Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

Hong Kong Air Pollution ‘Very High’

Angela Seet – Updated on Jan 23, 2009 – SCMP

Air pollution levels in Hong Kong were very high on Friday, with the air pollution index (API) reaching 140 in Central, a spokesman from the Environmental Protection department said.

At 6pm, roadside station readings at Central and Causeway Bay were recorded as “very high” with an API rating of 118 and 103 respectively. The station reading at Mongkok was slightly better at 92, but according to the standards set by the department, it is still considered to be “high”.

The department found that the contributing pollutant to all three station readings was nitrogen dioxide, which causes urban haze, or “photochemical smog”.

Environmental Protection officer Dave Ho said says the air pollutants were not dispersed because of recent calm weather conditions.

“The air is currently affected by the continental airstream, with relatively high background pollution. Over the last two days, the wind was very weak so the pollutants were trapped and thus, pushing up the air pollution index,” he explained.

Mr Ho also said that air pollution levels should reduce in the next few days, if the winds pick up strength as usual.

Between API readings of 101 to 200, air pollution levels are rated “very high” and those with existing heart or respiratory illnesses are advised to avoid prolonged stay in areas with heavy traffic.

“If you have to stay in streets or on roads with heavy traffic, do reduce physical exertion as far as possible,” a spokesman said.

Lawmakers are worried that the approaching 2010 targets for emissions reduction cannot be met as air pollution is not considered a serious threat.

Critics say that the city’s air quality objectives, set more than 20 years ago, are less stringent that the ones set by the World Health Organisation (WHO).

For example, if Hong Kong strictly followed the WHO target for sulfur content, the government would have to reduce current concentration levels by some 95 per cent.

Cleaner Air Equals Longer Life

Cleaner air, longer life: Study provides evidence

In a boon for supporters of air quality management, new findings show that the more particulate air pollution is reduced, the more life expectancy increases.

By Thomas H. Maugh II – January 22, 2009 – Los Angeles Times

For those wondering just how much effect cleaning up the air can have, researchers now have a much fuller picture.

Reductions in particulate air pollution during the 1980s and 1990s led to an average five-month increase in life expectancy in 51 U.S. metropolitan areas, with some of the initially more polluted cities such as Buffalo, N.Y., and Pittsburgh showing a 10-month increase, researchers said Wednesday.

The reductions in pollution accounted for about 15% of a nearly three-year increase in life expectancy during the two decades, said epidemiologist C. Arden Pope III of Brigham Young University, lead author of the study appearing today in the New England Journal of Medicine.

It is well known that particulate air pollution reduces life expectancy, said environmental epidemiologist Joel Schwartz of the Harvard School of Public Health, who was not involved in the study. But public policy makers “are interested in the question of, ‘If I spend the money to reduce pollution, what really happens?’ ” he said.

Schwartz reported two years ago that a study in six cities revealed increased life expectancy was associated with reductions in particulate pollution. Pope and his colleagues expanded on that connection, finding that in a large fraction of the U.S. population “the more particulate pollution went down, the more life expectancy went up.”

Their finding “greatly strengthens the foundation of the argument for air quality management,” wrote environmental health scientist Daniel Krewski of the University of Ottawa in an editorial accompanying the report.

The particulates in question are called fine particulates because they are smaller than 2.5 microns in diameter, allowing them to burrow deep into the small air passages of the lung. They have repeatedly been shown to produce cardiovascular and pulmonary disease. Larger particulates, which cause visibility problems, have a much smaller effect on health.

The fine particulates are produced by cigarettes, gasoline and diesel engines, coal power plants, foundries and a variety of other urban sources.

Pope and his colleagues studied two sets of data collected in 214 counties, comprising 51 metropolitan areas, in 1980 and 2000, comparing reductions in particulate levels and increases in life expectancies. They used a variety of advanced statistical methods to try to eliminate effects linked to changes in population, income, education, migration and demographics.

They concluded that for every decrease of 10 micrograms per cubic meter of particulate pollution in a city, average life span increased a little more than seven months — about the same amount seen in previous, smaller studies.

“We are getting a return on our investment to improve air quality,” Pope said.

Overall, the average life span in the 51 areas increased 2.7 years over the two decades, with the major share of the increase attributed to reductions in smoking and changes in socioeconomic factors.

