Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

New Hong Kong Air Pollution Policy Proposed

08-01-2009 – RTHK

The Legislative Council has passed a motion urging the government to do more to tackle air pollution. The motion, sponsored by the Democratic Party, calls on the government to adopt World Health Organisation standards for measuring air pollution. It also urged the government to establish an alarm system to warn people of health risks when air pollution is serious.

Sulfur Emissions Remain Well Above Target

Sulfur emissions drop but remain well above target, says top official

Cheung Chi-fai – SCMP – Updated on Jan 08, 2009

Sulfur dioxide emissions in the city have dropped back almost to 1997 levels, but they are still well above the government’s emission-reduction targets. Meanwhile, the city’s air quality standard, in terms of sulfur content, is much less stringent than that set by the World Health Organisation.

Environment Secretary Edward Yau Tang-wah told lawmakers yesterday that Hong Kong was narrowing the gap towards meeting the 2010 reduction targets agreed with Guangdong six years ago.

Last year, the total sulfur dioxide emission was just 2 per cent above 1997 levels, compared to 12 per cent above that level in 2006.

But considerable work remained as the target required the city to cut sulfur emission by 40 per cent below 1997 levels, or at least 26,000 tonnes.

“We are confident that we will be able to further reduce emissions and finally meet the target,” Mr Yau said.

He admitted difficulty in adopting WHO guidelines on sulfur pollutant concentration to replace the city’s 21-year-old air quality objective for the pollutant. The city’s standard for daily sulfur concentration is 350 micrograms per cubic metre of air, versus 20 in the WHO standard.

Endorsing the WHO target would mean a cut of at least 95 per cent in sulfur concentration.

He said the government was committed to reaching the WHO targets, but the public should decide on the pace of achieving them, the measures required and the trade-offs, such as higher power prices.

One of the measures being studied was a low emission zone that banned polluting franchised buses. A trial might be staged in collaboration with bus companies, Mr Yau said.

Three universities have also joined forces to work out ways to improve the air pollution index system, which has been criticised by lawmakers and green groups for failing to inform the public about the real health risks of air pollution.

Democrat legislator Kam Nai-wai urged Mr Yau to come clean on the air quality review soon to be released. “No more self-deception please by proposing any new objectives that the government thinks are achievable at the expense of public health.”

Albert Chan Wai-yip, of the League of Social Democrats, called environment officials “killers” because of their apathy to the seriousness of pollution, saying 35 asthma patients were admitted to hospital each day.

“Officials are giving more exemption to transport operators on idling engines. But the public has no exemption from air pollution and their lives are always under serious threat.”

Despair In The Air

Updated on Jan 08, 2009  – SCMP

Are local Hong Kong people concerned about air pollution? Yes, they are. If there are people who still think poor air quality is mainly a concern of the expatriate community, they need to look at the evidence. The Civic Exchange survey conducted in September and October last year, released on Monday, shows local people are extremely concerned about the bad air they have to breathe every day. They know Hong Kong’s air has deteriorated from a decade ago, and they know it is worse than the air in New York, Toronto, London and Tokyo. It is also no comfort to them to know that our air is better than that in Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou.

The results of the survey, conducted by the Hong Kong Transition Project, show that air pollution is now a major concern across all segments of the community. In general, older people are much more concerned than younger people. This probably indicates that the burden of environment-related health problems falls more heavily on older people.

However, a vast majority of both older and younger people now want the government to treat air pollution as a top priority. Women are also more concerned than men, probably because they spend more time caring for family members. After all, the survey shows that half of all respondents have suffered coughing, choking and stinging eyes; one-third have gone to a clinic with pollution-related problems; a quarter have bought over-the-counter medicine; a fifth have suffered more significant problems; one in 10 has missed school or work, and the same proportion has gone to hospital – all as a result of air pollution.

Shockingly, one in five people out of more than 1,000 randomly selected adults surveyed said they were considering leaving Hong Kong due to air pollution. As a representative sample, this equates to 1.4 million people. More than half of this group said they were thinking seriously about leaving and some had already planned to leave. The propensity to leave increases for higher-income earners, the highly educated, and people in professional, managerial and administrative positions. Many in this category may well have right of residence elsewhere.

