Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

October, 2008:

Time Running Out For Smog Review

Time running out for smog review
Government fails to make progress in its examination of air pollution standards

Cheung Chi-fai – SCMP – Updated on Oct 08, 2008

A year after the government began reviewing Hong Kong’s outdated air-pollution standards, officials have made no firm commitments to new air-quality objectives – and the exercise is due to end in less than three months.

The lack of progress has prompted suspicions among people involved in the review that the government plans to take a politically expedient shortcut instead of proposing tough, far-reaching objectives that will genuinely protect public health.

The review was launched in response to calls to replace the city’s 20-year-old air-quality objectives with the latest World Health Organisation guidelines, which are up to three times as tough as Hong Kong’s current standards. No country has yet adopted the WHO’s standards.

Sources close to the review say there are signs officials on the advisory panel want to roll out more politically acceptable options.

“You can’t only look at things you believe are workable since the issue in question now is public health, which offers little room for compromise,” said one of the sources, who asked to remain anonymous.

“Unless you have set the targets based on scientific evidence of health protection, there is no way to tell if the control measures at different stages are enough and timely.”

A spokesman for the Environmental Protection Department would not directly answer that contention but said: “Consultants are still examining and evaluating the practicability and effectiveness of additional control measures available for ensuring the earliest possible improvement of our air quality.”

The department said it planned to hold a public forum to gather views on the review’s findings, with a public consultation next year.

Hong Kong’s 24-hour average standard for respirable suspended particles – one of the main health-threatening pollutants – is 180 micrograms per cubic metre, compared with the WHO’s guideline of 50.

The sources said the panel – comprising industry stakeholders, experts and officials – had spent too little time in the past year discussing targets and too much time gauging views on proposed control strategies.

Recommendations included increasing the use of natural gas in electricity generation to at least 50 per cent, more use of nuclear energy, electronic road pricing, phasing out polluting trucks and introducing low-emission zones – projected to reduce pollutants by tens of thousands of tonnes in the long term.

The sources said a commonly adopted review approach was to lay down targets adequate enough to protect health before considering measures – no matter what they were or how tough they were to achieve – to reach those targets in phases.

Citing the example of electronic road pricing, one of the sources said he saw no reason why 2015 had been earmarked for its implementation, given the direct health risks posed by polluting vehicles.

“When it comes to buying out chicken vendor licences for avian flu prevention, the government did it in two months,” the source said. “So I can’t see why it takes seven years for it to do road pricing.”

Earlier studies on the health effects of air pollution estimated it caused about 550 deaths a year and the use of 19,700 hospital bed days. Hongkongers’ life expectancy was estimated to be shortened by 16 months, on average, due to bad air.

The source said the current exercise should focus on laying down a clear institutional and legal framework in which to review air-quality standards based on scientific evidence. The principle of health protection should also be stated in the Air Pollution Control Ordinance.

Hahn Chu Hon-keung, Friends of the Earth’s environmental affairs manager, said the public’s health would be at risk if the government turned a blind eye to scientific fact.

“How can the government pacify the souls of those who have died of air pollution if it seeks to politicise health issues arising from air pollution, hoping to delay what it can do by evading fundamental issues?” he asked.

EPA Is 16 Years Behind Legal Requirement For Reviewing NOx Rule

WASHINGTON, Oct. 7 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — The Environmental Integrity Project (EIP) and the Sierra Club put the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on notice today that they intend to sue the agency for violating its duty to review and update its emissions standard for nitric acid plants at least once every eight years, as required under the Clean Air Act. The two parties are represented by the Environmental and Natural Resources Law Clinic (ENRLC) at Vermont Law School.

In addition to compelling EPA to update its nitrogen oxide (NOx) emission standard, EIP and Sierra Club want EPA to start controlling nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from nitric acid plants. N2O is a powerful greenhouse gas. It is 310 times more potent than carbon dioxide in terms of its global warming potential. Nitric acid plants are, by far, the largest industrial source of N2O emissions in the United States, and these emissions would be surprisingly easy to control.

Eric Schaeffer, director, Environmental Integrity Project, said: “There are cost-effective ways to reduce nitrous oxide, using off-the-shelf technologies that have been available for years. This is one of easiest ways for EPA to start making a dent in global warming emissions.”

