air quality objectives to ensure proper protection of public health in line with the principles recommended by the World Health Organisation, our government is belatedly doing what the Basic Law requires.

The Basic Law does not tell the government what standards to adopt, but the fact that the duty to adopt health-based environmental standards is contained in a UN covenant has important implications. Because Beijing has ratified the covenant, it provides a common legal framework for Hong Kong and Guangdong to set appropriate air quality standards for the affluent Pearl River Delta region.

It also means that the international community is entitled to compare the government’s air quality objectives to international standards and decide whether Hong Kong deserves the title of Asia’s World City.

David Renton, Repulse Bay

Air Pollution vs. Allergies and Respiratory Illnesses

Choke hold

Hong Kong’s increasingly polluted air could be to blame for more allergies and respiratory ills than we realise

Hazel Parry – Updated on Jun 30, 2008 – SCMP

It may start with a few sneezes and a runny nose, progress to a cough and then turn into a full-blown hacking wheeze. At first you may think you’re suffering from a chest infection brought on by a cold, but when the cough fails to show signs of abating two weeks later, you consult your doctor. The problem: Hong Kong’s bad air. You’re suffering an allergic reaction to pollution.

The smog that regularly cloaks our skyline is getting worse, and it’s not only annoying tourists who make the trip up Victoria Peak only to see nothing and driving businesses to other Asian cities, it is also interfering with the quality of life and the general health of people who work and live in the city.

A recent report by the think-tank Civic Exchange claimed poor air quality was responsible for 10,000 premature deaths and 440,000 hospital bed days a year in the Pearl River Delta, at a cost of 6.7 billion yuan (HK$7.6 billion) annually.

And it’s not just the very young, old or those with existing respiratory problems such as asthma who are paying the price for pollution. Ear, nose and throat experts claim they are seeing an increasing number of seemingly healthy people seeking help for problems of the upper respiratory system caused by pollutants in the air they breathe.

Some are suffering in silence – blaming their symptoms on colds, stress or being overtired, and letting the problem affect their life, sleep patterns and working day. They may be dangerously self-medicating or dosing themselves with cold remedies. Others are seeking help from their GPs, only to find there’s little they can do.

The Civic Exchange report claims pollution is behind 11 million doctor visits a year. A separate study by the Chinese University of Hong Kong published in 2005 found a significant link between people making first visits to their GPs with upper respiratory tract problems on days of increased pollution. This led the researchers to conclude that “air pollution, besides affecting at-risk populations [those with existing problems], also affects the relatively healthy population.”

The Chinese University study monitored more than 300,000 consultations from 13 participating GP surgeries across Hong Kong between 2000 and 2002 to assess the risk of less serious or short-term effects of pollution on health (as opposed to the serious effects, which require hospitalisation). Researchers say about three-quarters of the consultations were first visits for new health problems – and of those, two thirds were for respiratory disorders. They also found that as the concentration of pollutants such as ozone and nitrogen dioxide in the air increased, the greater the number of first-time visits there were for upper respiratory disorders.

“Although these illnesses are minor in nature with minimum long term effects on health, they represent a substantial proportion of overall morbidity in the community,” the study concludes, adding that the problems are a financial drain on Hong Kong in terms of escalating medical costs and loss of productivity.

According to ear, nose and throat (ENT) expert John Woo Kong-sang, in most cases an allergy to pollution manifests itself as rhinitis or rhino-sinusitis – inflammation of the mucous membrane lining of the nose or sinuses – causing symptoms such as runny noses, sneezing and coughing. A sore throat, phlegm, loss of smell, watery or itchy eyes are also common reactions to pollution.

Woo, an honorary clinical associate professor in the department of otorhinolaryngology at Chinese University, estimates that patients with allergic rhinitis or rhino-sinusitis account for about 30 to 40 per cent per cent of cases at the ENT clinic, up from about 10 to 15 per cent a decade ago.

“We don’t know for sure whether the increase is due to the growth in population in Sha Tin [the area the clinic serves], but judging from the number of people turning up at our clinics, I am quite sure the problem has become worse as pollution has grown worse, and it is affecting the health of the population in general,” he says.

Woo says the nose, as the air filter for the lungs, is the first to suffer from exposure to pollution. “When it’s working properly, the nose filters out about 90 per cent of pollutants. But when you have a lot of pollutants in the air, it has to work harder,” he says.

