Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Aviation

Regulator is holding Chek Lap Kok back

Albert Cheng says air traffic control is not being fully utilised to increase capacity

South China Morning Post – Oct. 19, 2011

Last weekend, in his response to my recent column on aviation safety, the Civil Aviation Department’s assistant director general for air traffic management, Wong Ping-fai, said Hong Kong did not lack air traffic controllers. He pointed out that controllers worked an average of 36.17 hours per week and had 36 days of annual leave, which means there is no fatigue problem or overworked staff.

According to Wong, the department has 154 frontline air traffic controllers, up from 148 last year. Over the last five years, he said, there had been a 25 per cent increase in the total number of air traffic controllers.

But the number of annual flight movements has been on a rapid rise over the past four years: from 296,000 in 2007 to 310,000 last year. This year the figure is expected to reach 320,000. The volume of flight movements will therefore expand by 24,000 just over the past five years.

The current air traffic handling capacity at the Hong Kong International Airport is 62 flight movements per hour, which pales by comparison with others in neighbouring regions. Baiyun Airport in Guangzhou now handles 60 flight movements per hour, but a third runway under construction will boost capacity to 106 flights per hour when it is completed before the end of this year.

Beijing International Airport’s capacity is 68 flights per hour and London Heathrow’s is 85. It is unacceptable that Hong Kong,  as a regional aviation hub, can handle only 62 flight movements per hour.

The Civil Aviation Department has hurt our reputation by not optimising the capacity and resources of the airport. Yet department officials now propose to build a third runway, which will cost taxpayers hundreds of billions of dollars. What a waste of money! We could have reached a higher handling capacity if the department could better utilise resources.

The old Kai Tak airport, right in the midst of residential buildings and with only one runway, could handle 35 flight movements per hour. Now, Chek Lap Kok with two runways and a far less challenging location for pilots to land can’t even double the Kai Tak capacity. How ridiculous it makes us look.

The problem is that we are operating with the format of “one in, one out”. Incoming aircraft land on the northern runway while outgoing flights take off from the southern runway instead of utilising both runways for take-off and landing. It defies logic why we can’t allow both runways to operate independently.

It’s obvious that the stumbling block is the Civil Aviation Department’s refusal to move with the times. They appear to be reluctant to upgrade existing equipment to optimise the capacity of existing runways to allow landings and take-offs to take place on both runways.

The key to making this work is whether we can maintain the safety margin as well as efficiency when allowing incoming and outgoing flights to take place on both runways at the same time.

It’s true that the surrounding landscape at the airport does make it slightly difficult to come up with an ideal set of approach and departure procedures as well as missed approach procedures. But it’s not impossible.

The Civil Aviation Department is well equipped to handle the situation. In 2000, it bought a multimillion-dollar air traffic control radar – the Precision Runway Monitor, which provides the most up-to-date, real-time data to air traffic controllers to prevent any aircraft deviating from its intended flight path and give out timely warnings in advance.

The PRM could be put to better use to help raise our airport capacity. The department can’t keep on shirking its responsibility by putting the blame on outside factors such as the congested airspace in the Pearl River Delta region.

We need to seriously consider the option and allow both runways to operate at maximum capacity. At the same time, we must recruit more air traffic controllers to handle future flight movement increases. It’s time to welcome foreign talent.

Albert Cheng King-hon is a political commentator. taipan@albertcheng.hk

Wing and a prayer

Clear the Air says:   and this is before the current building of the midfield Chep Lap Kok airport extension is completed and then the Government CX , HACTL and DHL  want a third runway ………………….?

Hong Kong Standard – 14 Oct. 2011

Wing and a prayer

Phila Siu
http://www.thestandard.com.hk/newsimage/20111014/5_2011101319194814791cover_air02.jpg
Friday, October 14, 2011

Look up and listen and it’s almost certain there’s an aircraft arriving or leaving Hong Kong International Airport. Like its passengers, you will assume – if the thought even occurs – that besides its pilot and crew an aircraft is in the good care of controllers as they track it on screens in their Chek Lap Kok tower.

It’s probably because the fallout from anything less than 100-percent performances in the tower is so horrible to imagine that few people other than air crews actually get to thinking about controller performance. But we should all be wondering and perhaps fretting about what’s going on in the tower now that details of near misses in Hong Kong airspace have come to light.

If disgruntled personnel in Air Traffic Control are close to the mark, a human time bomb has long been ticking in the tower – “the lion’s den,” as some pilots call it – and near-misses brought to light in an investigation by The Standard give new lift to calls for remedial action on controller rostering.