If EPA does not commence a review of the new source performance standard (NSPS) for NOx during the required 60-day notice period, the parties will seek a court order compelling EPA to review its standards for controlling nitrogen oxide emissions from nitric acid plants. The NOx standard has not been revised since it was adopted in 1971, and the last review took place twenty-four years ago, in 1984. This means EPA has missed its deadline by a full 16 years.

Teresa Clemmer, associate director, ENRLC, said: “This is yet another example of regulatory foot-dragging that has become so commonplace at the EPA. Much more effective and affordable technologies have been available for many years, and EPA should get started updating its regulation without any further delay.”

Better technologies, capable of substantially reducing NOx emissions, have emerged during EPA’s long period of delay. In fact, EPA issued a report in 1991 describing some of these technologies, yet it has failed to apply these findings to the nitric acid industry.

Using outdated technologies has real world consequences. NOx — a precursor to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and ground-level ozone — is an important public health concern.

David Bookbinder, chief climate counsel, Sierra Club said: “EPA is well aware that PM2.5 is causally linked with heart disease, asthma, and lung cancer. Vulnerable populations, such as the elderly, children, and asthmatics, face the greatest risk. EPA must do a better job of protecting the public from the serious health threats posed by NOx emissions.”

EIP and the Sierra Club believe EPA should move quickly to review and revise the NSPS for nitric acid plants. Take Louisiana, for instance, which has several nitric acid plants. Many citizens of Louisiana are suffering health problems relating to NOx emissions, and the state has been ravaged by climate change.

A copy of the notice of intent letter is available at http://www.environmentalintegrity.org.

ABOUT THE GROUPS

The Environmental Integrity Project (http://www.environmentalintegrity.org) is a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization established in March of 2002 by former EPA enforcement attorneys to advocate for effective enforcement of environmental laws. EIP has three goals: 1) to provide objective analyses of how the failure to enforce or implement environmental laws increases pollution and affects public health; 2) to hold federal and state agencies, as well as individual corporations, accountable for failing to enforce or comply with environmental laws; and 3) to help local communities obtain the protection of environmental laws.

The Sierra Club members and supporters number more than 1.3 million. Inspired by nature, the Sierra Club and its members work together to protect communities and the planet. The Club is America’s oldest, largest and most influential grassroots environmental organization. For more information, go to http://www.sierraclub.org on the Web.

Vermont Law School (VLS) — a private, independent institution — is top-ranked in environmental law by U.S. News & World Report. VLS offers a Juris Doctor (JD) curriculum that emphasizes public service, a Master of Environmental Law and Policy (MELP) degree for lawyers and nonlawyers, and two post-JD degrees, the Master of Laws (LLM) in Environmental Law and the LLM in American Legal Studies (for international students). The school also features innovative experiential programs and is home to the Environmental Law Center and the South Royalton Legal Clinic. For more information, visit http://www.vermontlaw.edu.

SOURCE Environmental Integrity Project; Sierra Club; Vermont Law College
Published Oct. 7, 2008
Copyright © 2008 SYS-CON Media. All Rights Reserved.

Beijing Smog Takes Shine Off ‘Golden Week’

Al Guo – SCMP – Updated on Oct 04, 2008

The National Day “golden week” holiday ushered in the predicted post-Olympic deterioration in air quality, with the capital suffering four consecutive days of “light air pollution” up to yesterday.

Smog, the hallmark of bad air quality, has hovered above Beijing since Tuesday, the second day of the holiday, and there is little hope of the pollution clearing any time soon because many of the official measures put in place to combat air pollution ended with the Paralympics.

The Beijing Environmental Protection Bureau said the Air Pollution Index stood at 106 on Tuesday, 104 on Wednesday and 126 on Thursday before dropping back to 108 yesterday. Any number higher than 100 is considered light pollution and can cause breathing problems.

By comparison, the index during the August-September Olympic and Paralympic period was below 50 on 10 of the 17 days of the Olympics and between 50 and 100 on the others.

For the 12 days of the Paralympics last month, the Air Pollution Index was below 50 on two days and between 50 and 100 on the others.

