Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

Proposed 3rd runway on Chek Lap Kok creates more problems than the one that AAHK allege exists

The Airport Authority Hong Kong (AAHK)’s recent proposal to reclaim more land in the Pearl River Estuary to build a third runway has come under much flak, and perhaps rightly so. The AAHK is alleging that, based on the continued growth of air traffic volume in the past years, Chek Lap Kok’s capacity will be saturated by 2030. It seems obviously necessary to expand Chek Lap Kok, but this narrative is less appealing when one considers several other events at play: Chek Lap Kok is currently running only at about 65% capacity; neighbouring airports in Shenzhen and Guangzhou are aggressively expanding, providing fierce competition for the growth pie that is being projected; the airways around Chek Lap Kok are already congested in part because of this competition; poor economic horizon is on the horizon, which will affect airline profits; a growing market to consume internally China’s produce rather than exporting, reducing the demand for cargo shipment.

Rapidly expanding airports in Guangzhou and Shenzhen competes with Chek Lap Kok for both airspace and business. (Shenzhen Media Group)

Of course, AAHK can choose to ignore these warning signs and continue drinking the kool-aid. But they cannot ignore the very real problems that building the Third Runway is going to cause:

  • The increase in simultaneous air traffic is going to generate a lot more noise pollution, a concern for Tung Chung residents not just as annoyance but quite possibly a direct health hazard.
  • The reclamation work required for the runway expansion is huge, and will severely impact pink dolphins native to the Pearl River Estuary. This concern has already been thrown out of the window during the proposals for building the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau bridge and should not be ignored again.
  • The expansion comes into a direct conflict of interest with Shenzhen’s cargo shipping network. Height restrictions on cargo ships passing through shipping channels in the vicinity of the airway will come into play, which will deeply displease Shenzhen’s port development authorities. Incidentally, they are already fuming over a failed proposal to expand the waterways near Chek Lap Kok, which the Hong Kong government rejected on precisely the environmental concerns for the pink dolphins that they themselves now ignore; Shenzhen officials see this slight as Hong Kong’s tactics to stave off competition.

AAHK’s representative saw fit to address only the issue of cargo shipping space, and even there, all there is is a single vague assurance: “putting in place an appropriate administrative arrangement between the relevant authorities in Hong Kong and Shenzhen”; no evidence that they have given the real problems substantial thought.

James Middleton makes a simple and salient point: it would be easier and cheaper to soundproof every single Tung Chung residence and change Chek Lap Kok’s from an 18-h to a 24-h airport, than to build a new runway.

It's probably easier to soundproof all apartments in Tung Chung than to build a third runway. (Square Foot)

Decision makers would do well to step back from dreaming of grand projects and justifying their legitimacy with visions of problems, while ignoring the real problems they would cause.

Click here for more coverage on this issue:

Officials’ comments on preliminary ICAO aircraft emissions agreement

SCMP, AFP (Montreal):

A first-ever global deal on curbing the airline industry’s rising carbon emissions was agreed on Friday, the International Civil Aviation Organization said, though hammering out the details could take years.

The full agreement is not scheduled to take effect until 2020 but the most contentious issues have been resolved, officials said, as the ICAO’s full assembly met behind closed doors in Montreal.

The deal “is an historic milestone for air transport and for the role of multilateralism in addressing global climate challenges,” ICAO Council President Roberto Kobeh Gonzalez said in a statement.

Air transport “now becomes the only major industry sector to have a multilateral global market-based mechanism agreement in place to help govern future greenhouse gas emissions,” he added.

Leading up to the vote, China and India had joined the United States and Russia in balking at a European Union push for a carbon levy on flights within three years.

But at midday, after some 1,400 delegates representing 170 member states voted on the executive committee’s resolution, officials said the plan had been passed and details of the accord would follow.

“The good news is (in) having concluded a general agreement that includes China and India,” said a diplomat involved in the negotiations.

Aviation accounts for around three per cent of global CO2 emissions but the ICAO forecasts that by 2050 emissions will have risen between four and six times the levels they were in 2010.

Last year, the EU suspended its CO2 Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) for intercontinental flights, after facing a storm of criticism.

Under the EU’s ill-fated arrangement, airlines flying in EU airspace were required to buy pollution credits to cover 15 per cent of their CO2 emissions for the entire flight, wherever it originated.

Several nations rejected the scheme that threatened to tip into a trade war.

The ICAO resolution “is a strong message to Europe after it lost three votes on its proposals,” a negotiator said.

According to a draft text of the agreement submitted for consideration at the ICAO meeting, countries must agree by 2016 on a global market-based mechanism and reject all regional schemes, according to the negotiator.

The measure is to be accompanied by a series of technical and operational steps to reduce emissions, said a European Commission statement.

Specific proposals under consideration for curbing CO2 emissions include a carbon tax and a carbon trading system.

The European Union would thus have to abandon its more ambitious ETS and adhere to the new global system for curbing greenhouse gases linked to global warming.

Even so, European Commission Vice President Siim Kallas praised Friday’s outcome.

“I am very pleased that after long and hard negotiations we finally have a global deal on aviation emissions,” Kallas said in a statement.

“This is good news for the traveling public, good news for the aviation industry, but most importantly it is very good news for the planet,” he said.

Furthermore, he added, the deal averts a “damaging conflict among trading partners.”

European Commissioner for Climate Action Connie Hedegaard meanwhile congratulated the ICAO members.

“After so many years of talks the ICAO has finally agreed to the first-ever global deal to curb aviation emissions,” she said.

In addition to the mechanism for curbing emissions, the accord also calls for promoting the use of better alternative aviation fuels and fuel-saving navigation.

There is also an exemption clause that provides a “fair and equitable solution” for a number of countries facing “special circumstances or with limited capabilities,” said the EU.

