Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Air Pollution Affects Health In Asian Cities

BERNAMA, November 13, 2008 15:13 PM

BANGKOK, Nov 13 (Bernama) — A first-of-its-kind rigorous multi-city study on the effects of air pollution on health in Bangkok, Hong Kong, Shanghai and Wuhan has found significant mortality effects of acute exposure to urban air pollution.

Dr Frank Speizer of the Harvard Medical School and chairman of the Health Effects Institute’s (HEI) International Oversight Committee, said the study brought fresh local evidence that the substantially higher levels of air pollution in Asia were also associated with significant health effects.

“While a strong scientific literature exists in the developed world, documenting the adverse relationship between air pollution and health, differences between developed and developing world populations have sometimes limited the use of western science in developing countries,” he said at the Better Air Quality(BAQ) workshop here.

Over 900 participants are attending the BAQ, making it the largest gathering on air pollution and climate change in Asia.

The study on, “Public Health and Air Pollution in Asia (PAPA): A multicity study of Short-term Effects of Air Pollution on Mortality” was funded by HEI as a major project for Clean Air Initiative-Asia (CAI-Asia). It is the first integrated assessment across multiple Asian cities using modern analytic methods that allow direct comparison with western results.

The study’s finding of a 0.6 per cent increase in mortality for every 10 microgrammes (µg) of exposure to particulate air pollution is strikingly similar to comparable western results (which range from 0.4 per cent to 0.6 per cent) and provides increased confidence in the new Asian results.

The conference was told that with daily levels of Asian particulate air pollution routinely at levels above 100 micrograms (much higher than the World Health Organisation (WHO) Air Quality Guidelines), and very high population density in many Asian cities, these findings are a major cause for concern about the impact of air pollution on the health of Asian populations.

Sumi Mehta, senior scientist at HEI and co-author of an EHP editorial accompanying the studies, said that those with existing heart and lung diseases, the leading causes of death in Asia, were at increased risk of mortality due to air pollution.

“As Asian populations age, these risks can be expected to increase. In light of this recent science, Asian countries should consider whether their current standards, and current levels of air pollution are adequately protecting the public’s health,” Mehta said.

The study was part of a broader effort by the HEI to bring together the world’s data on the acute effects of air pollution by funding a series of related analyses in North America, Europe, Latin America and Asia.

“We are seeing the early stages of an emerging consistency in carefully coordinated studies conducted across regions that can provide policy makers with confidence that population effects are more similar than different.

“Similarly, pollution reduction measures can be expected to yield beneficial results no matter where they are implemented,” said Bob O’Keefe, Vice-President of HEI.

Wong Video Targets Wheezy City

Clara Mak – SCMP | Updated on Nov 08, 2008

Like a lot of people living in Hong Kong, Magic Boy director Adam Wong Sau-ping suffers bouts of hay fever. But instead of just blowing his nose into an endless number of hankies, he chose to address the issue of air pollution, which he believes triggers the reaction.

His concerns are probably justified. A recent Greenpeace report states that frequent exposure to air pollution can lower resistance to respiratory diseases and also increase chances of developing conditions such as asthma and bronchitis.

Greenpeace added that the Hong Kong government’s Air Pollution Index, its daily measure of air quality in the city, doesn’t quite reflect the reality. The index has been neither reviewed nor updated in the past two decades to match the World Health Organisation (WHO) standards, so Greenpeace has launched its own “Real Air Pollution Index”.

Meanwhile, Wong (pictured) filmed a short video to help promote the Greenpeace campaign. The 33-year-old recruited a group of children, whom he shot undertaking various activities around the city.

“At the beginning of the video, these 10 lovely children went out after they were reassured by the weather report that the air quality on the day was suitable for them to do outdoor activities,” he says. “So, they went out taking deep breaths in Kwun Tong, running in Sha Tin, blowing balloons in Central, playing music with a pianica and singing on the Tsing Ma Bridge.

“But by the end, you will hear these children coughing and wheezing because the current index just simply does not reflect the true air quality level here. We are using a standard that is some 20 years behind and far below the WHO standard,” Wong says.

