Clear The Air News Blog Rotating Header Image

Health

‘Warn public on health risks of air pollution’

Experts press case for a new alert system to replace the current index, which they say fails to spell out the hazards of inhaling toxic chemicals and particles
Cheung Chi-fai
Aug 03, 2012

Air pollution experts have again called for a new alert system to warn the public about health risks created by extreme pollution like the grey pall over Hong Kong yesterday.

They issued the appeal as the city choked for a second consecutive day in what green activists called “life-threatening” levels of air pollution.

Roadside readings in Central hovered at or above 190 for 20 hours beginning on Wednesday. They peaked yesterday at 7am with a reading of 212 – the highest ever recorded in Hong Kong with the exception of a sandstorm in 2010.

Roadside levels in Causeway Bay reached a historic peak of 200. By 8pm last night, the roadside readings were all still above 160.

The pollution, dominated by excessive levels of nitrogen dioxide, coincides with a heat wave that has driven the mercury to 37 degrees Celsius in Happy Valley, among other locations.

Environment officials blamed the pollution on a mass of still, subsiding air caused by Typhoon Saola near Taiwan.

Professor Wong Tze-wai, from Chinese University’s School of Public Health, said he expected a surge in the number of people seeking treatment for respiratory diseases in the next few days. “Even wearing a mask wouldn’t have made any difference in the past two days,” he said.

Alfred Tam Yat-cheung, a paediatrician in Central, confirmed Wong’s worries, saying he treated more patients than usual yesterday. “Some kids whom I had thought were recovering had their allergies and asthma back again or getting worse.”

The Hedley Environmental Index – a real-time tracker of Hong Kong’s air pollution – said yesterday’s extreme levels would lead to more than 17 premature deaths and over 800 hospital admissions. Despite the threat to public health, Wong said the government’s alert system failed to link pollution levels with health risks.

To clarify that link, a group of experts from local universities, including Wong, developed a new alert system several years ago that takes health risks into account. The system grew out of a study commissioned by the Environmental Protection Department.

“We did our studies and handed it to the Environmental Protection Department in 2009,” Wong said. “But we have no idea what is blocking it from being introduced.”

He said the proposed new system is based on a cocktail of indicators, including concentrations of particular pollutants and the health consequences of exposure.

Erica Chan, from the Clean Air Network, said environment officials were slack in warning the public about the severe pollution.

“They should have sent a scientist to explain the matter, as most people don’t quite understand what the air pollution index means,” Chan said. “They could offer more suggestions specific to different groups of people, particularly street workers.”

An EPD spokesman said the department had an established mechanism to inform the public about air pollution readings. It would consider revamping the API system when it upgraded the air quality objectives. The city’s air quality standards have not been revised since 1987.

chifai.cheung@scmp.com

Kids wheezing Down Under – what about those in HK?

SCMP

Jul 25, 2012

There is less than cheery news from Australia on the subject of air pollution and child health.

A national study of 2,860 primary school children found nitrogen dioxide (NO2), found in motor vehicle exhaust, was present in the lungs of two-thirds of the children from the 55 schools tested, according to Melbourne’s The Age newspaper. Researchers found that vehicle pollution is giving otherwise healthy children asthma-like symptoms, potentially affecting their lung growth and function.

In cases where NO2 was found, children experienced ”asthma-like” symptoms, including wheezing. Their lung volume was reduced and their airways inflamed.

The study found that NO2 exposure was not producing typical asthma but a non-specific lung effect that did not improve with asthma medication.

The National Environment Protection Council commissioned the Australian Child Health and Air Pollution Study and noted that air pollution has a greater impact on children than adults.

Interestingly, that kind of report could not be produced in Hong Kong under the present structure of the Environmental Protection Department. So far as air pollution is concerned it just measures emissions and has no remit to concern itself with public health.

That is the concern of the Department of Health, which likewise does not concern itself with emissions. This is all part of the emasculation of the EPD that has occurred over the past decade. Critics argue that the EPD should have a clear public health remit.

It would be an interesting test of the government’s complacency over air pollution to conduct a similar survey on the health of children in Hong Kong.