In people with allergic tendencies who have become sensitised to pollutants, a slight increase in pollution may be too much for the nose to bear, resulting in an allergic reaction – the inflammation and all the symptoms which come with it.

“You may think you have a cold and the symptoms may be the same. But the difference is that an infected condition, even without treatment, is self-limiting. It may last one or two weeks and then you get over it,” says Woo. “With allergic rhinitis, the symptoms will linger on.”

It’s the lingering nature of the symptoms that distinguishes an allergy from a cold, and which eventually leads many people to their GPs. Likewise, it’s the fact that symptoms occur year-round that makes many experts believe the problem is more likely to be pollution than pollen.

Respiratory specialist Lam Bing, an honorary assistant professor at the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Hong Kong, says rhinitis is known to affect about 20 to 30 per cent of the world’s population.

A recent report by the multi-centred International Study into Allergies and Asthma in Childhood claims that although cases of asthma appear to have reached a plateau, rhinitis is on the rise.

“I would say in Hong Kong the number of people with rhinitis is a similar number to the worldwide figure,” says Lam. “If you were to ask people a simple question such as, `Do you suffer from nasal discharge, blockage or congestion in the morning?’ you would probably find many people suffer some kind of complaint.”

“It’s a common problem, but many people ignore it. Especially as a typical feature of rhinitis is that the symptoms are worse in the morning but gradually improve during the day, so people tend to think they can cope with problem. If they have a sore throat they think it’s because they have talked too much or that it’s an infection.”

To what precise extent pollution is to blame for the growing number of minor respiratory problems is difficult to say because of the lack of research, says Lam, although studies have also shown that people living nearer highways have far more chance of developing respiratory problems than those living in urban areas.

Johnny Koo Tak-ching is in no doubt pollution is partly to blame for Hong Kong’s worsening coughs, sniffles, sneezes and sore throats. He’s an ENT expert at a private clinic in Central, the majority of whose patients are expatriates who move from city to city in their work.

“Those patients who have long-term rhinitis, sinusitis and nasal polyps get worse when they’re working in a city with higher pollution. They can tell which city has the worst pollution by how bad their symptoms get,” he says.

“They feel much better in places like the Mediterranean and some northern Chinese cities, such as Harbin, but feel worse when they move to places like Shanghai, Beijing and Hong Kong. Singapore is better than Hong Kong, and Kuala Lumpur is better than Singapore.”

The bad news for everyone living and working in central Hong Kong is that there’s little we can do while pollution remains a problem.

Antihistamines, which reduce allergic reactions, can alleviate itching and sneezing, steroid-based nasal drops can reduce some of the inflammation and clear the nose, and pain killers provide relief for a sore throat. But all of these treatments only address the symptoms and not the cause, and, in the long term, nasal allergies can lead to nasal polyps, which may require surgery.

Koo says: “Reduce your exposure to very polluted areas. If you know you’re going to a more polluted area, then start the preventive medicine for the allergy before you go. If you have minor symptoms such as throat discomfort or more phlegm, keep an eye on your health, drink more water and take some vitamin C, and you should be fine.

“However, if symptoms last more than a week, you had better see a doctor to see if there’s a more serious problem.

“Unfortunately, my impression is, generally, there is no escape – unless you move to another country that’s less polluted.”

Koo’s observation is reflected by the experience of Elaine Tse, who has suffered from a sore throat that has persisted for months despite the installation of a HK$12,000 air purifier in her home. “Nothing was working, so I went to the ENT specialist, who stuck a camera up my nose and down the back of my throat,” she says. “He asked me if I’d visited any toxic plants in China. I hadn’t, of course. He concluded that it was allergies to the pollution and gave me antihistamines.”

That conclusion was borne out when Elaine took a trip to Australia. “After just 24 hours the sore throat went away,” she says. “Now I am back in Hong Kong, it’s back again.”

Smoke Screen

Updated on Jun 26, 2008 – SCMP

A certain amount of government spin is inevitable, but it is also time for officials to improve the message. The worst thing is to obfuscate and hope the public won’t see the fudge. A member of the public recently showed me a letter she had written to environmental protection officials, together with their reply. She asked why public health isn’t the government’s top priority, in terms of air pollution control. The writer said it was intolerable that the government had not accepted World Health Organisation air quality standards for Hong Kong.

The reply noted that the administration had appointed consultants to draw up a new set of standards and devise a plan to meet them. It would be finished by the end of the year. Most importantly, it said, the government was determined to tighten the standards “to ensure proper protection of public health, in line with the principles recommended by the WHO”.