Living in the busy district of Mong Kok, Wong has developed ways of dealing with air pollution. He takes a few steps back when he waits to cross the road to avoid breathing in fumes and he rinses his mouth with water when he gets home to prevent a sore throat.

Air pollution, he says, is as serious as the recent Chinese milk powder scare. “It’s like telling a child the milk he drinks is contaminated with melamine. The difference is if you don’t drink the milk every day or eat a large quantity of White Rabbit candies in one go, you probably won’t develop a kidney stone or die. However, you can’t choose not to breathe even though the air is polluted. It’s just scary.”

Wong tries to protect the environment by using fewer plastic bags and recycling plastic bottles. He says he was heavily influenced by Japanese animation master Hayao Miyazaki’s films which often touch on environmental subjects.

“One of his films, Nausicaa of The Valley Of The Wind [1984], talks about the friendship between an insect and a human. The eyes of the bug go red when it is angry and turn blue when the people are being friendly to it. It taught me the relationship between nature and human beings and how the two should live together peacefully.

“Besides, we are not here to conquer the world,” he says.

To watch Wong’s video and to learn more about the Real Air Pollution campaign, visit www.greenpeace.org/china.

Air Quality Targets Dangerously Inadequate For Public Health

SCMP – Updated on Oct 31, 2008

We agree with views expressed by Anthony J. Hedley and Wong Chit-ming, of the University of Hong Kong (“New air quality measures inadequate“, October 25).

We are extremely concerned that the government is proposing to use the very lowest tier of the WHO air quality targets as our air quality objectives.

The World Health Organisation interim target-1 is not much of an improvement compared with our 21-year-old air quality objectives, and far from what is needed to drive air quality improvements.

For example, the annual mean concentration (the 12-month average) for PM10 (particulate matter smaller than 10 micrometers) specified in the interim target-1 is 70 micrograms per cubic metre, while our air quality objectives specified an annual mean of 55 micrograms per cubic metre.

International and local studies have shown that, among all the criteria pollutants, particulate matter is by far the most significant contributor to both the chronic and acute health risk.

Let us not forget just how far behind Hong Kong’s particulate matter standard is when compared with European cities. In Europe, the PM10 standard is now 40 micrograms per cubic metre, while the WHO air quality guideline of 20 micrograms per cubic metre will take effect in 2010.

After all the hype and public expectation in Hong Kong about strengthening our air quality objectives, a recommendation to take a backward step to 70 micrograms or staying with our outdated 55 micrograms is just unbelievable.

We must set targets that protect public health, and not arrive at a target which is dictated by some limited vision of what can or cannot be done in a few years.

What is being set is a loose target which shows the government is abrogating its responsibility to push hard for a policy of public health protection.

This is wrong-headed and dangerous because we will all be paying the price with our health.

Alexis Lau, director, atmospheric research centre, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology and Wong Tze-wai, professor, community and family medicine, Chinese University of Hong Kong

HK And Guangdong Air Quality Shows Slight Decline On Last Year

Joyce Ng – SCMP | Updated on Oct 30, 2008

Air quality in Guangdong and Hong Kong in the first half of the year was marginally worse than a year earlier, data from a regional network of monitoring stations shows.

Only three stations showed improvements over the same period last year, and pollution levels at all 16 exceeded the national air quality standard set for general residential areas part of the time.

Air quality was unsatisfactory 28.07 per cent of the time on average, compared with 27.68 per cent in the corresponding period last year. A Hong Kong government source said it would not be scientific to compare two years’ data and conclude air pollution had not improved.

The three stations which showed improvement were in Guangzhou and Foshan. The other 13, including the three stations in Hong Kong – in Tsuen Wan, at Tung Chung near the airport on Lantau and at Tap Mun, or Grass Island, in Mirs Bay off the north coast of Sai Kung – all had worse readings than a year earlier.

The government source ascribed the improvement in air quality in Foshan to the relocation of highly polluting ceramics factories. The worst air quality was recorded in March because winds were too light to dispel pollution, the source said. Coastal areas had better air quality because summer ocean winds dispersed pollutants. Regional air quality is graded from 1 (the best) to 5 (the worst).

