Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

October, 2008:

Beijing’s New Traffic Rules Fail To Curb Gridlock, Pollution

Agence France-Presse in Beijing – SCMP – Updated on Oct 13, 2008

Beijing rolled out new traffic control measures on Monday, but they had little effect as the capital’s roads remained clogged and a grey smog shrouded the city.

The new measures, which are less strict than curbs used during the Beijing Olympics in August, are aimed at banning the city’s 3.3 million cars from the road for one day a week each, based on license plate numbers.

But Beijing Television’s morning traffic programme showed the capital’s streets jammed up as usual, while small accidents around the city ensured gridlock on many roads.

As Monday was the first day of the new system, police were not levying the 100 yuan (US$13) fine for drivers violating the ban. The fines will begin next week, local media said.

According to the system, license plates ending with one or six will be banned from the roads on Monday, plates ending with two and seven on Tuesday, three and eight on Wednesday and so on.

The rules, which only apply from 6am until 9pm and do not include weekends, are also supposed to curb air pollution, but Beijing’s normally grey, smoggy sky was on full display on Monday.

Despite the gridlock during the morning rush hour, officials insisted the new rules had improved traffic flow.

“Normally the traffic here moves at between 15 and 20 kilometres per hour [nine to 12 miles an hour], today it has been moving as fast as 40 kilometres an hour,” a policeman on one of Beijing’s ring roads told state television.

Beijing’s air is among the most polluted in the world, and the problem is getting worse with about 1,000 new private automobiles bought each day by increasingly affluent city residents.

The tighter Olympic restrictions, which expired on September 20, had limited private motorists to driving on alternate days, removing more than a million vehicles from the streets each day.

The measures led to unusually blue skies. Authorities said atmospheric data showed Beijing enjoyed its best air quality in a decade thanks to the measures.

Pollution Stains Image

SCMP – Updated on Oct 13, 2008

I have just returned from San Francisco and again can’t get over the difference in air quality.

When I say I’m from Hong Kong, the terrible air quality is almost always mentioned and the fact that the government seems to be in a state of denial over the problem.

People do not even want to go on holiday here so how about us poor residents? So much is being said and done about the tainted milk powder; while that is certainly awful, a lot more of our children are going to have terrible long-term health problems due to the air pollution.

Admittedly, some of the problem has to do with the mainland, but at least the Hong Kong government could immediately put a ban on all idling engines in Hong Kong and cross-border trucks and coaches.

Suzanne Chung, Mong Kok

Beijing To Reinstate Car Ban

Associated Press | 11 October 2008

Beijing will ban half of its 3.4 million cars from the roads during periods of very heavy pollution, state media reported yesterday. The city would temporarily reinstate measures introduced during the Olympic Games and ban cars on alternate days – depending on whether their number plates were odd or even – if pollution rose to extreme levels, the reports said. Work would also be suspended at construction sites and high-polluting factories. The restrictions will be imposed only if the air pollution index reaches 300, a threshold far above the city’s normal air quality level.

Mixed Success

Daniel Sin – SCMP – Updated on Oct 11, 2008

The chief executive set a hefty agenda in 2007 and achieved much of it, but many targets were modest and major challenges remain, writes Daniel Sin in his final article ahead of Wednesday’s policy address

Twelve months ago, the chief executive made more than 60 pledges to promote economic and community development and foster social harmony. Donald Tsang Yam-kuen’s 2007 policy address was titled “A New Direction for Hong Kong” and, to achieve this lofty goal, he proposed 10 major infrastructural projects, a number of measures to protect the environment and conserve heritage, and various initiatives to improve the welfare of the poor.

One year on, many of his environmental and welfare proposals have come to fruition, but his success with the infrastructural projects has been mixed.

And experts argue that many other achievements – on the environmental front, in particular – are limited by the fact that the targets were modest. Little progress has been made on air pollution, for example, the single biggest environmental issue.

Mr Tsang predicted that the infrastructural projects, which he intended to press ahead with during his term of office, would create 250,000 jobs and add more than HK$100 billion to the economy.