Los Angeles, and Southern California in general, had large increases in life expectancy during the period, even though pollution levels did not drop as much as in other cities. Pope attributed the increase in life span to a string of smoking bans begun in 1994.

Pope thinks there is room for further improvement. The average countrywide fine-particulate concentration in the early 1980s was about 20 micrograms per cubic meter, and that dropped to about 14 micrograms by 2000.

“It’s reasonable to expect that we could reduce it by that much again, but then we reach a point of substantially diminishing marginal returns,” he said.

Reduced Air Pollution Adds Years To Your Life

eFluxMedia By Anna Boyd – 12:58, January 22nd 2009

Pollution has always been thought to reduce survival due to its noxious effects on people’s health. Previous studies have linked pollution to increased risk of heart attack, stroke, lung cancer, asthma and other serious diseases.

No further than last year, a study published in Circulation: Journal of the American Heart Association revealed that pollution harms people with coronary artery disease, causing worrying changes on the heart traces of patients recovering from heart attacks.

Another study conducted by the Harvard School of Public Health, which focused on air pollution’s effects on clotting in the veins found that exposure to air pollution from traffic fumes raises risks of potentially fatal clots in the leg; it alters the blood’s coagulation properties and heightens the risk of deep vein thrombosis (DVT). A study published in 2007 in Stroke: Journal of the American Heart Association found that breathing fine particle pollution during warm weather months can increase stroke risk.

According to the World Health Organization, air pollution accounts for three million deaths worldwide every year. Cars, trucks and industrial plants are the greatest source of air pollution emissions that increases the rates of heart attacks.

Other studies found that when particulates are cut even for a short period of time, death rates fall. As an example, when Hong Kong imposed reductions in sulfur dioxide, or when Dublin imposed a coal ban, they saw immediate reductions in death rates from cardiovascular diseases.

Now, researchers at Brigham Young University and the Harvard School of Public Health come to underline the idea that pollution really increases someone’s risk of dying. Their study was published in the January 22 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine. According to the findings, the average of life expectancy in 51 US cities increased nearly three years over recent decades due to steps taken to reduce air pollution.

“We find that we’re getting a substantial return on our investments in improving our air quality. Not only we are getting cleaner air that improves our environment, but it is improving our public health,” C. Arden Pope III, PhD, a BYU epidemiologist and lead author of the study, said.

For the study, he and his colleagues plotted pollution data for 1979-1983 against 1978-1982 life expectancies for 217 counties within 51 metropolitan areas around the country. Then, they compared 1999-2000 pollution data with 1997-2001 life expectancies. The researchers looked at how air pollution influenced life expectancy in both time periods.

Pollution levels were about 21 micrograms per cubic meter in the early 80s and had fallen to an average of 14 micrograms per cubic meter by 1999-2000.

The study found that due to this decrease in air pollution, average US life expectancy increased by about three years over the period of the study and cleaner air was responsible for as much as 15 percent of the increase in some metropolitan areas.

Commenting on the findings, Daniel Krewski of the University of Ottawa said the study “provides direct confirmation of the population health benefits of mitigating air pollution and greatly strengthens the foundation of the argument for air-quality management.”

Ambient Air Pollution vs. Life Expectancy

Evaluating the Effects of Ambient Air Pollution on Life Expectancy

Daniel Krewski, Ph.D. – The New England Journal of Medicine – 22nd Jan 2009

Air pollution is an important determinant of population health. In this issue of the Journal, Pope et al.1 provide data that once again reinforce this fundamental concept. In an analysis that correlates reductions in fine particulate matter (i.e., particles less than 2.5 µm in aerodynamic diameter, or PM2.5) in the air with life expectancies, the investigators found that a decrease in the concentration of PM2.5 of 10 µg per cubic meter is associated with an increase in life expectancy of 0.77 year. Their analysis is based on correlating reductions in particulate air pollution over the past several decades with increases in life expectancy in 217 counties in 51 metropolitan areas in the United States. Although ecologic in nature (i.e., reflecting associations between air pollution and life expectancy at the county rather than the individual level), these results appear to be robust with respect to adjustment for changes in socioeconomic, demographic, and smoking patterns occurring over the same period.