A careful reading shows that the government did not commit itself to adopting WHO standards. The concern among public health physicians and air quality experts is that the administration will not, in fact, adopt such standards, for fear of being unable to meet them any time soon. Hong Kong is unique among developed economies in having extremely lax air quality standards, referred to as air quality “objectives”. Indeed, a mistaken understanding of what the WHO standards are about has led to officials denying themselves a powerful instrument to improve air quality.

The WHO standards are based on the best available data and indicate the health risks arising from air quality. If met, the standards correspond to a level that can be said to represent a lower risk, and the pollutant levels show what authorities around the world should strive for. There is, in fact, no real argument over the standards, which were reviewed before being published as recommendations globally in 2006. The real question is why they should not be adopted.

The fact is the Hong Kong government has never made public health the raison d’etre for air quality management. The empowering legislation to control pollution does not mention public health, unlike its equivalent on the mainland, in the United States and Europe. Thus, the Air Pollution Control Ordinance needs to be amended. The government-appointed consultants should make a clear recommendation in this regard. Otherwise, they will have to explain why Hong Kong remains an exception, and how it is going to clean itself up. In truth, public health needs to become a legal requirement to get officials to act.

Once protection of public health is the goal, our officials would have to devise policies to get us there, over time. The public understands that merely resetting standards will not improve our air. It is, however, the necessary first step. The WHO also recognises this. So, governments need to devise air improvement plans in phases.

Officials would have to explain how each proposed measure would work and what improvements could be expected. They would have to track results, so that adjustments could be made to ensure their initiatives delivered the expected results. The WHO guidelines are there to remind everyone of the level of risk the community faces when they are not being met.

By linking health outcomes to air-pollution-control initiatives, our officials would have to be more directly accountable for their decisions and actions. It would not be enough to push one initiative at a time – such as, say, a ban on idling engines. Information would have to be provided about what such an initiative could be expected to achieve. And maybe, even when all the initiatives are taken into account, officials may find that it still isn’t enough to reduce the health risk. That would provide pressure to do more.

Yes, there would be additional costs, but Hong Kong is a rich city, and it is time officials dropped their developing-economy mindset and joined the developed world.

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange. cloh@civic-exchange.org

Asthma Linked To Traffic Pollution

23rd June 2008 SCMP

Children who live near a busy road have about a 50 per cent greater risk of developing asthma, hayfever or eczema than those living 1km or more away, according to German researchers, who say their study shows the strongest link yet between pollution and childhood allergies. Researchers from the Helmholtz Research Centre for Environment and Health studied 3,000 healthy children in Munich for their first six years, Reuters reports. “We consistently found strong associations between the distance to the nearest main road and allergic disease,” says team leader Joachim Heinrich.

The Neglected Dangers Of Ultraviolet Exposure

Updated on Jun 22, 2008 – SCMP

Everyone is aware of the dangers of air pollution; fewer people are concerned about those from ultraviolet light. Yet too much exposure to it can be just as dangerous. According to the World Health Organisation, four out of five cases of skin cancer result from too much exposure to sunlight. But a lesser known danger from ultraviolet light comes from a WHO statement, which warns up to 20 per cent of cataract cases worldwide are caused by such overexposure. If left untreated, cataracts can lead to blindness.

Hong Kong’s ultraviolet readings are among the highest in the world, mainly because of its position on Planet Earth. Clearly, more public education to raise awareness is needed. It is, therefore, commendable that the Observatory will start issuing hourly advice via public announcements from next month when ultraviolet (UV) levels reach “extreme exposure”, which means above 11 on the UV index.

Since 1999, the Observatory has been providing daily ultraviolet readings. Currently, visitors to its website – the most widely viewed of all the government Web services – can also find ultraviolet forecasts for the next day. But it provides only index levels, instead of precautions to take to avoid exposure. But, just as it now issues warnings when air pollution reaches dangerous levels, there is a need to extend the same service to sunlight exposure.

This new service will be especially important to schools, where young pupils are regularly exposed to the sun during physical education classes. While increasing numbers of schools now advise pupils to put on hats and use sunscreen lotion, many are still woefully unaware. Yet overexposure from a young age clearly increases health risks later in life. This month, a University of Hong Kong survey found people are not nearly as aware of the damage that excessive ultraviolet exposure can inflict on the eyes as of its ill-effects on the skin. Teachers and parents, therefore, need to be better educated about the dangers of too much exposure to sunlight.