Of the 10 projects, only six have definite construction timetables: the MTR South Island line; the Sha Tin-Central rail link; the West Kowloon Cultural District; the Tuen Mun Western Bypass; the Tuen Mun-Chek Lap Kok link; and the Hong Kong-Macau-Zhuhai bridge. All are targeted to start before 2011.

Timetables for the remaining four – the Kai Tak development, Lok Ma Chau loop, Chek Lap Kok-Shenzhen Airport rail link and new development areas in the northern New Territories – are less definite.

Legislator Patrick Lau Sau-shing is confident the rail projects will proceed as scheduled but he is alarmed at the lack of progress with the Kai Tak project, which comprises a cruise terminal and various low-density residential developments and community facilities.

“The chief executive should give up-to-date progress of the various projects,” Professor Lau said. “All the issues have been resolved and there should be nothing to hinder the development of Kai Tak. The government should speed up the project.”

The engineering sector is not overly concerned about delays as long as works contracts can be churned out steadily to keep the industry occupied, according to Institute of Engineers vice-president Reuben Chu Pui-kwan.

“Delays in construction projects are not uncommon, particularly where the community plays an increasingly greater role in development projects. And for projects that involved co-operation with, and participation of, mainland authorities, progress is sometimes beyond the government’s control,” Mr Chu said.

“What the government should do is to phase in the infrastructure projects, and should have longer-term planning on the works programme. This would ensure that the sector would have steady demand. In the past, projects were either cramped together at the same time, leading to a sharp increase in the salaries of engineers and workers, or we had no projects at all.”

Lawmaker Raymond Ho Chung-tai agreed that Mr Tsang should push ahead – at least to the stage where major works contracts could be tendered out.

However, he was concerned about there being insufficient consultation.

“For projects such as the Lok Ma Chau loop, and new development areas, the government must do a better job on environmental protection and conservation. Public consultation should be conducted thoroughly, even if it means some delay to the works schedule,” said Mr Ho.

That was preferable to aborting works at an advanced stage when the government had to revise its plans.

He said the Kai Tak cruise terminal was a classic example. Because the government had decided to build it on its own, he was worried it would not canvas the views of future operators.

“I am concerned that the government would construct something that the trade cannot use,” he said.

Mr Ho hoped the policy address would include some evidence that the government was planning beyond the projects already announced.

“For example, the financial secretary chaired a committee to look into the north Lantau Island development a couple of years ago. Nothing has been heard since. The chief executive should explain what progress has been achieved and should consider reviving the logistic parks proposal,” he said.

With regard to the environment, Edwin Lau Che-feng, director of green group Friends of the Earth (HK), said Mr Tsang appeared to have achieved a lot because he had cast his net wide.

The government has issued carbon-audit guidelines, concluded an agreement to better regulate emissions by power companies and introduced a law requiring a changeover from industrial diesel to ultra-low-sulphur diesel. It has also implemented the Greening Master Plan, and injected HK$1 billion into the Environment Conservation Fund to step up education and research.

Mr Lau said the government’s achievements were modest. The power companies had plenty of room to reduce emissions and their schemes of control were due for renewal anyway, so it wasn’t hard to put higher emission standards in the new agreement.

And the diesel changeover was insignificant because the level of industrial diesel use was low, he added.

However, little progress had been made with the most pressing environmental concern – air pollution.

“People consider air pollution as the most serious [environmental issue], but has the chief executive given the strongest prescription to cure the problem? Are the measures effective? A few years ago, the government set aside HK$3.2 billion as subsidies to encourage drivers to replace heavy-diesel vehicles with cleaner models. However, the take-up rate has been very low. Many polluting vehicles are still on the road,” said Mr Lau.

“The government should do more. It could impose a timetable to require truck operators to replace polluting vehicles while at the same time increase the subsidy. This will give the trade both a carrot and stick to help improve air quality.”

Mr Tsang has completed the public consultations he promised on mandatory implementation of building energy codes, and on legislation requiring motorists to switch off idling engines.