The finding is comparable with previous predictions of reductions in life expectancy of 1.11 years in the Netherlands,2 1.37 years in Finland,3 and 0.80 year in Canada4 resulting from increases in ambient PM2.5 concentrations of 10 µg per cubic meter. However, the strength of the study by Pope et al. resides in its ability to demonstrate an increase in life expectancy resulting from actual reductions in particulate air pollution. This finding provides direct confirmation of the population health benefits of mitigating air pollution and greatly strengthens the foundation of the argument for air-quality management.5

This work could be extended to take into account quality of life. For example, Coyle et al.4 estimated that an increase of 10 µg per cubic meter in PM2.5 concentrations would lead to a quality-adjusted reduction in life expectancy of 0.60 year, as compared with the unadjusted reduction of 0.80 year. The work by Pope et al. represents an important contribution to the large and growing body of evidence linking ambient air pollution with adverse health outcomes. At the global level, the World Health Organization6 estimates that 1.4% of all deaths and 0.8% of disability-adjusted life-years are the result of particulate air pollution.

The short-term health effects of particulate and gaseous air pollutants have been well documented, largely through time-series studies relating short-term elevations in ambient levels of such pollutants to increases in morbidity and mortality from cardiorespiratory conditions. A recent combined analysis of time-series data from 124 of the largest cities in North America and Europe produced an estimated increase in the rate of death from any cause ranging from 0.2 to 0.6% for an increase in ambient PM10 concentrations of 10 µg per cubic meter,7 depending on the assumed lag time between exposure to particulate matter and death and on the method used for seasonality control, the form of the temporal smoothing function, and degree of smoothing. Risk estimates for Europe and the United States were similar but were higher in Canada.

The long-term effects of exposure to “criteria” air pollutants (particulate matter, ozone, sulfates, sulfur dioxide, nitrous oxides, and carbon monoxide) have been documented in large-scale cohort studies, including the Harvard Six Cities Study8 and the American Cancer Society Cancer Prevention Study II.9 The American Cancer Society cohort, which includes more than 1.1 million people followed since the time of enrollment in 1980, has provided consistent evidence of an association between increased mortality and ambient air pollution in follow-up analyses through 1989,10 1998,11 and 20009 (Table 1). Further analyses of the data, using refined estimates of exposure to ambient PM2.5 and follow-up through 2004, are under way.

Evaluating the effects of ambient air pollution on life expectancy

The effects of ambient air pollution on population health can be addressed within the broader context of risk assessment and management. Population-health risk assessment involves the systematic assessment of genetic, environmental, and social determinants of health; identified health risks can be addressed using a combination of regulatory, economic, advisory, community-based, and technological risk-management interventions.12 Craig et al.5 recently produced a document on how scientific evidence on the effects of ambient air pollution on population health can be used in developing strategies for air-quality management.

Research priorities for airborne particulate matter have been identified by the National Research Council, and progress toward their achievement was monitored from 1998 through 2004.13 The goal of the research was to increase scientific understanding of the health effects of particulate air pollution, including the biologic mechanisms by which particulate matter in ambient air can lead to increased mortality in the general population. Recent scientific evidence suggests that increased mortality from cardiopulmonary disease is due to increased formation of atherosclerotic plaque, which in turn is due to the induction of systemic inflammation and oxidative stress mediated by cytokines after inhalation of PM2.5.14

The National Research Council also provided a framework for evaluating the benefits of air-quality regulations.15 Whereas analyses of regulatory benefits are based on predictions of the health benefits resulting from air-pollution control, Pope et al. provide documented evidence of such benefits as a consequence of actual reductions in air-pollution concentrations occurring over the past several decades in the United States. Hedley et al.16 have attempted to document improvements in population health resulting from reductions in exposure to airborne particulate matter in Hong Kong.

An important component of environmental-health risk management is the evaluation of the effect of a particular intervention.17 Although ambient air-pollution concentrations in the United States and other developed countries have been declining in recent decades, reflecting efforts to reduce emissions from both point (e.g., smokestacks) and mobile (e.g., cars and trucks) sources, few studies have documented an improvement in population health as a consequence of reductions in exposure to air pollution. The Health Effects Institute has emphasized the need for such evaluations by proposing an accountability framework for air-quality management.18 This framework tracks the effects of interventions to enhance air quality in terms of emissions reductions, improvements in air quality, reductions in human exposure, and, ultimately, improvements in population health. Because long-term exposure to particulate air pollution has a much greater effect on population health than short-term exposure, the results of the study by Pope et al. are of particular importance within the accountability framework established by the Health Effects Institute.