Furthermore, about one in four have heard colleagues at work say they might leave Hong Kong due to air pollution. Almost one in 10 have heard of occasions when their company tried to hire someone who turned down the job specifically due to air-pollution-related health problems. This does not mean Hong Kong will definitely see a large brain drain but it certainly should be a loud and clear message that many people are so bothered by air pollution they have thought of leaving, taking a job elsewhere, and some are making arrangements to depart. There are Hongkongers working or studying overseas who may not return.

So, the potential for a brain drain is real. Presumably, they would stay, or return, if the government had convincing plans to make substantial improvements to our air quality over a reasonable period. Bad air quality has made Hong Kong a less-desirable location.

Indeed, a report by the City of London on the future of Asian financial centres, published last October, noted that poor air quality was increasingly recognised “as a critical element in the ongoing competition to attract talent into the city” and that Singapore had “made strenuous efforts to highlight its lifestyle credentials as a safe, clean and hospitable environment in comparison to Hong Kong”. Annual International Monetary Fund reports about Hong Kong have also highlighted air pollution as a recurring concern.

The new Hedley Environmental Index shows the annual direct cost of air pollution is already some HK$2 billion; indirect costs are about HK$20 billion. These figures are, in fact, very conservative. The sobering fact is that air pollution makes Hong Kong less desirable because it damages our health and quality of life. But we need not despair; there are solutions – given the will to act.

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange. cloh@civic-exchange.org

Hong Kong’s Silent Epidemic

Globe-Net – 8th January 2009

An independent public policy think tank has released the findings of a 1,020-person public opinion survey that explored attitudes towards air pollution and associated health risks in Hong Kong. The survey results suggest one in five Hong Kong residents are prepared to leave the city because of its poor air quality.

According to the survey conducted by Professor Michael DeGolyer, Director of Baptist University’s Hong Kong Transition Project, these findings equate to 1.4 million residents thinking about moving away, including 500,000 who are seriously considering or already planning to move according to the survey conducted for the think tank Civic Exchange.

Those most seriously thinking about leaving include top earners and highly educated workers, raising fears about the city’s ability to attract and retain top talent. And other cities in Asia, particularly Singapore, would love to attract those who choose to leave Hong Kong, noted DeGolyer, referring to the long-standing rivalry between the two Asian cities to attract top talent.

Professor DeGolyer highlighted four key findings from the survey:
Public concern about air pollution rose dramatically between 2001 and 2008.
All sectors and segments of Hong Kong society are concerned about air quality;
Hong Kong people believe air pollution makes Hong Kong an undesirable location for both locals and prospective international talent to work there; and
Hong Kong people believe air pollution is damaging their quality of life.

However, almost no-one is expressing their concerns to government leaders, members of the legislature, or members of the media, noted DeGolyer. This silence indicates a serious breakdown in communication and trust, and a need to review the public consultation system, according to the survey findings.

This reluctance to speak out is at the root of Hong Kong’s Silent Epidemic says Christine Loh, CEO, Civic Exchange. “This survey presents the voice of the “silent” public – and it is a worried voice.” She hopes these findings can be used constructively to inform the government’s Air Quality Objectives consultation and an upcoming debate on air pollution issues.

The survey also debunked the myth that concerns about air pollution were confined to the city’s foreign residents, as only three percent of the respondents were expatriates.

Air pollution across Hong Kong last year reached its highest level since records began according to official figures released last week, although the Hong Kong government insisted improvements had been made with respect to air quality.

The pollution is mainly caused by huge numbers of factories over the border in southern China, as well as transport and coal-fired power generation in Hong Kong.

Another Civic Exchange report last year said that at least 10,000 deaths were caused every year in Hong Kong, Macau and southern China by the region’s worsening air pollution.

Hong Kong Chief Executive Donald Tsang has called improving air quality a ’matter of life and death’ for the city. “The quality of Hong Kong’s air is of deep concern in the community and the Environment Bureau (ENB) and Environmental Protection Department (EPD) have been working vigorously to achieve improvements,” notes the government’s website.

To bring the message home about the impact of Hong Kong’s poor air quality a new Environmental Index has been set up and made public on the World Wide Web. “The purpose of the newly created Hedley Environmental Index is to make information on the risks to public health arising from air pollution available to the whole community,” said Dr. Hak-Kan Lai of the School of Public Health of Hong Kong University.

“By comparing the community-wide health impacts the Index shows with the specific complaints reported by members of the public shown in the Civic Exchange survey, it is clear that Hong Kong people feel the negative impacts of air pollution deeply.”