Controllers complain about a lack of staff in the tower and unreasonable working routines that lead to fatigue. Pilots say it’s reflected in declining standards among the people they depend on above most others.

http://www.thestandard.com.hk/newsimage/20111014/6_2011101319194814791cover_CAD02.jpg

Against them, top managers in the Civil Aviation Department say there are enough well-rested controllers to meet the traffic demands at what ranks as the world’s 10th busiest airport, where passenger traffic reached five million in August and 28,940 planes landed and depa

rted in the month.

On paper, there does seem to be enough controllers to look after all of us who fly. Overall strength at present is around 165 “active” controllers in three sections: tower, approach and area control.

There are also between 40 and 50 seasoned controllers in project groups and evaluation and training units. (Gender, it should be noted, does not count in this job, with women comprising about 40 percent of overall strength.)

But something was lacking on September 18, a day when Hong Kong people’s long and easy acceptance of air travel as a sure way to get around would have been tested to breaking point if technology had not been in the hands of pilots at the top of their game.

For on this day there were two near- miss situations – meaning aircraft came close to collisions – above us. Two Cathay Pacific wide-bodied Boeings and a Dragonair Airbus were involved.

As one controller tells it, it was a day when there was just not enough personnel in the tower. The situation became so bad that a supervisor and a watch manager had to sit in front of screens when they should have been shouldering broader responsibilities on a rainy, windy day.

Making the situation worse, it’s said, was the fact this was a Sunday, meaning a lack of support personnel who on any other day could and should have been alerting senior managers elsewhere in the complex that the people in Air Traffic Control were having trouble living up to the sign on their door.

It was close to 1pm when calm control gave way to something close to chaos, with pilots on approaches or in holding patterns waiting longer than expected for landing instructions. Some reported fuel tanks getting worryingly low as they circled and awaited landing clearances for Hong Kong, others sought to divert.

That was when Cathay Pacific flight CX841 from New York almost crashed with Dragonair KA433 from Kaoshiung, passing each other at a distance of 1,850 meters.

By aviation measures that’s dangerously close when you take account of speed, but a collision was avoided because one aircraft climbed and the other descended thanks to the automatic activation of onboard avoidance systems.

Former Civil Aviation Department chief Albert Lam Kwong-yu estimates they were six seconds from a likely disaster. “The chance of a crash is absolutely high,” he says of the speed and distances between the aircraft. Although they didn’t know it “the passengers really came back from hell.”

More than 600 passengers and crew members were on the two planes.

Yet new danger was roaring in for the people on the Dragonair flight. A few minutes after the near miss with CX841 more avoidance action was required of KA433 to get clear of another Cathay Pacific flight, CX347, arriving from Beijing. This time the distance between aircraft was about 7,000m.

The stress brought on by the first near miss saw the controller concerned having to be relieved by a supervisor. And after the supervisor handled the second near miss she decided that she herself needed to be relieved.

The series of near-misses have sparked an uproar of criticism among controllers and pilots, who have aired their discontent on an aviation forum PPRuNe Forums, throwing even more light on the situation.

In seeking to fend off claims from controllers that fatigue must be taken into account when looking at such incidents, a spokeswoman for the Civil Aviation Department talks of the staffing situation on September 18.

Normally, she says, there are perhaps eight controllers in the tower, but on September 18 there were 13 because of the bad weather.

And the controller involved with the first near-miss, who has worked in Air Traffic Control for over 14 years, was fresh from a day off, so fatigue was unlikely to be a factor.

She also pointed to the department having well-worked contingency plans for emergencies such as the danger of a mid-air collision. They include a controller applying radar-supported disciplines and instructing aircraft to take specific headings away from each other and to change altitudes while still feeding data to the crews concerned.

But a Standard request for a transcript of tower recordings on the events of September 18 was rejected as it would be inappropriate and “also not fair to the involved parties for any part of the evidence or data to be released to a third party during the investigation.”

A controller tells The Standard that the problems of September 18 have been a long time in the making, and like colleagues he claims a shambles in the leave and days-off system in a 10-day cycle is the cause.

Controllers must work more than the required or recommended hours each month, he says, and many cannot enjoy proper annual leave or count on rest days.

And controllers cannot look to a union to fight for their interests, he adds. The last union president seeking a better deal on conditions quit the office after being faced down by seven senior managers.

The on-off roster system can be hard to figure, that’s for sure.

A 10-day roster should include three days off in a system that has three shifts. A controller can expect to work on all shifts over the 10 days, though with many variations.

One particularly sore point, the controller says, is that if someone is granted two days of annual leave during a 10-day cycle they will then be rostered on for two of the normal rest days. “They end up working the same amount of hours that month as everybody else. Bizarre!”