Air quality during the Olympics was aided by a series of government orders that shut down work at construction sites, took about half of the vehicles off the street and stopped production at polluting factories in and around Beijing.

But these measures ended with the conclusion of the Olympics, clearing the way for a return to smoggy skies.

Liang Xiaoyan, general manager of Friends of Nature, one of China’s best-known environmental-protection groups, was not surprised by the smog’s return.

“We all knew what we would get after those temporary measures were dead,” Ms Liang said.

She said she doubted authorities would now place environmental concerns ahead of other priorities, such as economic development.

“Do you want to encourage the development of the vehicle industry for a better economy, or do you want to curb the industry for a better environment? Without addressing such fundamental questions, there is no way environmental protection will top the government’s agenda.”

But there are signs of change. The city announced that from next Saturday every car would have to stay off the road one day a week until April to help ease congestion and reduce emissions.

Ms Liang said that even though her organisation was expecting bigger policy changes, it was willing to push ahead with even small moves that could help improve air quality.

She said Friends of Nature was trying to identify five main streets in the capital best and worst suited for cycling.

The study will be submitted to Beijing lawmakers this month in the hope of encouraging more bicycle-friendly policies.

Street Fighting

HK MAGAZINE – October 3rd, 2008

Look both ways before crossing this one
From pollution to urban renewal and quality of life, a lot of Hong Kong’s problems can be traced back to unnecessary road construction, writes John Robertson.

Which is more important in Hong Kong—cars or you? If you read the pedestrian chapter of the Transport Department’s official “Road User’s Code,” you are bombarded with images of people fleeing for their lives or cowering in fear of the next luxury sedan barreling around the corner. “Look out for traffic turning into the road in which you are crossing,” warns one passage, “the driver may not see you or give way to you.” Another warns, “Before crossing a driveway, look all around for approaching traffic and listen. If there is no approaching traffic likely to use the entrance or driveway then carry on. Do not loiter in a driveway but walk straight across it.”

The pro-vehicle bias in this guidebook is emblematic of a larger, and much more disturbing one that guides all of our town planning, and has caused its fair share of controversy over the years. Remember the destruction of the Central Star Ferry Pier? That was part of the Central reclamation area, a project designed to introduce a bypass from Central to Wan Chai. Meanwhile, the proposed extension of Route 4 through Pok Fu Lam and Kennedy Town, which architect, planner and designer Peter Cookson Smith calls unnecessary and says “will spoil the shoreline for pedestrians,” has also caused an outpouring of opposition. Other contentious future plans include the demolition of Temple Street to build a highway connecting West and East Kowloon (refer to map, right, for list). Cars take precedent over pedestrianized areas, sidewalks, and road crossings. Many walkways in the city are flanked by metal barriers and railings, making crossing difficult. All of this despite the fact that cars remain a luxury item in Hong Kong, affordable only for the upper and upper-middle classes—no more than 5.3 percent of Hong Kongers are owners—and wholly unnecessary with Hong Kong’s first-rate public transport system soon expanding to the very places where new roads are being planned.

Designing Hong Kong convenor Paul Zimmerman is one of the many people fed up with kowtowing to vehicles. “Road planning here goes on ahead of actual urban planning, and whatever’s left over of the land goes in for zoning at the Town Planning Board,” Zimmerman says, citing the West Kowloon and new Central Waterfront projects as prime examples. Accordingly, Civic Exchange chief executive Christine Loh says, “the government’s planning process gives priority to building roads without considering good town planning or air quality.”

Such rampant road building—ordered by the government ostensibly to relieve both current and future, hypothetical congestion—ruins our cityscape and has exacerbated our already dangerous pollution problem.