Pope et al. note that although decreases in fine particulate air pollution (PM2.5) could account for as much as 18% of the increase in life expectancy of approximately 2.74 years occurring in the United States between 1980 and 1999, other factors may also be partly responsible. Further analyses of this association, adjusting for changes in individual-level variables such as tobacco use, socioeconomic status, dietary patterns, body-mass index, physical activity, and access to health services, would be of value both in identifying other factors contributing to the increased life expectancy observed over this period and in confirming the ecologic findings of Pope et al. Consideration of the joint effects of copollutants would also be of interest.9 In the interim, these investigators have made an important contribution to air-quality management through their pioneering attempts to document the population health benefits of reducing ambient air pollution by correlating past reductions in ambient PM2.5 concentrations with increased life expectancy.

Dr. Krewski reports serving as Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Industrial Research Chair in Risk Sciences, a university–industry partnership program, at the University of Ottawa, and as chief executive officer and chief risk scientist for Risk Sciences International (http://demo.risksciencesint.com). No other potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Document available here: http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/360/4/413

Hong Kong’s Economic Growth Spluttering On Filthy Air

20th Jan 2009 – AFP

HONG KONG (AFP) — In recent years, a thick haze originating from factories in southern China has enveloped Hong Kong for large chunks of the year, blocking views of its famous harbour and raising health fears.

Combined with the city’s home-grown pollution, scientists and business leaders say [air pollution] presents a serious economic risk to the financial hub, both for its ability to attract and retain talent and the associated health costs.

When Teena Goulet moved to Hong Kong in 1995 she thought she would never leave but five years after moving here, the keen outdoorswoman developed a chronic cough.

For someone who spent all her spare time outside — hiking, dragon boating, rowing — health was a major concern and after being diagnosed with adult onset asthma, Goulet, 45, decided last year to leave.

“It is just so vibrant and so safe,” the US banker said of Hong Kong.

“There is an amazing quality to it. Doing business is so easy, the low tax is great, the food and restaurants are great.

“I would have retired there,” said Goulet, speaking by phone from her new home in California. “But when you cannot breath, it kind of tells you what to do.”

Within a week of moving to California last March, her cough stopped.

US investment guru Jim Rogers, who moved to Asia in 2007 with his family because of his conviction that China would be the major driver of the world economy, chose to live in Singapore.

“I don’t want to breathe Hong Kong air,” he said.

A report for the City of London last October about the potential challenges from Asian financial centres, said the “only consistently negative issue” cited by professionals about Hong Kong related to environmental pollution.

The Hedley Environmental Index, a new website set up by a group of academics that combines air quality and public health data, puts the associated costs of the city’s poor air at 12.5 billion Hong Kong dollars (1.6 billion US) since the start of 2004.

[Air pollution in Hong Kong] caused 6,108 premature deaths.

Anthony Hedley, the public health professor at Hong Kong University after whom the index is named, said the website’s figures were conservative, as they excluded the long-term health effects of breathing toxic air.

“We are building up an enormous debt of trouble, which will manifest itself in one, two, three decades and could rear a huge toll on our children,” said Hedley.

‘Hong Kong is choking on its own greed’ —

A recent study commissioned by think tank Civic Exchange said one in five residents were considering leaving Hong Kong because of its dire air. Of the more than 1,000 people surveyed, 97 percent were local Chinese.

Michael DeGolyer, a political science professor at Hong Kong Baptist University who did the study, said the mood was such that one “tipping point” could provoke an exodus, particularly among managers and administrators.

“And Singapore wants them,” said DeGolyer.

The American Chamber of Commerce found in a recent member survey that 70 percent knew of professionals who had either left or were considering leaving because of the pollution.

“Hong Kong needs to lead the way (to improve air quality). That is what being a world city stands for,” said chamber chairman David Cunningham.