From the sublime to the ridiculous

Government complacency over air quality and its effect on the population is matched by absurdity elsewhere.

We have seen extracts of a meeting that reported on the progress of street cleaning along Wan Po Road, which runs past Lohas Park to the landfill. This road has the distinction of being washed six times a day – eight times a day at Lohas Park. This is presumably because the residents don’t like refuse trucks running along the road. This is the problem with living in a residential development built in the middle of an industrial estate. But there is more.

Taxpayers will be delighted to hear that the trees along the road are washed regularly. This occurs under the watchful eye of none other than officers from the Environmental Protection Department

Cancer fears threaten incinerator plan

http://www.heraldscotland.com/mobile/news/environment/cancer-fears-threaten-incinerator-plan.18210277?_=40e1cb2028cd0e9d896c25d22f83cbc57fe712ba

Published on 22 July 2012

EXCLUSIVE by Rob Edwards Environment Editor

A SERIES of highly toxic emissions from Scotland’s newest waste incinerator in breach of safety limits are threatening to upset plans to build similar controversial plants across the country.

An energy-from-waste plant at Dargavel in Dumfries has had its operations restricted by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (Sepa) after it admitted releasing cancer-causing dioxins up to two-and-a-half times permitted levels into the air.

The company that runs the plant, Scotgen, is now facing difficulties obtaining a pollution permit for a second waste incinerator at Dovesdale Farm, near Stonehouse in South Lanarkshire. This proposal has prompted 24,000 objections from local residents and others concerned about the health risks.

Scotgen’s problems are also likely to hamper plans by other companies for another 14 incinerators across Scotland. Most of them have run into fierce opposition from local communities.

Scotgen’s Dumfries plant, commissioned in 2009 to “gasify” more than 20,000 tonnes of hazardous and municipal waste a year at high temperatures, has had a troubled history. Its pollution performance has been condemned as “very poor” by Sepa.

Before the plant was shut down in April 2011, it suffered some 200 breaches of emission limits, two of which were because of dioxins. According to Sepa, it also had 100 “short-term exceedances” and prompted 45 noise complaints.

Problems began again soon after the plant was restarted towards the end of March this year. On May 29, it emitted 0.25 nanograms of dioxins. The permitted limit is 0.1 nanograms.

Sepa ordered that the offending boiler be closed down while the breach was investigated. During trials in June there were a further two dioxin breaches. After further investigations, the plant was allowed to restart last week.

Dioxins are a group of highly dangerous and persistent pollutants produced by combustion. As well as triggering cancer, according to the World Health Organisation they can cause reproductive and developmental problems and damage the immune system.

Sepa told the Sunday Herald that it would not grant a pollution permit for Scotgen’s Dovesdale plant until it received “key information to demonstrate the viability of the technology” in Dumfries.

According to Sepa, Scotgen has also had financial difficulties. The company was sold just before its previous owners, Ascot Environmental, went into administration on May 18, 2012.

John Young, from the Action Group Against the Dovesdale Incinerator, urged Sepa to shut down Scotgen for good. “This company has a failed track record in protecting both the environment and public health,” he said.

Scotgen confirmed there had been dioxin breaches in Dumfries, but pointed out that Sepa had approved the restart of operations last week. “Scotgen is continuing to work closely with its regulator,” said the company’s director, Lloyd Brotherton.

Dirty air takes breath away

http://www.theage.com.au/environment/dirty-air-takes-breath-away-20120721-22gso.html

Date July 22, 2012 2 reading now

Deborah Gough

POLLUTION is giving otherwise healthy children asthma-like symptoms, potentially affecting their lung growth and function and casting doubt on whether national air quality standards are strong enough.

A national study of 2860 primary school children found nitrogen dioxide, contained in motor vehicle exhaust, was present in the lungs of two-thirds of the students of the 55 schools tested. In cases where NO2 was found, children experienced ”asthma-like” symptoms, including wheezing. Their lung volume was reduced and their airways inflamed.

Researchers concluded NO2 exposure was not producing typical asthma but a non-specific lung effect that did not improve with asthma medication.