In principle, controllers work the same number of hours as any other civil servant who has a 42-hour week. But controllers are not Monday-to-Friday, daytime-only workers.

Annual leave is another source of strain. Some longer-serving controllers qualify for 40.5 days of annual leave, but low down the scale it’s two weeks.

Then there are some expatriate controllers who would like to save some leave until the end of a contract but are forced to take it all annually, while young local staff might apply for leave but have to wait until what’s owed is close to the legal limit.

Extreme case

Many controllers are said to have accumulated the legal maximum of six months of untaken leave and up to 400 hours for days worked when they should have been resting. One was actually owed more than 10 months off in leave, though that’s an extreme case.

“Any aviation specialist will agree that it is vital for pilots and controllers to have a long break of two to three weeks away from work at least once a year – preferably twice,” the controller says.

But the CAD spokeswoman says claims that controllers face problems about taking time off are “incorrect.”

In the last five years, she says, 85 percent of long-leave applications – that is, more than 14 days – have been approved.

In addition, 3,543 leave days were approved to 155 operational control staff in the first seven months of this year. On average, a controller had 22.8 leave days during the seven months. The controller who provided much of the inside story on the Chek Lap Kok tower claims that managers play with numbers to come up with this satisfactory-looking picture.

He also says the fact that some colleagues lack skills should be put down to many experienced controllers leaving “because of dissatisfaction with management, only half the salary of what they can earn overseas and the generally poor working conditions and atmosphere in Air Traffic Control.”

Frozen salaries

On pay, he claims that salaries have effectively been frozen since 1997 – a year before the opening of the airport at Chek Lap Kok. A student air traffic control officer starts on HK$16,855 a month while a senior operations officer makes between HK$82,975 and HK$95,595.

Pilots, meanwhile, continue to make their feelings known about what comes out of the tower, or what doesn’t.

One said that many pilots are becoming increasingly frustrated because some controllers appear to lack an understanding of how air traffic works.

There can be an uncomfortably long wait for instructions, he added, though he accepted that could also be due to controllers being overworked in an understaffed tower rather than a lack of skills.

There is also concern about the Civil Aviation Department trying to keep some matters under wraps – such as not offering information about the September 18 incidents until after The Standard pushed for it. (Top officials in the CAD had said previously that people should be kept in the dark about most aviation-linked incidents as it would be “inappropriate” to go public with much information about mishaps.)

There were about 500 incidents carrying classifications from “minor” to “serious” from January 2009 to April this year. Details of about 29 were made public.

And while we have yet to hear of all the lessons that may have been taken to heart after September 18, there has been one change in manpower in the tower after that frightening day.

A “contingency roster” – a boost in manpower – can now be brought into play in response to bad weather or other testing scenarios.

“It sounds very good, but the problem is that the controllers they are making available are from management,” says the tower insider. “They are not up to speed and could cause more problems.”

Roger, over and out. For now.

Virgin to develop low carbon fuel

11 Oct. 2011

Virgin Atlantic has announced plans to develop a low carbon aviation fuel “with just half the carbon footprint of the standard fossil fuel alternative”, and hopes to use the fuel for flights from China and India to London within two to three years.

The carrier is partnering with clean energy technology company LanzaTech in a project which it says will see “waste gases from industrial steel production being captured, fermented and chemically converted using Swedish Biofuels technology for use as a jet fuel”.

Virgin plans to demo the biofuel in 12-18 months, before using it on commercial routes from Shanghai and Delhi (as LanzaTech develops facilities in China and India) to London within two to three years.

Speaking at the announcement of the new partnership, Sir Richard Branson said that the new technology is “scalable, sustainable and can be commercially produced at a cost comparable to conventional jet fuel”.

Virgin said that the new generation technology “overcomes the complex land use issues associated with some earlier generation biofuels”, and added that it believes the development “will take the airline well beyond its pledge of a 30 per cent carbon reduction per passenger km by 2020”.

For a report on how airlines are attempting to reduce their environmental impact, see The race to go green in the February 2011 issue of Business Traveller.

For more information visit virginatlantic.com.

Report by Mark Caswell

Carbon tax on airlines upheld

South China Morning Post – Oct. 7, 2011

World airlines vow to continue their fight against emissions charge plan after court adviser finds in favour of European Union’s cap-and-trade system

The world’s aviation industry yesterday suffered a setback in its fight against a European Union plan to make foreign airlines pay hundreds of millions of dollars in carbon tax for flights to and from the EU.

The blow came when an adviser to the European Union Court of Justice told judges that the decision to impose the EU’s carbon cap-and-trade system on airlines beyond the region’s borders would be lawful, advice the court is likely to follow.