While the filth from thousands of toy, clothing and electronics factories in neighbouring Guangdong province dominates headlines, Alexis Lau, an atmospheric sciences professor at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, said home-grown emissions from coal-fired power stations and dirty trucks were a more serious problem.

“We still believe the local pollution is more important for health,” Lau told a recent conference.

Hedley, who is leaving Hong Kong after 21 years here partly over worries about the air — he was diagnosed with adult onset asthma in his 60s — said the government must wake up to the time bomb.

“(The question for the government is) how many premature deaths are you prepared to accept?” said Hedley.

Chief Executive Donald Tsang said in 2007 improving air quality was “a matter of life and death,” and the government is currently reviewing its air quality guidelines, 20 years after they were last revised.

A spokeswoman for the Environmental Protection Department said tough measures had already helped reduce levels of several roadside pollutants and it was working with Guangdong authorities to reduce the haze.

New technology was being introduced to reduce emissions from power plants.

The department said the number of overseas companies with regional headquarters, offices or local operations in Hong Kong had increased to 6,612 in 2008 from 5,414 in 2003.

Any tougher regulations are likely to face opposition from sections of the local business community, which operates around 55,000 factories in Guangdong.

Goulet, who is now planning a move to Japan, said such intransigence was short-sighted: “Hong Kong is choking on its own greed.”

Don’t Hold Your Breath

As you get older, your skin will get duller. But you don’t have to sit back and accept it as a forgone conclusion. The aging of the skin is accelerated by pollution, which also creates lots of other skin problems.

Ivy Ong-Wood -Tuesday, January 20, 2009 – The Standard

As you get older, your skin will get duller. But you don’t have to sit back and accept it as a forgone conclusion. The aging of the skin is accelerated by pollution, which also creates lots of other skin problems.

Said dermatologist John Yu Ho-tak: “Pollution causes infection, in the form of acne and folliculities, which affects hair follicles. It also sparks off inflammation, which presents itself in skin allergies like eczema.”

Other long-term effects of pollution are wrinkles and irregular pigmentation.

Hong Kong is one of the worst places to be in if you want to escape that. Official figures released early this month showed that air pollution in many parts of the city last year reached its highest level since records began.

According to the Environmental Protection Department, the number of hours for which street-level pollution exceeded the danger level in some districts rose by 14 percent last year.

Pollution levels in Central, Causeway Bay and Mong Kok reached dangerous levels for more than 2,000 hours last year – the highest figure since the department began taking roadside recordings in 2000.

A quick check in the department’s website shows that biggest culprits are respirable suspended particulates (dust to us laymen), nitrogen dioxide and sulfur dioxide.

Dust is the most visible of the three but, believe it or not, the ones that pose the most danger to our skin are the two gases that we cannot see.

Said Yu: “Suspended particles like dirt and tar are irritants which can be removed by simple washing. But airborne gas pollution are oxidizers, which can cause long-term damage as they cause free radical activity to occur on your skin.”

He added: “Our skin has a natural antioxidant defence, which is a cell membrane containing vitamin E. When the vitamin E in the membrane meets a free radical, it will neutralize it by binding the free radical. However, if there are too many free radicals attacking it, the vitamin E will lose its binding power, like a bee losing its sting.

“One way to reactivate this vitamin is to give it a dose of antioxidants. This is important because if a cell has been attacked too many times, it will die. Cell death causes skin pigmentation. Free radicals can also damage the skin’s collagen fiber cells, resulting in wrinkles.”

As the most exposed areas on our bodies, the face and forearms are the first places to show the effects of pollution.

Simple ways to counteract this effect, said Yu, are to stay indoors when the pollution index is high, wash your face after being outdoors and keeping skin moisturized to create an additional barrier.

“Some people think eating more fruits and vegetables will help,” he added.

“Eating more of that stuff is good for the body in general but it is unrelated to pollution. Once in the gut, the antioxidants are digested and broken down. The body takes in only as much as it needs and doesn’t store up a reserve.”

The best way is to apply antioxidant directly on the skin. But Yu cautioned: “You can’t just put tomato slices on your face or buy just any product to slap on your skin. To be effective, the antioxidants need to be absorbed by the skin.”

