Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

More studies demanded on third runway impact

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-06/18/content_12727350.htm

18 June 2011

Green groups charge many environmental factors not addressed in airport study

The Airport Authority is attempting to dismiss environmental concerns about the proposed third runway, green groups alleged on Friday.

Nine environment groups argued the Airport Authority should address the influence on various aspects of the environment such as the marine life, including the habitat of Chinese White Dolphins.

It should assess noise pollution, and carbon emissions by aircraft and their affect on air quality, the groups said.

In this connection, they urged the authority to release more information and extend the public consultation period.

The Airport Authority responded that it already explained the findings in the preliminary impact assessment study.

The authority said it has collected invaluable views and that it will continue to explain the preliminary findings and carefully consider the views it received.

It also expressed hopes to conclude public consultation on Sept 2 as planned.

The Airport Authority recently published a consultation paper on planned expansion.

It contains two options, with the first being to maintain the present two runways to address medium-term development.

The second option proposes a third runway to increase the capacity beyond 2030.

The authority planned to consult the public for three months.

Nine green groups from Hong Kong on Friday had a three-hour meeting with Stanley Hui, the authority’s chief executive, and his senior management team.

Speaking to a media conference after the meeting, Thomas Choi, senior environmental affairs officer of Friends of the Earth, said the groups were concerned with air quality if the third runway goes ahead.

Besides, the report does not take into account carbon emissions by vehicles passing by the airport’s vicinity, including Tung Chung and North Lantau, Choi said.

Samuel Hung, chairman of the Hong Kong Dolphin Conservation Society, said the authority has attempted to dismiss the impacts on the Chinese White Dolphins by modifying the document on dolphin movements that he had prepared for the Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department.

The authority management finally apologized to the green groups. The environment groups responded that the authority should apologize to the public for having misled the people of Hong Kong.

Alan Leung, WWF Hong Kong’s conservation manager, also voiced concern for the environment of the Chinese White Dolphins.

He also asked the authority to provide more information on the ecological environment of the site designated for reclamation because the site is restricted area.

China Daily

Airport plan can’t take off without reliable growth forecast and cost-benefit analysis

South China Morning Post – 18 June 2011

The discussion over the airport expansion is being played out with few facts and much emotive fervour: if we don’t expand, Hong Kong will no longer have the great airport we have all become so used to. And that is, of course, a horrible idea, as I don’t know any airport that is as efficient.

Digging through the avalanche of slick advertising, the appendices of the technical report reveal the assumptions of growth behind the third runway. But where is all this growth going to come from?

After all, Hong Kong’s population is flatlining and the forecast growth in passengers goes well beyond the wildest arrival forecasts of visitors who intend to stay in Hong Kong for at least one night, or head for one of our gambling cruises.

As for cargo, the growth numbers are even more staggering. The anticipated volumes are well beyond what we make or consume in Hong Kong. So where are the flows supposed to come from?

Neither of these questions are answered. Rather than using detailed gravity models, growth in both passengers and cargo is forecast based on simple linear regression models along the lines of “gross domestic product will go up, people and cargo will move”. But does that make sense?

For a long time, Hong Kong was the only provider of international flights and quality cargo handling in the Pearl River Delta. Today, it handles 80 per cent of all international passengers and 90 per cent of all international air cargo in the delta. To assume it will retain that role is rather arrogant.

Proponents of a third runway say Guangzhou’s new cargo handling capabilities are not as efficient, and their customs operations are cumbersome. Surely Guangzhou will say they are ironing out the issues.

On top of this, the question is whether it is sustainable to run trucks between manufacturers and Hong Kong when they can and should have closer facilities. The additional fuel used and associated emissions, the roads that need to be built, the additional cost of trucks and drivers, all appear a bad business proposition and a burden on our environment.

Proponents quickly chime in to explain that it is not just cargo to and from the mainland; we can be the air cargo hub for the region. That business model involves flying cargo to Hong Kong only to repack it and send it out to other destinations on old, noisy and polluting planes. Travel trade representatives have tried scare tactics: if we don’t expand the airport, residents will no longer be able to enjoy direct flights to their destination, since competition for limited landing slots will result in the consolidation of routes.

In the same breath, they explained how everyone else in Asia should fly indirectly via Hong Kong – an expectation beyond belief.

The proponents of the third runway are asking the Hong Kong taxpayers to fund a HK$100 billion shortfall. What the papers don’t show are the external costs we will have to bear: more emissions from aircraft and associated road traffic; more noise pollution; the additional road and rail capacity to be built; the large pieces of land to be reclaimed.

It is unclear who, exactly, benefits from this investment. Yes, a huge “return” is identified but it simply says “more passengers and goods equal more money”. That’s an interesting circle, as the increase in passengers and goods was based on the simple “more money, more people and goods” model in the first place. There is no breakdown of origin and destination of the passengers or the cargo. Hub traffic brings few benefits to Hong Kong.