China and India unhappy with EU over Aircraft Emissions Taxes

The European Union has, for the past few years, pushed for capping aircraft carbon emissions and taxation, in an effort to reduce one of the biggest contributors to greenhouse gases. The proposed plan, however, ran into an insurmountable obstacle: taxing aircrafts of foreign airlines flying to and from Europe. Taxation for emissions that take place outside of Europe (for instance, a large part of a journey between Shanghai and London will not be in EU airspace) is considered by non-EU countries to be extraterritorial and sovereignty-violating, and many threatened retaliatory tariffs on European airlines if the EU went ahead with the plan unilaterally. The US even passed a preemptive law banning US airlines from compliance, and China flashed warnings of a trade war with a moratorium on aircraft orders from Airbus that was only partially lifted recently.

The International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) of the UN has stepped in with a plan to hash out a global agreement over aircraft carbon emissions. Brussels then agreed last November to a one-year suspension of emissions taxes for foreign airlines while the agreement is being worked out. As it turns out, the ICAO target for reaching full agreement is 2016, coming into force only in 2020. Non-EU countries, however, continue to voice their displeasure, fearing that the plan would severely impact their fast-growing aviation networks.

Some in the European transport industries do not consider airlines outside the EU and US as big players in global aviation. (Jimmy LWH/flickr)

It remains to be seen if this round of politicking will be resolved at all.

Click here for the most recent coverage by Charlotte So of SCMP:

68 flights an hour still won’t be enough for Hong Kong: aviation chief

dynamco Sep 16th 2013
7:38pm

Maybe he forgot his and his wife’s ATC training about A1 , terrain, wind shear etc?
1977-1981 Student Air Traffic Control Officer
1981-1984 Air Traffic Control Officer III
(1982 – 1996) Volunteer Pilot with the Auxiliary Air Force / GFS
1984-1988 Air Traffic Control Officer II
1988 – 1994 Operations Officer
(1991 – 1993) Secondment to Dragonair
1994 – 1996 Senior Operations Officer
1996 – 1997 Chief, Flight Standards
1997 – 2000 Assistant Director-General (Flight Standards) / Deputy Chief Inspector of Air Accidents
2000 Principal Assistant Secretary for Security (Special Duties)
2000 – 2002 Assistant Director-General (Air Traffic Management)
2002 – 2004 Deputy Director-General of Civil Aviation
2004 – present Director-General of Civil Aviation and Chief Inspector of Accidents

dynamco Sep 16th 2013
6:09am

Disingenuous oaf
32,395 movements last month = 1045 a day
18 hour operational day =58 movements /hr
19 hour operational day =55 movements /hr 0700-0200 hrs
so we have a white elephant airport that does not operate a full 24 hour day
We already know flightpath A1 is the busiest on the planet with 2 way traffic
Without enlarging the size of the tube there is a limit to the size of the movements through it let alone no central command & control centre covering the region
So with a 3rd runway they intend to have simultaneous takeoffs & landings closer to a mountain range with wind shear?
It will be far cheaper to erect sound barriers around Tung Chung apartments & operate a 24 hr airport
24 hrs x 65 flights =1560 per day =48,360 per month =49.3%increase over last month

Where shall I send the consultancy fee note ?

South China Morning Post

Published on South China Morning Post (http://www.scmp.com)

Home > 68 flights an hour still won’t be enough for Hong Kong: aviation chief



68 flights an hour still won’t be enough for Hong Kong: aviation chief

Monday, 16 September, 2013, 12:00am

News›Hong Kong

TRANSPORT

Johnny Tam johnny.tam@scmp.com

Flight capacity at Chek Lap Kok airport could be expanded to more than 68 flights per hour, but it would not be enough to meet the needs of the city’s future economic development, the civil aviation head says.

“The increase would be only very small, so small it wouldn’t help the city’s economic development much,” Norman Lo Shung-man, director-general of the Civil Aviation Department, said on TVB’s On The Record programme yesterday.

The remark came after it was announced the airport set records for passenger throughput and flight movements last month for the second month in a row.

Lo said capacity would rise to 68 flights per hour in 2015 and the department could cope with up to 70 flights, although this could compromise the level of service.

“We don’t want to see it overloaded because if it is, several factors will appear – the safety co-efficient would drop, although not to an unacceptable level, and … flight delays could be more serious, causing bad feeling among passengers,” he said.

Lo said capacity would reach saturation point in 2017 if a third runway was not built.

Yesterday, the Airport Authority announced the airport handled 5.6 million passengers and 32,395 flights last month – year-on-year growth of 8.2 per cent and 6.3 per cent respectively.

A green group said any debate over whether to build a third runway should also evaluate the city’s capacity to accommodate an increase in the already large influx of visitors each year.

“If the director-general says [the capacity of] the two runways will reach saturation after two years, then many Hongkongers would say the capacity of Hong Kong to welcome more visitors has reached saturation now,” said Roy Tam Hoi-pong, president of Green Sense.

The idea of a third runway was first floated in 2006. It would cost about HK$130 billion and boost flight handling capacity to 102 per hour, the authority said.



Links:
[1] http://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1308597/aviation-officials-say-third-runway-only-option-handle-extra-traffic

Flight capacity won’t be enough: aviation chief

dynamco Sep 16th 2013
6:09am

Disingenuous oaf
32,395 movements last month = 1045 a day
18 hour operational day =58 movements /hr
19 hour operational day =55 movements /hr 0700-0200 hrs
so we have a white elephant airport that does not operate a full 24 hour day
We already know flightpath A1 is the busiest on the planet with 2 way traffic
Without enlarging the size of the tube there is a limit to the size of the movements through it let alone no central command & control centre covering the region
So with a 3rd runway they intend to have simultaneous takeoffs & landings closer to a mountain range with wind shear?
It will be far cheaper to erect sound barriers around Tung Chung apartments & operate a 24 hr airport
24 hrs x 65 flights =1560 per day =48,360 per month =49.3%increase over last month
Where shall I send the consultancy fee note ?