Unimpressed By Anti-Pollution Measures

Most people unimpressed by anti-pollution measures: poll

SCMP – 7th January 2009

About 80 per cent of people polled by the Democratic Party found government measures to clean up the air either ineffective or only slightly effective. In interviews of more than 500 people from December 29 to Monday by telephone, it was found that only 12 per cent said the measures were effective. Nearly half felt that air pollution was now even worse than in the previous two years. The poll also found that the air-pollution sources needing to be addressed most urgently was transport, followed by cross-boundary emissions and power plants. More than a third of respondents also said schools should be closed at times of serious air pollution.

One In Five Say They May Leave Over Pollution

Bad air could cause bigger exodus than brain drain in ’90s, poll finds

SCMP – Cheung Chi-fai – Jan 06, 2009

Air pollution has the potential to cause an exodus from Hong Kong bigger than the brain drain prompted by pre-handover jitters in the 1990s, a survey has indicated.

One in five residents, according to the poll, are considering leaving the city to escape the contaminated air, while one in 10 are seriously considering such a move or already have plans to go because of health fears.

That could mean an exodus of 700,000 to 1.4 million people, eclipsing the pre-handover brain drain, during which 450,000 people are estimated to have left.

“It is an astonishing figure and it is bigger than the brain drain. But it is just caused by the air,” said Michael DeGolyer, director of the Hong Kong Transition Project at Baptist University, which conducted the poll for the Hong Kong-based think-tank Civic Exchange.

The survey of more than 1,000 people, of whom some 3 per cent were expatriates, also found that like the earlier brain drain, the exodus could be led by high-income earners and highly educated people from the professional and managerial ranks.

One in 10 respondents to the poll, conducted in September and October last year, also said they had heard of foreigners turning down job offers because of air pollution.

Professor DeGolyer said the pre-handover brain drain had led the government to spend billions of dollars to expand the university system.

While many people who left before the handover eventually returned, air pollution had since emerged as a major factor affecting people’s decisions on whether to work in Hong Kong, he said.

Citing a recent report on the future of Asian financial centres released by the City of London Corporation, Civic Exchange chief Christine Loh Kung-wai said Singapore had replaced Hong Kong as the third global financial centre after New York and London.

“They do think Hong Kong is a good place, except for air quality,” she said, adding that the city’s “particular social problem” had turned into a “business problem”.

Ms Loh said that while Hong Kong had increasingly come under an international spotlight because of its air quality problems, the survey presented the “worried voice” of the silent public, who were predominantly Hong Kong Chinese.

Professor DeGolyer said there was a “silence epidemic” in regard to air pollution as many people had become so frustrated that they had given up talking to the government.

Compared to the results of a similar survey conducted in 2001, the results of the latest poll showed that more people were concerned about air pollution and that most believed the problem was a top priority for officials to deal with.

In an attempt to mitigate the effects of air pollution, two-thirds said they had closed windows and turned on air conditioning when the air was particularly polluted. Half of them said they suffered from coughing and itchy eyes, while a third said they had to go to clinics for pollution-related health problems.

Earlier studies have found that air pollution causes 1,600 premature deaths and HK$2 billion in direct economic losses each year.

Hong Kong Air Pollution Worst Since Records Began

Hong Kong – January 3, 2009 – 8:06PM – The Age

Air pollution across large swathes of Hong Kong last year reached its highest level since records began, despite government efforts to improve the environment, official figures showed yesterday.

Hong Kong suffers high air pollution, caused partly by huge numbers of factories over the border in southern China, and there have been fears the problem could compromise its position as an international finance centre.

The number of hours for which street-level pollution exceeded the danger level in some of the city’s busiest districts rose by 14 per cent in 2008, according to Environmental Protection Department figures.

The department said air pollution levels in the three main shopping and business districts were dangerous for more than 2,000 hours last year — the highest figure since it began taking roadside recordings in 2000.

An Air Pollution Index (API) of more than 100 is considered dangerous, indicating immediate health risks, especially to people with respiratory or heart problems.

The latest figures are for Central, Hong Kong’s main business district, and the Causeway Bay and Mongkok shopping areas.

They were released as Hong Kong’s acting environment secretary proposed a ban on running engines of parked vehicles, the latest in a series of measures to improve the city’s air quality.

The city’s Chief Executive Donald Tsang has called improving air quality a “matter of life and death” for Hong Kong, and said he expects the full backing of Chinese authorities.