The study also found airborne fine particles of soot had an impact on children’s lung function and airways.

The National Environment Protection Council commissioned the Australian Child Health and Air Pollution Study. Air pollution has a greater impact on children than adults, the report said. ”Although air pollution levels are relatively low in most regions of Australia, they may not be low enough to prevent adverse health effects,” the report warned.

The Asthma Foundation NSW chief executive, Michele Goldman, said Australia’s air monitoring was 10 years behind the rest of the world despite compelling evidence of harm.

“Studies have shown that children constantly exposed to cigarette smoke or traffic fumes are three times more likely to develop asthma,” she said.

with Sarah Whyte

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/environment/dirty-air-takes-breath-away-20120721-22gso.html#ixzz21KLr4L1s

A methodological oddity

SCMP Lai See 07 July 2012

The Economist Intelligence Unit has adjusted its methodology for determining the world’s most “liveable” city. As a result, Hong Kong has been catapulted from 10th position to first, ahead of Amsterdam, Osaka, Paris and Sydney. The Economist notes this has resulted in “a few oddities”. It cites Hong Kong, noting that “a generation of schoolchildren are condemned to carrying asthma inhalers because their little lungs are speckled with contaminants blowing across the harbour from mainland China”. They might have added “and from Hong Kong’s roadside pollution”.

Description: Liveable? Tell that to the kids

Liveable? Tell that to the kids

Now, injectable oxygen can avoid cardiac arrest, brain injury

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Now-injectable-oxygen-can-avoid-cardiac-arrest-brain-injury/articleshow/14480408.cms

NEW DELHI: Can’t breathe? No worries. Now, oxygen can now be injected.

In a major breakthrough, a team of doctors, chemical engineers and particle scientists from the Boston Children’s Hospital have designed tiny, gas-filled microparticles that can be injected directly into the bloodstream to quickly oxygenate the blood.

This will be a boon for patients unable to breathe because of acute lung failure or an obstructed airway needing another way to quickly get oxygen to their blood to avoidcardiac arrest and brain injury.

Scientists report that an infusion of these microparticles into rabbits with low blood oxygen levels restored blood oxygen saturation to near-normal levels within seconds.

When the trachea was completely blocked, the infusion kept the animals alive for 15 minutes without a single breath and reduced the incidence of cardiac arrest and organ injury.

The microparticles consist of a single layer of lipids (fatty molecules) that surround a tiny pocket of oxygen gas and are delivered in a liquid solution.

Announcing this in the journal of Science Translational Medicine, John Kheir of the Department of Cardiology said the microparticle solutions are portable and could stabilize patients in emergency situations, buying time for paramedics to more safely place a breathing tube or perform other life-saving therapies.

“This is a short-term oxygen substitute — a way to safely inject oxygen gas — to support patients during a critical few minutes. Eventually, this could be stored in syringes on every code cart in a hospital, ambulance or transport helicopter to help stabilize patients who are having difficulty breathing. The microparticles would likely only be administered for a short time, between 15 and 30 minutes, because they are carried in fluid that would overload the blood if used for longer periods,” Kheir said.

The particles are different from blood substitutes, which carry oxygen but are not useful when the lungs are unable to oxygenate them. Instead, the microparticles are designed for situations in which lungs are completely incapacitated.

Kheir began investigating the idea of injectable oxygen in 2006, after caring for a little girl who sustained a severe brain injury resulting from a severe pneumonia that caused bleeding into her lungs and severely low oxygen levels.

Despite the team’s best efforts, she died before they could place her on a heart-lung machine. Frustrated at his inability to save her, Kheir formed a team to search for another way to deliver oxygen.

He said, “We drew each other’s blood, mixed it in a test tube with the microparticles and watched blue blood turn immediately red, right before our eyes.” Over the years, Kheir and his team have tested various concentrations and sizes of the microparticles to optimize their effectiveness and to make them safe for injection.