Land reclamation for the Central-Wan Chai BypassMuch of this pedestrian-unfriendly urban design is inherited from outdated colonial planning procedures, conceived long before Hong Kong declared itself an aspiring world city. As Friends of the Earth chairman Edwin Lau emphasizes, “rather than sustainable development, in the past everybody was talking about ‘efficiency.’” The official wisdom was that building new, wide roads increased efficiency and reduced congestion. Shortsighted bureaucrats failed to see that without adequate controls on the number of vehicles in the city, more roads would only serve to encourage more cars.
Our government still seems to be trapped in that way of thinking. Together with Wesley Wan, the president of the Hong Kong Automobile Association, they cite a growing influx of cross-border vehicles over the coming decades as one major justification for new roads. Yet as Civil and Structural Engineering Professor Hung Wing-tat of the Polytechnic University points out, “once you build a road, it stimulates development and generates traffic, and you end up with a chicken-and-egg scenario.” Far from thinking ahead, government planners are fixated on short-term goals. Hung believes that “the head of planning just thinks, ‘if I can do this in my term, then I can retire and the next guy can take care of the situation.’”

The existing administrative structure only promotes such narrow-mindedness. Currently, no single authority oversees the design of the city, which is a clumsy, piecemeal process. Professor Patrick Lau, an architect and planning legislator, puts Hong Kong’s “most essential planning and design problems” down to the fact that Roads and Railways Ordinances and the Town Panning Ordinance are entirely separate, despite their overlapping concerns. The Transport Department reports to the Chief Executive, while the Town Planning Board, through which public consultations are held, is powerless to stop its roads, and is forced to zone around them afterwards.

Construction on the Stonecutters BridgeOn top of all this, it doesn’t help that a continuous stream of money is allocated to infrastructure projects by an outdated funding mechanism. In 1982, the colonial government created the Capital Works Reserve Fund, a repository for all revenue from land sales. All money from this fund was designated solely for infrastructure projects. Decades later, when major projects have become not only unnecessary but detrimental to the city’s environment, the fund is still collecting money for them. Rather than redirecting the funds to areas where it might be needed—improving quality of life, addressing the widening rich-poor gap—the government continues to channel it toward unnecessary roads and bridges.

Part of this comes down to the same focus on short-term benefits. Yet many also suggest that the government is susceptible to influence from the developers and construction companies who have profited from such infrastructure projects and have a vested interest in keeping them going. The Route 4 extension is itself being built to provide extra vehicle access to new hotel developments proposed for the area, and Professor Hung notes that “there is further pressure on the government from people who want to develop places such as the Southern District industrial area, with its vacant factories.”

No Exit?
Many experts believe the government and private car owners can get out of our vehicle-centric mindset, but it will take some forceful prodding. Since these new roads are intended to reduce congestion, one obvious alternative would be to reduce the number of cars on the roads. This can be accomplished by introducing more fuel taxes, and higher import and registration taxes for car owners, such as is done in Singapore. The Transport Department’s own records show that such a policy would be effective. During the years 1982 to 1986, the number of private cars licensed in Hong Kong dropped every year due to rising license fees and registration taxes. When the fees and taxes were rescinded in 1987, the number of private car registrations went up again.

Aside from controlling car ownership, congestion can also be reduced through means such as road pricing. Studies on Singaporean-style Electronic Road Pricing have been conducted by the government for more than two decades, yet no measures have ever been implemented. When we pressed the government on the issue, they concedes that road pricing could come into effect on Hong Kong Island, but only after the completion of the Central-Wan Chai Bypass. But many experts agree that that is not enough. According to Zimmerman, road pricing will also soon be necessary in Kowloon too, if you consider the government’s projections for more cross-border traffic in the coming decades. “The new roads to China can only be financed by having more vehicles going over them, and the only way we can stop those vehicles from going to places like Mong Kok is by road pricing, not by simply building more roads elsewhere.”

These measures would all go a long way toward curbing congestion, but would not solve the overall problem of needless, controversial road construction. That would require a comprehensive overhaul of the planning procedures. Road planning would need to be submitted to the Town Planning Board, where the public could be consulted about the bigger picture of the outline zoning plans—as opposed to the piecemeal, post-zoning consultation that happens at the moment. That kind of reform, guided by what is essentially the democratic involvement of the public, might be a little farther down the road than anyone would like.

Roads to Nowehere

As if we haven’t got enough already, the government is planning to build several more highways in the next 30 years. Here’s the short list.

1.  Tuen Mun—Chek Lap Kok Link
To aid in linking the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macao Bridge to the city, an underwater tunnel will be built to link the Tung Chung exit of the bridge to Tuen Mun. This is also planned to link with the soon-to-be-completed West Tuen Mun Bypass, which will be a major passageway to the western border checkpoint with China.