The strongest antioxidants are evident in L-ascorbic acid (vitamin C), alpha-tocopherol (vitamin E) and plant essence – ferulic acid from most plants and phlorectin from apples.

“But you have to pay attention to the delivery system,” said Yu. “Does it get into the cellular level? It’s no use if it just sits on the skin.”

He advises buying a product that has a low pH or is more acidic. “L-ascorbic acid, for example, is stable at a pH of about two to three. Any higher or lower and it won’t work. But you have to balance that against the fact that the higher the acidity, the higher the likelihood of skin irritations.”

Youth Speak Truth On State Of Air Quality

Updated on Jan 19, 2009 – SCMP

Sometimes it takes youth to speak the truth to those in power. Such was the case when 500 Hong Kong residents gathered on January 10 to discuss the growing epidemic of air pollution.

Hong Kong’s air is toxic and getting worse.

Recent studies reveal sulfur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide and particulate matter 200 to 400 per cent above the levels recommended by the World Health Organisation (WHO) to protect basic health. The Hedley Environmental Index, developed by University of Hong Kong professor Anthony Hedley, shows the real costs in monetary and health terms.

Hong Kong suffers an average of four additional unnecessary deaths a day due to airborne toxins.

Hongkongers get the message. A survey released last month by the Hong Kong Transition Project reported that 81 per cent of local adults want the government to make reversing air pollution a priority – an almost 200 per cent increase from public opinion in 2001.

Two thirds of Hong Kong residents regularly avoid outdoor exercise and shield themselves with air conditioning; 500,000 are seriously considering leaving the city permanently.

The participants at the Air We Breathe conference, organised by Civic Exchange, sought more comprehensive solutions. Their suggestions were numerous, innovative and thoughtful, yet none seem to be on the government’s radar.

Refreshingly, it was the teenage contingent who put the issues to Secretary for the Environment Edward Yau Tang-wah most clearly. Their message to Mr Yau, who attended the conference, was: “You have the power; you should act. This is an issue of life and death, and the lives are ours. Fix it – now.”

Among the numerous fixes suggested, the top three were:

  • Set legally binding standards (not unenforced guidelines) for air quality, using human health as the guiding principle;
  • Adopt the latest WHO standards, which are based on the best science available to mankind; and
  • Commit to a near-term target for reaching the pollutant levels (say, 2011) and assign a blue-ribbon team, amply supported by government experts, to come up with a plan.

The people of Hong Kong have spoken. It’s time for the government to act.

Rachel Fleishman, Mid-Levels

Hong Kong’s Air Pollution Causes Some to Think Twice About Living There

By Kari Jensen, VOA News.com – 15 January 2009

Air pollution in Hong Kong has gotten so bad that some businesses are losing staff and customers. A city watchdog group says the government is not doing enough to reduce pollution, much of which comes from mainland China.

Hong Kong’s skies were clear and blue when Alan Knight first arrived there in 1993. But, within 12 years, the city had become so polluted there were days when he could not see through the gray haze across Victoria Harbor.

Knight’s work requires travel. He is a journalist and professor. He also has a lung condition, which usually is dormant. But it flared, a few years back, when he returned to Hong Kong. He was hospitalized and received high dosages of antibiotics. Once he was back in Brisbane, Australia the condition resolved itself.

Knight says he is looking to move back to Asia, but not Hong Kong.

“I think the atmosphere in Hong Kong is really toxic,” he said. “I’d love to come back to Hong Kong. I love the city. I love the people. I love the place. But, quite frankly, I’m likely to live in Singapore.”

The city’s poor air quality is affecting both its residents’ health and its economy. A recent survey shows one in five Hong Kongers may leave the city, because of air pollution. Air pollution costs more than $283 million annually in health care costs and lost job prospects.

Michael DeGolyer is a professor in international studies at Hong Kong Baptist University. He conducted the air pollution survey for Civic Exchange, a public policy think tank.

He says about 30 percent of those who are seriously considering leaving because of bad air are mid- to high-level professionals.

DeGolyer says more than 97 percent of those surveyed were ethnic Chinese. He says air pollution is not just an expat concern.

“Everybody breathes air,” he said. “And, it’s become a concern to everybody now.”