However, Mr Lau felt that these were not enough. “Conducting public consultation is easy. It is more important to implement the legislation and, even then, there must be sufficient resources given to enforce the regulations to ensure that they are fully compiled with.”

On heritage conservation, the government has imposed a requirement for impact assessments on all public works projects involving heritage sites.

Earlier this year, a commissioner for heritage office was set up and a financial assistance maintenance scheme launched to encourage private owners to protect their historical buildings. Heritage activist Daniel Cheung said the government should be doing more to promote the maintenance scheme, including meeting owners of historic buildings and encouraging them to apply.

Mr Cheung suggested Mr Tsang set up a task force to co-ordinate the efforts of different departments in conservation matters.

“There are legal, financial and administrative issues to sort out among government departments. A central co-ordinating body is required to put efforts together.”

One area in which Mr Tsang does get a pass mark is that of social welfare. Hong Kong University social work Professor Nelson Chow Wing-sun said Mr Tsang had delivered what he promised in setting aside HK$1 billion to fund 3,000 three-year employment opportunities for young people, set up the Task Force on Youth Drug Abuse, and provide 12 years of free education.

He noted that the government has spent HK$300 million to set up the Child Development Fund, pledged HK$60 million for improving residential care for the elderly, and earmarked another HK$200 million for home maintenance for the elderly.

Professor Chow cautioned that there were three issues that still had to be addressed.

“The chief executive has announced that government would promote social enterprise actively but, apart from organising a summit last year, little has been achieved. With unemployment likely to rise, and poverty becoming more widespread, the government must put more effort into this area. In the Hong Kong context, social enterprises may not create as many jobs as the chief executive has hoped unless government can secure co-operation from large corporations.” He doubted if that was possible.

Professor Chow said there also needed to be a clear direction on whether the old-age allowance should be increased.

“I would suggest that, rather than giving an across-the-board increase, the government should provide an income supplement to those elderly people who do not meet the asset-limit criteria to receive comprehensive social security assistance payments, but are still facing financial hardship,” he said.

Professor Chow also said that little had been done to improve the conditions of the poor in remote areas like Tin Shui Wai. “The proposed housing scheme for elderly persons in Tin Shui Wai is not an elderly home project. It would not contribute towards creating significant employment opportunities in the area. The government speculated that some 800 jobs can be created, but it would be lucky to have 200,” he said.

“And the suggestion to promote factory outlet business is not practical because the location is too remote to attract shoppers.”

Beijing Goes (Reluctantly) Off-Road

China Journal –Juliet Ye – October 10, 2008, 7:14 am

Beijing’s private car restrictions are set to go into effect tomorrow, in an effort to bring back the days of clean air and more peaceful street’s the bustling city enjoyed during the Olympics. Naturally, many of the city’s road warriors aren’t happy about it.

Under this new restriction, which covers the heavily metropolitan area surrounded by Beijing’s Fifth Ring road, private cars with licensed plate numbers ending with a 1 or 6 can’t be on the road on Mondays. Those with 2 or 7 as the last digit are banned on Tuesday, 3 or 8 on Wednesday, 4 or 9 one Thursday and 5 or 0 on Friday. On weekends, all cars are allowed on roads.

The restrictions follow bans earlier this month on the number of government and corporate vehicles, a popular measure among Beijingers. But the restrictions on private cars are “unfair,” say many drivers in polls and online. An unscientific online survey on the Web site of the People’s Daily, the state-run newspaper, 68% out of 400,000 voters said that “it’s pointless to ban private cars.”

Web users packed online forums and listed reasons to “say no” to restrictions on private cars, and major web portals are hosting forums for people upset with the new regulations.

Netizen “endless99″ made a comparison between the subway maps in Beijing and several other cities, including Hong Kong and London. The person concluded, “The ban can only work out the traffic problems temporarily. Mature metropolitans such as Hong Kong and Tokyo all have well-served urban public transport system.” (The post in Chinese.)

One Web user wrote a blog post, titled “We Are Extremely Upset About the New Restrictions,” that the restrictions discriminate against those in the suburbs.