Though the new service is being offered by the Observatory, the Education Bureau should join in efforts as well. Better awareness will help reduce the number of cancer and cataract cases in the years to come.

Xining Special Steel Company

Province battles dual nightmares: black skies, 1m below poverty line

Shi Jiangtao – Updated on Jun 22, 2008

In the suburbs of Xining , the provincial capital and largest city of Qinghai , smokestacks at a large industrial plant spew billows of black, white and red smoke and steam into the city’s grey sky.

The chimneys belong to Xining Special Steel Company, the largest producer of stainless steel and structural iron in northwestern China and employer of 9,000 workers. Listed in Shanghai and one of Qinghai’s biggest taxpayers, the steel plant is the pride of the financially distressed local government.

The factory just a few kilometres upwind of the city centre makes no effort to curb or clean its emissions.

Local residents say they have suffered under thick, dirty fallout from the factory for decades.

“It is a nightmare to live near the factory,” said a resident whose husband works at the steel plant. “We used to see clear blue skies every day, but what else can we say? China is `the world’s factory’ now.”

Amid growing public anger, authorities have promised again this year to crack down on industrial pollution, which has shown signs of worsening in recent years.

The factory has been named and shamed repeatedly by local environmental authorities over the years, but that has not stopped it reappearing on the provincial green watchdog’s list of top industrial polluters.

Bai Ma , chairman of the Qinghai provincial committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, admitted that the plant has had serious pollution problems for years due to old equipment.

“Pollution is a serious problem with old equipment and the factory is trying to replace it or upgrade its steel-production technology,” he said. “But it needs a lot of money, which makes the cleanup effort difficult to proceed with smoothly.”

Most of Qinghai’s economic indicators show that its gross domestic product is among the smallest on the mainland.

“Qinghai’s GDP for 2006 was just 64.1 billion yuan [HK$72.84 billion], which was hardly comparable to eastern provinces,” said party chief Qiang Wei .

“Our local fiscal revenue in 2006 was 4.2 billion yuan, smaller than that of a district or a county in Beijing.”

The socio-economic disparities among the different regions in Qinghai are widening, according to official statistics.

Nearly 68 per cent of the provincial population, or 3.7 million people, are crowded into Xining and its eastern suburb Haidong prefecture, which is only 3 per cent of the total area. They absorbed 58 per cent of the provincial economic output.

About 20 per cent of the province’s total population, or 1.04 million people, live below the official poverty line, mostly in rural and mountain areas, with more than 60 per cent concentrated in the source regions of the Yangtze, Yellow and Lancang (Mekong) rivers.

Eliminating poverty remained the biggest challenge for the province, Mr Qiang said.

Provincial leaders insist that Qinghai has witnessed some extraordinary changes, with annual GDP registering double-digit growth for the past consecutive six years thanks to Beijing’s western-development policies.

But the province lags ever farther behind affluent coastal regions.

Guangzhou’s GDP for 2006 was 10 times that of Qinghai.

Despite the province’s 12 per cent rise in GDP last year, research by the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences last year found that the province’s overall economic competitiveness had slipped.

But that could be the price Qinghai must pay while it tries to lift hundreds of thousands of people out of poverty and conserve the already fragile Tibetan Plateau, according to Mr Bai.

“Our government has made environmental conservation a prerequisite for economic development,” he said.

A total of 7.5 billon yuan has been invested in the river-source regions to relocate more than 40,000 Tibetan nomads in Guoluo, Huangnan and Yushu counties and reverse the degradation there.

The three areas have also been exempted from mandatory goals of economic growth since 2006.

“The top priority for the … regions is environmental conservation, which is crucial for sustainable development of the province as well as the whole Tibetan region,” said Governor Song Xiuyan .

Qinghai recently launched another ambitious campaign to clean up Qinghai Lake on the eastern edge of the vast Tibetan Plateau and an important wildlife refuge.

Ecological degradation in the province, experts warn, will affect the entire northwestern and Himalayan regions and pose grave threats to the upper reaches of the Yellow River.

Mr Bai said he was optimistic about the future of the province, which is rich in natural resources, including hydropower resources, Tibetan herbs, numerous saltwater lakes and the country’s largest potassium fertiliser production base.

He said the province attached great value to expanding schools and vocational education, and luring talent from around the country.