2. Route 8
We already have two bridges linking Tsing Yi—but soon we’ll have a third. The Stonecutters Bridge (crossing Stonecutters Island), currently under construction, will become the backbone of a new passageway linking Tsing Yi and Cheung Sha Wan. It should be in use by next year.

3. Central Kowloon Bypass
The rationale? Build a highway to link Tsim Sha Tsui to Kai Tak to take enhance the development of the latter. The damage? The route might go straight through Temple Street, destroying one of our most precious cultural gems. Which sounds more important to you?

4. Route 4 (Kennedy Town to Aberdeen)
No one quite understands this—the government has decided to build two rail lines linking Aberdeen and west Hong Kong Island to north Hong Kong Island, and yet they are still considering building a highway linking the two districts. Are we that road-crazy?

5. Central-Wanchai Bypass
Let’s recap—the government says roads in Central and Wan Chai are way too congested and we therefore need to build a new highway linking the two districts. Running out of land to do so? Let’s reclaim some. And of course, many experts believe that the most surefire way to attract more traffic is to build more roads.


A Good Road Model

Think Hong Kong is running out of land for roads? Think of Singapore. The city-state, just two-thirds the size of Hong Kong, has imposed strict measures to control the number of privately owned vehicles on the road. The four major measures they imposed are not exactly rocket science, and our government has been studying them for years. But don’t expect to see them all in action here just quite yet. While we don’t necessarily advocate all of them, certainly a combination of deterants can solve our congestion problems without having to build new roads. Here are the four measures.

Imposing a Quota
Under the Vehicle Quota Scheme, would-be car owners bid each month for a limited number of Certificates of Entitlement, required for purchase of any vehicle and valid for only ten years. Bidding prices are so high (currently almost HK$77,000 for one) that it’s simply stupid to try and get one, unless of course you are fabulously rich.

High Vehicle Taxes
Bidding for a certificate is just the first step in a long and expensive procedure when it comes to owning a car in Singapore. Car buyers need to pay 150 percent of the car’s value as a registration fee, then a 41 percent customs duty, and finally an additional $5,446 fee for a private vehicle.

Yet More Taxes—The Road Tax
Next up are road taxes. They are renewable on a six-month or annual basis and the amount depends on your engine capacity. You also need to have your car inspected every two years (at your cost of course) in order to pay the road tax.

Pricing the Roads
Upon purchasing a car in Singapore, you also have to buy a device for the Electronic Road Pricing system and install it in your vehicle. The system employs a pay per use scheme, with different rates charged depending on which expressway or major road you use and at what time of the day. There is no charge during off-peak hours.

So How Expensive Exactly?

Taking all the above into account, buying an Audi A4 costs you roughly $990,993 in Singapore, while in Hong Kong, only $408,300.

Hong Kong Pioneers Sustainable Construction

by David Masters – October 3, 2008 – Fair Home

Hong Kong city government plans to lead the way in green construction, by ensuring that new flagship infrastructure projects are built according to strict environmental standards.

Ten ‘mega projects’ are planned for the city state, to upgrade the city’s infrastructure.

Projects include new railway lines, cross-boundary infrastructure, new development areas, and a cultural district.

The projects will be used to showcase techniques for sustainable construction.

Secretary for Development, Carrie Lam, announced the projects in Australia at the World Sustainable Building Conference, after visiting sustainable building projects in the country.

Lam said the projects will enable Hong Kong to adapt to sustainable and environmental construction practices, and will involve partnership between the public and private sector to ensure that the projects are a success.

In the past, Hong Kong has been criticised for its heavy pollution and lack of concern for environmental issues.

Past initiatives – including lights out days and measures to reduce shipping industry emissions – have failed to have a lasting effect on the city’s image.

‘Yellow-Label’ Cars Face Ban in Beijing

‘Yellow-label’ cars face ban from city in green drive

Zhuang Pinghui – SCMP – Updated on Oct 03, 2008

Beijing will phase out polluting vehicles known as “yellow-label” cars over the next year in a bid to improve the capital’s notoriously poor air quality.