The team used a device called a sonicator, which uses high-intensity sound waves to mix the oxygen and lipids together. The process traps oxygen gas inside particles averaging two to four micrometers in size (not visible without a microscope). The resulting solution, with oxygen gas making up 70% of the volume, mixed efficiently with human blood. “One of the keys to the success of the project was the ability to administer a concentrated amount of oxygen gas in a small amount of liquid. The suspension carries three to four times the oxygen content of our own red blood cells,” he added.

Intravenous administration of oxygen gas was tried in the early 1900s, but these attempts failed to oxygenate the blood and often caused dangerous gas embolisms. “We have engineered around this problem by packaging the gas into small, deformable particles,” he explained. “They dramatically increase the surface area for gas exchange and are able to squeeze through capillaries where free gas would get stuck,” he added.

CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

http://www.macaudailytimes.com.mo/macau/36605-cuhk-to-start-10-year-plan-on-ka-ho-residents%E2%80%99-health.html

Home | Macau | CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

18/06/2012 10:05:00

The government has commissioned the Chinese University of Hong Kong for a 10-year study of health conditions of the residents in Ka Ho, where local people complained of illness due to the air pollution from ashes from the nearby incinerator. The Health Bureau said they had agreed with the university on the detailed procedures of the study to monitor the health conditions of residents in the area near Hac Sa. The University was quoted as saying details of the monitoring mechanism and study methodologies would be disclosed to the public next month. Preliminary arrangements require an annual report to be published, but the final conclusion will be ten years away. The Health Bureau said the study will be conducted scientifically, impartially and independently in a professional manner. The health issues were discovered early last year when hundreds of residents, many of them students and teachers in the schools there, complained of lung and respiratory problems after the contractor working the incinerator was found to have broken safety regulations by disposing of the ashes into open areas, and a large amount of them carried to residential districts by wind

IMPERIAL COLLEGE UK STUDY

Sent: Monday, January 30, 2012 19:05
To: ‘dynamco@netvigator.com‘; ‘chair@cleartheair.org.hk‘
Cc: Andrew Tristem; ‘Frances Pollitt’; ‘Kelly, Frank’; Elliott, Paul
Subject: FW: Incinerator study

Dear Mr Middleton

Thank you for your enquiry on behalf of ‘Clear The Air’ in Hong Kong.

The English Health Protection Agency announced last week that they have approved funding for a Small Area Health Statistics Unit study to investigate whether there is any potential link between municipal waste incinerators and reproductive health – see

http://www.hpa.org.uk/NewsCentre/NationalPressReleases/2012PressReleases/120124Incineratorstudystatement/

This is for a two year study starting in April 2012.  Results will be made publicly available once accepted for publication in a peer-reviewed journal.

Best wishes

Anna Hansell

(Dr) Anna Hansell  MB BChir MA MRCP MSc PhD FFPH

Clinical Senior Lecturer

Assistant Director, Small Area Health Statistics Unit (SAHSU)

MRC-HPA Centre for Environment and Health

Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics

School of Public Health Faculty of Medicine

Imperial College London St Mary’s Campus, Norfolk Place  LONDON W2 1PG

Phone: +44 (0)20 7594 3344

Fax: +44 (0)20 7594 0768

Email: a.hansell@imperial.ac.uk

From: James Middleton [mailto:dynamco@netvigator.com]
Sent: 30 January 2012 09:43
To: Kelly, Frank; p.elliott@imperial.ac.uk
Subject: Incinerator study

Dear Prof Elliott,

We are an NGO Charity based in Hong Kong.

Our website is www.cleartheair.org.hk

Could you please tell us what is the status of your Unit’s investigation regarding possible incinerator proximity dangers and when the study would likely be complete ?

Kind regards

James Middleton

Chairman

chair@cleartheair.org.hk

Patrons:

Professor Judith Mackay

Professor Anthony Hedley

Inquiry is ordered into incinerators and health hazards they may pose

An investigation is to be launched – the first of its kind in this country – into whether incinerators present a risk to public health.

by Mark Metcalf

Wednesday, June 8th, 2011

A team from Imperial College, London, has been commissioned to carry out the inquiry by the Health Protection Agency after fears were raised about the health risks of incinerators, particularly for young children.