South China Morning Post

Published on South China Morning Post (http://www.scmp.com)

Home > Flight capacity won’t be enough: aviation chief



Flight capacity won’t be enough: aviation chief

Monday, 16 September, 2013, 12:00am

News›Hong Kong

TRANSPORT

Johnny Tam johnny.tam@scmp.com

Flight capacity at Chek Lap Kok airport could be expanded to more than 68 flights per hour, but it would not be enough to meet the needs of the city’s future economic development, the civil aviation head says.

“The increase would be only very small, so small it wouldn’t help the city’s economic development much,” Norman Lo Shung-man, director-general of the Civil Aviation Department, said on TVB’s On The Record programme yesterday.

The remark came after it was announced the airport set records for passenger throughput and flight movements last month for the second month in a row.

Lo said capacity would rise to 68 flights per hour in 2015 and the department could cope with up to 70 flights, although this could compromise the level of service.

“We don’t want to see it overloaded because if it is, several factors will appear – the safety co-efficient would drop, although not to an unacceptable level, and … flight delays could be more serious, causing bad feeling among passengers,” he said.

Lo said capacity would reach saturation point in 2017 if a third runway was not built.

Yesterday, the Airport Authority announced the airport handled 5.6 million passengers and 32,395 flights last month – year-on-year growth of 8.2 per cent and 6.3 per cent respectively.

A green group said any debate over whether to build a third runway should also evaluate the city’s capacity to accommodate an increase in the already large influx of visitors each year.

“If the director-general says [the capacity of] the two runways will reach saturation after two years, then many Hongkongers would say the capacity of Hong Kong to welcome more visitors has reached saturation now,” said Roy Tam Hoi-pong, president of Green Sense.

The idea of a third runway was first floated in 2006. It would cost about HK$130 billion and boost flight handling capacity to 102 per hour, the authority said.



Airspace management reform urged

http://www.chinadailyapac.com/article/airspace-management-reform-urged

Airspace management reform urged

By Xin Dingding
October 30, 2012 – 9:35am http://www.chinadailyapac.com

http://www.chinadailyapac.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/content/images/20121030/0013729e477111f95e2e18.jpg

http://www.chinadailyapac.com/sites/all/themes/chinadaily_theme/images/btn_left_l.gifhttp://www.chinadailyapac.com/sites/all/themes/chinadaily_theme/images/btn_right_l.gif1 of 1

Airplanes taxi at Shenzhen Bao’an International Airport in 2011. (Zhang Bin / for China Daily)

The Pearl River Delta is one of the most congested parts of China’s airspace, with five major airports in the region, and none of them more than 200 kilometers apart from each other.

That’s a rare situation in the world, industry insiders said.

Yet, the region has a new runway under construction, another runway approved, and a new airport under consideration.

Civil aviation experts worried that the soon-to-be-added facilities will worsen congestion problems, given that only a small part of the Chinese airspace is for civil use, and called for a reform of the airspace management mechanism.

The new runway under construction at Guangzhou Baiyun International Airport came after the National Development and Reform Commission approved the expansion plans in July.

The expansion project – which also includes plans for a new terminal and two more runways – aims to prepare the facility to handle 80 million passengers a year by 2020, up from 45 million passengers last year.

Guangzhou has been appointed as one of the country’s three main international aviation gateways, according to the country’s 12th Five-Year Plan (2011-15). The capital city of South China’s Guangdong province will mainly connect Oceania and Southeast Asia.

Guangzhou’s plans have clearly put pressure on Hong Kong International Airport, currently the busiest airport in the region. It handled 54 million passengers and 3.97 million tons of cargo last year.

As a way to secure the airport’s leading position in the region, the Hong Kong government has this year agreed in principle to a third runway, though some industry insiders believe that the runway won’t be ready for use until 2023.

Meanwhile, media reports said that Guangzhou is mulling a new airport in the Nansha New Area, a State-level development zone.

The city’s leadership believes that Nansha needs an airport to increase its appeal to investors, said Ouyang Jie, a professor at the Civil Aviation University of China who specializes in airport studies.

“Otherwise, air passengers, upon their arrival at Guangzhou Baiyun airport, will have to travel through crowded downtown Guangzhou in order to get to Nansha, which is situated at the southernmost edge of Guangzhou,” he said.

City officials also believe that because Nansha is at the geographical center of the Pearl River Delta region, the new airport will be able to cover the population of the whole region, which the Baiyun airport, located at the north of city, is unable to do, Ouyang added.

Experts are not optimistic about the future of a second airport in Guangzhou, though.

“If the military and the local government cannot reach a consensus and expand the airspace for civil use, the second-airport project cannot possibly be approved,” said Li Kun, a researcher with the Comprehensive Transport Institute, which is affiliated with the National Development and Reform Commission.

Congested airspace

The region’s sky has been so severely congested that the International Air Transport Association has said that the situation in the Pearl River Delta is one of the top three global air traffic control problems.

In the past few years, even though new runways were added, they failed to fuel traffic growth because of the congestion problems.

The congestion also increases fuel consumption. Researchers at the Aviation Policy and Research Center of the Chinese University of Hong Kong estimated that the congestion costs more than HK$1 billion ($130 million) a year in fuel alone.

The most direct cause behind the congestion problems is that four of the five airports – in Shenzhen, Zhuhai, Hong Kong and Macao – are all packed at the mouth of the Pearl River, forcing planes to make detours to ensure safe take-offs and landings, professor Ouyang said.