A report released last year by the Hong Kong-based think tank Civic Exchange said that at least 10,000 deaths every year in Hong Kong, Macau and southern China are caused by the area’s worsening air pollution.

A spokeswoman for the Environmental Protection Department cautioned that the figures did not give a full picture of air quality because they reflected only the level of the pollutant that posed the greatest health risk.

However, Edwin Lau, director of pressure group Friends of the Earth Hong Kong, said this meant the true picture could be even worse than the figures indicated.

“You can look at the data from another perspective and say the problem could be even more worrying if the levels of the other pollutants were also taken into account,” he told AFP.

Lau said the government needed more effective policies to improve roadside air quality, such as banning heavy diesel vehicles from driving in busy districts during peak hours.

Eastern Hong Kong Island Enjoys Best Air

Pollution worst in western areas that are close to container terminals

Daniel Sin – SCMP – Updated on Jan 02, 2009

While many districts suffer rising levels of health-threatening pollution, residents in the east of Hong Kong Island have the cleanest air, and it has been improving over the years.

Eastern district has not recorded a reading of more than 100 on the Air Pollution Index since 2005 and, with the two other cleanest districts, Tai Po and Sha Tin, has recorded consistently improved readings.

In contrast, ambient readings at general stations in Yuen Long, Kwai Chung, Sham Shui Po, Central and Western, and Tung Chung are consistently worse than the rest of the city. In particular, in Kwai Chung last year, the number of hours when the API exceeded 100 – an alarm threshold of poor air quality – increased by 166.6 per cent from 2007.

Visibility has improved, with more blue skies creating an illusion of cleaner air. A visibility level of below 8km is defined as “reduced visibility”.

In the first 11 months of last year there were 1,654 hours of reduced visibility at the airport – an improvement of 10.4 per cent from the same period in 2007.

During the same period, there were about 1,000 hours of reduced visibility at the Observatory, the same level as last year. But experts said more clear days did not necessarily mean the air was cleaner.

“Improved visibility has little to do with the reduction of pollutant concentration, especially in areas at close range to people,” said Angus Wong Chun-yin of Friends of the Earth.

Simon Ng Ka-wing of the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, explaining why western areas usually suffered poorer air quality, said: “These districts are close to the container terminals. The emissions from vessels are high in sulfur dioxide concentration that could explain the high readings of the API from general stations in these districts.

“Besides, the air quality in these areas is more affected by the emissions from factories in the Pearl River Delta than the rest of the city.”

One exception was the isolated Sai Kung island of Tap Mun, which suffered high pollution despite having no traffic.

“This is because Tap Mun is close to a sea route to [the Shenzhen container port of] Yantian .”

Dr Ng said the impact of high pollutant concentration could be reduced with better town planning, building designs, and energy conservation measures.

Air quality objectives adopted in 1987 define the highest concentration of pollutants that can be tolerated within a given time without causing immediate health risks.

These include sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, ozone and breathable respirable suspended particles. For example, sulfur dioxide should not be allowed to exceed 800 micrograms per cubic metre of air in one hour.

Samples are collected at three roadside monitoring stations and 11 general monitoring stations that check ambient air quality in urban areas, new towns and rural areas.

The Environmental Protection Department compares the concentration of each of the pollutants against the respective air quality objective and picks the highest sub-index as the API.

Hong Kong Air Pollution

Air pollution danger days rise in 2008

API shows street-level air worsens

Daniel Sin – SCMP – Updated on Jan 02, 2009

Despite clearer skies and government efforts to switch vehicles to cleaner fuel, the air was dirtier than ever across much of the city last year, according to air pollution index data.

The number of hours in which street-level pollution exceeded danger levels at three of the most crowded areas rose by 14 per cent – and by more than 40 per cent in one area.

Meanwhile, in the western parts of the city, which have the worst air quality, the number of hours in which the ambient air pollution exceeded danger levels also rose, although cleaner areas of the city saw an improvement in air quality.

The figures prompted a warning from a university expert of the long-term health effects on residents.

But the government insisted air quality was in fact improving, saying the API as now calculated did not give the full picture – a response that raised questions from an environmental group about why it is still being used.

The number of hours last year when roadside pollution, measured by monitoring stations in Central, Causeway Bay and Mong Kok, exceeded an API of 100 totalled 2,007, up 14 per cent from 1,760 hours in 2007, and a six-year high.