Beijing issues yellow labels to cars whose emission levels fail to meet Euro I standards and green labels to those that do. The city has around 357,000 yellow-label vehicles; most are heavy trucks. Most domestic vehicles manufactured before 1996 or imported ones manufactured before 1998 are in the yellow category.

Xinhua reported that municipal authorities ordered all yellow-label government vehicles off the road from Monday and those involved in ancillary services, such as refuse transport, replaced within a year.

From January 1, all yellow-label vehicles, except those involved in food supplies and refuse transport, will be banned within the Fifth Ring Road. The ban will extend to the Sixth Ring Road, close to the boundary with Hebei province, on October 1 next year.

Xinhua said yellow-label vehicles accounted for only 10 per cent of the total in Beijing but were responsible for more than half of total vehicle emissions.

Traffic control measures, including daylight bans on yellow-label cars, were implemented for the Olympics and the Paralympics to ensure improved air quality.

The report cited a Tsinghua University survey as saying during the Olympic period pollutants from vehicles had declined by 30 to 40 per cent.

It quoted Beijing Environmental Protection Bureau official Feng Yuqiao as saying that nighttime air pollution levels were 15 to 20 per cent higher than in the day mainly because of the yellow-label vehicles coming into the city in the evening.

The ban on the polluting vehicles is part of a series of post-Olympics car restrictions that take effect this month in the hope of sustaining smooth traffic and good air quality after the Games.

Under the new traffic restrictions from October 11, 30 per cent of government vehicles will be garaged and the remainder of government vehicles and private cars will take turns on the roads on weekdays depending on their number plates.

The ban will apply from 6am to 9pm for private cars and around the clock for government and corporate vehicles. It is expected to cut Beijing’s average traffic flow by 6.5 per cent and speed up traffic within the Fifth Ring Road by 8 per cent.

Mainland Firms To Increase Emission Reduction Projects – Future Of Carbon Credit Trade Dim As Global Pact Nears End

SCMP, Eric Ng – Oct 02, 2008

The mainland is expected to supply more than half the credits for greenhouse-gas emission trading worldwide until 2012, but the future of such trade remains uncertain as no agreement has been hammered out for when the current global pact expires.

Emission reduction projects on the mainland would cut 116.83 million tonnes of carbon dioxide discharged in each of the next four years, or 52.17 per cent of the global total, according to United Nations data. That represents a sharp increase from 16.61 million tonnes in May 2006, or 30.67 per cent of the global total.

So far, 1,551 projects have been approved by Beijing while 269 projects have also been accepted by and registered at the UN, accounting for 23 per cent of the global total.

Developers of pollution-cutting projects earn so-called carbon credits that can be sold to polluters in countries with mandatory emission limits, primarily in Europe and Japan, which are committed to reduction targets.

Annual greenhouse-gas emission credits from the mainland would amount to more than US$2.5 billion under the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), according to a report by World Wide Fund for Nature on China’s emission reduction credits market.

Beijing also collects a levy from a percentage of the credits depending on the type of project.

Feng Shengbo, an associate researcher at National Development and Reform Commission Energy Research Institute’s CDM Project Management Centre, said the government had so far collected more than 100 million yuan (HK$112.48 million), which would be used to help the nation combat climate change.

The most popular projects on the mainland include the replacement of ozone-depleting refrigerants, wind and hydro power generation and energy efficiency improvement.

Of the emission reduction volume in projects approved by the central government, about 23 per cent or 27.45 million tonnes came from the five national state-owned power generation firms.

China and India are among the developing nations that have ratified the Kyoto Protocol, a global pact on greenhouse gas reduction, but they are only required to report their emissions and are not committed to any targets.

The United States rejects emission limits set by protocol, but it is widely expected the country, together with China and India, which are among the world’s largest polluters, will commit to some form of reduction after the protocol expires in 2012.

However, Merrill Lynch director of Asia-Pacific commodities solutions Jennifer Jiang Hongbo said uncertainties over the regulatory environment after the protocol expired and Beijing’s ban on credit sales beyond that meant no such credits had been sold so far.

“This has brought valuation challenges for such trade,” she said. “In addition, the sellers prefer to save the credits for themselves ahead of potential emission reduction commitments by China.”