The Guangzhou Baiyun airport is a little up in the north, but flights leaving the four airports for northern destinations all have to fly over Baiyun airport, adding to the problems there, he said.

Many people wonder why the airports were built so close to each other. Ouyang said that is due to complicated factors, involving “historical reasons”.

“Shenzhen, a pioneer of China’s reform and opening-up efforts, which started more than 30 years ago, tried to cooperate with the Hong Kong airport, but the different social systems and border policies made it impossible,” he said.

Hong Kong returned to China in 1997. Shenzhen, unable to wait for an airport to boost economic development, built an airport that opened in 1991.

It was a similar case in Zhuhai, which opened its airport in 1995, though it had mulled cooperating with Macao, which did not return to China until 1999, he said.

Ouyang believes that the only way for the five airports to survive in the region is if they have different functions, like the five airports in the Greater London area.

Zhuhai airport has the weakest performance among the five airports in the Pearl River Delta, as its planned scale is found to have surpassed the actual needs of the city’s population of 600,000.

A blessing in disguise for Zhuhai is that its redundant capacity has allowed it to host a biennial air show and develop general aviation flights, which refers to all civil aviation activities except for scheduled flights, he said.

However, the competition between Guangzhou and Shenzhen airports needs more attention, he said.

As the Hong Kong airport is an international air hub and the Macao airport aims to attract leisure tourists, intense competition exists mainly between Guangzhou and Shenzhen, with both seeking development in passengers and cargo transportation, he said.

Coordination between the two airports will be difficult, since the two are run by two separate and independent corporations, he said.

Expansion needed

Expanding the airspace is also urgent, experts said.

The scarce airspace available for civil use has been noted by the government, especially when China’s civil aviation industry is still developing at a rapid pace, said Li with the Comprehensive Transport Institute.

Air passengers throughout China last year were 620 million, and that number is estimated to double by 2020.

Airports, fleets and air routes all have to expand to meet the demand, he said.

“It’s not just a problem for Guangzhou. The same problem exists in Beijing, Wuhan and Changsha,” Li said.

According to a draft plan on the development of the civil aviation industry issued by the Hunan provincial authorities, 21 more general aviation airports will be built in the Central China province before 2030, the Changsha Evening News reported on Thursday.

In neighboring Hubei province, nine airports will be built in the next 18 years, increasing the total number of airports in the province to 13.

In Wuhan, Hubei’s provincial capital, a second airport will be built, according to local media reports.

“Though the negotiation process over airspace will be time-consuming and difficult, it will work out finally. It has to,” Li said.

Xu Wei contributed to this story.

xindingding@chinadaily.com.cn

Iata chief demands regional airspace overhaul as the losses mount

Friday, 18 August, 2006, 12:00am

Russell Barling

The International Air Transport Association (Iata), aviation’s de facto governing body, next month will increase its outlook for industry losses this year largely on higher fuel costs.


The new figures will bring further pressure for an overhaul in how authorities in the Pearl River Delta region handle their airspace.


It will be Iata’s third upward shift this year, which speaks volumes about the volatile nature of the industry; even the experts have a hard time getting it right.


In June, Iata forecast industry losses of US$3 billion this year based on US$66 as the average trading price for a barrel of Brent crude.


The breakeven price for the industry is US$50 a barrel. The average price so far this year has been US$68.27, so losses will mount, according to Iata’s top executive, Giovanni Bisignani (pictured).

Iata’s projections for losses ‘will increase because we are seeing fuel bills higher than anticipated,’ Mr Bisignani said.

The good news is that Iata’s prognosticators were wrong in other areas too, some of which should at least have a positive impact on the carrier’s bottom lines.


Airlines’ load factors – the proportion of available seats they sell – are higher than expected thanks to strong demand and better attention to capacity management.


Carriers have also bought stronger fuel-hedging positions than was anticipated with jet kerosene prices so high, lowering their exposure to the upward trend.


Iata expected airlines to hedge on average 42 per cent of their fuel needs this year; it now looks like that proportion will be closer to 50 per cent.


‘Last year it was higher, but hedging at these levels scares people,’ Mr Bisignani said.


Industry yields – average earnings per kilometre flown – have also beaten expectations due to higher than expected demand for premium-class travel.


The problem is that premium-class travel, which has undergone a sustained period of growth over the past 18 months to account for 15 per cent of current demand on long-haul routes, is skittish.


It depends heavily on increasingly nervous US corporates, which have one eye on the Middle East and the other on Wall Street, and it remains to be seen if robust commercial activity in Europe and Asia can offset the impact of a slowdown in the US economy. Iata’s number-crunchers are trying to understand how much the positive surprises this year will mitigate the impact of the inexorable rise of jet fuel. One thing we know is that American carriers are on track to lose another US$5 billion this year, half of what they lost last year.


For the past two years, economists have struggled to figure out how high the price for a barrel of oil can go before it triggers a global slowdown. Those that predicted that US$50 barrels would start the slide have returned to their abacuses. Consensus now is that a slowdown will start at US$80 to US$85 a barrel. If that happens, airlines will still be facing escalating operating costs, but their yields will shrink and they will no longer have the shield of 6.5 per cent growth in passenger numbers.

What is certain is there is not much else the carriers can do to counter the price of fuel.
Which is why Iata has turned to the skies for answers.


Mr Bisignani said inefficient air traffic control systems were the top priority for Iata simply because they hold the most promise for savings.

Nowhere is that more true than in the Pearl River Delta, where a lack of centralised air traffic control results in flights into the region being 20 minutes longer than is necessary, costing airlines US$300 million a year in fuel.


Civil aviation departments on both sides of the border have been trying to hammer out an agreement.


But, predictably, the authorities have been reluctant to cede control of their airspace, even for the greater good.


It appears any agreement still remains a long way off and, with fuel prices rising with each day, time is of the essence for an industry whose options to cut costs are dwindling.