In southern China, factories are closing down, in part because of tougher environmental standards. Still, Chinese factories in the Pearl River Delta north of Hong Kong are the city’s major source of pollution.

But half the time, Hong Kong’s pollution comes directly from its power plants, vehicular emissions and marine traffic.

In the city’s urban areas, tall buildings trap particulates, instead of allowing them to be dispersed by the wind. Residents live close to the roadways and are constantly exposed.

Local activists are looking to other major cities to see what they did to curtail pollution. DeGolyer says research in California shows money spent on air pollution abatement was more than recovered by reduced health care costs and improved worker productivity.

Civic Exchange is pushing Hong Kong to impose stricter air quality standards. It wants the environmental standards to also protect public health. It hosted a clean air conference recently, where international researchers, scientists, economists and academics discussed green measures.

Hong Kong’s present guidelines have not been updated for more than two decades. The city’s air quality, in terms of sulfur content, is much less stringent than World Health Organization guidelines set in 2006.

A Hong Kong legislature’s environmental affairs committee plans to review air quality guidelines and possibly adopt more stringent standards this year.

Hong Kong’s Environmental Protection Department has made efforts to curtail pollution. It has tightened vehicle and power plant emissions and introduced cleaner fuels.

Although sulfur dioxide emissions in the city have dropped back to almost 1997 levels, they are still well above the government’s emission-reduction targets. Air pollution worsened this past year.

Government detractors say, in terms of addressing air pollution, the legislature favors business, especially the transport lobby.

Businesses are quick to defend themselves. Al Hendricks works for a company that manufactures energy-saving equipment. He says industry is less resistant to change than government.

“There’s people here who just don’t want to make changes and are either afraid to or just don’t want to rock the boat for whatever reason,” he said.

Hendricks says the government needs to offer incentives if it wants businesses to enforce environmental standards.

As upper-level professionals leave Hong Kong for jobs in less-polluted cities, businesses may be forced to change without government prodding. The demand for top talent across Asia is high.

It is a delicate balance. By imposing stricter standards, Hong Kong may lose business to nearby Chinese ports and cities, which have looser standards. But, by not cleaning up its air, Hong Kong is already losing professionals and businesses.

The Hong Kong government is working with the government of southern Guangdong province to reduce regional emissions.

Guangdong has agreed to ban the construction of new coal-fired or oil-fired power plants.

Still, even if Hong Kong addresses its air pollution, it can not force Guangdong to take the same measures.

Silence Is Not Golden

CHRISTINE LOH – SCMP – Jan 15, 2009

It’s curious, but people are not voicing their concern about air pollution to those who can most do something about it. The government needs to adopt the national environmental plan and set a good example. Civic Exchange’s full survey report, titled “Hong Kong’s Silent Epidemic” and carried out by the Hong Kong Transition Project, was released last Saturday. It looked at how the public is reacting to air pollution and public health. It found that people discuss air pollution with family, friends and co-workers but most of them are not taking matters up with the government, legislators and the media.

So why don’t people complain publicly? They say they don’t think it will help. Some say they don’t know how to, while some don’t believe air pollution is affecting them.

Government officials should pay close attention to the report. It reflects badly on them when people say complaining won’t help. These people have lost confidence in the government’s ability to deal with the problem. The administration also has a responsibility to those who don’t know how to complain, or don’t believe they are affected. Hong Kong’s high level of air pollution speaks for itself – officials need to act.

Moreover, the level of dissatisfaction with government efforts is a very high 77 per cent. Past efforts have included switching taxis and minibuses from using diesel to LPG, supplying ultra-low-sulphur diesel, pushing regulation of idling engines, providing subsidies to replace highly polluting commercial lorries, and tightening emission caps for power plants. But despite these, the public remains dissatisfied, even though people have been silent. Pollution levels have not changed much, according to scientific data, and most people don’t feel any different. Those in charge will no doubt argue that Hong Kong will see substantial reductions in power-plant emissions because of the addition of flue gas desulfurisation technology. With the phased commissioning, Hong Kong should see lower emissions later this year. By 2011, 90 per cent of sulfur dioxide emissions from power generation should have been eliminated, and other pollutants significantly reduced. Officials have focused on power plants in their pollution-reduction strategy. They have yet to get to grips with another major polluter – transport. Viewed in this light, power plants are the easy option. There are only two power utilities in the city. Yet, transport involves many operators, on land, sea and in the air. The major public health culprits are diesel-powered road vehicles – vans, buses and lorries – and marine vessels – tugs, barges, ferries and ships of various sizes.