He made an appeal to Hong Kong to invest in the province. “Qinghai is a resource-abundant province that has yet to be fully explored.

“There is plenty of room for Hong Kong’s advantage in investment, talent and technology to play a bigger role in our future development.”

Aussie Track Athletes To Miss Opening

16th June 2008 – SI.com

MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) -Because of scheduling issues and a concern about air quality, many of Australia’s track and field athletes will miss the Aug. 8 Olympic opening ceremonies in Beijing.

With the Beijing athletics program not starting until Aug. 15, one week after the opening, Athletics Australia has chosen to hold its pre-Olympic training camp in Hong Kong.

Competitors will then fly to Beijing three or four days before their scheduled events.

“As many sports have said, China presents difficulties for athletes going in and being there for a period of time,” Athletics Australia national performance manager Max Binnington said Monday.

“Anything more than five or six days and they inevitably end up with some sort of respiratory problem. So that was why many of the sports who don’t have to be in there early are choosing not to go in. And the outcome is that it’s almost impossible to go for the opening ceremony.”

Australia’s triathletes will also miss the opening ceremonies for similar reasons.

“Most of our athletes have accepted the decision straight away,” Binnington said.

Sun Weide, a spokesman for the Bejiing organizing committee, said countries and teams could be flexible for the opening ceremonies.

“Every team can arrange its schedule according to its own plan,” Sun said. “As for the environmental problems, we’ve said many times that we’re confident that we can provide clean air during the Olympic Games.”

Chinese officials have said that from July 20 to Sept. 20, most construction will halt and heavy industries will close in an effort to cut pollution.

A plan for Beijing’s notoriously clogged traffic has not been formalized, but reports suggest that about half of the city’s 3.3 million vehicles will be banned each day, possibly using an odd-even system from registration plates.

The Australian Olympic Committee earlier said the decision was about logistics rather than health concerns.

“Most of the athletes have decided to come in later and not march,” AOC spokesman Mike Tancred said.

“Generally those competing of the first day or the second day don’t march, standing up for eight hours a day or so before competition isn’t a medically smart thing to do,” Tancred said .

The Australian women’s basketball team also won’t be marching at the opening, because of scheduling. The Australians, who won silver medals at the past two Olympics – losing to the United States each time – has a 9 a.m. game on Aug. 9 against Belarus.

Clean Environment Is Essential

Clean environment is essential for our long-term development

Updated on Jun 13, 2008 – SCMP

With the buoyant economy, more people are able to afford luxury cars which are major polluters. It is ironic to see that citizens are on the one hand enjoying the fruits of economic success but, on the other, ignoring the environment and exacerbating our pollution problems.

A society can only enjoy sustainable development if it has a good environment. A society depends upon profitable investments, but unless it has a clean environment it will not achieve its full potential.

Leading figures from the international business community have repeatedly urged the Hong Kong government to make cleaner air its priority if it wants to retain its status as an international financial centre. Many foreign bankers and their families and other businessmen, have been attracted to other cities in the region, because they have lower pollution levels. Our government must be aware of this growing trend and it should not be neglected.

World leaders have woken up to the fact that we must clean up our act. Studies have shown us the strong correlation between the quality of air we breathe in and the chance of us succumbing to respiratory-related illnesses. Some studies have suggested that air pollution costs our city about HK$21 billion a year in terms of medical expenses and lost productivity.

Health problems aside, Hong Kong’s slipping rank in quality-of-life surveys is also becoming an embarrassment for the government, with Hong Kong slipping down the table compiled by the ECA International Survey of the best locations to live in.

Our government should bear the responsibility to protect its citizens and ensure their health does not deteriorate. A workforce enjoying good mental and physical health performs better.

In Hong Kong, where the economy depends heavily on tourism, improving the air quality can benefit the territory by enticing more people to visit.

In the long term, we still need to aim for sustainable development. Through raising people’s living standards by keeping the environment clean, we can be assured of a rapid and sound development.

Borromeo Li Ka-kit, Kwun Tong

Adoption Of WHO Standards Urged

Mary Ann Benitez – Updated on Jun 12, 2008 – SCMP

Hong Kong should quickly adopt World Health Organisation standards on air quality in light of its enormous impact on people’s health, a Civic Exchange study says.

Hospital bed-days, lost productivity and doctor visits associated with polluted air cost 1.8 billion yuan (HK$2.03 billion) a year in the Pearl River Delta, HK$1.1 billion in Hong Kong and HK$18 million in Macau, the study said.