‘We appreciate all the efforts the local organisations are making [to resolve the airspace issue in the Pearl River Delta],’ Mr Bisignani said.


‘But when I see target dates of 2010, I say it’s too much. We have to be fast in achieving this.’

Topics:

Finance

Finance

International Air Transport Association

Giovanni Bisignani

Hedge

Business



Source URL (retrieved on Aug 2nd 2013, 5:00pm): http://www.scmp.com/article/560647/iata-chief-demands-regional-airspace-overhaul-losses-mount

Open military airspace to ease jams, says study

Sunday, 15 June, 2008, 12:00am

Yau Chui-yan

Flight limitations in Pearl River Delta adding millions to fuel costs

The central government should consider opening up military airspace and introducing integrated air-traffic management to ease air congestion in the Pearl River Delta region, researchers have said.

The suggestions were made in a Chinese University study that found congestion above the region’s five airports costs airlines hundreds of millions of dollars in extra fuel costs – partly as a result of having to constantly switch between three air-traffic control centres.

The airports at Hong Kong, Macau, Shenzhen, Zhuhai and Guangzhou, are served by air-navigation services in Guangzhou, Zhuhai and Hong Kong.

‘Aircraft flying near or across sector boundaries are frequently delayed as they are transferred from one controlling facility to another,’ the paper says.

It says more runways will not necessarily provide more capacity if the airspace congestion cannot be solved.

The Airport Authority began the second phase of a study on a third runway last month.

The researchers suggested that Beijing could open up military airspace for civilian use whenever possible, a principle widely adopted in Europe and the United States.

‘The dominance of Chinese military control over airspace is one of the reasons leading to airspace congestion. Also, there are more and more planes but the airspace remains limited,’ Law Cheung-kwok, a member of the research team, said.

‘But in the US, the Federal Aviation Authority owns and manages all the airspace. It provides the same services to the military as to civilians. This means the airspace can be better co-ordinated,’ Dr Law said.

According to the Civil Aviation Department, all airspace within the Hong Kong flight information region is available for civilian use.

It could not comment on mainland airspace.

Under requirements enforced by mainland authorities since colonial days, aircraft crossing from Hong Kong into Zhuhai airspace have to fly at about 5,000 metres, to minimise the effect on other air traffic. It has become known in aviation circles as an ‘invisible wall’.

The study found that seven out of every 10 Dragonair mainland flights, 90 per cent of all its total flights, experienced delays in 2006. In 2004 the figure was 3.6 in 10.

Government data quoted in the paper shows that more than 3,000 flights from Hong Kong were delayed in 2006, more than three times the number recorded in 2004.

The paper also estimated that extra fuel costs from detours caused by the ‘invisible wall’ amounted to about HK$605 million in 2006.

The Civil Aviation Administration of China, the Hong Kong Civil Aviation Department and the Civil Aviation Authority Macau set up a working group in February 2004 to optimise the use of Pearl River Delta airspace.

Last year, the group agreed that a future air-traffic management plan might include changes to airspace structure and establishment of more routes.

In order to alleviate congestion, mainland authorities recently dropped the altitude requirement from 11pm to 7am, the effectiveness of which has been questioned by academics.

‘How many flights are there in this time period?’ Dr Law asked.

The paper also stated that air-traffic congestion within the Pearl River Delta affected Hong Kong most directly.

The Pearl River Delta includes five major airports in close proximity: Guangzhou New Baiyun International Airport, Hong Kong International Airport, Macau International Airport, Shenzhen Baoan International Airport and Zhuhai Airport.

Although Guangzhou airport is about 140km from Hong Kong, the other three airports are less than 60km from the city.

After looking at US and European Union models, the study concluded that an integrated military-civilian air-traffic management infrastructure might be the solution to air congestion in the Pearl River Delta.

The unfriendly skies

Congestion in the Pearl River Delta airspaces is causing problems in the areas of…

Flight time

The percentage of Dragonair flights delayed in 2006: 70%

Fuel consumption

The extra fuel costs incurred by all flights arriving or departing from Chek Lap Kok in 2006: HK$605m

SOURCE: CHINESE UNIVERSITY

Topics:

Air Traffic Control

Airport

Airport

Association of Asia Pacific Airlines

Pearl River Delta



Source URL (retrieved on Aug 2nd 2013, 3:58pm): http://www.scmp.com/article/641709/open-military-airspace-ease-jams-says-study

China’s airport outrage: all about airspace?

Jul 18, 2013 9:58am by Lydia Guo

http://blogs.r.ftdata.co.uk/beyond-brics/files/2013/07/Changshui-International-Airport-167x111.jpgEdward Snowden must be getting a lot of sympathy in China, at least among those fed up with being stranded at airports. Delayed flights are a common experience and it’s getting worse. Why is it so hard to get flights on time in China?

Airport outrage has exploded into more and more violent encounters between passengers and airport staff. Click here for a video showing one recent example from Beijing Airport.

http://blogs.r.ftdata.co.uk/beyond-brics/files/2013/07/god-of-punctuality-391x448.jpgIt’s not only passengers who are fed up with the delays. Here, two flight attendents pray to their self-made “god of punctuality” on a food trolley turned altar. The photo has gone viral in China.

The official Xinhua news agency commented on the photo, blaming failures of punctuality on a combination of air traffic control, transport links to and between airports and airline management and other factors.

Chinese airports were shamed in a recent report by FlightStats, a US company that tracks airline and airport performance. Airports in Shanghai, Beijing and Guangzhou took the last three places out of 35 in a ranking for punctuality, with only about a quarter of flights leaving on time compared with more than three quarters at most other international airports.