The Hong Kong public would be better off with the development of high-quality airports with excellent air cargo terminals close to the destinations throughout the region. This would minimise energy consumption, pollution and traffic.

It would also take the pressure off Hong Kong’s airport. We can continue to invest in making our existing runways and airspace more efficient by fixing our air traffic control systems and procedures so we can handle our home-grown traffic well into the future.

If the proponents really want a third runway, let them pay for it themselves with landing charges – and, if so, please make sure that old, polluting planes pay more.

Paul Zimmerman is CEO of Designing Hong Kong

Authority defends impact study decision on runway

Hong Kong Standard – 15 June 2011

The Airport Authority has defended its decision not to commission an environmental impact study on the third runway before seeking the views of the public.

Authority chief executive Stanley Hui Hon-chung said yesterday a detailed assessment will only be carried out once the public has agreed to give the controversial project the go-ahead.

The government-owned authority has put forward two options for the public to consider.

One is to build a third, parallel 3,800-meter runway north of the existing two at an estimated cost of HK$136.2 billion, with inflation factored in.

It will be Hong Kong’s costliest single infrastructure project and requires reclamation of 650 hectares, the second- largest in local history.

The other is an expansion of the two- runway airport, costing up to HK$42.5 billion, including inflation.

In an interview with The Standard, Hui said: “We don’t know which option will win the hearts of Hong Kong people in the end.

“It may need more than HK$100 million to conduct an environmental impact assessment.

“If we did it now, some might question the rationality of only carrying out an impact study on [the third-runway option but not the other].”

He said environmental protection and economic development are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

The aviation industry currently accounts for more than 2 percent of global carbon dioxide.

Hui said the authority has presented to the public both “very comprehensive” and “credible” information provided by its consultants.

“If you find our information incorrect, you may seek views from your own experts,” he said.

On the possibility of enhancing collaboration with mainland and Macau airports, Hui was more guarded.

He said this matter has to be handled carefully so as to abide by the principle of one country, two systems.

After all, mainland cities and Macau may wonder why they should cooperate with Hong Kong International Airport just to benefit the territory.

In response to concerns over the HK$136.2 billion price tag, Hui said on the grounds of reclamation alone, costs should not be directly compared with those of new runways overseas.

Hong Kong Airport 3rd Runway debate

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-06/11/content_12675548.htm

Airport upgrade warrants more options

By Song Sio-Chong (HK Edition)

Updated: 2011-06-11 07:43

On June 2 the Airport Authority (AA) released its “Hong Kong International Airport Master Plan 2030”. One option outlined is a plan to upgrade the two existing runways at a cost of HK$23.4 billion with HK$432 billion of economic benefits. The other option is to build a third runway with an investment of HK$86.2 billion, accruing HK$912 billion of economic benefits over 50 years.

Which one do you choose? As the first upgrading option will still see saturation of airport capacity by 2017, then the obvious answer is the second option judging by its face value. I will certainly vote for option two if there is no third option on the table. But are there in fact any more viable alternatives?

I believe other related factors should be considered before making any decision. The first is about the site area and location of the airport. With two existing runways, the total site area of the airport is about 1,255 hectares. With an additional third runway, the total site area would then be 1,905 hectares. That is to say about 650 hectares of land will have to be reclaimed from the sea for the second option to work. As the reclamation will be carried out at a rather deeper seabed compared with the existing runway, the land reclamation alone will cost HK$38.9 billion plus an additional HK$9 billion to prevent the release of toxic mud.

This cost will be sufficient to build a new airport in the New Territories with one runway (option three). Then the new second airport could cater for another runway and meet needs beyond the 2030s or 2040s. But in the current option two, when all three runways are at full capacity by the 2030s, it will be impossible to build the fourth runway. So what will our options be if other potential locations have already been occupied?

The second factor concerns economic benefit. At first glimpse, one may believe the economic benefits from option two (HK$912 billion) is much better than option one (HK$432 billion), but if the investment between option two (HK$86.2 billion) and option one (HK$23.4 billion) are compared, it appears that option one will produce better benefits in terms of returns in the future, provided that there is another airport development before option one is saturated in 2017. If this is the case, then the combination of option one and option three appears to be better than option two alone.

Both option one and option two have the same capacity of 34 flights per runway per hour, thus the total capacity of option one ( with two runways) will be 68, and option two (with three runways) 102 per hour respectively. My third related issue is with how we can increase this capacity. Technically speaking, the capacity of any runway depends on aircraft types, its taxiway system, air traffic control techniques, and apron capacity, landing aids etc. If all conditions are satisfactory, the world maximum figure could rise to 50 flights per hour under the Visual Flight Rule. I wonder whether the Hong Kong record could be improved from 34 to 40 or 45 flights per hour without sacrificing safety as the first priority. If the capacity for the existing runways to handle flight movement could be substantially expanded, then the time before saturation would be extended.