“How about those out of the Fifth Ring circle? We all paid the same amount of tax. It’s really unfair,” the user said, adding, “who is going to pay for my taxi?” (The post in Chinese.)

Others are unhappy with the lack of proper administrative procedure in getting the restrictions out. In an online poll on Sohu.com, 93% out of 6,000 people participating said “the restrictions on private cars should have been deliberated by the National People’s Congress before it went out.”

Demand To Adopt WHO Guidelines

Cheung Chi-fai – SCMP – Updated on Oct 09, 2008

Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen should endorse the World Health Organisation’s air-quality guidelines in his policy address next week to protect the public from the adverse health effects of air pollution, a green group said yesterday.

Friends of the Earth also called on the government to push ahead with measures to curb roadside air pollution, such as forcing all pre-Euro and Euro I diesel commercial vehicles, including franchised buses, off the roads before 2010.

The calls came after the South China Morning Post revealed the government had yet to make any commitment to update the city’s outdated air-quality objectives, a year after beginning a review of the standards.

Officials involved in the review are considering various measures – mainly transport and energy related – to improve air quality.

“It is time for Mr Tsang to do something concrete on air quality by adopting the WHO’s guidelines right away,” said Friends of the Earth director Edwin Lau Che-feng.

“The health impact of air pollution, particularly on the roadside, can no longer be neglected.

“How many human lives would be sacrificed and economic losses incurred by not having those polluting diesel vehicles taken off the roads now?”

The WHO’s guidelines, which were promulgated in 2005 but have yet to be adopted by a single country, set daily standards for suspended particulates at least three times more stringent than Hong Kong’s, yet they are said to be the minimum required to protect public health.

Friends of the Earth said Hong Kong should adopt the WHO’s guidelines and raise licence fees for polluting vehicles next year.

It also proposes an increase in the number of mandatory inspections of polluting vehicles, the setting of long-term energy-saving targets, and an increase in the percentage of electricity produced by gas-fired power stations to 50 per cent by 2010.

A 2003 study commissioned by the Environmental Protection Department showed respirable suspended particulates emitted by old diesel vehicles had been responsible for 8,000 cases of cancer.

City Rated Poorly By Expatriate Parents

Peter So – Oct 09, 2008 – SCMP

Expatriates give Hong Kong a low rating as a place to raise children because of its high costs and limited outdoor lifestyle, a survey has found.

The city ranked 11th among 14 places covered in the poll, conducted by HSBC (SEHK: 0005, announcements, news) between February and April. Only the Netherlands, Britain and the United Arab Emirates finished below Hong Kong.

The survey asked 2,155 expats, in more than 48 countries, about their experiences of raising children while living and working abroad.

Formula One Circuit Would Just Make Pollution Worse In HK

Updated on Oct 09, 2008 – SCMP

I refer to the letter by Guy Shirra (“We could have had F1 circuit”, September 30).

I would object to a Formula One track or indeed any other type of car-racing circuit in Hong Kong. In an age where global warming and pollution are primary concerns, the toxic emissions from petrol-driven racing car engines can only cause further damage to our environment.

While some may promote the alleged advantages of having an F1 circuit, such as the creation of jobs or the ability to attract tourists, the threat to human and environmental health far outweighs any perceived economic benefit. The deafening sounds from the cars would exacerbate the noise pollution problem in our crowded city. More importantly, however, the exhaust fumes generated through racing would harm the health of not only the residents living near the racing circuit, but also of those living further away, because air pollutants disperse widely. Car racing is an extravagant misuse of oil, a scarce resource which would be better utilised in buses and lorries, which transport people and goods. Racing cars serve no higher purpose than that of amusement, and unnecessarily contribute to our poor air quality.

Mr Shirra said we Hongkongers must somehow distinguish ourselves, to compete with cities like Singapore. Hong Kong is a vibrant city that draws millions of visitors – in 2006, we had 15.8 million tourists, to Singapore’s 7.6 million. However, many potential tourists may well be deterred by the air pollution and opt for greener destinations. Having an F1 circuit is not the hallmark of a world-class city. Having a clean, green environment where residents and visitors alike can enjoy city life, is.