Dozens of incinerators have been built around the country as Britain struggles to cope with its mounting refuse problems. But campaigners have become concerned that the price is being paid with poor health among babies and infants in the localities where such amenities are sited. One such activist is Michael Ryan, who lives in Shrewsbury, and who lost his only daughter at 14 weeks – and then suffered further personal tragedies when his teenage son and his mother both died, too. All lived downwind of an incinerator.

Mr Ryan began a painstaking piece of research into the subject of health – and deaths – of people living in close proximity to incinerators. The results from London are startling. In 12 of the capital’s 625 wards, there were no infant deaths between 2002 and 2008. But Southwark, which has two incinerators close by, had the highest rate with 7.2 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in that period.

Critics say it’s not microscopic particles from incinerators that kill babies and young children, but poverty. And while it is true that some people living close to incinerators are at the lower end of the social scale, Mr Ryan’s research reveals that death rates in more affluent middle class areas are higher if there is an incinerator nearby. Affluent Chingford Green ward in Waltham Forest has the second highest average number of child deaths in London. It happens to be close to Britain’s largest incinerator. “If it’s all about poverty, then how come the levels of infant mortality in countryside areas, where wages have always been below average, aren’t high?” asks Mr Ryan.

Now, to cries of “at last” from Mr Ryan, HPA head Justin McCracken has said that following discussions with Professor Paul Elliott, head of the Small Area Health Statistics Unit at Imperial College, it has been “concluded that an epidemiological study of birth outcomes around municipal waste incinerators would produce reliable results. Work is now progressing in developing a detailed proposal for what will be a complex study.”

In 2004, a study in Japan found a “peak decline in risk with distance from the municipal solid waste incinerators for infant deaths and infant deaths with all congenital malformations combined”.

http://www.tribunemagazine.co.uk/2011/06/inquiry-is-ordered-into-incinerators-and-health-hazards-they-may-pose/

Small Area Health Statistics Unit, Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College, London, UK

CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

http://www.macaudailytimes.com.mo/macau/36605-cuhk-to-start-10-year-plan-on-ka-ho-residents%E2%80%99-health.html

Home | Macau | CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

CUHK to start 10-year plan on Ka Ho residents’ health

18/06/2012 10:05:00

The government has commissioned the Chinese University of Hong Kong for a 10-year study of health conditions of the residents in Ka Ho,where local people complained of illness due to the air pollution from ashes from the nearby incinerator. The Health Bureau said they had agreed with the university on the detailed procedures of the study to monitor the health conditions of residents in the area near Hac Sa. The University was quoted as saying details of the monitoring mechanism and study methodologies would be disclosed to the public next month. Preliminary arrangements require an annual report to be published, but the final conclusion will be ten years away. The Health Bureau said the study will be conducted scientifically, impartially and independently in a professional manner. The health issues were discovered early last year when hundreds of residents, many of them students and teachers in the schools there, complained of lung and respiratory problems after the contractor working the incinerator was found to have broken safety regulations by disposing of the ashes into open areas, and a large amount of them carried to residential districts by wind

Dying from Particulate Air Pollution on Hot and Cold Days in Shanghai, China

http://www.co2science.org/articles/V15/N24/C3.php

Reference
Cheng, Y. and Kan, H. 2012. Effect of the interaction between outdoor air pollution and extreme temperature on daily mortality in Shanghai, China. Journal of Epidemiology 22: 28-36.

Background
Noxious air pollution is bad enough under temperature regimes to which people are accustomed; but when the stress of extreme heat or extreme cold is added to the mix, it could logically be expected that the negative effects of air pollution on peoples’ health may be amplified. And the question thus arises: which is the more deadly in this regard, extreme heat or extreme cold?

What was done
In a study designed to answer this question for the inhabitants of Shanghai, China (the country’s largest city), the authors employed a generalized additive model with penalized splines to analyze mortality, air pollution, temperature and covariate data over the period 1 January 2001 through 31 December 2004, focusing on particulate matter of diameter 10 �m or less (which is commonly referred to as PM10) and ozone (O3).