The fourth factor regards the air traffic forecast. Flight movements at Chek Lap Kok International Airport have risen on average by 6.5 percent per year, and the two existing runways will become saturated by 2017. Although the growth figures may be accurate in retrospect, it may not necessarily have the same accuracy in forecasting the future. The reasons are twofold: one is the competition from adjacent airports, particularly Shenzhen Baoan Airport and Guangzhou Baiyun Airport. As they can build their airports with similar flight capacity at a cost of about 10 percent of that of Hong Kong, they collect much less airport charges than Hong Kong. Notwithstanding that the Hong Kong AA is operating under prudent commercial principles, Hong Kong AA may not compete with its adjacent counterparts respecting airport charges as Hong Kong has a much more expansive airport.

The other reason is the development of the super railway and highway networks on the mainland. In light of China developing the fastest super railway system in the world, a short-haul flight of up to 800 kilometers cannot compete in terms of cost and time, unless Hong Kong can have much shorter check-in time, cheaper tickets and more frequent flights. Medium-haul flights of about 2,000 km may also find it difficult to compete with the super railway network. With a more convenient highway network, Hong Kong residents who live in Kowloon and New Territories (East and North) may also prefer to use Shenzhen Baoan Airport rather than Hong Kong Chek Lap Kok Airport in the future.

Based on this twofold analysis, I believe the forecast of 6.5 percent growth is too optimistic as short distance flights will be reduced, and medium-haul flights may have not grown as expected. If I remember correctly, the government had briefed the Legislative Council on its plan to proceed with the privatization exercise of the airport in February 2004, and the Economic Development and Labour Bureau published a consultation document on Partial Privatization of the AA in November 2004 that showed an unsatisfactory equity return of less than 2 percent in a worst-case scenario. It would be really interesting to note what made the AA take a U-turn on the subject of airport development.

I do not mean to discourage Hong Kong airport development. On the contrary, I strongly believe Hong Kong should have a wise strategy for airport development in order to maintain its status as a center of international and regional aviation as required by Article 128 of the Basic Law. More options and deeper study are needed.

The author is a current affairs commentator.

(HK Edition 06/11/2011 page3)

http://www.thestandard.com.hk/news_detail.asp?we_cat=12&art_id=111926&sid=32674402&con_type=3&d_str=20110610&fc=7

” Sung believes too that what officials fear most is an environmental impact assessment unfavorable to the project.

The airport opened in July 1998. Seventy billion dollars of public and private money went for terminals, runways, taxiways, bays and ancillary facilities.

Another HK$34 billion went into the airport railway, and billions more on bridges, tunnels and expressways to make the Lantau site  accessible.

The all- in cost was HK$155 billion.”

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-06/24/content_12764351.htm

” The diversification of firms such as Foxconn and the consequent drop in air cargo have taken place therefore mainly at the Hong Kong International Airport, and it probably explains the monthly declines in cargo turnover in April and May this year. If this truly is the case and the decline is structural instead of seasonal, one should expect further declines in air cargo shipments in the coming months and perhaps even years.  It may become a long-term declining trend if the metropolitanization process in the PRD region turns it into a service economy instead, thereby forcing most of the manufacturing activities to shift to places further away from the core areas of Guangzhou and Hong Kong. Thus Hong Kong’s airport will lose the local industry’s demand for air cargo freight from the region forever.

Hong Kong has to find new sources of demand to sustain its current operations and the new runway beyond the next 12 years. Even so, the competition will be very acute because of the large increase in capacity in the regional cluster of airports. Thus late expansion of the airport in Hong Kong is running counter to any conventional wisdom.

The author is head of China Business Centre, Hong Kong Polytechnic University. ”

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-06/18/content_12727350.htm Hong Kong  China Daily

More studies demanded on third runway impact By Joseph Li (HK Edition) Updated: 2011-06-18 06:45

“Besides, the report does not take into account carbon emissions by vehicles passing by the airport’s vicinity, including Tung Chung and North Lantau, Choi said.

Samuel Hung, chairman of the Hong Kong Dolphin Conservation Society, said the authority has attempted to dismiss the impacts on the Chinese White Dolphins by modifying the document on dolphin movements that he had prepared for the Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department.  The authority management finally apologized to the green groups. The environment groups responded that the authority should apologize to the public for having misled the people of Hong Kong.  ”

www.scmp.com

Emissions from aircraft will grow   Letters Page

The 2 per cent aviation emissions figure Cathay Pacific  Mark Watson cites (“Aviation industry is committed to addressing climate change impact”, June 20) in response to my letter (“Emissions accelerating, not declining”, June 13) differ from the 3-3.5 per cent cited by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) website.