“The inclusion of international aviation in the EU emissions trading scheme is compatible with the provisions and principles of international law invoked,” advocate general Juliane Kokott wrote in a legal opinion for the Luxembourg-based court, rejecting arguments filed by the international aviation industry.

Several carriers and airline associations have challenged the 2008 decision by the 27 EU states to force airlines flying in and out of Europe to buy the permits under the bloc’s Emissions Trading System (ETS), fearing that it will cost their industry US$1.2 billion a year.

“Foreign governments are unlikely to accept this interpretation of the validity of the ETS being imposed unilaterally on foreign airlines,” said Andrew Herdman, director general of the Kuala Lumpur-based Association of Asia-Pacific Airlines. “This is certainly not the end of the matter.”

Tony Tyler, the head of the International Air Transport Association, said: “We are disappointed with the opinion but it is only part of a complex set of developments concerning” the carbon-trading system.

Tyler said that “many governments were rightly concerned about the infringements on sovereignty” and warned that 20 states had signed a declaration “vowing to challenge the plan’s extra-territoriality” at the International Civil Aviation Organisation, a United Nations agency.

Last month, the China Air Transport Association warned that dozens of airlines would be involved in another lawsuit it aimed to lodge by the end of the year.

China has said it fears its aviation sector will have to pay an additional 800 million yuan (HK$974.6 million) a year on flights originating or landing in Europe, and that the cost could be almost four times higher by 2020.

“If they charge us, we will charge back,” Wei Zhenzhong, the secretary general of the China Air Transport Association, told an industry conference in Hong Kong last week.

Cathay Pacific (SEHK: 0293) said: “This decision represents a green light towards an emerging patchwork of complex, bureaucratic and punitive regional schemes which will ultimately have no impact on improving the environment and will hit passengers.”

The ETS, started in 2005, is the cornerstone of the EU’s plan to fight global warming and cut carbon dioxide emissions by 20 per cent from 1990 levels by 2020.

EU Climate Commissioner Connie Hedegaard said that while the EU doesn’t want to “dictate the world”, aviation could not be excluded from such measures forever.

“I am glad to see that the advocate general’s opinion concludes that the EU directive is fully compatible with international law,” she said. “The EU reaffirms its wish to engage constructively with third countries during the implementation of this legislation.”

Bloomberg, Agence France-Presse

Lockheed Stratoliner: Is it a bird? Is it a plane? It’s both… and pollution free too

http://www.terminalu.com/travel-news/lockheed-stratoliner-is-it-a-bird-is-it-a-plane-it%e2%80%99s-both-and-pollution-free-too/16888/

Description: Lockheed Stratoliner: Is it a bird? Is it a plane? It’s both... and pollution free too

Photo: William Brown/courtesy of Tuvie

A British designer has shared a concept for a hydrogen-powered commercial jet that can fly any distance non-stop, after taking inspiration from a bird that makes the longest non-stop migratory flight in the world.

Description: The Lockheed Stratoliner concept aircraft and its bird-like design is based on the bar-tailed Godwit

The concept plane’s wings are inspired by the Bar-tailed Godwit – birds known to fly the longest routes without feeding or drinking.

The Lockheed Stratoliner concept aircraft and its bird-like design is based on the Bar-tailed Godwit: a long-billed wading bird that makes the 11,500km (7,145 mile) journey from its breeding ground in Alaska to New Zealand without the need to feed or drink.

Designer, William Brown says the Stratoliner’s oversized wings would generate large amounts of lift and allow the plane to fly at higher altitudes. It would be powered by four Cryogenic Hydrogen Turbofan engines, which would produce no pollution and use less fuel.

Brown’s work was unveiled on ‘Tuvie’ – a website that encourages users to submit a futuristic design or concept for publication.

Description: Lockhead stratosphere bird plane

Lockheed Stratoliner fact box: Click image to enlarge

The beaked concept plane may be impractical but it pushes the envelope of what passenger air travel could be like in future and how planes might be powered, as the airline industry continues to develop greener alternatives to fossil fuels.

In reality, research so far has shown that hydrogen – once seen as a potential super fuel for powering tomorrow’s passenger jets – has not proven itself to be any greener than other energy sources. Scientists also point to the high energy costs to produce the highly flammable fuel.

Description: http://www.terminalu.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/829279-lockheed-stratoliner.jpg

Photo: William Brown/courtesy of Tuvie

Hydrogen-powered planes

In 2000, Airbus was involved in a European Union funded Cryoplane Project to assess the feasibility of hydrogen, in a bid to develop a zero carbon-emissions aircraft of the future.