So far, government initiatives have, on the whole, been end-of-pipe solutions, such as switching to cleaner fuels and adding emissions traps. There have been limited efforts to combine them with urban planning and demand-side management tools to reduce the “canyon effect” on streets and create better roadside environments for the public. And hardly anything has been done to combat the pollution from the burning of toxic bunker fuels, by marine vessels, that gets blown to where people live and work.

It has become blindingly obvious that the government needs to change direction. Public health needs to be an explicit regulatory and legislative driver, and government bureaus and departments must integrate their work. There has been a lack of vision and leadership at the very top. Now the legislature has formed a new subcommittee to tackle air pollution, lawmakers can play a much more active role in calling officials to account and pushing for integrated policies. Without this, we have little to look forward to.

There will be those who say it is not the time to push because of the economic situation. The national 11th Five-Year plan would make good reading for them. The plan puts environmental protection on a par with economic growth and recognises that change must involve comprehensive action using legal, economic, technological and administrative measures. There is a national vision – would Hong Kong’s officials like to get on board?

Christine Loh Kung-wai is chief executive of the think-tank Civic Exchange. cloh@civic-exchange.org

Birth Defects Caused By Environmental Pollution

Stephen Chen, SCMP – Updated on Jan 09, 2009

One-tenth of all birth defects in Jiangsu, one of the mainland’s richest provinces, are caused by environmental pollution, and half of the remaining cases are at least partly related to the environment, according to a five-year medical study in 13 cities.

From 2001 to 2006, the number of birth-defect cases on the mainland rose by 50 per cent to 1.2 million, but there has been no large-sample study to explain why it happened. The biggest data pool on the issue was amassed by the Jiangsu Birth Defects Intervention Programme, which tracked more than 26,000 pregnant women from 2001 to 2005.

The team, led by Hu Yali of Nanjing University, will receive the Chinese Medical Science and Technology Award in Beijing today for its findings, the Chinese Medical Association confirmed yesterday.

Researchers found the most prevalent defect was congenital heart disease. The disease, closely related to air pollution, is often fatal and difficult to detect. The situation is particularly severe in some hospitals lacking proper equipment and trained staff.

Cleft lip was the second-most-common condition and also related to air pollution. Unlike heart disease, the defect can be detected by ultrasound and is not fatal, but many parents chose to abort fetuses with the condition, fearing that it might lead to some other, more severe defects.

The third most frequently reported disease was congenital hydrocephalus, or excessive fluid in infants’ brains, which, according to some overseas studies, is sometimes a result of vehicle exhaust emissions.

“Birth defects have become the single biggest killer of mainland infants,” Dr Hu was quoted by the Nanjing Morning Post as saying.

Jiangsu’s defect rate, about 1 per cent, is about one-sixth of the national average. In poorer provinces, or areas with heavy industry, the figure is much higher. But mainland studies about the relationship between the environment and birth defects have been limited.

A 2007 study carried out in Taiyuan , capital of coal-rich Shanxi , showed that the abundance of small particles in the air, a major contributing factor to the mainland’s air pollution, was a significant reason for miscarriage, birth defects and neonatal deaths.

A study by the Shenzhen Maternal and Child Health Institute last year found that the city’s birth-defect rate was higher than the national average, indicating that birth defects did not necessarily go down as income increased. Urban dwellers typically make more money than people outside cities.

Health education was an effective way of countering the problem, the Jiangsu study found. The children of workers, farmers, poorly educated people and low-income groups were the most at risk of birth defects, the study said.

A programme involving more than 3,000 families in the province showed that even simple education about precautionary measures could dramatically increase would-be parents’ awareness of the dangers, helping doctors make correct diagnoses and take preventive measures.

The mainland was in desperate need of key intervention technology and standardised practice, Dr Hu said. In one district of Wuxi , only 15 couples took premarital medical tests in 2005 after the government abandoned mandatory testing – a change that raised the risk of birth defects. Medical personnel also needed better education and training, the study said.