The ICAO’s projected aircraft emissions growth of 3-4 per cent per year contrasts with Mr Watson’s planned halving of emissions by 2050. In 38 years, a 3.5 per cent exponential growth will quadruple, not halve, current emissions: 628 million tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) annually will become 2,512 million tonnes. Because aircraft engines release CO2, nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulates into the stratosphere, their impact is amplified. Current contrail-generated cirrus clouds insulate the atmosphere adding an independent warming effect greater than all previous aircraft CO2/NOX emissions since we began flying. Also, the 70 per cent of improvement in aircraft fuel efficiency has already been achieved. To “radically reduce” that remaining 30 per cent of emissions is technically increasingly difficult.

Any future efficiency improvements are offset by the doubling of flights projected by the Airport Authority……………… I quote: “HK’s GDP forecast at compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 3.4 per cent” (GDP doubles in 20 years); “Mainland’s CAGR at 7 per cent” (an unrealistic quadruple GDP increase over 38 years); “Air traffic demand doubling by 2030”, coincidentally, a 3.5 per cent annualised growth in demand. Where is this growth to come from? Cheap extractable oil, without which these growth projections are unfeasible, is almost exhausted.   If the authority’s growth projections are correct, aircraft emissions will rise exponentially, making climate change a major problem – or Peak Oil will terminate the 20th century infinite-economic-growth/business-as-usual model, making flying prohibitively expensive, thereby killing demand. Thus, a third runway either adds to climate change or is redundant.

Richard Fielding, Pok Fu Lam

http://sph.hku.hk/faculty_and_staff_detail.php?id=20

http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-asia-miles/1221482-third-runway-hong-kong-international-airport-going-needed-cathay-pacific-7.html#post16671845

Airport upgrade warrants more options

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-06/11/content_12675548.htm

Airport upgrade warrants more options

On June 2 the Airport Authority (AA) released its “Hong Kong International Airport Master Plan 2030”. One option outlined is a plan to upgrade the two existing runways at a cost of HK$23.4 billion with HK$432 billion of economic benefits. The other option is to build a third runway with an investment of HK$86.2 billion, accruing HK$912 billion of economic benefits over 50 years.

Which one do you choose? As the first upgrading option will still see saturation of airport capacity by 2017, then the obvious answer is the second option judging by its face value. I will certainly vote for option two if there is no third option on the table. But are there in fact any more viable alternatives?

I believe other related factors should be considered before making any decision. The first is about the site area and location of the airport. With two existing runways, the total site area of the airport is about 1,255 hectares. With an additional third runway, the total site area would then be 1,905 hectares. That is to say about 650 hectares of land will have to be reclaimed from the sea for the second option to work. As the reclamation will be carried out at a rather deeper seabed compared with the existing runway, the land reclamation alone will cost HK$38.9 billion plus an additional HK$9 billion to prevent the release of toxic mud.

This cost will be sufficient to build a new airport in the New Territories with one runway (option three). Then the new second airport could cater for another runway and meet needs beyond the 2030s or 2040s. But in the current option two, when all three runways are at full capacity by the 2030s, it will be impossible to build the fourth runway. So what will our options be if other potential locations have already been occupied?

The second factor concerns economic benefit. At first glimpse, one may believe the economic benefits from option two (HK$912 billion) is much better than option one (HK$432 billion), but if the investment between option two (HK$86.2 billion) and option one (HK$23.4 billion) are compared, it appears that option one will produce better benefits in terms of returns in the future, provided that there is another airport development before option one is saturated in 2017. If this is the case, then the combination of option one and option three appears to be better than option two alone.

Both option one and option two have the same capacity of 34 flights per runway per hour, thus the total capacity of option one ( with two runways) will be 68, and option two (with three runways) 102 per hour respectively. My third related issue is with how we can increase this capacity. Technically speaking, the capacity of any runway depends on aircraft types, its taxiway system, air traffic control techniques, and apron capacity, landing aids etc. If all conditions are satisfactory, the world maximum figure could rise to 50 flights per hour under the Visual Flight Rule. I wonder whether the Hong Kong record could be improved from 34 to 40 or 45 flights per hour without sacrificing safety as the first priority. If the capacity for the existing runways to handle flight movement could be substantially expanded, then the time before saturation would be extended.