Researchers found that planes would require fuel tanks four times larger than today’s to run the fuel, which would increase energy consumption by up to 14 percent and operating costs by 4 to 5 percent. Experts say other challenges include the ability to produce hydrogen in large enough volumes to fuel the airline industry and in an environmentally friendly way.

The airline industry has changed its focus to developing a sustainable supply chain for aviation biofuels and continues to press ahead with tests for fuels powered by algae, jatropha and camelina crops individually or blended with regular jet fuel (kerosene).

In June, KLM launched the world’s first scheduled biofueled flight, which flew 171 passengers between Amsterdam and Paris using kerosene mixed with recycled cooking oil.

While Boeing continues to research the potential of liquid hydrogen for unmanned aircraft. The plane maker expects to fly its Phantom Eye unmanned aircraft – which will be fully fuelled with liquid hydrogen – by early November. The flight is expected to demonstrate the aircraft’s capability of flying at 65,000 feet for four days without refuelling.

Zhuhai – Hong Kong Airport Joint Venture

http://www.hongkongairport.com/eng/media/press-releases/pr_909.html

Zhuhai – Hong Kong Airport Joint Venture formed
23 November 2007) – Hong Kong-Zhuhai Airport Management Co. Ltd. (HKZAM),
the joint venture between the Zhuhai Municipal People’s Government and
Airport Authority Hong Kong that manages Zhuhai Airport, today celebrated
its first anniversary with a ceremony officiated by Central and Southern
Regional Administration of Civil Aviation of China Deputy Director-General
Xu Qiuju; Zhuhai Municipal Committee of the Communist Party of China
Secretary Deng Weilong; Airport Authority Chairman Dr Victor Fung and Chief
Executive Officer Stanley Hui; and HKZAM Chairman Raymond Lai and General
Manager Vivian Cheung.
HKZAM has managed Zhuhai Airport (ZHA) since 1 October 2006. In the joint
venture’s first year, air traffic at ZHA reached record levels, a series of
enhancement projects were completed, in-town check-in lounges opened, new
airlines began serving the airport, and Hong Kong and international shops
and restaurants opened at ZHA.

On 17 February 2006, the HK Airport Authority confirmed it will hold 55%
stake in a company that operates the Zhuhai Airport, with the remaining 45%
owned by Zhuhai Airport. The company will not own the assets or the
liabilities of the airport.
http://www.zhairport.com/

Freight volumes decline dramatically to/from Hong Kong reflecting global freight trends

http://www.centreforaviation.com/analysis/freight-volumes-dropping-quite-dramatically-tofrom-hong-kong-reflecting-global-freight-trends-59064

Cathay Pacific, Hong Kong International Airport, Asia Airfreight Terminal (AAT) and Hong KongAir Cargo Terminals Limited’s (HACTL) respective Aug-2011 traffic results revealed two distinctive trends: Passenger traffic to/from Hong Kong remained strong over the summer peak while the weakness in the freight market continued in the month. The situation in Hong Kong is playing out elsewhere. According to IATA said recently that global freight markets are expected to remain weak throughout the remainder of the year, although a pick-up is likely in the lead up to the Christmas period.

The global air freight market (domestic and international) is now around 10% weaker than pre-recession levels, driven by domestic declines, IATA said.

The past few years have highlighted the financial volatility and the susceptibility of air freight to worldwide economic conditions. The sector witnessed a massive slump in demand in 2008, followed by a sharp rebound in 2009 and 1H2010, before trending to a steady decline from 3Q2010 into 2011. As noted byCathay Pacific CEO John Slosar in the Aug-2011 edition of staff magazine CX World, the current “financial and economic whirlwind” is a “stark reminder that we can’t take anything for granted”.

While a pick-up in the lead-up to Christmas is anticipated, concerns remain about the arrival of new capacity, ordered during the pre-2008 boom and occurring amid the introduction of three new widebody cargo aircraft models (the B777F in 2009, the A320-200F in 2010 and the B747-8F this year).

A brief consumer confidence snapshot

According to The Conference Board last month, US consumer confidence “deteriorated sharply in August, as consumers grew significantly more pessimistic about the short-term outlook. The index is now at its lowest level in more than two years.” Indicators measuring CEO confidence and employment trends also weakened.

The European Commission Economic and Finance Affairs similarly stated the Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI) declined by 5.0 points to 97.3 in the EU and by 4.7 points to 98.3 in the euro area in Aug-2011. “This decline resulted from a broad-based deterioration in sentiment across the sectors, with losses in confidence being particularly marked in services, retail trade and among consumers”, it said.