HK’s Take On Climate Crisis Hits The Big Screen

Yau Chui-yan – SCMP – Oct 01, 2008

An Inconvenient Truth, the documentary about global warming presented by former US vice-president Al Gore, was a box-office blockbuster that brought global warming to the world’s attention.

Now Hong Kong is going to have its own version of An Inconvenient Truth, albeit shorter and not presented by a green statesman.

From today, a 30-second movie trailer called Climate Crisis will screen in eight Broadway cinemas around the city. The short will screen for three weeks, and is expected to reach more than 55,000 viewers.

It will be the first such film specifically targeting a Hong Kong audience and highlighting climate change.

Oxfam Hong Kong, which produced the film, hopes the short will attract younger audiences and get them to pay more attention to the consequences of global warming.

“It is more effective to arouse people’s attention by using moving images in cinemas, as people are sitting there attentively,” Fiona Shek Hoi-wai, the communications officer of Oxfam Hong Kong, said.

In the movie trailer, a young Hong Kong girl uses a hair dryer and leaves the fridge door open for a long time, just as many people do in their daily lives. The movie contrasts such behaviour with footage of ice melting at the North Pole and someone losing their family because of flooding.

“The film is intended to arouse people’s consciousness about the relationship between excessive consumption of energy and damage to somebody’s home elsewhere,” Ms Shek said.

“To many people in Hong Kong, climate change is only about the environment. However, this is not the full picture: climate change also affects many people’s lives. The girl in the movie can use moisture cream when the weather is dry. However, for people in Africa, the dryness will affect agriculture and damage the people’s livelihoods.”

Producers Huang Kwai-fung, 28, and Chow Tze-chun, 23, said their understanding of climate change increased markedly from producing the movie.

“Some of my friends did question the relationship between our excessive consumption of energy and disasters happening elsewhere. However, I became deeply impressed [by the strength of that relationship] while making this movie,” said Huang, who was a prize winner at this year’s Hong Kong Independent Short Film and Video Awards. The production cost HK$15,000.

Mong Kok Pollution ‘Three Times’ WHO Levels

Peter So – SCMP – Updated on Oct 01, 2008

A green group and legislator warned the worsening air quality at tourist spots would scare off visitors, and are urging government to tighten the air-quality measuring standards.

Greenpeace have conducted on-site monitoring of the levels of respiratory suspended particulates (PM-10) and fine suspended particulates (PM-2.5) on Monday and Tuesday this week – prior to the peak tourist period of “Golden Week” – in a pedestrian area of Mong Kok.

The experiment discovered that the concentration levels of both particulates had three times exceeded the World Health Organisation’s most stringent standards. It means tourists and local residents’ health could be threatened if they are exposed to the area for several hours.

Paul Tse Wai-chun, a legislator in the tourism sector, said the poor air quality would damage the city’s image in the long run.

An earlier survey found 48.8 per cent of local tourist guides had received complaints from tourists about the city’s air pollution, Greenpeace said.

Meanwhile, Mr Tse called on the government to amend the air-quality measuring standards in accord of the WHO guidelines which [were] established in 2006.

The current government standards had been adopted since 1987, and it did not include PM-2.5 – which research suggests can penetrate deep into human lungs and have more severe health effects than larger particulates.

“The current standards are too loose and outdated,” said Mr Tse.

He said it is the responsibility of the government to update the Environmental Protection Department’s Air Pollution Index to let the public know the real situation of air pollution.

Mr Tse added that initiatives to improve the “wall effect” created by high-rise buildings and the control of traffic flow in busy districts should be undertaken.

Despite the government would commission a study to review the air-quality objectives and development a long-term management strategy, Greenpeace campaigner Prentice Koo Wai-muk said the government has no time-table to amend current standards to meet the WHO’s more stringent standards progressively.

And the green group would update a “Real Air Pollution Index” on the website – www.airtruth.org – which would monitor air pollutants including sulphur dioxide, ozone, respirable suspended particles and nitrogen dioxide with the updated WHO standards.

Meanwhile, Greenpeace has made travel tips on the city’s scenic spots with better air quality to tourists. Mr Tse said the government can promote those spots as a remedy.