The fourth factor regards the air traffic forecast. Flight movements at Chek Lap Kok International Airport have risen on average by 6.5 percent per year, and the two existing runways will become saturated by 2017. Although the growth figures may be accurate in retrospect, it may not necessarily have the same accuracy in forecasting the future. The reasons are twofold: one is the competition from adjacent airports, particularly Shenzhen Baoan Airport and Guangzhou Baiyun Airport. As they can build their airports with similar flight capacity at a cost of about 10 percent of that of Hong Kong, they collect much less airport charges than Hong Kong. Notwithstanding that the Hong Kong AA is operating under prudent commercial principles, Hong Kong AA may not compete with its adjacent counterparts respecting airport charges as Hong Kong has a much more expansive airport.

The other reason is the development of the super railway and highway networks on the mainland. In light of China developing the fastest super railway system in the world, a short-haul flight of up to 800 kilometers cannot compete in terms of cost and time, unless Hong Kong can have much shorter check-in time, cheaper tickets and more frequent flights. Medium-haul flights of about 2,000 km may also find it difficult to compete with the super railway network. With a more convenient highway network, Hong Kong residents who live in Kowloon and New Territories (East and North) may also prefer to use Shenzhen Baoan Airport rather than Hong Kong Chek Lap kok Airport in the future.

Based on this twofold analysis, I believe the forecast of 6.5 percent growth is too optimistic as short distance flights will be reduced, and medium-haul flights may have not grown as expected. If I remember correctly, the government had briefed the Legislative Council on its plan to proceed with the privatization exercise of the airport in February 2004, and the Economic Development and Labour Bureau published a consultation document on Partial Privatization of the AA in November 2004 that showed an unsatisfactory equity return of less than 2 percent in a worst-case scenario. It would be really interesting to note what made the AA take a U-turn on the subject of airport development.

I do not mean to discourage Hong Kong airport development. On the contrary, I strongly believe Hong Kong should have a wise strategy for airport development in order to maintain its status as a center of international and regional aviation as required by Article 128 of the Basic Law. More options and deeper study are needed.

The author is a current affairs commentator.

HK needs to coordinate with PRD region airports

10 June 2011

http://www.cdeclips.com/en/hongkong/fullstory.html?id=67404 04-Jul-11

The nine cities in the Pearl River Delta (PRD) region are undergoing a process of integration or
metropolitanization under the active intervention of all levels of government. Originally it was
planned that economic integration of the PRD cities would essentially be achieved in 2020.
Guangdong province’s 12th Five-year Plan approved in March this year moved forward the
target date for regional economic integration to 2015.
This may have been encouraged by the smooth progress of the merger of Guangzhou and
Foshan, which has been regarded as the first example of economic integration in the region with
a demonstrative effect on other inter-city integration processes. If the target is accomplished, by
2015 we should see the rudimentary form of a regional metropolis centering on Guangzhou.
As planned, the PRD regional network of railways – inter-provincial high speed, inter-city fast
speed, and local subways (400 kilometers of railway lines in total in Guangzhou, Shenzhen,
Foshan and Dongguan) will also be completed and in operation by 2015. Thus there will not
just be institutional changes, but also socio-physical changes in time-space compression. The
Guangzhou-centric region will be a one-hour socio-economic zone for a resident population of
40-50 million.
But so far PRD economic integration has not been incorporated in Hong Kong. Through the
cooperation framework agreement signed between the two governments of Hong Kong and
Guangdong, however, there is a platform for integrative cooperation. This will be more
important for Hong Kong than Guangdong as the PRD will be much larger than Hong Kong
with a per capita GDP by 2015 of more than $20,000 (in Guangzhou and Shenzhen at least) and
has an economic dynamism that is envied by most countries in the world.
Given the scale and economic dynamism of the PRD, the importance of Hong Kong to the
region has declined substantially and the whole region could do without Hong Kong. But Hong
Kong cannot survive without the PRD. It needs it for water, food, daily necessities, corporations
for IPOs, and money for shares in the stock market, properties in the real estate market and
goods in the consumer market.
And the Guangzhou-centric PRD could do without the Hong Kong international airport. The
Guangzhou airport is rapidly expanding its international destinations and it has many flights to
emerging markets that Hong Kong does not have. Everyone now knows very well that emerging
markets represent the future. The advanced economies appear to be going into a general decline
because of deindustrialization and ageing population. The Hong Kong International Airport’s
overconcentration in flights to the advanced economies would prove to be a mistaken or too
short-sighted strategy.
If we take the PRD as being akin to Greater London, then the Guangzhou airport could be
compared with Heathrow Airport and Shenzhen could well be Gatwick Airport if its trend of
adding international flights continues. If Greater London can support five airports, the PRD
should be able to do so as well in the coming years as they continue to develop. In such a
scenario, Hong Kong airport may be incorporated into the regional system to take over the role
of Shenzhen and take on a supportive role to Guangzhou’s airport, which is planned to have five
runways.
We all know that air space over the PRD is rather limited. By adding new runways without a
correspondent increase in the use of air space would not result in any significant increase in
flights. The existing five airports in the region (or seven if the two smaller ones in Foshan and
Huizhou are added into the mix) with a total number of operating runways at eight (with the
ninth now under construction in Guangzhou) have already caused congestion and delays.
Without coordination the three major cities in the region – Guangzhou, Hong Kong and
Shenzhen – are each going their own way to build in the coming years an additional two
runways for Guangzhou, and one each for Hong Kong and Shenzhen. The problem of
congestion would multiply and all airports would suffer.
If Hong Kong is not included in the regional system, the third runway in Hong Kong may not be
given priority over the other runways in Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Hong Kong also does not
have a priority in the allocation of air space time. The only viable option for Hong Kong is
therefore its incorporation into the regional system and to ask for better coordination among the
five airports.
I believe that if Hong Kong is willing, the central and provincial governments will welcome
Hong Kong airport to serve as the Gatwick for Guangzhou. At the same time, the Shenzhen
airport could very well serve as the second airport of Hong Kong. There will still be a need for a
third runway at Hong Kong airport, but it should be the next runway to be constructed in the
region with the full blessing of the central and provincial governments to ensure that it is placed
ahead of Guangzhou and Shenzhen. Hong Kong needs to cooperate with Guangzhou and see
itself as part of the greater PRD metropolis, not as a competitor to the emerging PRD
metropolis.