The sense of being badly treated is widespread. One engineer at Hainan Airlines who asked not to be named told beyondbrics it was normal for both passengers and airline staff to be kept waiting for hours with no information on when they might fly. “Military control of the airspace is the most important reason for the current situation,” he said.

China’s airspace has been controlled by the military since 1950s,. The engineer said only 20 per cent of airspace was authorised for use by civil aviation, with the rest reserved for military use.

Article 28 of the Basic Rules of Aviation in the People’s Republic of China stipulates that the air force of People’s Liberation Army controls all air traffic in the country, although there is no information on how much is allocated to civil aviation.

Chinese media also put the blame on military control. But The Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC) is coy about handing out blame. In its 2012 annual report, it said 38.5 per cent of delays were caused by airlines, 25 per cent by air traffic control and 21.6 per cent by bad weather.

Congestion is only getting worse. In the past five years, the number of people travelling has increased at an annual rate of more than 14 per cent. In its five-year plan for 2011 to 2015, the CAAC expected growth to continue at 9 to 10 per cent a year. And here it is clear on the biggest challenge: a shortage of airspace

http://blogs.ft.com/beyond-brics/2013/07/18/chinas-airport-outrage-all-about-airspace/?

新闻专题网易首页–新闻–体育–亚运–娱乐–财经–汽车–科技–数码–手机–女人–论坛–视频–博客

搜索请输入关键词 [新闻 \/]

[搜索]

Rss

http://img2.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/12/201008120011157a679.jpg

近来,面对层出不穷的航班延误事件,乘客不解、愤怒、甚至是见怪不怪,延误已经成为了航空运输“不可分割”的一部分。实际上,飞机延误其实是一个极其复杂的过程,在现实中,民航飞机甚至比汽车在地面受到的限制还多。而一旦其中一个环节出现问题,各种因素会相互叠加,坏状况就会将像链条一样传导下去。其实,“天高任鸟飞”还只是想象。

航空管制:“天高任鸟飞”只是理想

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/12/2010081208312336158.jpg

并不是所有空域民航飞机都能随意飞行。

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/201008111924500dacf.jpg

开放空域少是造成商业航班晚点的主因。

中国大约80%的空域不能为民用航空所用

目前,中国空域管理与使用处于一种“分离状况”:空域管理权属于空军,民航总局只能在空军的允许范围内使用空域,要随时接受空军的管理。中国大约80%的领空处于军方的直接管制之下,而民航能够利用的空域只有不到20%比例,这20%还得在军方的严厉管控下方可使用。相比之下,美国逾90%的领空留作民用。中国空军在主要城市上空强制设置了禁飞区。在军事意义不大的偏远地区,政府划定了禁飞区,因为雷达系统和其它基础设施不足,无法保障安全。

当某片空域要进行军事活动,或者有空军的飞机活动时,就会下达通知周边所有机场此处空域演习,所有民用航班要进行管控。空中演习由于属于国家机密,这种空中管制来的往往比较突然。管控理由、管控时间、管控区域等都属于军事机密,无法透露给普通乘客,这也是航空公司往往对航班延误无法做出明确解释的原因之一。[详细]

全国约有上百个空中管制区

中国大陆及临海上空划分为11个飞行情报区,总面积约1081万平方公里。除台北和香港两个飞行情报区外,目前全国划设19个高空管制区,28个中低空管制区,25个进近管制区,1个终端管制区;军方划设了2个空中禁区、66个空中危险区、199个空中限制区,以及若干个军事训练空域。[详细]

总航线中仅有38%为国内航班的固定航线

目前中国的航路航线总距离约16.4万公里,其中国际航路航线约占46.2%,临时航线约占16.2%。近五年来,全国航路航线总距离年均增长约2.6%,远远低于我国航空运输总周转量年均两位数的增长。全国临时航线总数达到77条,总距离达2.67万公里。2010年约21.5万架次航班使用临时航线。[详细]



航线航路:空中塞车并非奇谈

http://img2.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/201008111918335139d.jpg

空中“塞飞机”甚至比地面塞车更加频繁。

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/20100811192011c784a.jpg

每座机场通常只有1到3个进出场航路,飞机起飞降落都必须经过此航路。

飞机只能在宽20公里,高0-14000米的航路上飞

“很多旅客觉得天空那么大,怎么会像地面道路一样发生堵塞,完全可以随便飞嘛。”实际上不是这样的。飞机也要按既定的航路飞行,当航路无法容纳不断增长的航班时,一样会发生拥挤。例如京广航路,就是一条宽20公里、高度从0至14000米的空中通道。飞机只能在这一航路上飞行,不能有任何偏离。京广间的所有航班,以及从郑州、武汉、长沙等地至北京、广州方向的航班,从东北等地前往广州方向的航班,都要在这一航路上飞行。在这种情况下,随着民航运量的不断增加,特别是京广以及京广以东的航路,航路拥堵带来的流量控制成为必然。

一航路多航线共用,“车多路少”只能排队飞

目前,中国大部分航路已实现了雷达管制。在此之前采用程序控制,同一高度上每架飞机之间要相隔150公里。雷达管制后这一距离很快缩短至75公里。现在东部地区一些航路上,飞机间隔已缩至20公里。据介绍,现在北京、上海、广州三个最繁忙区域正在争取到年底把距离从20公里缩至10公里,这样也会减少流量控制发生的几率。

与水平距离相对应,飞机飞行也需要相应的垂直距离相隔,也就是垂直面上的平行飞。此前,民航客机理论上在垂直距离每间隔600米可以有一架飞机飞行。2007年11月后,华东地区航路的垂直间隔飞行高度层由600米调整到了300米,使得在8400米到12500米的垂直空域中飞行高度层由过去的7个增加到13个。这也意味着此航路变成了水平方向一“车道”,垂直方向13“车道”的大“马路”。虽然实现了航路的扩宽,但相比增速更快的客流量,塞飞机的现象还是没有好转。