Respirable suspended particulates were a bigger problem than the three other pollutants measured – ozone, nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide.

In parts of Guangzhou, Foshan and Huizhou, the level of respirable suspended particles of a diameter of 10 microns or more (known as PM10) exceeded safe levels between 20 and 29 per cent of the time, or for 25 to 47 days in six months.

The monitoring network was set up by Guangdong’s Environmental Protection Bureau and the Environment, Transport and Works Bureau in Hong Kong three years ago.

Despite a lack of significant improvement in air quality since then, the source said the government was confident of achieving some of the 2010 targets jointly set for emissions reductions. As well as factories relocating, vehicles in some Guangdong cities had switched to cleaner fuels, the source said.

Alexis Lau Kai-hon, an atmospheric scientist at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, said his research showed there had been hardly any improvement in air quality in the region since 2004, although there was no clear sign either that it was getting worse.

He agreed that joint monitoring was beneficial, but urged the mainland authorities to release data on a daily basis instead of once every six months to allow for better research.

Hahn Chu Hon-keung, environmental affairs manager for campaign group Friends of the Earth, said the closure of some factories on the mainland and the relocation of others might have helped improve air quality in some places, but it was time governments stepped up efforts to reduce roadside pollution.

“One major source for PM10 is vehicular emissions. There is plenty of room for mainland authorities to reduce roadside pollution,” he said.

“For Hong Kong, power plants’ emissions reductions have had an effect, but there’s a need to replace old heavy diesel vehicles more quickly.”

New Air Quality Measures Inadequate

SCMP | Updated on Oct 25, 2008

The announcement by the chief executive that the government will adopt the very lowest tier of the World Health Organisation air quality interim targets, rather than the WHO guidelines, will not help clean up Hong Kong’s air and may even cause further deterioration (“Beginner air quality standards criticised“, October 16).

We should be concerned about this move.

The low tiers of interim targets are there to help poor countries with low levels of expertise move to an entry level for environmental management, not regions with a high gross domestic product and capable of making urgent radical interventions.

The 24-hour target for particulates of 150 micrograms per cubic metre is so permissive it is 15 micrograms per cubic metre above the maximum level observed in 99 per cent of days in 2006. Compliance will not lead to any improvement in the present high average annual levels of pollution.

There is a real risk that retaining a permissive target level will lead to further increases in pollution as has happened with the present inadequate air quality objectives.

Hong Kong’s typical daily levels of pollution, particularly in the cool season, are consistently so high that they always exceed the WHO annual guidelines by several hundred per cent.

These current annual levels of pollution are associated with our very high burden of avoidable illness, premature deaths and community costs due to health care and lost productivity. There will be no reduction of this burden without more stringent regulations.

The 24-hour targets are not intended to be used in the absence of an appropriate annual target which would improve air quality across the year.

The WHO 24-hour guidelines should be applied together with the annual guidelines in order to maximise health benefits and reduce both short-term and longer-term morbidity and mortality. The chief executive’s proposal appears to pre-empt the outcome of the government’s current review of our outdated air quality objectives, but it is clearly not part of a strategy for air quality improvement in the foreseeable future.

Anthony J. Hedley, Wong Chit-ming, school of public health, University of Hong Kong

Air Pollution Lowers Birth-Weights

Belle Dumé – environmentalresearchweb | Oct 23, 2008

Last year, a groundbreaking study by researchers at Yale University, US, found that air pollution increases the risk of low-birth-weight babies. But the results were criticised for various reasons, such as the fact that some pre-term babies were included in the analysis. The authors have now addressed these issues through a new analysis and have also investigated other factors, including whether some infants were particularly susceptible to air pollution effects based on the mother’s age, or the sex of the baby.

Michelle Bell and colleagues have found that the mother’s age – whether she is younger than 24 or older than 40 – or the sex of the baby do not make a difference to the relationship between air pollution and low birth weight. The original results also remain the same if the pre-term infants (those born at less than 32 weeks) are excluded from the study. The researchers estimate lower birth weight with higher exposure to pollutants, even those that meet federal limits.