The runway debate

South China Morning Post

With debate on the pros and cons of building a third runway at Chek Lap Kok under way, John Slosar is convinced the plan is critical to Hong Kong’s future growth while Albert Lai wants the airport authority to provide a comprehensive report of its potential impact and alternatives
John Slosar and Albert Lai 
Jun 09, 2011
The debate on a third runway for Hong Kong’s airport is now in full swing – and so it should be. I believe the community decision – build a third runway or tinker around the edges of the status quo – is crucial to the sustainability of the Hong Kong economy and, therefore, to the long-term prosperity (SEHK: 0803,announcements, news) and well-being of Hong Kong people.

There are important cost-benefit, environmental and social issues to be addressed, and I am confident a constructive community debate will identify and resolve them. All of Hong Kong will need to pull together on this one.

Cathay Pacific’s position is clear – we believe a third runway is essential to the long-term growth and development of the Hong Kong economy. We also believe the need for it is urgent, and becoming increasingly so.

Why do we believe we need a third runway at the Hong Kong International Airport? It’s important to frame the debate through the prism of Hong Kong’s place in world. That means a focus on three key contexts:

  • The airport has been a fabulous success story and will reach capacity saturation 15 to 20 years before the original forecast date of 2040. We should invest on the back of that success.
  • Aviation is the foundation on which the four pillars of Hong Kong’s economy – finance, trade and logistics, tourism and professional services – are built. These are international, not domestic, industries that rely heavily on our connectivity to the rest of the world.
  • It has taken more than a decade to achieve the critical mass needed for Chek Lap Kok to become Asia’s premier aviation hub. We have many regional competitors ready to take that mantle if we let it slip.

That’s the big picture. And as a key driver of our economy, aviation is at the core of that big picture. The industry supports more than 260,000 jobs, or over 7 per cent of the total working population and accounts for 8.2 per cent of our gross domestic product, according to a Chinese University of Hong Kong study.

These facts speak for themselves.

The four pillars of our economy will be at risk if we don’t have the future runway capacity at Chek Lap Kok to leverage our superb location at the heart of Asia and our unrivalled access to the mainland market.

The Airport Authority’s master plan to 2030 spells out with great clarity the challenges facing the airport if long-term growth is constrained. It rightly says Hong Kong would begin to lose its status and competitiveness as an international business centre and aviation hub.

Are there alternatives to a third runway? One option is to nip and tuck around the edges with the existing two runways. Frankly, this option only buys us a couple more years of growth and then we run into constraints again. The great artery that is our aviation hub would then still clog up and no amount of bypass surgery will fix it. And that would mean a slow choking of the lifeblood of our economy, with the resulting loss of growth, opportunities and jobs.

It has been suggested that we collaborate with one or more of the other four airports in the Pearl River Delta to obviate the need for a third runway. One idea is to split “duties” between two airports – Hong Kong handling long haul, Shenzhen handling domestic flights with a rail link connecting the two airports. A great idea on paper that just won’t work.

As David Dodwell pointed out on this page last week, experience around the world shows that passengers simply do not like inter-airport transfer. And why should they when they can be served by a single, magnificent airport like the one we have in Hong Kong?

Attempts to link airports elsewhere in the world – even two airports within the same metropolitan area – have not been successful.