Japanese consumer confidence was steady in Aug-2011 after rising in the previous three months, as the economy continued to recover from the 11-Mar-2011 earthquake, the Japanese Cabinet Office said this month. Concerns centre around faltering global growth and concerns that a strong yen may dampen private spending in coming months.

Meanwhile, Chinese consumer sentiment among households, entrepreneurs and bankers weakened in the most recent quarter, according to a survey by the People’s Bank of China released this month. Concerns focus around the expected monetary-policy tightening by Beijing, with interest rates set to rise in 4Q2011, while income and job expectations also declined.

Cathay Pacific cargo volume down on both 2010 and 2009 levels in Aug-2011; gradual improvement expected over coming weeks

Cathay Pacific last month stated it expects its freight business to slow in 3Q2011 as a result of economic uncertainties. The carrier stated the cargo business performed “reasonably” in the first quarter of the year, but was appreciably weaker in the second quarter. Cathay noted that demand for cargo shipments from its two main markets, Hong Kong and mainland China, was weaker than expected in the second quarter.

Moving into the third quarter and Cathay’s overall cargo and mail tonnage showed a significant decline in Aug-2011 compared to 2010 levels. The market from Asia to Europe and trans-Pacific remained weak, though “intra-Asia continued to perform solidly”, according to GM Cargo Sales and Marketing James Woodrow. Meanwhile, additional freighter frequencies to Australia were added for Sep-2011 due to strong imports driven by the strong Australian dollar.

Cathay Pacific and Dragonair combined reported a fifth consecutive month of cargo volume reductions. The carriers handled 131,448 tonnes of cargo and mail in Aug-2011, an 11.8% year-on-year decline – to be marginally weaker than the Aug-2009 level. According to Mr Woodrow, “the first half of September overall remained soft as expected, though tonnages should start to gradually improve over the coming weeks.”

Cathay Pacific cargo volume (kg, mill): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h1.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

Cathay Pacific’s cargo and mail load factor also weakened notably in Aug-2011, down 7.8 ppts to 64.9%, marking the 12th consecutive month of year-on-year cargo load factor declines. Cargo load factors have been weaker than both 2010 and 2009 levels for three consecutive months.

Cathay Pacific cargo load factor (%): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h2.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

The significant load factor weakness occurred as cargo capacity (available cargo/mail tonne kilometres) increased 1%, marking the 18th consecutive month of capacity growth, compared to a 9.7% reduction in traffic (cargo and mail tonne kilometres flown). Cargo traffic has declined on a year-on-year basis for the past five months, but remains stronger compared to 2009 levels.

Cathay Pacific Revenue Freight Tonne Kilometres (mill): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h3.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

Cathay Pacific Available Freight Tonne Kilometres (bill): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h4.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

Strong traffic growth in summer peak for Cathay Pacific. Yields continue strong performance

It was however a different story for passenger traffic at Cathay Pacific. Traffic remained strong in the summer peak, with the increase in traffic (RPKs) in line with capacity (ASKs) growth.

“We continued to see a strong performance in the region, in particular from Southeast Asia, South Koreaand the secondary Chinese cities, though demand in the Middle East remained weak. Our premium traffic continued to have a strong performance and we are seeing good growth in terms of both volume and yield,” Cathay Pacific GM Revenue Management James Tong said.

The carrier has separately stated that demand for economy class seats was slightly less than expected. Demand for premium class seats remained strong, despite economic uncertainties in a number of world economies. Yields rose in both first and business classes

Cathay Pacific and Dragonair combined handled 2.5 million passengers in Ag-2011, a 3.6% year-on-year increase, and load factors averaged 84.2%, a 0.2 ppt year-on-year decline.

Cathay Pacific passenger numbers (mill): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h5.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

Cathay Pacific Airways Passenger Load Factor (2009 to 2011)

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h6.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airline reports

Cathay Pacific CEO John Slosar in late Aug-2011 stated Cathay has no plans to delay new aircraft as Asia is avoiding the worst of the global economic slowdown. The carrier is scheduled to receive eight new aircraft, including five freighters, in 2H2011, followed by 16 new aircraft in 2012. Cathay is “still pretty confident” about the outlook, Mr Slosar said.

Hong Kong International Airport reports cargo decline

Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA) similarly noted a 7.8% year-on-year decline in cargo levels in Aug-2011 to 319,000 tonnes, reflecting weaker economic conditions in the US and Europe.

Hong Kong International Airport Air Cargo (tonnes, ‘000s): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h7.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airport reports

The cargo declines were mainly attributed to an 11% year-on-year drop in export volume. Imports and transshipments also declined, by 5% and 1% respectively. Europe, North America, Taiwan and Japanexperienced double-digit year-on-year decreases in overall cargo traffic.