The pollutants considered were nitrogen dioxide (NO2), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter with aerodynamic diameters of less than 10 m and 2.5 m (PM10 and PM2.5) during pregnancy. The analysis was based on 358,504 births in the US states of Massachusetts and Connecticut from 1999 to 2002. Birth data was obtained from birth certificate registries from the Division of Vital Statistics, Reproductive Statistics Branch of the National Center for Health Statistics.

For each baby, Bell and colleagues took the following factors into account: place of birth and residence; the mother’s age and racial origin; mother’s marital status; parental education level; whether the mother smoked or drank alcohol during her pregnancy; gestational age in weeks; child’s sex; birth weight; type of birth (caesarean or natural); quality of prenatal care; and birth order. The dataset was limited to single births with a gestational length of 32 to 44 weeks and weights of 1 kg to 5.5 kg.

The team estimated air pollution in a given area using data from air monitors and weather reports. Air pollution data was obtained from the US Environmental Protection Agency, and weather data from the National Climatic Data Center.

“Findings indicate that while some populations are at higher risk of low birth weight (for example, infants of younger or older mothers, female infants, and infants born in more polluted regions), the relationship between air pollution and low birth weight did not differ by mother’s age or infant’s sex,” say Bell and co-workers. “Results were further robust to exclusion of pre-term births.”

The study also showed that lowered birth weight was linked to exposure to particulate pollution in the second and third trimesters of pregnancy, and exposure to carbon monoxide in the first and third trimesters.

The team does stress however, that many questions remain unanswered, such as why exactly air pollution should affect the birth weight of infants. The effect of individual pollutants also needs to be better analysed.

The researchers published their work in Environmental Research Letters.
About the author

Belle Dumé is a contributing editor to environmentalresearchweb.

‘Beginner’ Air Quality Standards Criticised

Cheung Chi-fai – SCMP – Updated on Oct 16, 2008

The government is considering adopting a set of what critics called “beginner-level” World Health Organisation pollution standards to replace the city’s outdated air quality objectives.

The chief executive outlined the plan in the policy address, marking the first time the administration has offered clear ideas on how it is going to revise the objectives as a result of a review launched last year.

Donald Tsang Yam-kuen did not, however, give any time frame for achieving the objectives.

The proposed standards, if adopted, would see Hong Kong taking on pollutant level standards up to 64 per cent more stringent than the present ones. A new standard on fine particles suspended in the air might also be introduced.

“To improve the air quality in the long run, we will adopt targets in stages, giving due regard to the World Health Organisation’s guidelines,” Mr Tsang said.

Released in 2006, the WHO guidelines, based on the latest scientific evidence, are designed to protect people from air pollution. They list up to three sets of recommended interim targets for different types of air pollutants before the ultimate objectives are achieved.

Mr Tsang said one feasible way to improve air quality was to boost the use of natural gas to produce 50 per cent of electricity, which could be made possible by a recent deal with the mainland for a long-term gas supply.

Highlighting air quality as one of his top priorities, Mr Tsang said the government would continue to improve the air in co-operation with Guangdong as both parties were working on turning the delta region into a quality living environment.

Critics said the targets were too low to protect people’s health. They insisted more aggressive targets should be adopted.

“While the policy address says Hong Kong is a modern and advanced city, we are adopting beginner-level targets [designed] for the developing world. No developed country would ever set its eyes on these targets any more,” said Alexis Lau Kai-hon, an atmospheric scientist with the University of Science and Technology.

Professor Lau said he was also disappointed by the lack of effective measures to address air pollution.

But a senior environment official said Mr Tsang’s statement on air quality targets was a “strong political message” of commitment to the WHO’s ultimate standards.

“Now everybody knows the direction we are heading but we can’t decide a time frame now as there has not been any public discussion yet,” the official said, promising that the public would be consulted both on targets and control measures.

The official said the targets set would inevitably depend on achievability. The pace of implementation would depend on public acceptance and affordability.

Friends of the Earth expressed disappointment, while Greenpeace urged Mr Tsang to make a clear commitment to the WHO’s ultimate targets.