In London, Heathrow and Gatwick do not operate as one airport and transfer traffic between the two is almost non-existent. In the United States, New York, Chicago and San Francisco have been unable to generate transfer traffic between the major airports in each city. And closer to home in Japan, Haneda and Narita airports do not support each other. There is not a single example anywhere in the world where a two airport “link-up” has worked.

In any event, Shenzhen airport’s second runway is due to open later this year but, even with this additional runway, it will face capacity constraints around the same time that our own airport reaches a bottleneck. So it’s not a starter, either.

As a major international financial centre, trade and logistics hub and prime travel destination, Hong Kong needs to have its own airport with long-term capacity to keep us ahead of the game. And while our aviation hub might be winning the race now, our competitors will gallop past us if we don’t keep up the pace. We need to invest on the back of the spectacular success of our aviation hub by growing it, not stifling it. That way enables us to seize the opportunities so uniquely provided to us by our special relationship with China and our strategic location at the heart of Asia. If we don’t grasp this great opportunity, the only people celebrating will be our rivals in Singapore, Seoul, Taipei and Bangkok.

John Slosar is chief executive of Cathay Pacific Airways (SEHK: 0293)


The nervousness of the officials selling the plan for a third airport runway last week was matched only by the impressive line-up of the lobbying team. The voice of politicians and academics backing the plan swamped the airwaves for days after it was announced.

The authority knows it has a tough plan to sell: a price tag of HK$136 billion, the biggest reclamation of land since the handover, an irreversible damage to an important dolphin habitat, and a yet-to-be quantified impact to climate change and air quality. Despite the adverse impact, the best chance for the government to convince the community of its plan is to adopt an honest approach in public engagement.

Economists and commentators were quick to question the authority’s estimate of economic return – HK$912 billion over 50 years. But the biggest surprise of the plan was not what it contains, but what it omits despite years of preparation.

In 2007, when Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen was pursuing his second term, he promised a grand plan to link up the Hong Kong and Shenzhen airports with a high-speed rail line. At that time, this was touted as an ingenious way to integrate the two airports and to enhance Hong Kong’s competitive position as an air traffic hub. Nothing much has been heard since.

Government officials were silent on this project in the launch last week. Has this been considered as an alternative or supplement to the third runway? If and when the third runway is built, are we going to spend another HK$100 billion or more on this rail link? If plans for the rail link have been dumped, don’t Hongkongers have the right to know even though that means the chief executive may lose face over yet another broken promise?

The people cannot be expected to decide on the basis of incomplete options, which should include not just the rail link, but other possibilities such as a shorter third runway to cater primarily for mainland-bound flights.

Another major omission is the lack of proposed measures to mitigate the negative environmental impact. Officials vow to “balance” economic development with environmental protection. One would therefore expect estimates of economic gains on one hand, and plans for marine conservation, pollution reduction and carbon offset on the other. Instead, the public was told that none of the latter would surface until an environmental impact assessment is conducted after the project gets the nod.

Given the deficiency of the current system for environmental impact study, this is a recipe for confrontation. What we need now is a platform for negotiation among stakeholders. The pros and cons of various options should be put on the table. The costs and benefits of mitigation plans should be examined and openly debated. Only then can a sensible balance be struck. Any attempt to delay such discussion or hide away relevant plans will only increase the mistrust of those most affected by the project.

The Airport Authority may rightly feel that it cannot jump-start the statutory environmental impact assessment process now. But it should still conduct strategic impact studies to provide sufficiently concrete plans for public scrutiny. The time and effort it spends in this exercise will be earned back during the formal process of an environmental assessment, if and when that is required. Meanwhile, the authority should release the full range of consultancy reports it commissioned over the years, and invite the Legislative Council to appoint an independent checker to verify its economic claims.

Some officials privately claim their worst fear is a judicial review that will delay the project, given the recent verdict on the bridge to Macau and Zhuhai. However misguided this claim may be, officials should nevertheless learn to engage the public early, lay out honest alternatives, and explore the best available technologies to protect the environment, in accordance with international best practice. Hong Kong has the resources to do it right.

The project comes at a difficult time for Hong Kong. Despite economic growth, Hong Kong is going through a “social recession”, as defined by Tim Jackson of the British government’s Sustainable Development Commission: rising income inequality, soaring property prices, declining social mobility and an acute sentiment of injustice in both the middle class and the grass roots. Pumping HK$136 billion into a single infrastructure project in a social recession is not likely to boost Hong Kong’s happiness index.

Yet the city has excelled in providing airport and airline services. Maintaining this competitive edge is not just about economic growth, but also about a vital means to strengthen our cultural nexus to the world. The question is how.

Albert Lai Kwong-tak is chairman of the Professional Commons and vice-chairman of the Civic Party

Runway may be a waste of money, expert says

South China Morning Post — 6 June 2011

Chek Lap Kok plan needs to address problem of crowded airspace over Pearl River Delta region

A new airport runway will not help relieve congestion because much of the problem stems from restrictive use of civilian flight routes over the Pearl River Delta region, an aviation expert warned.