An API of over 100 indicates the pollutants in the air pose immediate health risks, especially to people with respiratory or heart illnesses.

The API figures, published by the Environmental Protection Department, show that roadside air quality was the poorest in Central, where 1,013 hours of API readings over 100 were recorded, up 34.2 per cent from 2007. This was followed by Mong Kok, which had slightly fewer than 600 hours above the threshold, a drop of 18.1 per cent. In Causeway Bay, there were 402 hours of poor air quality, up 42.6 per cent from 2007.

An Environmental Protection Department spokeswoman said that as the API was based on just one of a list of pollutants that recorded the highest concentration on a given day, the readings did not represent the trend of air pollution concentrations.

“A more scientific, robust and commonly adopted approach by professionals to assess long-term air quality trends is to examine the annual trends of air pollutant concentrations,” she said.

Friends of the Earth environmental affairs officer Angus Wong Chung-yin found the explanation confusing.

“[It] shows the API is not sufficient to give the public an accurate picture of the air pollution if people are not able to draw a conclusion from the trend figures,” he said. “In this case, the government should review the approach and develop better indicators to help people understand the changing situation in air quality.”

On the department’s claim that roadside concentrations of some pollutants had fallen, Mr Wong admitted there had been an improvement, but it appeared to have levelled off since 2004.

Professor Wong Tze-wai, of Chinese University’s department of community and family medicine, said the health impact could be long-lasting. “Our research shows that an increase in 10 micrograms of a pollutant in every cubic metre of air will increase the rate of death, hospitalisation or treatment in a clinic by 1 to 1.5 per cent, depending on the type of the pollutant,” he said.

Roadside Air Pollution Levels Cannot Be Ignored

Jan 02, 2009 – Leader

More frequent clear skies over our city have helped boost the government’s claim that its efforts against air pollution are succeeding. To an extent, the claim is merited. The levels of some major pollutants have indeed fallen sharply. Their roadside concentrations have been reduced by about 20 per cent in the past decade. Among these are respirable suspended particulates, nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide, all of which pose a major health risk.

Improved visibility also means better safety for vessels and planes; and clear blue skies are good for Hong Kong’s international image, which has been tarnished by high air pollution. No one wants to remember the Pearl of the Orient as being engulfed in choking gray smog. But picture-perfect skies do not tell the whole story. What we see is not a good indicator of what we actually breathe into our lungs.

As we report today, the number of hours that roadside monitors have clocked up above the alarm level of 100 on the air pollution index has soared in the past year. The three monitoring stations in Central, Causeway Bay and Mong Kok recorded a total of 2,007 hours, up 14 per cent from 1,760 hours in 2007. Central alone recorded 1,013 hours, a jump of 34 per cent from the year before. Causeway Bay had 402 hours, up 42.6 per cent, but Mong Kok dropped about 18 per cent with 592 hours.

The Environmental Protection Department has argued that air pollution trends are best measured by the concentrations of pollutants rather than the number of hours the API goes above 100. To be sure, unfavourable weather patterns often contribute to high API levels, but they are not necessarily the cause of a long-term trend. Admittedly, the overall decade-long trends of major pollutants have seen their concentrations either falling or levelling off. Positive contributing factors include the conversion of taxis and minibuses to LPG, the introduction of ultra-low-sulfur diesel and tighter vehicle emission standards for buses. Tougher control measures imposed by Guangdong authorities are also a significant contribution.

However, the department’s arguments are not entirely convincing. Weather patterns work both ways. Just as unfavourable conditions can push up the API, favourable ones can help bring about clear skies. More misleading is the department’s claim that frequently high API readings at roadside levels are not a good indicator of air quality trends. The department itself sets up the index as a simple way to inform the public about air quality. Surely the amount of time the index measuring roadside pollution as being above alarm levels is a highly relevant factor to consider. Otherwise, the index has no use for the public.

Many air-quality objectives the department has achieved deserve recognition. But contrary indicators may also be a warning signal. During the recent economic boom years, the number of private cars has shot up. People should be discouraged from driving in congested districts, such as by pedestrianising more roads.

More importantly, a government review panel is close to finalising a study of stronger World Health Organisation standards on air quality introduced two years ago. Despite the tougher standards, the WHO does not impose them, but encourages individual cities to adopt a realistic plan to introduce them in phases. The panel should make adopting the WHO standards a matter of urgency. A world city needs clean air and world-class standards to maintain it.