HK’s Competitiveness Threatened By Poor Air Quality: Survey

Angela Seet – SCMP – Updated on Oct 14, 2008

The seriousness of Hong Kong’s air pollution could affect the city’s competitiveness, the American Chamber of Commerce warned on Tuesday.

The chamber said its latest survey raised concerns about the impact pollution was having on attracting people to work in Hong Kong.

AmCham’s third annual environment survey of 318 member companies showed 40 per cent of them had difficulty attracting professionals to the territory. In addition, 69 per cent knew professionals who intended to leave; and 56 per cent said they would prefer not work in Hong Kong because of the bad air pollution.

AmCham chairman Steven DeKrey said: “This year’s findings reinforce the reality that air pollution not only threatens our health but also the long-term competitiveness of Hong Kong as a world-class talent centre in Asia.”

AmChan urged the government to take more action to improve air quality.

“This year’s survey suggests that Hong Kong can productively focus on other aspects of air pollution especially ground-level pollution,” Mr DeKrey said. “This is something the residents and the government can address together,” he added.

The respondents support the government rapidly phasing out all diesel-run vehicles (81 per cent), bringing air quality objectives in line with those of the World Health Organisation (80 per cent), and using the cleanest buses (72 per cent).

Other key findings included:

  • Some 97 per cent supported converting diesel-run vehicles to liquified petroleum gas (LPG)
  • Ninety-one per cent wanted more ‘pedestrian only’ zones in the city centre
  • Eighty-one per cent were prepared to pay more for cleaner public transport.

However, not many were confident things would change in the next 12 months. Nearly 90 per cent of respondents felt the “quality of the natural environment in Hong Kong will not improve”, the survey noted.

What Do You Think Of HK’s Low Rating For Raising Children?

SCMP – Updated on Oct 14, 2008

Having recently relocated to Hong Kong with three children under the age of nine, I was very surprised that the article on expatriates raising children in Hong Kong did not even mention air quality (“City rated poorly by expatriate parents”, October 9).

The number one issue we have faced since moving our children to the city is the air pollution.

Having moved from Australia, most people we talked to back home cited air pollution as the main reason they would not consider moving to Hong Kong regardless of the salary or opportunities on offer. The air and water pollution has turned out to be a much bigger issue than we imagined and would be the main reason for returning home.

The second issue is the cost of schooling and quality of food.

Last, outside play would be a consideration.

Danni Harnett, Pok Fu Lam

Demand To Adopt WHO Guidelines

Cheung Chi-fai – SCMP – Updated on Oct 09, 2008

Chief Executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen should endorse the World Health Organisation’s air-quality guidelines in his policy address next week to protect the public from the adverse health effects of air pollution, a green group said yesterday.

Friends of the Earth also called on the government to push ahead with measures to curb roadside air pollution, such as forcing all pre-Euro and Euro I diesel commercial vehicles, including franchised buses, off the roads before 2010.

The calls came after the South China Morning Post revealed the government had yet to make any commitment to update the city’s outdated air-quality objectives, a year after beginning a review of the standards.

Officials involved in the review are considering various measures – mainly transport and energy related – to improve air quality.

“It is time for Mr Tsang to do something concrete on air quality by adopting the WHO’s guidelines right away,” said Friends of the Earth director Edwin Lau Che-feng.

“The health impact of air pollution, particularly on the roadside, can no longer be neglected.

“How many human lives would be sacrificed and economic losses incurred by not having those polluting diesel vehicles taken off the roads now?”

The WHO’s guidelines, which were promulgated in 2005 but have yet to be adopted by a single country, set daily standards for suspended particulates at least three times more stringent than Hong Kong’s, yet they are said to be the minimum required to protect public health.

Friends of the Earth said Hong Kong should adopt the WHO’s guidelines and raise licence fees for polluting vehicles next year.

It also proposes an increase in the number of mandatory inspections of polluting vehicles, the setting of long-term energy-saving targets, and an increase in the percentage of electricity produced by gas-fired power stations to 50 per cent by 2010.

A 2003 study commissioned by the Environmental Protection Department showed respirable suspended particulates emitted by old diesel vehicles had been responsible for 8,000 cases of cancer.