Hong Kong International Airport reports record passenger traffic in Aug-2011

On a more positive note, HKIA reported another busy month for passenger traffic, with passenger traffic and flight movements setting new monthly records in Aug-2011. Fuelled by the burgeoning demand during the traditional summer peak season, passenger traffic continued its upswing, registering a year-on-year growth of 6.5% to a new record high of 5 million.

Hong Kong International Airport passenger numbers (mill): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h8.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airport reports

The growth in passenger traffic in Aug-2011 was mainly driven by visitors’ traffic and transfer/transit passengers which saw growth of 10% and 8% respectively over the same period last year. Passenger traffic to/from South East Asia performed particularly well.

During the month, flight movements also reached a new high of 28,940, up 6.7% year on year, breaking the previous record made in Mar-2011.

Hong Kong International Airport aircraft movements (‘000s): 2009 to 2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h9.png

Source: CAPA – Centre for Aviation and airport reports

Airport Authority Hong Kong CEO Stanley Hui Hon-chung stated the airport has seen continuous growth in passengers using the cross-boundary transport. During the month, a new high of more than 249,000 passengers used the ferry services at the SkyPier connecting HKIA to eight ports in the Pearl River Delta, which represented a year-on-year growth of 11%. Mr Hui added that the growth momentum in passenger traffic at HKIA would continue as another travel peak is anticipated during the National Day Golden Week holidays.

AAT and HACTL report declined in cargo traffic. Export cargo hit the hardest. Transshipment levels increase

Asia Airfreight Terminal Co Ltd (AAT) stated tonnage throughput in Aug-2011 fell 8% to 55,203 tonnes. Export cargo registered 38,260 tonnes, a decline of 12% year-on-year. Import cargo volume weakened slightly, by 0.3% to 16,133 tonnes. Trans-shipment cargo volume was 811 tonnes, a 68% year-on-year increase.

Commenting on the result, AAT General Manager for Corporate Development, Kenneth Yeung said, “Although export has been affected by the US and European economy, import growth has been more encouraging. Maybe a sign of more balanced trade.“

Hong Kong Air Cargo Terminals Limited (Hactl) similarly reported a 9.3% year-on-year decline in air cargo tonnage throughput for Aug-2011 to 221,375 tonnes. Export volume in Aug-2011 slumped 13.3% to 117,771 tonnes and import volumes declined 8.9% to 55,345 tonnes. The transshipment volume was 48,259 tonnes in Aug-2011, to be the only growth area (+1.7%).

Outlook: Freight weakness a concern

The positive passenger traffic results in the peak month of Aug-2011 provided some welcome news for Cathay Pacific and Hong Kong International Airport amid an increasingly weak cargo sector. While cargo volumes traditionally pick-up ahead of the Christmas peak, an increasing and continued imbalance between capacity and demand is a challenge for freight operators worldwide. This combination of plentiful capacity and weak export demand from China could spell trouble for cargo load factors, yields and profitability in the months ahead.

APPENDIX:

Cathay Pacific Aug-2011 traffic highlights

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h10.png

Source: Cathay Pacific

Cathay Pacific Aug-2011 traffic highlights

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h11.png

Source: Cathay Pacific

Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA) traffic highlights for Aug-2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h12.png

(1) +/- % refers to changes over the same period of the previous year.
(2) Passenger and cargo figures are rounded to the nearest 1,000, and flight movements to the nearest 5.
(3) Total figure for passengers include originating, terminating, transfer and transit passengers. Transfer and transit passengers are counted twice.
(4) Cargo Handled includes import, export and transshipment (counted twice) cargo. Air mail is excluded.
(5) Flight Movements includes civil international passenger, cargo and non-revenue flights. Military and local flights are excluded
Source: Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA)

Asia Airfreight Terminal Co Ltd traffic highlights for eight months to  Aug-2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h13.png

Source: Asia Airfreight Terminal Co Ltd

Hong Kong Air Cargo Terminals Limited (Hactl) traffic highlights for Aug-2011

http://www.centreforaviation.com/images/stories/2011/september/19/h14.png

Source: Hong Kong Air Cargo Terminals Limited (Hactl)

Build third runway at Shenzhen

Letter to South China Morning Post

In its future development plan, the Hong Kong Airport Authority put forward two options.

Option one would maintain the existing two-runway system and this would cost costs HK$42.5 billion. Option two would see a three-runway system costing HK$136.2 billion

These proposals have major flaws. It is thinking within the box; there is a third option.