Civic Exchange chief executive officer Christine Loh Kung-wai said: “One thing that the government does not do here is to link health and control of air pollution.

“You and I know that bad air pollution means it’s bad for our health, but what we are not able to do is to understand that in much greater depth,” she said. “By doing long-term health tracking and studies to track effectiveness of policies – that is the only real way to inform policymakers whether any of the initiatives that they roll out are having a beneficial impact on public health.”

She welcomed a review of the 20-year-old Air Quality Objectives that the government said would be completed by next year.

“The question is whether they will tighten [air quality standards] to WHO standards and then announce measures and a time frame … to reach them, or set looser standards,” she said.

Anthony Hedley, chair professor of the department of community medicine at the University of Hong Kong, said: “From the public health point of view, we regard the adoption of WHO guidelines an absolute imperative and priority.”

Ms Loh added: “The problem has been the government feels that if it’s a standard they set, they have to pass it. But they are forgetting that even other societies have not necessarily met the WHO guidelines, but they use it as a measure of public health risk and … therefore to come up with measures to reduce air pollution.”

Alexis Lau Kai-hon, an atmospheric scientist at the University of Science and Technology, said revising regional objectives in line with WHO guidelines “would provide powerful drivers to improve air quality and public health.”

Coming Clean

Updated on Jun 12, 2008 – SCMP

Extraordinarily, Hong Kong has yet to make an explicit policy link between air quality and public health. We all know that air pollution affects our health yet, in public policy terms, the weighting towards our well-being is missing. This must change, otherwise the government will never quite get its priorities right about environmental protection and its duty to improve air quality, so that it no longer poses a daily threat to people. The same can be said of Guangdong, one of the wealthiest parts of the country; health gains from social and economic development will otherwise be compromised.

Research released yesterday using data from 2006 shows that air pollution levels were attributable to 10,000 deaths in Hong Kong, Macau and the Pearl River Delta, with 94 per cent of these occurring across the border. Moreover, air pollution is responsible for some 440,000 annual hospital bed-days and 11 million outpatient visits annually throughout the whole region. Industrialised areas such as Guangzhou and Foshan suffer from very high levels of sulfur dioxide, which is associated with cardiovascular and respiratory disease, and death. These figures could be lowered with improved air quality; these premature deaths and illnesses are avoidable.

The cost of these hospital bed-days, lost productivity and doctor visits associated with the impact on people’s health amounts to 1.8 billion yuan (HK$2.03 billion) a year in the delta, HK$1.1 billion in Hong Kong and HK$18 million in Macau. Adjusted for differences in gross domestic product, the health-related monetary costs of air pollution in the delta are seven times higher than those in Hong Kong. These represent only the economic losses, and do not take into account pain and suffering, or put a value on life. Research also shows the lack of local studies in the delta, Hong Kong and Macau on air pollution and health. The public and government policymakers will still not fully understand the impact of poor air quality on health without long-term studies that measure the total years of life lost to air pollution. Conducting studies that provide feedback essential to evaluate the effectiveness of air pollution control measures will help governments shape policy. If public health was a policy priority, we would invest more in health-related research.

It is now indisputable that smoggy days have increased dramatically over the past two decades. Although some pollutant types and sources have decreased, others have remained steady or increased. This is particularly true in the delta’s industrial areas. Only with frequent reviews of air pollution data and an evaluation of policy measures will it be possible to devise appropriate strategies. The authorities need to review regional emissions data for last year, as satellite information indicates that conditions have worsened since 2003.

Authorities in the delta, Hong Kong and Macau can exercise leadership by tightening air quality standards. Replacing the existing piecemeal approach with a total air quality management framework focused on public health is the first step. It has proved successful in controlling emissions elsewhere in the world.

Taking collaborative action before Hong Kong and Guangzhou host the East Asian and Asian Games in 2009 and 2010, respectively, will allow the region to take advantage of lessons learned from Beijing’s attempts to improve air quality for the Olympics, and for the region to position itself as a leader in fighting air pollution. A powerful short-term measure would be to use cleaner fuels not only in vehicles and ships but also in factories using power generators. This won’t be easy at a time when energy prices are high, but policymakers must spell out the damage to people’s health if they are to rally support for change.

This is the right time for such a change. National policy is shifting towards environmental protection; Hong Kong and Guangdong, as the wealthiest parts of the country, should be the first to make an explicit health link.

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange. cloh@civic-exchange.org