We must understand that the Earth’s ability to sustain life as we know it is being threatened by human activities, and non-renewable resources are being wasted through their careless allocation. Let us be responsible citizens, and conserve the environment that supports our very existence. In this way, all that we take for granted from nature may still be enjoyed by future generations.

T. W. Wong, professor, department of community and family medicine, school of public health, Chinese University of Hong Kong

Guangzhou: Toxins Levels In 70% Apartments Excessive

China Daily – Oct. 8

BEIJING — Researchers have discovered about 70 percent of apartments in Guangdong’s provincial capital contained formaldehyde levels exceeding national standards, the Guangzhou Daily reported. On average, levels were 64.3 percent higher than the standard, it said.

Experts have urged local residents to avoid undertaking extensive home improvements, the newspaper reported. They also urged home-buyers to wait until their new residences pass environmental inspections before moving in. If toxicity levels exceed the standard, remedial measures should be undertaken before owners take up residence in the homes. In addition to installing ventilators and air filters, residents can grow Spider Plants, aloes and kumquats, which absorb toxins in the air. Researchers made the remarks in Guangzhou during the 4th Seminar of Sustainable Development of Guangdong Province, Hong Kong and Macao Special Administrative Regions on Monday.

Guangzhou municipal environmental monitoring center official Li Yingwen said most dwellings with indoor air pollution were constructed with substandard artificial panels and fiber boards, and poisonous paints. Some leather furniture also emitted formaldehyde.

The chemical can irritate the eyes and lungs, and even trigger asthma attacks. Long-term exposure has also been linked to leukemia. “The more luxurious the apartments are, the more likely they are to be seriously contaminated,” Li said.

The formaldehyde levels in some recently completed luxury apartments are as high as 0.6 mg per sq m – 5 times the national standard. Li urged local residents to use high-quality materials for home improvements.

In addition to formaldehyde, researchers found levels of many other toxins in Guangzhou apartments often exceeded national standards.

Local white-collar worker Liang Xiangqiong said she waited for months to move in after her apartment was completed last year to allow the airborne toxins to disperse. “But I have no idea what else to do, because it is hard to find quality interior decorating materials,” she said.

Bold Steps Needed In Air Pollution Battle

SCMP – Updated on Oct 08, 2008

It is two years since the World Health Organisation toughened its air-quality guidelines for a minimum level of health protection against pollution. The government responded by launching a review of our current air-quality objectives and strategies. Details have emerged of ideas the review panel has been discussing to clear the air. Some will be controversial – for example, measures to discourage the use of cars. Such measures are needed. But people must be persuaded they are necessary for the sake of their health.

The review required a sense of urgency, especially with regard to the guidelines. Not only are the present pollution benchmarks low compared with the new WHO standards, but we often fail to meet them. The WHO suggests governments set interim targets on the way to its more stringent standards. This has not yet been done in Hong Kong. As a result, the panel has been discussing ways to combat pollution without any clear targets to aim for. As we report today, this has aroused concerns among some experts that officials will lean towards more politically acceptable options, rather than ones which aim to meet scientifically based air-quality targets.

Hopefully, the panel’s report will lay these fears to rest, either by adopting the WHO’s guidelines or setting a timetable for phasing them in. We should not prejudge the work of the review panel as it still has three months before it submits its report. Worryingly, though, without a timetable for tougher air-quality objectives, the panel has put short-, medium- or long-term time frames on suggested measures – from before 2015 to later than 2020. That does not convey a sense of urgency. In health and lifestyle terms there is no question that a developed society like Hong Kong should adopt the WHO guidelines and strive to meet them. But the government may well feel that it is politically unwise to adopt standards it considers to be unattainable in the foreseeable future.

But the setting of new, more stringent standards, based on health concerns is necessary. It is good that the review panel is looking at various options. But it must not shy away from recommending the bold steps required to win the battle against air pollution.