What was learned
Cheng and Kan report that they “did not find a significant interaction between air pollution and higher temperature [>85th percentile days],” but they say that “the interaction between PM10 and extreme low temperature [<15th percentile days] was statistically significant for both total and cause-specific mortality.” More specifically, they found that compared to normal temperature (15th-85th percentile days), a 10-�g/m3 increase in PM10 on extreme low temperature days led to all-cause mortality rising from 0.17% to 0.40%. And they add that “the interaction pattern of O3 with low temperature was similar,” noting that their finding of “a stronger association between air pollution and daily mortality on extremely cold days confirms those of three earlier seasonal analyses in Hong Kong, Shanghai and Athens,” citing the studies of Touloumi et al. (1996), Wong et al. (1999, 2001) and Zhang et al. (2006).

What it means
Not only is extreme coldness in and of itself a greater killer of people than extreme warmness – see Health Effects (Temperature – Hot vs. Cold Weather) [“] in our Subject Index – but it would appear from this study and the others it sites that extreme cold also enhances the killing power of the noxious air pollutants PM10 and ozone.

References
Touloumi, G., Samoli, E. and Katsouyanni, K. 1996. Daily mortality and “winter type” air pollution in Athens, Greece – a time series analysis within the APHEA project. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 50, Supplement 1: 47-51.

Wong, C.M., Ma, S., Hedley, A.J. and Lam, T.H. 1999. Does ozone have any effect on daily hospital admissions for circulatory diseases?Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 53: 580-581.

Wong, C.M., Ma, S., Hedley, A.J. and Lam, T.H. 2001. Effect of air pollution on daily mortality in Hong Kong. Environmental Health Perspectives 109: 335-340.

Zhang, Y., Huang, W., London, S.J., Song, G., Chen, G., Jiang, L., Zhao, N., Chen, B. and Kan, H. 2006. Ozone and daily mortality in Shanghai, China. Environmental Health Perspectives 114: 1227-1232.

Reviewed 13 June 2012

customize the footer from the template

WHO cancer report a wake-up call for Hong Kong on air pollution

SCMP – 18 June 2012

One of the leading questions of our times is just what it will take to convince the government to treat air pollution with a greater sense of urgency. It is a life and death issue. The Hedley Environment Index, maintained by University of Hong Kong researchers, shows that there has been an annual average of 3,200 avoidable deaths due to the city’s bad air quality for the past five years, a fact which remains undisputed by officials. Perhaps the answer to the question is a decision by World Health Organisation experts to raise the cancer risk of breathing in diesel fumes to the same level as that for passive smoking. But we should not hold our breath in anticipation. We have a farcical idling engine ban that is now founded on exemptions, and we have an unconvincing attempt to ban smoking in public indoors, which shields the owners and managers of bars, restaurants and the like and doesn’t much frighten anyone else. The incoming administration of chief executive-elect Leung Chun-ying has a chance to show from the start that it really means to make a difference by putting the public interest before sectional and vested interests.

The WHO’s International Agency for Research on Cancer, comprising independent experts, has just reclassified the links between diesel exhausts and lung and bladder cancer from probable to definite. Its findings are based on analysis of decades of published studies, evidence from animals and limited research on humans. Hong Kong recently adopted new air-quality targets that still fall short in key areas of those recommended by the WHO seven years ago. More recently, however, the Environmental Department reported the worst-ever levels of respirable suspended particles and nitrogen dioxide. Officials blame low rainfall, sunny days and industrial activity beyond our borders in the face of evidence that polluted air is largely of our own making. The authorities know the real cause and what must be done to stop it – two coal-burning electric power stations, harbour traffic and vehicles, especially those with diesel engines. But as the watering down of the idling engine law shows, business interests still prevail over the public interest, even at the astronomical economic cost to the city of unnecessary deaths and ill health.

That said, officials have shown what can be done if they try, with marked reductions in the levels of some pollutants, encouragement to take old, polluting vehicles out of service and power firms gradually switching to cleaner fuel. It is not a question of money. Leung should give priority to air quality in his plan to make better use of the city’s huge reserves. For the sake of public health and the city’s attraction as a place to live and work, we trust the link between diesel fumes and cancer serves as a wake-up call.