The authority has overlooked the serious implication of air pollution resulting from an unbridled increase in flights.

Many overseas companies and expatriate staff are already relocating to Singapore because of air pollution in Hong Kong.

A third option would be to build the third runway outside Hong Kong. Take a regional perspective and think in terms of Pearl River Delta regional development. The third runway can be located at Shenzhen airport, as the gateway for all passengers from China. A new airport railway can be built linking Shenzhen and Hong Kong airports.

Help can be sought from the central government to identify another plot of farmland in or outside Shenzhen to build a new supporting airport for Hong Kong, with capacity to build the fourth runway.

We would benefit from this plan in a number of ways.

The development plan would not be confined to the administrative boundaries of Hong Kong.

It would circumvent the prohibitively expensive reclamation costs and the labour shortage in Hong Kong.

It would be ore environmentally friendly, for marine ecology and air quality in Hong Kong. There would Increased regional co-operation which would benefit all parties concerned.

There would be a re-prioritisation of the landing space of Hong Kong airport to high value-added flights.

Sam Chow Tung-shan, Mid-Levels

Green tax to hit air passengers

South China Morning Post – 6 Sept. 2011

Carriers face a US$400m bill on flights to Europe next year due to levy on carbon emissions – and cost will ‘inevitably’ be passed on to customers

http://www.scmp.com/files/SCMP/Opinion/Static%20Files/SCM_News_cartoon.6.jpg

Asian airlines including Cathay Pacific (SEHK: 0293) are likely to have to pay up to US$400 million a year for their carbon emissions on European routes from January – a cost likely to be passed on to passengers.

The green tax, imposed by the European Union in an attempt to lower greenhouse gas emissions, would mean an extra cost of US$8 per passenger on average.

That figure was based on a total of 2.5 billion passengers and the 650 million tonnes of carbon dioxide emitted globally by carriers last year, said Andrew Herdman, general director of the Association of Asia Pacific Airlines.

A Cathay Pacific spokesman said yesterday: “It is inevitable that the increased costs will be passed on to the passengers.” Carbon credits, which are used to offset the carbon emissions, traded at an average of €15 (HK$166) to €20 per tonne on the European market last year.

It is estimated that the carbon footprint of one passenger on a round trip from Hong Kong to London – a total of 19,244 kilometres – is about 1.4 tonnes of carbon dioxide.

The extra cost seems affordable, but airlines operate on thin margins.

Global airlines made US$18 billion in net profit last year, their best year since 2000. That translates into a profit of approximately US$7 per passenger, compared with the US$8 in carbon pricing per ticket.

In three out of the past 10 years, when airlines turned a profit, their margins were between 1.1 per cent and 3.2 per cent. “The airlines industry is so competitive that any difference in the margin translates into market share gain and market share loss,” said Herdman. “That’s why we are demanding fairness in the scheme and are against any kind of distortion in the rules.”

Cathay agreed that a price should be put on the carbon footprint, but not through a “territory system”, said John Slosar, chief executive of the airline, at a press conference last month.

Airlines, which account for 2 per cent of global carbon emissions, protested against the EU scheme because it charged for the entire flight, even if the flights are over non-EU territories. This scheme penalises carriers operating at hubs far away from Europe, while benefiting those nearer, such as Middle East airlines.

US carriers have sued the EU in the European Court of Justice for including airlines in the emissions trading scheme. A panel of judges will publish an opinion on October 6.

The US case is key because its arguments focus on the legitimacy of the EU applying its emission scheme to all airlines. A ruling in favour of the US carriers would apply to others.

Air China (SEHK: 0753, announcements, news) and other mainland carriers have also threatened to sue.

Herdman predicted the lawsuit would eventually turn into political disputes between governments and would need to go through the International Civil Aviation Organisation, a specialised agency of the United Nations that governs airlines.

These political battles could be solved only by bilateral discussions between governments, he added.

Under the EU scheme, airlines are granted 85 per cent of their carbon emissions for free and need to buy the remaining 15 per cent through auctions, based on their traffic figures for last year. Those that cannot come up with a quota sufficient to cover their emissions will be subject to penalties equivalent to €100 per tonne of emissions.

charlotte.so@scmp.com

August air cargo throughput down

http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/hkedition/2011-09/03/content_13610188.htm

Air cargo throughput via Hong Kong in August fell 9.3 percent from a year earlier, data from Hong Kong Air Cargo Terminals Ltd (Hactl) released on Friday showed.

Cargo exports and imports from the city in August decreased 13.3 percent and 8.9 percent, respectively, from a year earlier.

(so why does HKG need a third runway ??)