进出港线路少且固定,极易造成拥堵

每座机场都有固定的进出港航路,所有飞机都必须按照固定航路飞行,不能乱飞。以广州新白云机场为例,该机场一共只有三个出口,北出口在韶关,东边的出口在龙门,西出口在南宁。每个进出口到机场上空的距离约两三百公里,这段路程被称为空中走廊。白云机场每天进出港的近千架飞机,在进入机场的管制区后,都只能通过这三个出口起降。



天气原因:不只是托词

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/20100811191613544b0.jpg

天气原因常常是航空公司面对晚点最常用的“借口”,但事实上真正影响飞行的天气原因并非普通乘客能够简单感受到的。

眼前天气晴朗,但飞机不一定能起飞

目前,天气原因是造成航班延误的主要原因。但从乘客的角度来说,天气恶劣就是出发地和目的地的天气是好是坏,但这只是天气原因中的一个。一般民航服务人员往往和旅客一样也不了解具体是什么恶劣天气影响航班的。“天气原因”简单的四个字实际包含了很多种情况:除了出发地机场天气状况不宜起飞;目的地机场天气状况不宜降落以外,还有其他更多更重要的原因。由于航线航路上空的天气问题难以解释,飞机又不能绕道走,所以航空公司通常用“天气原因”四个字来解释,就极易造成乘客误解。

最重要的因素:全程航路上气象状况不宜飞越

事实上,一旦在狭窄的航路上出现雷雨区等状况,某些条件下可采取饶过雷雨区的方式通过,但出于飞行安全和军方空管需要,民航航路是严格受限的,可饶飞、回旋的余地很小,异常气象区较大时,此方法就行不通了。特别在长途飞行中,航线长并且窄,在漫长的航线上只要有任意一个区域天气状况不适合飞行,就有可能造成航班延误。

不同机型和不同机组对天气的要求不一样

航班延误过程中,往往同样是飞往某地的航班,有些能走,有些却被告知因天气原因走不了?出现这种情况的可能性很多,首先要明确的是飞机起降的标准与飞机机型有关,同样的机型在各航空公司定的具体安全标准也可能有差异,机长对当前气象及趋势作出决策也会有所不同。取决于机长对飞机状态、机场、气象等判断后的决定。民航法规定,“机长发现民用航空器、机场、气象条件等不符合规定,不能保证飞行安全的,有权拒绝飞行”。



旅客原因:飞机其实很脆弱

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/20100811191323081ae.jpg

乘客也是飞行安全和效率的组成部分之一。

乘客晚到舱门不能正点关上,无法申请排队起飞

乘客也是飞行安全和效率的组成部分之一,乘客的配合程度与飞机正点与否密切相关。在乘客登机这一环节,开放登机口后,航空公司总会劝说旅客尽快登机。当所有旅客上机,舱门关闭那一刻非常重要,关舱门时飞行员就申请航班(所以通常说的航班时刻其实是关舱门的时刻,关上舱门后最终的起飞时间就交给塔台了)。白云机场的航班密度非常大,航班时刻很紧张,旺季两三分钟就起飞一架,飞行员延误一分钟申请航班,就要给后面所有正点申请的航班让路。有时候甚至要让过后面十几班航班才能起飞。所以一旦乘客由于种种原因导致飞机没有在正点关上舱门并报备申请飞行,需要重新排队,甚至还会影响到其他正点飞机的飞行。

3个以上的乘客位置重量变化飞机将重新报备

每架飞机起飞前,都会在所有乘客落座后,打印出舱单,根据旅客的位置和重量,通过电脑计算,制作飞行平衡图。737这样的大飞机,因为载重平衡点比较宽,可以容忍1到3个乘客的变动。也就是说,3个以内的乘客发生变动,飞行员还可以用手工方式修改平衡图。如果是不到100座的小飞机,一个乘客的位置变化都可能导致飞机的平衡重心发生变化,都需要飞行员重新制作舱单和平衡图,重新回电脑进行验正。一旦有乘客不遵守安全规则导致飞机不能正点报备,延误就成为必然。[据三联生活周周刊]



飞机调配原因:晚点一架,牵出一串

http://img1.cache.netease.com/cnews/2010/8/11/20100811191023d6d89.jpg

由于不是一条航线一架飞机,所以任何一班航班的异常都会引起多条航线的异常反应。

400架飞机跑上千条航线,前一航班晚点会引起连环晚点

南航现有的403架飞机,平均每架飞机的飞行时间要达到10小时/天,相当于每架飞机每天要承担3~4趟航班,再加上飞机在地面上下客、清洁、装卸货、例行检查等过站时间,一般每天运行16小时左右。从经营角度考虑,这种尽量增加飞机运营时间的策略并没有错。但一旦出现大面积航班延误,就容易出现飞机周转困难——航空公司并没有也不可能有充足的备份飞机来代替未按时到岗的飞机。每架飞机的航班计划都预先排好,周旋余地不是太大。前一航班出现任何疏漏都可能引发后续航班的连锁反应,往往越到后面延误时间越长。

准备大量备用飞机成本高昂

按照运营常规,每家航空公司都要留出一定量的飞机作为备份,一旦发生飞机延误,不能按时到岗时,备份飞机可以执行航班任务。但专门准备大量备用飞机是不可能的,这将会大大增加公司运营成本。航空公司的大部分飞机都是租赁的,如果停在机场不动,每小时的停机费约7万元,这是一笔极其高昂的费用。[据三联生活周周刊]



航班延误是一个世界性难题,本身就是一块难啃的“硬骨头”。目前国外航空公司航班正常率也只在80%左右。而国内民航航班能够利用的空域不多,使得延误问题异常突出。此外,航空公司由于种种原因由无法与乘客充分沟通,造成的信息不对称最终导致了僵局的出现。

China Air Traffic Congestion Worsened by Military Control

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-16/china-air-traffic-congestion-worsened-by-military-control.html

China Air Traffic Congestion Worsened by Military Control

By Jasmine Wang – May 17, 2013 5:31 PM GMT+0800

China’s skies don’t have enough space.