Dr Law Cheung-kwok, associate director of Chinese University’s Aviation Policy and Research Centre, said a third runway could be a waste of money unless the problem of crowded airspace in the delta region is resolved.

He also said the Airport Authority could consider building a shorter runway to save money.

At yesterday’s RTHK City Forum, Law urged Hong Kong to discuss with Beijing more efficient use of airspace. “If not, there is no use having more runways,” he said.

China’s airspace is mainly controlled by the military, with civilian flights allowed to operate only on limited routes and at limited altitudes. Hong Kong’s airspace is not under the Chinese military control, but many flights still pass over the mainland.

The Airport Authority last week launched a three-month public consultation on plans to expand the Chek Lap Kok airport to cope with future needs.

One option calls for building of a third, parallel runway north of the existing two at a cost of about HK$136 billion. A cheaper option is to upgrade the existing two runways, costing HK$42.5 billion.

Law recently returned from a study trip to Frankfurt and revealed a fourth runway is being built there for under HK$10 billion. He said Hong Kong, like Frankfurt, could build a shorter, 2,800-metre runway instead of a standard 3,800-metre runway.

He added: “It should be long enough because about a third of flights using the Hong Kong airport are short-haul or domestic flights to and from China.

“There is no need for these small planes to use a long runway.”

An authority executive director Wilson Fung Wing-yip argued it was value for money because it could generate HK$900 billion in economic benefits over 50 years.

Legislator Raymond Ho Chung-tai, also an authority board member, argued short-haul visitors from the mainland would turn to taking high-speed trains to Hong Kong and that the city should focus on catering for international flights.

HKIA 2030 Primary Traffic Forecast

Download (PDF, 2.2MB)

Top Airlines Want Aviation Emissions In Climate Pact

Reuters By David Fogarty, Climate Change Correspondent, Asia – 12 Feb 2009 04:20:23 GMT SINGAPORE, Feb 12 (Reuters)

Four leading airlines called on Thursday for aviation emissions to be included in a broader climate pact, after growing criticism from green groups that the sector was not doing enough to fight global warming. The move is the first step by the world’s airlines, which account for around two percent of global pollution, to steer the debate on an emissions pact towards a deal they are happy with, rather than having one imposed on them.

Air France/KLM , British Airways , Cathay Pacific <0293.HK>, Virgin Atlantic [VA.UL] and airport operator BAA issued the call in Hong Kong and outlined a series of principles a new global deal for aviation must adhere to. Conservation groups such as WWF say aviation has not been doing enough to tackle the sector’s growing share of greenhouse gas pollution and must pay for its emissions like many other industries.

Emissions from international aviation comprise about two percent of mankind’s total carbon dioxide (CO2) pollution from burning fossil fuels and deforestation and are expected to keep rising as economies and populations grow. Green groups and governments say airlines should be part of emissions trading schemes as a start.

“This is the first time a group of airlines has got together to call for aviation to be included in a climate change treaty,” Dominic Purvis of Cathay Pacific told Reuters.

“We’re contributing to climate change and we need to play our part,” said Purvis, the airline’s general manager for environmental affairs.

Nations meet at the end of the year in the Danish capital Copenhagen to try to agree on a broader climate pact that replaces the Kyoto Protocol, the United Nations’ main weapon to fight global warming. Kyoto’s first phase ends in 2012.

The idea is to find a way for developing nations to sign up to emissions curbs and to include aviation and shipping, which together make up 5 percent of mankind’s CO2 emissions, a fifth of which come from U.S. emissions of 6 billion tonnes a year.

COST-EFFECTIVE

The United Nations’ International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) has been working for more than a decade to develop a global scheme to tackle aviation emissions.

Purvis said the four airlines would discuss existing proposals to curb emissions and feed the group’s ideas to ICAO and other airlines to try to settle on a fair and environmentally sound approach for inclusion at Copenhagen. “The best thing is to have something effective and easy to apply and cost-effective rather than to wait for someone else to come up with it and potentially take a course of action not necessarily appropriate for aviation,” he said.

The four airlines and BAA are meeting in Hong Kong and in their communique laid out principles for a global approach that included balancing social and economic benefits of flying with the industry’s responsibility to cut global emissions. The airlines also said a new global climate deal for aviation must preserve competitiveness and avoid market distortions. Many airlines say only a global approach is fair and criticise the European Union’s decision to include aviation in the bloc’s emissions trading scheme from 2012. Airlines will have to pay for their emissions over the entire route, not just within EU airspace, a rule many Asian airlines flying long-haul routes to Europe say is unfair. (Editing by Clarence Fernandez)