The country’s air force controls airspace and allots only 20 percent to civil aviation. With China’s three biggest airlines planning to add at least 273 planes in the next three years, traffic congestion that already delays 25 percent of flights is set to worsen.

Enlarge image China Air Traffic Congestion Worsened by Military Restrictions

China Air Traffic Congestion Worsened by Military Restrictions

Nelson Ching/Bloomberg

Exhaust emits from a jet-engine on an Air China Ltd. airplane burning a mixture of jet fuel and bio-liquid fuel at Beijing Capital International Airport in Beijing. China’s air force, which has controlled the airspace since the People’s Republic was established in 1949, has started gradually relaxing some of the curbs. Photographer: Nelson Ching/Bloomberg

“At present, the limited airspace resource has restricted the development of civil aviation,” said Li Jiaxiang, the head of Civil Aviation Administration of China. “We will strive to further open up the airspace,” he said in Beijing yesterday.

Air China Ltd. (601111), China Eastern (670) Airlines Corp. and China Southern Airlines Co. (1055) have expanded their fleet as economic growth spurs air travel demand in the world’s most populous nation. The country is expected to have 4,200 commercial aircraft in 2020, compared with the current fleet size of 2,001 with 46 airlines, CAAC’s Li said.

China’s civil aviation uses about a fifth of available routes of the nation’s total airspace, Shi Boli, who heads the department of Air Transportation Regulation at CAAC, said in an interview. Military controls about 52 percent of airspace in eastern China, home to the country’s biggest cities of Beijing and Shanghai, according to a 2011 June report by the official China News Service.

“We are working hard and the military is also trying to improve the management of airspace,” Shi said. “But, it could take some time to achieve some improvement.”

U.S. Airspace

In the U.S., military restrictions don’t have much impact on civilian aviation because its airways tend to be located in desert regions or over oceans, far away from the busy airport hubs in cities such as New York, said Kevin Hiatt, president of Alexandria, Virginia-based Flight Safety Foundation. The military has also allowed its airspace to be used by civilian flights on some occasions such as busy holiday periods, he said.

Airspace over Europe is managed as a single unit and segregated on a “dynamic basis according to the needs of users,” air traffic supervisory agency Eurocontrol said. In general, areas will only be reserved for military use at certain times and at certain altitudes, it said in an e-mail.

The on-time performance rate of China’s airlines was about 74.5 percent last year, CAAC’s Shi said. In the U.S., 82 percent of the flights arrived on time in 2012, according to Bureau of Transportation statistics.

‘New Leadership’

“People are hoping that the country’s new leadership can have a breakthrough in getting more airspace released to accommodate the rapid growth,” said Kelvin Lau, a Hong Kong-based analyst at Daiwa Securities Group Inc. “Otherwise, delays will persist and hurt the airlines’ long term growth prospects.”

China’s air force, which has controlled the airspace since the People’s Republic was established in 1949, has started gradually relaxing some of the curbs. It has begun to open low-altitude airspace and released more information about the availability of temporary routes, the Official Xinhua News Agency reported in August.

Still, the pace isn’t quick enough to catch up with the airlines’ growth as the number of annual passengers has more than doubled in the past seven years, said David Wei, an aerospace analyst with Shanghai Securities Co.

‘Historical Reasons’

“The military has a bigger say in China’s airspace usage for historical reasons,” Wei said. “It has no incentive to concede the right unless the government wants it to.”

Four calls to the press office of China’s Ministry of National Defense went unanswered today. Questions faxed to the office also didn’t receive an immediate reply.

Airspace congestion is severe in main locations around China’s big hubs, according to Andrew Herdman, director-general of the Kuala Lumpur-based Association of Asia Pacific Airlines.

“You need flexibility. The military need access to airspace but not all the time,” Herdman said. “The big reality is that civil aviation has grown spectacularly and will continue to do so. And that has to be taken into account.”

Airspace restrictions also force airlines to fly longer distances on some routes, said Liu Jieyin, executive vice president at closely-held Okay Airways Co., which operates flights between cities including Tianjin, Hangzhou and Sanya.

Military Drills

“This is still better than before when we had to wait on ground for hours for the completion of military drills,” Liu said. “We couldn’t take proactive measures as we wouldn’t know drills until the last minute and couldn’t tell passengers the real reason either.”

Air China (753), Asia’s biggest carrier by market value, will receive 113 aircraft in the next three years, according to a company statement. China Eastern will add 93 planes in two years while China Southern will have 67 additions this year, the carriers have said.

‘Tomorrow’s growth will further pressure the system,’’ said Will Horton, a Hong Kong-based analyst at CAPA Centre for Aviation, which advises airlines. “While reforms are gradually being made, the military seems impervious to the government’s wish for more airspace.”

While carriers await the easing of airspace rules, the nation is expanding its airport infrastructure. Beijing has won approval for its new facility with an investment of more than 70 billion yuan ($11 billion), Beijing News reported in January. The country targets to have 260 airports by 2020 from 183 at present.

“The emergence of a rapidly growing middle-class with aspirations to travel, along with record levels of urbanization and continued growth in business, has created a pressing need for better aviation infrastructure across China,” said Will Lau, an aviation consultant with EC Harris (Hong Kong) Ltd. Still, “the physical assets on the ground will not effectively respond to the passenger demand unless additional capacity is also made available in the skies above.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Jasmine Wang in Hong Kong at jwang513@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Vipin V. Nair at vnair12@bloomberg.net